WEBVTT

00:06.102 --> 00:08.745
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm Jason Pack and this is Disorder.

00:09.506 --> 00:25.442
[SPEAKER_00]: The show where we probe deeper and deeper into the events of the post-Cold War period, seeking to uncover how the world got so disordered and then try to ask those practical questions, what can we do about it to order the disorder?

00:26.892 --> 00:37.335
[SPEAKER_00]: We are recording on September the 11th, 2026 and viewed from my personal experience as well as from our vantage point of 2026.

00:38.156 --> 00:45.718
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly 25 years ago, September 11th, 2001 increasingly looks like one of the pivot points in human history.

00:46.478 --> 00:54.121
[SPEAKER_00]: There was a moment of unipolar ordering capacity for the western alliance that really began to dissipate from that day onward.

00:55.041 --> 00:59.182
[SPEAKER_00]: America entered the 21st century as the world's undisputed superpower.

01:00.443 --> 01:03.143
[SPEAKER_00]: And then after 9-11, it had something even rareer.

01:03.763 --> 01:08.345
[SPEAKER_00]: It had an extraordinary amount of international sympathy and allied solidarity.

01:08.965 --> 01:12.286
[SPEAKER_00]: NATO invoked Article 5 for the first and only time in its history.

01:12.926 --> 01:21.168
[SPEAKER_00]: And as we discussed with my colleague, Jamie Shey, that was the moment when the allies could have been united for a purpose.

01:21.908 --> 01:24.109
[SPEAKER_00]: But what followed was division and disorder,

01:25.529 --> 01:30.733
[SPEAKER_00]: Afghanistan led to Iraq, the war on terror, and then this notion of forever wars.

01:31.654 --> 01:41.602
[SPEAKER_00]: And here we are looking back at the disastrous withdrawal from Kabul, the frame of the Western alliance, and the fear or the thought that maybe America won't even defend NATO allies.

01:42.143 --> 01:44.265
[SPEAKER_00]: We see the return of great power war in Europe.

01:44.945 --> 01:47.507
[SPEAKER_00]: and maybe another forever war in the Middle East.

01:48.208 --> 02:00.457
[SPEAKER_00]: Then when we look at home, we have the politics of fear, emergency powers, surveillance, and distrust have eroded the confidence in those very democratic institutions that I thought we should go fight for.

02:01.458 --> 02:12.961
[SPEAKER_00]: So, did 9-11 begin a quarter-century process in which America responded to an attack on the Western Order by inadvertently overreacting and leading to the destruction of the very order.

02:13.481 --> 02:14.962
[SPEAKER_00]: It thought it was defending.

02:15.862 --> 02:23.804
[SPEAKER_00]: Few people are better placed to delve into this topic and help unpack it than Lieutenant General Ben Hodges.

02:24.544 --> 02:31.547
[SPEAKER_00]: He spent nearly four decades in the U.S. Army serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, commanding NATO Allied land command.

02:32.128 --> 02:42.773
[SPEAKER_00]: And from 2014 to 2017, commanding the U.S. Army in Europe, where he became one of the clearest voices warning that Russia represented the most serious military threat to Europe.

02:43.333 --> 02:44.834
[SPEAKER_00]: Ben, welcome to disorder.

02:45.875 --> 02:52.618
[SPEAKER_01]: Jason, what an opening to your show and very pleased to have the privilege to join you.

02:53.509 --> 02:53.909
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.

02:54.970 --> 03:00.272
[SPEAKER_00]: The listeners will have heard my story of what happened to me on September 11, 2001.

03:01.072 --> 03:06.715
[SPEAKER_00]: Where were you and what did you think that you would be called upon to do in its wake?

03:07.747 --> 03:15.509
[SPEAKER_01]: I was a colonel, a brand new colonel, serving at the Joint Readiness Training Center, the JRTC and Fort Poct, Louisiana.

03:15.749 --> 03:20.730
[SPEAKER_01]: It's one of the Army's training centers and a very desolate part of Louisiana.

03:21.670 --> 03:29.651
[SPEAKER_01]: It's where light infantry units would go through every month to be a new brigade would come through and train against a tough enemy force.

03:37.633 --> 03:44.639
[SPEAKER_01]: We had a unit who had come from Fort Drum, New York, and the 10th Mountain Division had just arrived to go through their training rotation.

03:45.319 --> 03:51.104
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was heading out of the building out to get my vehicle to move out to the field to start this exercise.

03:51.504 --> 03:53.145
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm just as I'm getting ready to walk out.

03:53.265 --> 03:58.950
[SPEAKER_01]: I hear somebody go, hey, did you hear about the plane that flew into the World Trade Center?

03:59.823 --> 04:20.984
[SPEAKER_01]: And the way he said it, it's almost was like a joke like, hey, a guy walks into a bar and says, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah,

04:21.397 --> 04:22.838
[SPEAKER_01]: But we still had a mission to do.

04:23.319 --> 04:26.901
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I headed out into the training area, the woods.

04:27.882 --> 04:32.746
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was there for basically the next two weeks with our unit rotation still going on.

04:33.486 --> 04:41.092
[SPEAKER_01]: But at the same time, even Fort Poet, Louisiana was shut down because nobody knew.

04:41.573 --> 04:45.936
[SPEAKER_01]: So access to military installations, everything was shut down.

04:46.782 --> 04:54.804
[SPEAKER_01]: You try to get your head around what's going on, but we're stating the field and so over our radio's people would say, hey, I just heard this or I just heard this.

04:55.816 --> 04:59.717
[SPEAKER_01]: But that was my experience on the day and the immediate aftermath.

05:00.217 --> 05:13.780
[SPEAKER_01]: But of course, this changed the nature of every training rotation coming up because by now, it was already known that the Army and the U.S. actually was going to go to Afghanistan and go after Al Qaeda.

05:14.680 --> 05:19.802
[SPEAKER_01]: I was already slated to become a brigade commander in the 101st Airborne Division, the following summer.

05:20.762 --> 05:23.002
[SPEAKER_01]: And by the time I got there,

05:26.503 --> 05:32.226
[SPEAKER_01]: So that was how this my whole everything changed as a result of course.

05:33.046 --> 05:48.193
[SPEAKER_00]: So NATO invoked article five, America had unprecedented international sympathy and I was of the view that working with the Northern Alliance and being in Afghanistan was a wise move and we

05:51.732 --> 05:59.720
[SPEAKER_00]: How do we go from that moment of working very well with our allies to fracturing the allies and making the crucial strategic mistake over Iraq?

06:00.737 --> 06:11.960
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I cannot explain how we ended up going to Iraq and I've read so many things have been written about the justifications and all that.

06:12.701 --> 06:17.642
[SPEAKER_01]: And I will confess to being as an incoming brigade commander.

06:18.282 --> 06:21.263
[SPEAKER_01]: I didn't think too long and hard about why are we going to Iraq.

06:21.783 --> 06:25.004
[SPEAKER_01]: My job was making sure that my brigade would be ready.

06:25.024 --> 06:26.465
[SPEAKER_01]: That we were as trained and ready.

06:27.345 --> 06:32.988
[SPEAKER_01]: as we could possibly be to deploy along with the rest of the 101st Airborne Division to do our mission.

06:33.749 --> 06:47.136
[SPEAKER_01]: But as I have had the chance now for more than 20 years to reflect back on all of this, and you see how, and of course, I live in Germany now, since I retired, I've stayed in my wife and I live here.

06:47.656 --> 06:51.859
[SPEAKER_01]: People lost a lot of trust in the United States.

06:52.884 --> 07:02.350
[SPEAKER_01]: because of how we went about our decision-making about Iraq, but also the decision to stay in Afghanistan as long as we did.

07:02.911 --> 07:10.095
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, everybody in NATO was prepared to support us in Afghanistan and all that, but Iraq was a different thing.

07:10.956 --> 07:19.141
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think the fact that we never had a clearly defined strategic objective for either Iraq or Afghanistan

07:20.147 --> 07:29.892
[SPEAKER_01]: after the first year that set us on a course they would make it harder and harder for allies to be able politically to stay with us.

07:31.273 --> 07:39.176
[SPEAKER_00]: So if we look at your time in Iraq and Afghanistan, was the US military used incorrectly?

07:39.297 --> 07:43.499
[SPEAKER_00]: It is a glorious fighting force and it can do defensive and offensive operations, but

07:44.652 --> 07:52.299
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not an imperial nation building army like the British military was in its empire.

07:52.419 --> 07:57.504
[SPEAKER_00]: Was it in your experience being used to do missions which were not appropriate for it?

07:59.352 --> 08:04.153
[SPEAKER_01]: This is a very, very good question, and not one that's easily answered, of course.

08:05.153 --> 08:16.295
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that the key, and I'm gonna sound a little bit like a scratch record, but if you don't get the strategic objective right, it's almost impossible to get the policy right.

08:16.816 --> 08:21.877
[SPEAKER_01]: Because the policies are what you do that you implement to achieve the objective.

08:22.697 --> 08:23.537
[SPEAKER_01]: And Afghanistan,

08:24.847 --> 08:35.663
[SPEAKER_01]: the objective was very clear, make sure that Afghanistan cannot be a base for training or launching future attacks by all kinds of against the United States or our allies.

08:36.817 --> 08:43.019
[SPEAKER_01]: If we'd left after the first six, eight months, we would not even be talking about it on this podcast.

08:43.539 --> 08:44.199
[SPEAKER_01]: It would have been done.

08:44.939 --> 08:58.502
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, there's a, you mentioned the Romans, there's a great historical analogy that happened, for what we could have done, happened just down the Rhine River here near Koblenz, which is where Caesar built the first bridge over the Rhine River.

08:58.522 --> 08:59.883
[SPEAKER_01]: And this was like, I think, 55 BC,

09:01.663 --> 09:21.213
[SPEAKER_01]: He was tired of the German barbarians kept coming across the Rhine and attacking Roman farms and burning farms and doing all that, and so he built a bridge of the Rhine River March several thousand troops across and destroyed everything within 50 kilometers of where he built the bridge, brought his troops back and disassembled the bridge.

09:22.096 --> 09:27.098
[SPEAKER_01]: And when the guy told me this, I said, well, why would he tear the bridge apart after doing that?

09:27.118 --> 09:29.399
[SPEAKER_01]: The first bridge that had ever been built across the run.

09:30.040 --> 09:34.422
[SPEAKER_01]: And of course this was Caesar telling the barbarians, I can do this whenever I want.

09:35.242 --> 09:37.024
[SPEAKER_01]: So you stay on your side of the river.

09:37.544 --> 09:42.709
[SPEAKER_01]: Don't come over here, messin' with our farms or causing problems, and we'll leave you alone.

09:42.969 --> 09:44.911
[SPEAKER_01]: But if you keep doin' it, we'll do this again.

09:45.452 --> 09:47.574
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think, I thought about this many times.

09:47.654 --> 09:56.742
[SPEAKER_01]: If we had done that in Afghanistan, you goin' there, you destroy the Taliban, you destroy Al Qaeda, and then you say, we can come back whenever we need to.

09:57.743 --> 09:58.484
[SPEAKER_01]: And then you go.

09:59.494 --> 10:00.795
[SPEAKER_01]: we would be in a different place.

10:00.815 --> 10:04.736
[SPEAKER_01]: So there's a case where the military was the right tool to use.

10:05.397 --> 10:11.580
[SPEAKER_01]: When you get into trouble, when you start diverting from their original purpose for being there in Iraq,

10:13.120 --> 10:20.185
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, the military part, the first or the combat operations in the first few months were done.

10:20.766 --> 10:24.889
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, Iraqis were disappearing faster than we could get there to kill them already, capture them.

10:24.909 --> 10:26.670
[SPEAKER_01]: They were disappearing.

10:27.771 --> 10:30.413
[SPEAKER_01]: And so now we're here and it's like, okay, so what are we going to do?

10:31.774 --> 10:37.098
[SPEAKER_01]: And the government or the administration made decision well, now we need to help reestablish this and this.

10:38.148 --> 10:43.535
[SPEAKER_01]: And it just kept going and going and we had success in some places, not in other places.

10:44.356 --> 10:48.641
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think with a couple of exceptions, General Patreus would have been one of the exceptions.

10:49.682 --> 10:54.909
[SPEAKER_01]: But most of the senior leaders did not really understand the nature of what we were doing.

10:56.131 --> 11:02.818
[SPEAKER_01]: They didn't really appreciate or understand the Iraqi culture ending in the environment.

11:03.478 --> 11:06.161
[SPEAKER_01]: And so we didn't have the clear objective.

11:06.241 --> 11:10.865
[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't have the right policies except with cases of like general betrayers.

11:12.347 --> 11:13.708
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think that's exactly right.

11:13.848 --> 11:20.395
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's worth pointing out that when I was in Iraq in 2003, I spent a bit of time in Carbalah and Najef.

11:21.330 --> 11:27.955
[SPEAKER_00]: And for the first five, six months, my Shia interlocutors were very happy, happy to be liberated.

11:28.735 --> 11:34.099
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, by two or three years in, the same people when I were chatting with them were like, what are you still doing here?

11:34.699 --> 11:36.481
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, it must be that you're here to take the oil.

11:37.341 --> 11:40.523
[SPEAKER_00]: No one said in the first six months, I'm a decent Arabic speaker.

11:41.084 --> 11:44.266
[SPEAKER_00]: No one would say to me, you're here to take the oil in 2003.

11:44.446 --> 11:48.029
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't hear it, among Shia, maybe into Crete, but not where I was.

11:48.709 --> 11:51.650
[SPEAKER_00]: Three, four years later, all they said is like, what are you guys doing here?

11:51.670 --> 11:53.010
[SPEAKER_00]: It must be Imperial overreach.

11:53.330 --> 11:54.350
[SPEAKER_00]: You're here to take the oil.

11:54.970 --> 12:04.512
[SPEAKER_00]: And I couldn't agree more with the way that you framed it, which is that deterrence works really well when you make this as me and that's you.

12:05.153 --> 12:07.373
[SPEAKER_00]: You have your side of the river, we have our side of the river.

12:07.933 --> 12:12.194
[SPEAKER_00]: So I will make one more historical parallel and then we'll move closer to the present.

12:13.134 --> 12:15.515
[SPEAKER_00]: I love your analogy about how

12:16.364 --> 12:26.509
[SPEAKER_00]: Julius Caesar built a bridge across the Rhine in 55 BC, crossed in Germania, and as a demonstration, Roman reached them with Drew and dismantled the bridge.

12:27.650 --> 12:40.476
[SPEAKER_00]: But what happened 64 years later, in nine AD, is Publius Quintassilus Varros was ambushed by our Minius at the Battle of Tutanburg Forest.

12:40.576 --> 12:42.717
[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean, Tutanburg Forest was

12:44.002 --> 12:48.266
[SPEAKER_00]: the greatest defeat that the Roman Empire suffered when at the height of its powers.

12:48.726 --> 12:50.788
[SPEAKER_00]: And therefore it's quite like the US in Iraq.

12:52.030 --> 13:11.003
[SPEAKER_00]: they were not able to really recognize the limits of their power and they tried to go beyond that and that's what happened at Tutanburg Forest and everything that you said about the mistakes that U.S. geostrachijic thinkers did in Afghanistan and Iraqis because they had no strategy and we can see that with the Roman Empire.

13:11.623 --> 13:14.445
[SPEAKER_00]: So now let's skip ahead to Kabul in 2021.

13:16.446 --> 13:21.809
[SPEAKER_00]: I was very confused why we would fully withdraw.

13:22.309 --> 13:30.733
[SPEAKER_00]: I understand that Trump made it a election promise and therefore, in a way, go to Biden into it.

13:31.573 --> 13:33.654
[SPEAKER_00]: But what was the calculation there?

13:33.774 --> 13:42.318
[SPEAKER_00]: And looking back, do you think that this change Putin's view about the West-lacking cohesion or a will to defend Ukraine?

13:43.766 --> 13:55.755
[SPEAKER_01]: So I have reflected a lot on what happened at the end there in Afghanistan, because 15 months I was there in Kandahar, 2009, 2010.

13:55.895 --> 13:57.536
[SPEAKER_01]: I was director of operations.

13:58.837 --> 14:02.059
[SPEAKER_01]: We were a predominantly European lead.

14:02.279 --> 14:05.421
[SPEAKER_01]: I had Dutch General General Mark the Coif.

14:06.182 --> 14:10.525
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the first three months, and then the last year, I had General Nick Carter.

14:14.320 --> 14:20.823
[SPEAKER_01]: although we had tens of thousands of American troops, as well as other allies, Canadians, Romanian, Dutch, etc.

14:21.623 --> 14:32.108
[SPEAKER_01]: And this was about the time that General McCrissel had shifted the strategic focus to protecting Afghans of Indians instead of just killing Taliban or killing Al-Qaeda.

14:32.828 --> 14:41.632
[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought that was exactly the right approach, and it was all about trying to get Afghans government someplace and let them take over building up their security forces.

14:42.451 --> 14:48.224
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I really felt confident at the end of 2010 as I was leaving.

14:48.284 --> 14:48.464
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean,

14:49.471 --> 14:51.853
[SPEAKER_01]: It just felt so much more solid.

14:52.513 --> 14:55.055
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, I was naive, but it felt solid.

14:55.075 --> 14:57.537
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, of course, it's not uncommon that people at the end of their tour thing.

14:57.798 --> 14:59.419
[SPEAKER_01]: Wow, look, I good at this, since I've been here.

14:59.819 --> 15:15.812
[SPEAKER_01]: So I'm willing to take that criticism, but nonetheless, it seemed that we were on a path, not to make Afghanistan look like Switzerland, but to get a release where they could protect themselves and that I'll kind of would not be able to get reestablished there.

15:17.295 --> 15:22.782
[SPEAKER_01]: So then 10, 11 years later, when it falls apart, and like, what the hell happened?

15:23.463 --> 15:25.165
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's how fast it happened.

15:25.826 --> 15:29.731
[SPEAKER_01]: And I have come up with four or five reasons why, in my view,

15:30.740 --> 15:32.881
[SPEAKER_01]: It collapsed, and we share them with us.

15:33.401 --> 15:36.201
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, well, thanks for letting me do this.

15:36.241 --> 15:41.823
[SPEAKER_01]: Number one, we did build up a huge military force, Afghan security forces, it was significant.

15:42.263 --> 15:44.523
[SPEAKER_01]: The problem is they look just like us.

15:45.183 --> 15:48.144
[SPEAKER_01]: And we modeled something that looked like Western military.

15:48.984 --> 15:56.546
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's great if you have unlimited contract support, unlimited logistics, exquisite, and tell all these things.

16:00.782 --> 16:05.045
[SPEAKER_01]: then this thing turns out it's artificially propped up and it's a collapses.

16:05.525 --> 16:09.368
[SPEAKER_01]: Nothing about what we did reflected afghan culture.

16:10.128 --> 16:19.334
[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, the best afghan unit I ever saw looked a lot like Taliban and they had a US Army Lieutenant Colonel Special Forces was with them and they wrote around and pick up trucks.

16:19.354 --> 16:21.455
[SPEAKER_01]: They did all that and they were super.

16:22.096 --> 16:24.798
[SPEAKER_01]: So that was one thing we built the wrong security force.

16:24.838 --> 16:27.760
[SPEAKER_01]: The second thing was of course we didn't have the

16:28.757 --> 16:30.559
[SPEAKER_01]: clearly the fine strategic objective.

16:31.200 --> 16:39.388
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, after that first year afterwards, and it this goes over a public and end democratic administrations, it was not really clear.

16:39.708 --> 16:46.536
[SPEAKER_01]: And so you end up, that's how you end up with a policy like a troop cap, no more than 100,000 or no more than 60,000.

16:46.856 --> 16:48.257
[SPEAKER_01]: What does that have to do with anything?

16:49.121 --> 16:55.123
[SPEAKER_01]: unless it's helping achieve the desired in-state, but you start getting policies that don't help.

16:55.843 --> 17:06.987
[SPEAKER_01]: The third thing was we acted as if Afghanistan was an island as opposed to being neighbored by Pakistan and Iran and Tajikistan and where it's said in the world.

17:07.728 --> 17:16.151
[SPEAKER_01]: So the collective we, I think, did not take into account the full geographic context and as you probably know,

17:17.491 --> 17:30.345
[SPEAKER_01]: And your listeners will know the way the U.S. divides up the military boundaries for our combatant commands, the boundary between U.S. central command, which is responsible for Afghanistan.

17:31.508 --> 17:37.609
[SPEAKER_01]: and U.S. Pacific Command, which was responsible for India, that boundary was right between Indian Pakistan.

17:38.669 --> 17:43.550
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't do anything with Pakistan without thing by India and vice versa, but yet that's where we had the boundary.

17:44.071 --> 17:50.852
[SPEAKER_01]: And so this was part of the problem of how we saw this strategic sense of the world.

17:51.592 --> 17:56.533
[SPEAKER_01]: The fourth thing was we somehow acted as if Pakistan was an ally.

17:58.032 --> 17:59.373
[SPEAKER_01]: clearly they weren't.

17:59.893 --> 18:13.221
[SPEAKER_01]: The Pakistan had no interest in seeing Afghanistan become strong vibrant self-reliant because they would have expected that it would have been more in favor of our more favorable towards India.

18:14.021 --> 18:16.443
[SPEAKER_01]: And so we foolishly believe that

18:17.678 --> 18:20.760
[SPEAKER_01]: at some levels, or we were not willing to make the hard decisions.

18:20.780 --> 18:28.384
[SPEAKER_01]: Let me say it that way that we're necessary to ensure that the Taliban could not use Pakistan as safe haven.

18:29.004 --> 18:30.905
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the last thing is more domestic.

18:31.626 --> 18:37.989
[SPEAKER_01]: No Americans paid any special tax for the war in Afghanistan.

18:38.970 --> 18:43.032
[SPEAKER_01]: Because of that, the vast majority of the country had no skin in the game.

18:43.272 --> 18:44.433
[SPEAKER_01]: Unless they had a family member.

18:45.252 --> 18:56.240
[SPEAKER_01]: or they live next to Fort Bragg or Camp LaJune or something like that, it didn't matter, it just, it was, unless there was a huge, terrible disaster one day or something, it didn't matter.

18:57.221 --> 19:05.387
[SPEAKER_01]: And so because of that, there was no pressure on any administration or the Congress to fix these things that I just laid out.

19:05.447 --> 19:10.871
[SPEAKER_01]: So those are my five sort of things that were, were majors for

19:12.761 --> 19:18.786
[SPEAKER_00]: And that was very clear, the Democratic legitimacy for a war has to do with its strategic objectives.

19:19.787 --> 19:23.871
[SPEAKER_00]: It's relationship to constitutionality and the rule of armed conflicts.

19:23.891 --> 19:26.933
[SPEAKER_00]: Something that you've spoken about so eloquently elsewhere.

19:27.054 --> 19:33.940
[SPEAKER_00]: I will include the link in the show notes to your discussion with our sister podcast Democrats.

19:34.540 --> 19:37.461
[SPEAKER_00]: versus dictators where you spoke about that very clearly.

19:38.102 --> 19:43.384
[SPEAKER_00]: So now skipping ahead, America is fighting Iran.

19:43.444 --> 19:44.725
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not a declared war.

19:44.965 --> 19:51.708
[SPEAKER_00]: It repeats the post-9-11 mistake of not having a clear strategy, not having congressional legitimacy.

19:52.608 --> 20:05.154
[SPEAKER_00]: and potentially the most important thing of America being good at destroying things militarily without having a sufficient political conception of what comes next or the regional context.

20:05.794 --> 20:15.859
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you were able to give advice to the current administration and magically they would listen, we know they wouldn't listen, but if they could listen, what would you advise?

20:23.010 --> 20:28.374
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, first of all, we have to get clarity on what, what is it we're trying to accomplish now?

20:28.634 --> 20:34.858
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, 99% of the effort seems to be focused on how do you get the straight-of-hormos open and keep it open?

20:35.218 --> 20:38.120
[SPEAKER_01]: That was not even in the 10 things that were listed ahead of the war.

20:39.261 --> 20:40.982
[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, that's all that we're doing right now.

20:41.082 --> 20:47.086
[SPEAKER_01]: So, it'd be time for a real clear out assessment of what is it we're trying to accomplish.

20:52.070 --> 21:17.139
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know that we have to do everything we're doing right now to, I mean, you could argue about JCPOA or not, that's, that's water under the bridge, but certainly we don't have to be doing what we're doing now to keep it on from having a nuclear weapon, and so that'd be the first thing, Mr. President, what is the desired outcome or here's what we think, Mr. President, the outcome should be, need you approval, that's the first

21:18.504 --> 21:22.768
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I would work very hard to rebuild the relationship with our allies.

21:22.868 --> 21:27.693
[SPEAKER_01]: It also have interest in the area, but we didn't bother to ask them to help on the way in.

21:28.646 --> 21:31.088
[SPEAKER_01]: It was more like, hey, we need you now.

21:31.508 --> 21:32.909
[SPEAKER_01]: That didn't help works with allies.

21:33.129 --> 21:40.554
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think I'd be going about trying to regain the trust of allies, which would probably involve a lot of saying, hey, we have to.

21:41.074 --> 21:45.197
[SPEAKER_01]: And we should have, so that would be a part of it.

21:45.857 --> 21:49.840
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the third thing is finding out how to isolate Iran.

21:50.220 --> 21:52.602
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, the Chinese are not going to allow Iran to fail.

21:53.282 --> 22:03.886
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, they first of all, they need the oil and gas out of the region, but also it's in their interest to see Iran make us bleed and in terms of resources.

22:04.207 --> 22:19.653
[SPEAKER_01]: And so we got to figure out a way to isolate Iran from Russia, from China, and from other places where they're getting support, and I think that starts with defeat Russia first.

22:20.489 --> 22:21.570
[SPEAKER_01]: If you help you crayon.

22:21.590 --> 22:22.030
[SPEAKER_00]: 100%.

22:22.570 --> 22:23.871
[SPEAKER_00]: Difficult.

22:24.512 --> 22:25.632
[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to pivot to that.

22:26.373 --> 22:39.161
[SPEAKER_00]: You're a very clear eyed strategic thinker, but I want to underline some of the wisdom that we've just heard, which is that you mustn't have a sunk cost fallacy when you're dealing with a war.

22:39.742 --> 22:44.345
[SPEAKER_00]: Mistakes could have been made, but you don't continue to say mistake just because you started.

22:45.025 --> 22:53.887
[SPEAKER_00]: And obviously, that requires eating humble pie and our leaders have never wanted to eat humble pie because that would require either learning or growth.

22:54.327 --> 23:04.248
[SPEAKER_00]: So now to summarize this section of the podcast, let's each in one minute say the answer to what we think about the following.

23:16.008 --> 23:22.993
[SPEAKER_00]: affected how America acts abroad and how it thinks about power at home.

23:23.714 --> 23:24.915
[SPEAKER_00]: I give you 60 seconds.

23:26.025 --> 23:40.108
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I think one thing, of course, is damage trust in the United States, allies that we desperately need where we have shared interest are going to be very reluctant about helping us again because they remembered what happened in the past.

23:40.528 --> 23:54.612
[SPEAKER_01]: And the second thing is their own population, I think, is severely divided now because they see that a government, Republican or Democrat, is willing to do things in the name of security that goes against the Constitution.

23:55.273 --> 24:03.405
[SPEAKER_01]: which is not to say that there may not be those times, but that's why you have to involve the Congress to make sure that the Congress is a part of all this.

24:03.485 --> 24:06.049
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think we have not done a good job of that.

24:07.493 --> 24:25.281
[SPEAKER_00]: know that I think that's brilliant because if you want to have a unified populist at home or the ability to work with your NATO allies, you need to say that forces the absolute less resort and it's constrained by various congressional and legal processes.

24:25.941 --> 24:33.205
[SPEAKER_00]: What I'm going to say is that the 25 years of emergency powers, secrecy, surveillance and fear,

24:34.305 --> 24:42.368
[SPEAKER_00]: really have eroded, not only the trust that you mentioned, but the ability to focus on the longer term questions.

24:43.028 --> 24:45.409
[SPEAKER_00]: Everything has become so short-term oriented.

24:45.929 --> 24:52.831
[SPEAKER_00]: If I look back to, and it's not just Clinton, it's also Herbert Walker Bush, building the post-Cold War period.

24:53.251 --> 24:58.673
[SPEAKER_00]: We were thinking about financial flows, potentially the ability to deal with climate change.

24:59.253 --> 25:03.915
[SPEAKER_00]: the ability to think about how to regulate computing and globalization.

25:04.335 --> 25:11.078
[SPEAKER_00]: But this war on terror made everything about what's happening right now, and this immediate, what's in your face.

25:11.498 --> 25:16.240
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's the same problem that has screwed up to my mind is really thinking.

25:16.701 --> 25:23.884
[SPEAKER_00]: Is that they're so obsessed with, we need to kill this one Hamas guy right now, and assassinate him, that they're not thinking

25:25.030 --> 25:27.991
[SPEAKER_00]: What are the implications of just beheading this guy now?

25:28.611 --> 25:33.053
[SPEAKER_00]: We need to be building up the allies on the other side that we can deal with.

25:33.133 --> 25:41.256
[SPEAKER_00]: And we kind of succumbed from a position of being very far-sighted in the 90s to being so myopic.

25:41.436 --> 25:46.078
[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm going to end this section and say, please rejoin us after the break.

25:46.438 --> 25:48.959
[SPEAKER_00]: Will we talk about Ukraine and the defense of Europe?

25:59.178 --> 26:10.432
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm back with General Ben Hodges and he is a very far-sighted thinker and we're really honored to have his 90,000 foot perspective.

26:11.153 --> 26:14.176
[SPEAKER_00]: So let's strip away the daily headlines.

26:14.977 --> 26:22.442
[SPEAKER_00]: If you're looking at the war in Ukraine, what are the salient things that have happened in the last year or two?

26:22.502 --> 26:40.574
[SPEAKER_00]: Because there's so many headlines and even if you love reading the BBC, the average non-military person can't follow all the changes in the drone war and they hit this pipeline and they defended this village and Donbass, they need someone like you to explain it to them.

26:41.034 --> 26:42.755
[SPEAKER_00]: What has happened in the last year or two?

26:43.834 --> 27:03.208
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I think Jason, thank you, the biggest thing that has changed is that Ukraine has developed the ability to produce weapons that can go great distances with precision and carry a large enough payload.

27:04.318 --> 27:05.579
[SPEAKER_01]: to achieve real effect.

27:05.619 --> 27:22.444
[SPEAKER_01]: And of course, I'm talking about these strikes against Russian oil and gas infrastructure and other critical weapons manufacturing sites that is making it increasingly difficult for Russia to export enough oil and gas to pay for the war.

27:23.225 --> 27:29.607
[SPEAKER_01]: So I mean, this is very effective long-range precision strike.

27:30.466 --> 27:36.251
[SPEAKER_01]: that is really damaging Russia's economic ability to sustain the war.

27:36.912 --> 27:47.802
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, the side benefit of that, of course, is when Russians and St. Petersburg and Moscow see refineries on fire in the metropolitan area, it's like, what the hell is going on here?

27:48.162 --> 27:56.249
[SPEAKER_01]: So there is a psychological bonus, but the real effect is what it's doing to their ability to export oil and gas.

27:57.310 --> 28:20.986
[SPEAKER_01]: The second big thing is that the Ukrainians have figured out how to stop Russian ground operations, even though Russians have enormous advantage in manpower, the Ukrainians through a combination of electronic warfare, drones, and good tactical actions have pretty much stopped and in fact,

28:26.450 --> 28:36.794
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's, and because of the way they've created this so-called dead zone, they've also reduced their exposure to Russian drones.

28:36.814 --> 28:43.537
[SPEAKER_01]: There's no doubt the Russians are killing a lot of Ukrainians, but the Ukrainians have been able to reduce that, which I think is important.

28:43.557 --> 28:46.758
[SPEAKER_01]: The third thing in that stop is the Russians still

28:47.368 --> 28:52.852
[SPEAKER_01]: have the ability to strike and kill innocent Ukrainians whenever and wherever they want to.

28:53.152 --> 29:03.059
[SPEAKER_01]: The Ukrainians, the combination of failure by the rest of us to provide them enough missile defense systems, but also their own lack of capabilities.

29:03.639 --> 29:06.621
[SPEAKER_01]: This is something I don't see changing anytime soon.

29:06.801 --> 29:10.884
[SPEAKER_01]: That's a birdie-gram heading into the winter as a birdie-gram assessment.

29:11.710 --> 29:13.972
[SPEAKER_01]: Fortunately, that's not decisive.

29:14.513 --> 29:18.297
[SPEAKER_01]: Bombing Ukrainian apartments is not going to win the war for Russia.

29:19.478 --> 29:31.011
[SPEAKER_00]: To paraphrase what we've heard there, Ukraine has a manpower problem, but it has innovated its way out, and it's mastered asymmetric warfare.

29:31.511 --> 29:32.853
[SPEAKER_00]: That asymmetry,

29:33.990 --> 29:37.411
[SPEAKER_00]: is harming Russia, bringing the war into Russia.

29:37.511 --> 29:41.332
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's really changed the nature of warfare in general.

29:41.813 --> 29:50.535
[SPEAKER_00]: Sadly, it's those same tactics that allow the Iranians to use asymmetry to hit our Gulf of Allies and to frustrate American and Israeli war aims.

29:50.595 --> 29:58.318
[SPEAKER_00]: So something about drones and the Internet and AI does seem to help the asymmetric player.

29:59.258 --> 30:06.081
[SPEAKER_00]: now it's a tragedy that Europe has not been able to build sufficient missile defense and air defense.

30:06.341 --> 30:08.341
[SPEAKER_00]: And I want to ask you about that.

30:08.361 --> 30:12.063
[SPEAKER_00]: So the Ukrainians are world leaders at drones.

30:13.063 --> 30:24.067
[SPEAKER_00]: Why is it that during the Trump one administration, Europe was really aware that Trump was against NATO said, you've got to spend more, you've got to do this.

30:24.127 --> 30:25.008
[SPEAKER_00]: I might abandon you.

30:25.948 --> 30:30.493
[SPEAKER_00]: And that started 10 years ago, Trump won the election in 2016.

30:31.293 --> 30:34.977
[SPEAKER_00]: How is it that Europe doesn't make sufficient air defense and missile defense?

30:35.277 --> 30:35.738
[SPEAKER_00]: This is 2026.

30:37.521 --> 30:49.485
[SPEAKER_01]: As an excellent question, there is still not the sense of urgency in too many parts of Europe, including the UK there, to take the threat for real.

30:50.705 --> 30:58.868
[SPEAKER_01]: Even in some parts of Eastern Europe, like Romania, they just had a Russian drone fly all over Romania and then land inside Moldova.

30:59.648 --> 31:04.770
[SPEAKER_01]: The Romanian who are not scared of anybody, but yet they're hoping that

31:05.730 --> 31:08.813
[SPEAKER_01]: drone won't actually hit them and so they let it go through.

31:09.614 --> 31:15.960
[SPEAKER_01]: So there's a them figured out how to deal with Russia's coercive attacks and in gray zone operations.

31:16.000 --> 31:22.946
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, of course here in life-sig Germany, we had a drone with explosives landed at the airport there.

31:23.026 --> 31:25.788
[SPEAKER_01]: Fortunately, it did not detonate and destroy aircraft.

31:26.770 --> 31:30.874
[SPEAKER_01]: But the Germans to their credit came out and said, OK, we know this was Russia.

31:30.914 --> 31:33.856
[SPEAKER_01]: We have DNA from two of the people that were part of this.

31:33.876 --> 31:34.777
[SPEAKER_01]: We've traced it back.

31:35.297 --> 31:39.001
[SPEAKER_01]: We know that Russia was behind this, but the actions

31:39.636 --> 31:54.153
[SPEAKER_01]: We're still very limited because of German domestic politics and a coalition government where one of the parties has a left wing that is still, let's just say, unwilling to take all Russia.

31:54.393 --> 31:55.674
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's a part of the problem.

31:55.855 --> 31:58.037
[SPEAKER_00]: And then I want to jump in and say,

31:59.045 --> 32:01.107
[SPEAKER_00]: people are not willing to call a spade a spade.

32:01.568 --> 32:13.600
[SPEAKER_00]: Olaf Schultz may have announced that sites and vendor, but then they didn't do the actions that were required to really make the air defense and missile defense and change Europe's defense capacity.

32:13.960 --> 32:18.344
[SPEAKER_00]: The irony is whether it was BAA systems or Ryan Matal

32:19.045 --> 32:25.810
[SPEAKER_00]: whichever European firm got their first, would not only be defending their nation, they'd make billions or trillions of dollars.

32:25.850 --> 32:39.819
[SPEAKER_00]: So there's something paradoxical here because wouldn't it be in the interest of a firm or a company to race ahead and make a product which is commercially viable and strengthens their nation?

32:40.499 --> 32:42.761
[SPEAKER_01]: So actually, I will tell you this.

32:42.841 --> 32:46.203
[SPEAKER_01]: At the last two years, I have seen a dramatic increase

32:49.339 --> 32:58.463
[SPEAKER_01]: and other European defense industry organizations leaning forward, even investing without waiting for government orders to do things.

32:58.503 --> 33:05.326
[SPEAKER_01]: So the problem, the main problem, not the only, but the main problem is still the political will to do what needs to be done.

33:06.346 --> 33:11.749
[SPEAKER_01]: I recently visited a site that would be a hell of a good target for a drone, a Russian drone.

33:12.848 --> 33:18.711
[SPEAKER_01]: And there still is uncertainty about, okay, who's responsible for defending an industrial site?

33:18.771 --> 33:29.657
[SPEAKER_01]: Is this this is inside a police jurisdiction, or is this the interior ministry, or is this the responsibility of the company to shoot down a drone?

33:29.777 --> 33:34.359
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, these are things that need to be sorted out before there is a disaster.

33:34.419 --> 33:39.382
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's the kind of stuff that you can do, war gaming on, it's part of Homeland Security.

33:39.462 --> 33:40.883
[SPEAKER_01]: This is not normal times.

33:41.683 --> 33:54.236
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what I mean, what's missing is the sense of urgency where the government says we'd better fix this before we have a drone loaded with explosive that lands inside an ammunition factory or an aircraft plan.

33:54.716 --> 33:56.738
[SPEAKER_01]: That's or a big refinery.

33:57.459 --> 33:59.360
[SPEAKER_01]: And these targets are all over.

34:00.277 --> 34:00.537
[SPEAKER_01]: Europe.

34:00.877 --> 34:07.760
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think they're in UK and in Germany, France, they still haven't figured this all out.

34:08.140 --> 34:14.043
[SPEAKER_01]: Even Poland though, Jason, you remember back a few months ago, he had a bunch of drones landed there.

34:14.343 --> 34:16.744
[SPEAKER_01]: There was 10 or 12 and one thing.

34:17.464 --> 34:23.947
[SPEAKER_01]: None of them were carrying a warhead, but they flew in the Polish response was to send up F-35s and F-16s.

34:26.886 --> 34:39.492
[SPEAKER_01]: at least they responded, but you would have thought that of all countries, Poland would have been ready after watching their neighbor, Ukraine get pounded, night after night after night, and the polls were not ready, so still don't have the sense of urgency.

34:40.212 --> 34:53.198
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, this is exactly what I talked about with Glenn Morgan and his book Beyond American Europe, the lack of will and the lack of coordination within the EU to solve these questions.

34:57.420 --> 35:00.492
[SPEAKER_00]: and think about what Ukraine can do differently.

35:01.538 --> 35:04.839
[SPEAKER_00]: There are wartime problems of governance for Zelensky.

35:05.319 --> 35:06.700
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, should there be elections?

35:06.740 --> 35:13.242
[SPEAKER_00]: Shouldn't there be elections if he fires the Chief of Staff or the Defense Minister, is that not democratic?

35:13.802 --> 35:17.683
[SPEAKER_00]: These are really complicated issues for Ukraine to deal with.

35:17.823 --> 35:24.285
[SPEAKER_00]: And then we've been witnessing an extraordinary confrontation between the SBU and the HUR.

35:25.005 --> 35:27.686
[SPEAKER_00]: How worried should we be about

35:28.546 --> 35:38.383
[SPEAKER_00]: Ukraine's own democratic legitimacy failing or rival centers of power and potentially corruption emerging inside Ukraine's security establishment.

35:39.298 --> 35:48.220
[SPEAKER_01]: OK, so I think you and many of your listeners will know that I've been a Ukraine advocate from the beginning going back to 2014 as a vibe.

35:49.000 --> 35:56.862
[SPEAKER_01]: OK, so you can people can take with some salt, what I'm going to say.

35:57.442 --> 35:59.303
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think, first of all,

36:00.378 --> 36:08.111
[SPEAKER_01]: Whenever I talk to Ukrainian friends about, hey, why aren't you doing this, whatever they always will say, our Constitution says this or the law says this.

36:08.451 --> 36:11.736
[SPEAKER_01]: So they are very conscious of legal,

36:12.893 --> 36:15.894
[SPEAKER_01]: their own legal system, their framework, the laws.

36:16.194 --> 36:26.739
[SPEAKER_01]: But it always impressed me that whether we're talking about conscription age or corruption or anything, they're very, very conscious of this.

36:27.119 --> 36:33.922
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that's a good thing, especially for what is an in fact a very young democracy.

36:34.542 --> 36:41.606
[SPEAKER_01]: you know we've been at it for 250 years in the U.S. and you know we're not exactly the ideal right now.

36:42.166 --> 36:49.710
[SPEAKER_01]: So when people point towards a corruption thing in Ukraine like so and so it was arrested or found found with it.

36:50.050 --> 36:58.234
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes that's bad when you see that somebody so close to President Zelensky was arrested but then you say okay well that means there's a there's a

37:02.076 --> 37:05.898
[SPEAKER_01]: The president's closest adviser is not immune from being arrested.

37:06.879 --> 37:11.502
[SPEAKER_01]: To me, that's not a claim that the United States can make right now.

37:11.542 --> 37:12.963
[SPEAKER_00]: And I want to jump in here.

37:13.979 --> 37:35.097
[SPEAKER_00]: Israel was strong when Ehud Almert could go to jail for taking the wrong kind of campaign finance donation, and Israel has become weak and moral pariah in a way when Netanyahu can instantly just stay in power and avoid all the accountability for all of the laws and corruption.

37:35.737 --> 37:38.420
[SPEAKER_00]: If you want to be defending, you need to be

37:39.613 --> 37:43.397
[SPEAKER_00]: defending by honoring your own laws and purpose.

37:43.617 --> 37:49.503
[SPEAKER_00]: And the Israelis were very good at that in the beginning of their phase, and they had become very poor at it now.

37:49.603 --> 38:00.674
[SPEAKER_00]: So, exactly Ukraine's ability to stick to its own laws, constitutions, and values is what would give the moral strength to when the fight.

38:01.294 --> 38:14.367
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think also, in a democratic society, I'm a strong believer that soldiers in democratic countries actually are going to do better than soldiers fighting in some sort of dictatorship or autocracy.

38:14.667 --> 38:22.614
[SPEAKER_01]: There is a, I think a myth or a perception somehow that, you know, man, they decision-making for them is so much easier, they just direct and things happen.

38:23.095 --> 38:25.097
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think that's the way it is on the battlefield.

38:26.598 --> 38:31.923
[SPEAKER_01]: Women and men are defending literally, defending their homeland and their families in Ukraine.

38:32.203 --> 38:40.952
[SPEAKER_01]: They're going to be much more effective than these unlucky draftees or conscripts or who recruits that Russia sends into Ukraine.

38:42.673 --> 38:49.237
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, I do think that the government has got to do a better job of changing the perception of the military.

38:49.257 --> 38:54.539
[SPEAKER_01]: There's still too many people that see the Ukraine army as this old Soviet prison army.

38:55.200 --> 38:58.261
[SPEAKER_01]: How do you Korean your friend describe it that way, to me one time?

38:58.762 --> 39:05.865
[SPEAKER_01]: They have to earn the confidence of families that their son or daughter or brother or whoever if they go in the military, they're not going to be wasted.

39:05.885 --> 39:08.687
[SPEAKER_01]: They're going to be properly training equipped and put in a unit.

39:09.372 --> 39:11.073
[SPEAKER_01]: that is effective.

39:11.293 --> 39:12.553
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what the government has to do.

39:12.573 --> 39:13.453
[SPEAKER_01]: That's not the Army's job.

39:13.473 --> 39:16.314
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the government's job is to make that case with the population.

39:16.414 --> 39:18.295
[SPEAKER_01]: I think they still have a ways to go there.

39:19.115 --> 39:20.135
[SPEAKER_00]: That was very well put.

39:20.615 --> 39:35.100
[SPEAKER_00]: A huge role of the government in any democratic state is to stay constrained by its constitutional legal and checks and balances frameworks so that it has the legitimacy to act and then to make the

39:36.640 --> 39:54.547
[SPEAKER_00]: to its allies in its own population about the reason and the strategic goals, and then that creates the magical advantage of a democracy, which can work in Israel, the UK, Ukraine, and America, of having the people united for a goal, because they see why.

39:54.948 --> 39:59.449
[SPEAKER_00]: And without that, you know, then there's no goal, there's no strategic continuity.

39:59.990 --> 40:01.110
[SPEAKER_00]: We've gotten a lot of wisdom

40:15.447 --> 40:19.494
[SPEAKER_00]: Wow, this has been a great podcast with General Ben Hodges.

40:20.255 --> 40:27.307
[SPEAKER_00]: I would love to draw on his wisdom to try to get to some solutions to order the disorder.

40:28.443 --> 40:43.934
[SPEAKER_00]: you and I both saw from 2014 onward that if Europe did not get together to create a defense industry, a unified command and ability to protect Ukraine, that it would only emboldened Putin.

40:44.695 --> 40:52.080
[SPEAKER_00]: So we are now at a position whereby Trump and Widkov keep suggesting that they can force

40:54.833 --> 40:59.057
[SPEAKER_00]: And Zelensky says, no, Ukraine needs more resources from Europe.

40:59.377 --> 41:02.200
[SPEAKER_00]: We're not going to be forced to give up our territory.

41:02.600 --> 41:07.384
[SPEAKER_00]: We're not going to have some Mafia war lord, twist our arm to do something which is illegal.

41:08.165 --> 41:12.429
[SPEAKER_00]: Is Washington still thinking about Ukraine in terms of managing the war?

41:12.449 --> 41:16.192
[SPEAKER_00]: Or are finally Trump and Whitkoff,

41:17.193 --> 41:21.135
[SPEAKER_00]: and Rubio going to be like, oh, the Ukrainians are winning.

41:21.255 --> 41:22.876
[SPEAKER_00]: Why don't we just enable them to win?

41:23.336 --> 41:28.779
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, first of all, I hope we'll never see Mr. Winkoff or Kushner anywhere near Ukraine or Russia.

41:28.979 --> 41:32.040
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that they have been a total disaster as the negotiating.

41:32.060 --> 41:32.801
[SPEAKER_00]: We know they will.

41:32.821 --> 41:34.501
[SPEAKER_00]: They were just there last week.

41:34.922 --> 41:35.742
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think so.

41:36.082 --> 41:42.485
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the president realizes that and everybody else can see that these guys have not accomplished anything.

41:44.600 --> 41:46.663
[SPEAKER_01]: responsibility of the president to make it clear.

41:46.783 --> 41:53.851
[SPEAKER_01]: So no matter who the negotiating teams are, if the president doesn't make it clear what he wants, then it's not going to work.

41:53.891 --> 41:59.358
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think one of the problems with the administration's approach from the beginning has been that they never cared.

42:00.159 --> 42:04.182
[SPEAKER_01]: why the war started, or why Ukraine is fine, they never cared.

42:04.462 --> 42:14.288
[SPEAKER_01]: All they want is to get it done, whatever that means so that President Trump can take credit for ending a war and also so they can get down to business.

42:14.548 --> 42:20.812
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's why they treat this like a Manhattan real estate situation instead of people fighting for their

42:21.192 --> 42:37.596
[SPEAKER_01]: homeland, and so the approach is going to be wrong, wrong-footed all along, and that's why I think we see Secretary Rubio, he wants nothing to do with this, because he sees it's a disaster, it's a failure, just like in against Iran, so he's trying to keep his fingerprints.

42:38.016 --> 42:44.158
[SPEAKER_01]: Even though he's a Secretary of State and the National Security Advisory, he's trying to stay just connected from it.

42:45.036 --> 42:56.149
[SPEAKER_01]: I think, unfortunately, this administration has no interest in actually bringing about a solution that is acceptable to Ukraine, or that should be acceptable to Europe, by the way.

42:56.833 --> 43:10.325
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so now moving more into solutions, you've spent years arguing that Europe needs to be capable of moving its forces rapidly, building ammunition at scale, creating missile defense and being ready to fight tonight.

43:11.125 --> 43:20.854
[SPEAKER_00]: So what are three things that you would say to European decision makers that would allow them to genuinely be capable of defending themselves?

43:21.434 --> 43:22.335
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, number one,

43:22.935 --> 43:24.636
[SPEAKER_01]: Make sure that you crane defeats Russia.

43:24.656 --> 43:30.959
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the best way to protect all the rest of Europe is that you crane defeats Russia Not just gets a better negotiating position.

43:30.979 --> 43:33.560
[SPEAKER_01]: That's that would be the best investment that they can make.

43:33.600 --> 43:38.662
[SPEAKER_01]: Number two Talk to your populations as if they are adults and explain the risk.

43:39.143 --> 43:44.085
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean people should understand that there will be missiles slamming into Bremerhaven

43:44.645 --> 43:53.690
[SPEAKER_01]: Gagansk and other seaports around Europe because the Russians, if they've made the decision to attack a NATO country, they know that NATO depends on rapid reinforcement.

43:54.070 --> 43:58.953
[SPEAKER_01]: And so airports and seaports are going to get hammered the way Ukrainian cities get hammered.

43:59.313 --> 44:03.196
[SPEAKER_01]: And they need to speak plainly to their population about.

44:03.816 --> 44:22.513
[SPEAKER_01]: that and explain this is what's happening and then the third thing the need to accept the Russia is already at war with Europe even though we don't want to say it we don't have missiles flying into Bremorhaven yet the fact is Russia is violating airspace is using drones is destroying infrastructure

44:23.033 --> 44:40.151
[SPEAKER_01]: It happens all the time, attacking defense industry sites, threatening or planning assassinations of defense industry leaders, shadow fleet vessels sailing out through the Baltic Sea past eight EU slash NATO countries without being stopped sufficiently.

44:40.792 --> 44:42.233
[SPEAKER_01]: These are the kind of things that are going on.

44:42.878 --> 44:53.247
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's quit goofing around and until they can inflict some sort of consequences on the Russians, the Russians are only going to continue moving forward, filling that space.

44:54.248 --> 44:57.771
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to paraphrase strategic communication and deterrence.

44:57.851 --> 44:58.751
[SPEAKER_00]: I put in a green more.

44:59.552 --> 45:04.676
[SPEAKER_00]: Three final bullet questions to close this very wisdom-filled interview.

45:05.733 --> 45:08.535
[SPEAKER_00]: What should Ukraine do differently over the next 12 months?

45:09.515 --> 45:17.200
[SPEAKER_00]: If it wants to not just survive a winter of assaults, but to change the trajectory of the war towards victory.

45:18.248 --> 45:36.898
[SPEAKER_01]: they've got to figure out how do they kill the archer and instead of trying to intercept all the arrows go to the source and that means the factories where Russia is making missiles and also the where the North Korean missiles are coming in and anything from China how can you get that at the source?

45:37.678 --> 45:39.058
[SPEAKER_01]: versus trying to intercept.

45:39.138 --> 45:43.619
[SPEAKER_01]: Of course, you crannies know that, but that would be part of an overall effort.

45:43.659 --> 45:51.341
[SPEAKER_01]: That would be, to me, it had to be at the top of my list, as well as, of course, continue in the attack on Russian oil and gas infrastructure.

45:52.201 --> 45:53.402
[SPEAKER_00]: Penultimate question.

45:54.242 --> 45:59.263
[SPEAKER_00]: We are speaking 25 years after 9-11, even though this episode is airing slightly after that.

46:00.284 --> 46:15.238
[SPEAKER_00]: What would an American grand strategy design to restore order and protect global order actually look like if in 2022, a new administration was coming into place that actually wanted to help order the globe?

46:15.839 --> 46:16.579
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

46:16.700 --> 46:22.165
[SPEAKER_01]: The importance of alliances and international institutions being effective,

46:22.647 --> 46:32.572
[SPEAKER_01]: and working with the United States being a trusted member of these things and being invested in them instead of viewing them as competitors or the enemy somehow.

46:33.453 --> 46:41.677
[SPEAKER_01]: We've benefited from a system for so long that was never perfect, but nobody benefited from it more than did the United States.

46:42.157 --> 46:47.740
[SPEAKER_01]: And now we're seeing, we're now paying the price for wrecking what was a very good system.

46:48.490 --> 46:54.254
[SPEAKER_00]: From your mouth to God's ears, I agree with literally everywhere I've heard, which leads us to our final question.

46:54.755 --> 47:00.219
[SPEAKER_00]: I knew you were going to reference allies, institutions, and a collective order.

47:01.100 --> 47:14.570
[SPEAKER_00]: If you could create one international organization or global institution to deal with the 21st century challenges, AI, climate, tax havens, kleptocracy,

47:18.007 --> 47:20.491
[SPEAKER_00]: do and how would it work?

47:20.611 --> 47:30.868
[SPEAKER_01]: I have to say Jason, I don't know that creating new organizations is always the best way to solve problems unless it's demonstrated that you need the new organization.

47:30.908 --> 47:32.090
[SPEAKER_01]: I think we've got so many

47:33.015 --> 47:52.031
[SPEAKER_01]: or had so many different frameworks for addressing these things, that I'd like to be sure we are trying to use what existed already, and work them more closely with the Congress to make sure you get the laws right and that you've got the will of the people is included in this as well.

47:52.611 --> 47:53.512
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, I love it.

47:54.633 --> 47:59.597
[SPEAKER_00]: It is important to build with what we have and to make it work more functionally.

48:00.017 --> 48:01.778
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for ordering the disorder with me.

48:02.780 --> 48:03.760
[SPEAKER_00]: General Ben Hodges.

48:04.560 --> 48:05.281
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Jason.

48:05.301 --> 48:06.861
[SPEAKER_00]: I've really enjoyed being on the show.

48:06.881 --> 48:11.402
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for the privilege.

48:11.962 --> 48:12.362
[SPEAKER_00]: Wow.

48:12.602 --> 48:21.184
[SPEAKER_00]: I hope you, the listener, have enjoyed hearing from General Ben Hodges as much as I have enjoyed discussing things with him.

48:22.644 --> 48:27.265
[SPEAKER_00]: If you found that inspirational as I did, please join our mega-orderers club.

48:28.069 --> 48:43.698
[SPEAKER_00]: You're going to have extra content there about my personal experiences of 9-11, 25 years ago, and how that changed my life, you're going to have ed free listening, you're going to have early release episodes, and my reaction to the guests, like you're going to have for this episode.

48:43.718 --> 48:45.179
[SPEAKER_00]: I have a lot that I want to respond.

48:46.145 --> 48:58.529
[SPEAKER_00]: Perhaps the lesson of the less-quarter century is that American power remains enormous, but power without clear objectives functioning alliances, an idea of the order you are trying to create can itself become an engine of disorder.

48:59.090 --> 49:02.791
[SPEAKER_00]: That's what I'm going to explore on the mega-orderer's response episode.

49:03.712 --> 49:04.152
[SPEAKER_00]: to this.

49:05.392 --> 49:09.533
[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, please join the mega ordering club if you want to hear that bonus.

49:10.453 --> 49:25.657
[SPEAKER_00]: Check out the show notes where we have the link to the sub stack and we'll also put back around about NATO the 25th anniversary of 9-11 and Ben Hodges amazing career.

49:26.737 --> 49:31.118
[SPEAKER_00]: As always, this episode has been produced by the one the only the George McDonald.

49:32.502 --> 49:38.747
[SPEAKER_00]: and disorder is powered by red circle our new co-production partners.

49:40.869 --> 49:45.313
[SPEAKER_00]: I want to wish you a happy September.

49:45.333 --> 49:51.718
[SPEAKER_00]: It is a moment where new things can emerge and back to school vibes are at play.

49:52.919 --> 49:56.222
[SPEAKER_00]: So, I am wishing you very orderness.

