WEBVTT

00:11.411 --> 00:22.734
[SPEAKER_02]: Dr. Michael Robb is a developmental psychologist and head of research at Common Sense Media, where he studies how media and technology are shaping the lives of kids and families.

00:23.618 --> 00:42.720
[SPEAKER_02]: In this conversation, we unpack common sense media's research on teens and pornography, including how young people are being exposed, what teens believe they're learning about sex from pornography, and how well they recognize the gap between porn and real life sex and relationships.

00:43.730 --> 00:58.139
[SPEAKER_02]: We also explore the rapidly changing landscape of AI-generated sexual content from explicit deepfakes to entirely unrealistic AI bodies, and what adults need to understand about helping young people navigate it.

00:58.999 --> 01:00.560
[SPEAKER_02]: With that, let's jump in.

01:01.361 --> 01:04.803
[SPEAKER_02]: We hope you enjoy this episode of Consider Before Consuming.

01:06.947 --> 01:11.758
[SPEAKER_00]: Dr. Michael Robham, so grateful to have you here joining us today on the Considerable for Consuming Podcast.

01:12.360 --> 01:15.707
[SPEAKER_00]: To start, can you introduce yourself and tell us a little bit about the work that you do?

01:16.610 --> 01:17.150
[SPEAKER_03]: Sure.

01:17.170 --> 01:18.151
[SPEAKER_03]: My name is Michael Robb.

01:18.211 --> 01:20.452
[SPEAKER_03]: I am the Head of Research at Common Sense Media.

01:21.273 --> 01:24.135
[SPEAKER_03]: I am a developmental psychologist by training.

01:24.935 --> 01:32.920
[SPEAKER_03]: And for the last decade or more, my job has essentially been to ask kids and families what their lives actually look like.

01:33.361 --> 01:34.582
[SPEAKER_03]: Especially as it relates to media.

01:34.642 --> 01:36.503
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, what are they watching?

01:36.543 --> 01:37.383
[SPEAKER_03]: What are they playing?

01:37.423 --> 01:38.364
[SPEAKER_03]: What are they using?

01:39.164 --> 01:41.406
[SPEAKER_03]: For parents, it's often about what's concerning them?

01:41.506 --> 01:42.487
[SPEAKER_03]: What are they excited about?

01:43.367 --> 01:48.693
[SPEAKER_03]: And then turn that into something that parents or educators or policy makers can act on.

01:49.594 --> 01:55.720
[SPEAKER_03]: I think a lot of the conversation around kids and technology runs on either anecdotes or runs on fear.

01:56.321 --> 01:59.164
[SPEAKER_03]: And so my job is to try to put real numbers underneath it.

01:59.484 --> 02:02.728
[SPEAKER_03]: So we're arguing about something that's of these that we're trying to measure.

02:03.973 --> 02:06.674
[SPEAKER_00]: It's very well said and we love the work common sense media does.

02:06.714 --> 02:13.817
[SPEAKER_00]: We reference it often, we're always excited when new research is coming out and I'm excited to get to discuss that with you today.

02:14.037 --> 02:20.679
[SPEAKER_00]: What role does research play in common sense media's broader work with kids, families, media and technology?

02:21.399 --> 02:30.345
[SPEAKER_03]: Sure, it is the foundation, honestly, because I think everything else that we do in common sense works better when we try to start from an evidence base.

02:31.066 --> 02:35.029
[SPEAKER_03]: And on a practical level, research does three things for us.

02:35.669 --> 02:42.234
[SPEAKER_03]: Number one, it helps parents to understand, kind of what's normal, you know, what's up, what else is happening out there.

02:42.254 --> 02:44.976
[SPEAKER_03]: I think a lot of parental anxiety comes from

02:45.796 --> 02:48.558
[SPEAKER_03]: not knowing whether their kid is the only one dealing with something.

02:49.479 --> 02:56.704
[SPEAKER_03]: I think we also, you know, the research helps to give educators a picture of what's actually walking into their classrooms.

02:57.605 --> 03:07.152
[SPEAKER_03]: And lastly, it helps to give policy makers something concrete because, you know, just saying, I'm worried about this does not move legislation.

03:07.532 --> 03:10.315
[SPEAKER_03]: But a, you know, a nationally representative number, good.

03:11.635 --> 03:15.378
[SPEAKER_03]: So the only other thing I'd say there is that the research helps to keep us honest.

03:15.998 --> 03:22.082
[SPEAKER_03]: So sometimes we go into a study expecting one thing and maybe the data says something different.

03:22.403 --> 03:25.765
[SPEAKER_03]: And then we have to change what we're telling families and that's just the nature of the job.

03:26.610 --> 03:26.850
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

03:27.271 --> 03:47.166
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's so important to mention as you spoke about how sometimes when we want to address these issues that's driven by fear, and sometimes we're afraid that the impact or the outcome of something might be one thing, but data shows us it's actually something completely different, and that's really important for us to make sure we're addressing the correct pieces of any of these issues.

03:47.246 --> 03:49.507
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's so so important to have that foundation.

03:50.068 --> 03:51.709
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I think more often than

03:53.581 --> 04:02.584
[SPEAKER_03]: It's not just giving the numbers like I feel like my job is often being like Captain Kiljoy and the terms of trying to get people like more complete and nuanced picture of what's going on.

04:03.044 --> 04:10.907
[SPEAKER_03]: So often when we talk about the things that are happening in kids lives we want to boil it down to like just one thing and it's very rarely just one thing.

04:10.927 --> 04:18.009
[SPEAKER_03]: You know they're they're very things so portable at solutions to really really big problems and in kids lives weren't society more broadly.

04:19.220 --> 04:32.073
[SPEAKER_00]: Well said and you know you've spent year studying young people's experiences with media and technology and when you look at kids growing up today, what has changed most significantly about the environment that they're growing up in now.

04:32.774 --> 04:34.476
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean there are several shifts.

04:34.856 --> 04:36.517
[SPEAKER_03]: So I'm going to cheap a couple of them.

04:37.718 --> 04:44.662
[SPEAKER_03]: I think one of the big shifts is that content that kids encounter is not something that kids go to find anymore.

04:44.822 --> 04:45.722
[SPEAKER_03]: It comes to them.

04:46.323 --> 04:53.547
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, when I was a kid, if you wanted to see something, you had to go looking and there was some friction at every step.

04:54.087 --> 04:54.888
[SPEAKER_03]: You needed a place.

04:55.308 --> 04:58.690
[SPEAKER_03]: If you were trying to see something that you weren't supposed to see, maybe you needed some privacy.

04:59.430 --> 05:00.291
[SPEAKER_03]: You needed a bit of luck.

05:01.211 --> 05:07.595
[SPEAKER_03]: And now the delivery mechanism is a recommendation algorithm and it doesn't care how old you are.

05:07.735 --> 05:19.101
[SPEAKER_03]: It doesn't often care whether you ask for something, kids, you know, when they you talk to them, they say they're kind of getting hit with things when they're just scrolling or even like in the middle of a mobile game or in an ad.

05:19.741 --> 05:21.062
[SPEAKER_03]: So that's a big shift.

05:21.622 --> 05:24.644
[SPEAKER_03]: I think a second one is that there's no longer a

05:25.644 --> 05:29.086
[SPEAKER_03]: a clean line between being an audience and being a subject.

05:29.106 --> 05:32.328
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, because kids used to consume media, that was about other people.

05:32.868 --> 05:41.613
[SPEAKER_03]: And now media gets made, or can get made about them, or it's made by them, or by their peers, and sometimes it's made without them knowing, I think that is a new...

05:42.744 --> 05:44.364
[SPEAKER_03]: psychological situation to grow up in.

05:44.404 --> 05:47.125
[SPEAKER_03]: I don't think we've fully vacuumed it, but I can do it with it.

05:48.145 --> 05:49.666
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think the third thing is the speed, right?

05:49.706 --> 05:54.267
[SPEAKER_03]: The gap between a technology arriving and adults figuring out how to handle it.

05:54.327 --> 05:59.388
[SPEAKER_03]: So perhaps that used to be in historical times, maybe that was years and now it's months.

06:00.368 --> 06:09.790
[SPEAKER_03]: And the institutions that are supposed to protect kids, your schools, laws, policies that individual technology platforms have, they're just structurally, very slow.

06:10.510 --> 06:16.395
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, we're still getting a handle on social media, and now we're also dealing with AI, so it just goes very fast.

06:16.595 --> 06:16.815
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

06:17.216 --> 06:24.321
[SPEAKER_00]: The safeguards can't necessarily keep up with the speed at which technologies advancing and the impact that that's having on young people.

06:24.542 --> 06:24.882
[SPEAKER_03]: That's right.

06:25.955 --> 06:43.762
[SPEAKER_00]: In 2023, common sense media released a report, which we reference all of the time called teens in pornography, and it's a nationally representative survey looking at teens exposure to and use of online pornography, and what prompted you to conduct that research and what were you hoping to better understand.

06:45.169 --> 06:45.809
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.

06:45.829 --> 06:46.409
[SPEAKER_03]: Great question.

06:46.770 --> 06:49.170
[SPEAKER_03]: What prompted it was there was a gap there, right?

06:49.190 --> 06:59.114
[SPEAKER_03]: There was a lot of strong opinion about teens and pornography and very little, you know, recent nationally representative US data.

06:59.534 --> 07:06.616
[SPEAKER_03]: So most of what existed was either older data, some of those coming from other countries or those small samples you couldn't really generalize from it.

07:07.157 --> 07:10.378
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, we have having debates or just kind of running on assumptions.

07:11.138 --> 07:14.161
[SPEAKER_03]: And we just kept hearing from parents and educators who wanted to know some very basic things.

07:14.301 --> 07:15.262
[SPEAKER_03]: How common is this?

07:16.022 --> 07:17.424
[SPEAKER_03]: How young is it affecting kids?

07:18.104 --> 07:19.826
[SPEAKER_03]: Or are they being exposed?

07:19.926 --> 07:22.708
[SPEAKER_03]: Is this happening like on purpose or is it happening to them?

07:22.788 --> 07:24.910
[SPEAKER_03]: And what do kids think they're getting out of it?

07:24.950 --> 07:28.573
[SPEAKER_03]: That's a question that that last question I think is one that we should also think more about.

07:28.853 --> 07:31.295
[SPEAKER_03]: Because I think this is there's a tendency to treat.

07:31.956 --> 07:46.881
[SPEAKER_03]: issues around online pornography and kids is just kind of a purely moral issue, you know, should they or shouldn't they, they and skip past some of the developmental questions that I'm interested in too, which is, you know, if the 12 year old is watching this, what is here she learning, learning something.

07:47.941 --> 07:50.182
[SPEAKER_03]: So we want to ask us directly instead of guessing on their behalf.

07:51.049 --> 08:01.277
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, which is so important, especially when we are making decisions about safeguards to protect children, we need to know what their actual experiences are with regard to things like this.

08:01.337 --> 08:09.003
[SPEAKER_00]: So the survey found that 73% of teens had seen online pornography with the average reported age of 1st exposure being 12 years old.

08:09.523 --> 08:13.827
[SPEAKER_00]: What stood out to you about how early and how common young people were encountering this content?

08:15.457 --> 08:16.878
[SPEAKER_03]: So I think two things stand out.

08:17.678 --> 08:22.380
[SPEAKER_03]: The first is that 12 is an average, which means a lot of kids are actually in below that.

08:23.340 --> 08:31.884
[SPEAKER_03]: And in that original 2023 study that we did, 15% of kids told us that they first saw pornography when they were 10 or younger.

08:32.244 --> 08:34.705
[SPEAKER_03]: So that's like around four fifth grade somewhere around there.

08:35.345 --> 08:43.109
[SPEAKER_03]: And in this new research set, we just released a few months ago, 12% said H10 or under and more than half had seen it by 12.

08:43.189 --> 08:47.791
[SPEAKER_03]: So it's fairly stable in our measurements, and it's pretty early, I think.

08:48.471 --> 08:55.215
[SPEAKER_03]: The second thing, and this is the one that I think parents are interested in, most of this isn't necessarily a choice.

08:55.895 --> 09:05.642
[SPEAKER_03]: So in the data that we have 61% of teens say that they have encountered pornography accidentally, and only 43% say that they've ever sought it out.

09:05.682 --> 09:06.943
[SPEAKER_03]: And there's over that between those two groups.

09:06.963 --> 09:10.105
[SPEAKER_03]: You can seek it out intentionally, or you could encounter accidentally.

09:10.525 --> 09:18.631
[SPEAKER_03]: But the headline is that the single most common way in American teenager first is pornography is not necessarily by looking for directly.

09:19.011 --> 09:21.413
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think that helps to reframe some of the conversation.

09:22.133 --> 09:29.496
[SPEAKER_03]: because if you're thinking of this as a discipline problem, you will respond one way.

09:30.136 --> 09:40.480
[SPEAKER_03]: And if you're thinking of this as an exposure problem, that it's arriving like uninvited into kids, feeds, maybe years before a kid has kind of any framework funder standing it, you may respond differently.

09:40.860 --> 09:45.762
[SPEAKER_03]: So it helps to stop being about catching your kid and more about preparing them.

09:46.845 --> 10:09.030
[SPEAKER_00]: That's really well said, you know, we often say it's not if it's when the young people will be exposed to pornography because so often it's not that they're seeking it out or it's that, you know, if parents have all of the quote unquote right or correct safeguards in place, they have filters, all of these things kids can still be exposed because there are so many different ways that that young people are

10:17.152 --> 10:43.178
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and actually in our earlier study, we asked about parent controls and in our that 2020 study only about a third of kids Sorry about a third of Of teens said that there were either content filters or controls active at all and that would and that dropped more like the older they got So right you know the older they got the less likely to work at the end of kind of controls And even when they exist, you know, sometimes those controls were aimed at the wrong target because like a filter is built to block a category or a website

10:43.878 --> 10:53.209
[SPEAKER_03]: It's not necessarily dope for a video that can serve as in a social feed or an ad inside of a like a mobile game that they're download or even just something that like a friend would drop into a group chat where a lot of this might happen.

10:53.869 --> 11:02.259
[SPEAKER_03]: So yeah, the practical controls I think is it's a part of the solution but it's um, it doesn't replace a conversation for sure.

11:02.955 --> 11:05.956
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, it's another example of technology advancing.

11:05.996 --> 11:15.299
[SPEAKER_00]: So rapidly, the ways that these ads can be implemented into games or other things so much more quickly than filtration software can keep up with oftentimes.

11:15.319 --> 11:19.980
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's certainly, it's a tool that can be used, but as you mentioned, it doesn't replace the conversation.

11:20.300 --> 11:22.661
[SPEAKER_00]: And I want to talk more about that in just a moment.

11:23.421 --> 11:30.383
[SPEAKER_00]: Speaking about kind of intentionally seeking out pornography, what did research tell you about why boys in particular,

11:30.923 --> 11:33.465
[SPEAKER_00]: or intentionally seeking out pornography at higher rates.

11:34.586 --> 11:49.038
[SPEAKER_03]: So I think that gap between the intentionality and accidental, like that's a real gap in our new data, 53% of boys say they've sought out pornography intentionally compared with 32% of girls overall exposure is high for both groups.

11:49.378 --> 11:56.203
[SPEAKER_03]: So 79% of boys and 68% of girls say they've seen it, but that intentional seeking is kind of where they diverge.

11:56.964 --> 11:58.205
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's for why you see that gap.

11:58.225 --> 12:08.191
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, I point to a few things that some of the broader research on this topic supports and that some of the interviews we've done one on one with kids about the subjects I had echoed.

12:09.752 --> 12:18.998
[SPEAKER_03]: Some of it is that boys report more solitary use that's tied to things like masturbation or pornography is mapping on to that desire directly.

12:19.578 --> 12:22.059
[SPEAKER_03]: Some of it is social, you know, for boys, this...

12:23.240 --> 12:35.403
[SPEAKER_03]: like a pornography can circulate as a group activity, something that you might send to a friend or joke about, that might lower the barrier, and some of it might be that girls face a higher social cost for admitting to it, so there's probably some under-reporting in that gap.

12:36.263 --> 12:50.366
[SPEAKER_03]: So, but yeah, the question about gaps is interesting, especially when I think about boys and girls, because I think sometimes it gets framed as a boy problem, and when that happens, then girls stop getting asked about it, and girls are seeing this content, so they need to

12:53.770 --> 12:54.570
[SPEAKER_00]: That's really well said.

12:54.590 --> 13:09.214
[SPEAKER_00]: I think culturally, there's certainly an acceptance in normalization, more so of boys consuming pornography than of girls, but it's certainly something that we were seeing, you know, fight the new drug our nonprofit was founded 17 years ago at this point.

13:09.734 --> 13:20.116
[SPEAKER_00]: And I would say what we were seeing with the normalization kind of split by gender around that time versus now is certainly we're seeing many more women and girls

13:24.197 --> 13:31.421
[SPEAKER_00]: as well as being targeted by pornography in ways that maybe it was previously targeting men and boys primarily.

13:31.481 --> 13:40.645
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's really important to have this conversation and be aware that this is something that even if culturally it's normalized for more for boys it's certainly something boys and girls are both seeing.

13:41.185 --> 13:41.606
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely.

13:42.946 --> 13:47.829
[SPEAKER_00]: I think people would be surprised by where teens are in kind of ring pornography.

13:47.949 --> 13:50.130
[SPEAKER_00]: So can you share a bit about where that's happening now?

13:51.053 --> 13:57.197
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and I think it is interesting because maybe it changes people's mental picture of how you encounter pornography.

13:57.277 --> 14:01.360
[SPEAKER_03]: I think the assumption is that it's happening on pornography websites, and that is true.

14:01.400 --> 14:01.660
[SPEAKER_03]: It is.

14:02.481 --> 14:04.682
[SPEAKER_03]: Those matter, but that is definitely not the whole story.

14:05.403 --> 14:18.952
[SPEAKER_03]: Teams tell us that they are seeing it regularly on social media, and on mainstream video platforms, places that nobody necessarily think of as adult sites that are on kids phones, that a lot of parents have approved.

14:20.221 --> 14:24.205
[SPEAKER_03]: And sometimes the places where kids here are really surprising.

14:24.245 --> 14:30.211
[SPEAKER_03]: So in our last study, 30% of teens said that they'd seen pornography during the school day.

14:30.892 --> 14:33.515
[SPEAKER_03]: So like not at home, not at midnight in the room, but at school.

14:34.035 --> 14:37.198
[SPEAKER_03]: And all of those teens, 44% said it happened on a school issued device.

14:38.117 --> 14:45.762
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, I think the mod of that a lot of parents have that this is like an a bedroom at night thing or this is like just a personal phone thing.

14:46.342 --> 14:55.548
[SPEAKER_03]: It's incomplete because it's happening in lots of spaces, it's happening in fees, it's happening in ads and games and group chats potentially on the laptop that the school district can't do it out.

14:56.449 --> 15:04.094
[SPEAKER_03]: Which is why things like filtering software alone was never gonna be the answer because you can't filter your way out of a delivery system that brought,

15:05.168 --> 15:34.362
[SPEAKER_00]: right exactly and you know even if you have all of the right things in place you won't always be with your child and they will be around other children with other devices with other safe guards in place or not in place and so it's just it's really important to have conversations as you mentioned which will continue to talk about one of the findings that really stands out is that 45% of teens say pornography is provided them with helpful information about sex so this goes back to what you pointed out earlier about what are they learning from this

15:34.903 --> 15:42.884
[SPEAKER_00]: And when teens describe pornography as quote-unquote helpful for learning about sex, what do we know about what they believe they're learning from it?

15:43.468 --> 15:45.570
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, that helpful framing is interesting.

15:45.670 --> 15:49.293
[SPEAKER_03]: Yes, 45% said pornography gave them helpful information about sex.

15:49.693 --> 15:51.494
[SPEAKER_03]: And then we asked, like, what specifically?

15:51.514 --> 15:58.620
[SPEAKER_03]: And then about four and five said that it was helpful for them just about learning how to have sex.

15:59.421 --> 16:04.144
[SPEAKER_03]: About three quarters said it was helpful because they learned what behaviors might be or pleasurable for them.

16:05.185 --> 16:10.770
[SPEAKER_03]: A similar amount said that the well-learning about what kinds of partners might be attractive to them.

16:11.510 --> 16:20.197
[SPEAKER_03]: And so it's important, I think, to try to understand what's happening here rather than just being alarmed by it, because I could, again, that helpful framing is important.

16:20.718 --> 16:23.079
[SPEAKER_03]: Like, the kids are not, they're not being perverse.

16:23.260 --> 16:27.903
[SPEAKER_03]: They have real questions about, you know, what is, what's happening here?

16:27.923 --> 16:31.406
[SPEAKER_03]: You know, what might be expected of me.

16:31.426 --> 16:35.529
[SPEAKER_03]: Certainly questions about, like, is my body normal or what does somebody want me to look like?

16:36.350 --> 16:38.991
[SPEAKER_03]: and pornography is a source that might answer those questions.

16:39.011 --> 16:42.533
[SPEAKER_03]: No, doesn't answer it correctly, maybe not.

16:42.953 --> 16:51.257
[SPEAKER_03]: But it is something that is available immediately privately at any hour with no adult present, no judgment present.

16:51.777 --> 16:57.360
[SPEAKER_03]: And you compare that to a sexized class that may or may not exist or a parent conversation that feels excruciating to them.

16:58.060 --> 16:59.901
[SPEAKER_03]: This may feel to some teams like a better choice.

17:00.081 --> 17:02.683
[SPEAKER_03]: Again, it might not actually be, but it might feel to a team like it is.

17:03.463 --> 17:10.392
[SPEAKER_03]: Um, obviously the problem here, like if that's the way they're feeling like this is essentially a curriculum that nobody has designed.

17:10.412 --> 17:10.973
[SPEAKER_03]: Right.

17:11.033 --> 17:16.721
[SPEAKER_03]: It's a pornography curriculum that is optimized for a browser and engagement and not accuracy.

17:17.201 --> 17:20.886
[SPEAKER_03]: So you're missing all the lessons on things like communication or consent.

17:21.667 --> 17:44.418
[SPEAKER_03]: Um, very few kids say they've ever seen pornography that, you know, we're somebody's asking for consent and more than half said they had seen depictions of the opposite of where, you know, more violent pornography that involved things like, uh, uh, they're simulated rape, choking, someone who seemed to be in pain, so they're, they're getting some kind of an education, it's oftentimes a, a bad one, um, but it might be the one that's available.

17:44.498 --> 17:48.260
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think that, maybe that's an indictment of the alternative, more than of, of the

17:49.655 --> 17:49.915
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

17:50.235 --> 17:58.618
[SPEAKER_00]: And how well our teens able to distinguish between pornography as performance and what sex and relationships actually look like in real life?

18:00.039 --> 18:05.981
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, the honest answer is probably better than adults give them credit for and probably less well than they give themselves credit for.

18:06.622 --> 18:07.642
[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, they're probably true.

18:07.662 --> 18:08.622
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.

18:08.762 --> 18:14.965
[SPEAKER_03]: I think only a quarter of teens say that pornography accurately shows the way that most people have sex.

18:15.625 --> 18:20.987
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, that means roughly three quarters of them know that its performance or not really accurate.

18:21.547 --> 18:28.889
[SPEAKER_03]: And when you talk to them, like they'll tell you it's fake and that it's staged, or like the body's aren't realistic, that's not how anybody believes behaves.

18:29.509 --> 18:36.532
[SPEAKER_03]: So, they're not necessarily naive, but I think that knowing something is fake, and then being unaffected by it are different things.

18:37.252 --> 18:39.953
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, that's probably a good place to push back on

18:41.050 --> 18:43.653
[SPEAKER_03]: an argument that, well, kids are savvy, they'll be fine, argument.

18:44.113 --> 18:49.559
[SPEAKER_03]: You can know perfectly well that a magazine covers airbrush and you can still feel plenty bad about your body.

18:50.940 --> 18:56.205
[SPEAKER_03]: Cause knowledge is not something that just automatically neutralizes the influence of something I have.

18:56.265 --> 18:58.568
[SPEAKER_03]: Especially when that exposure starts really young, right?

18:58.588 --> 19:02.592
[SPEAKER_03]: When it's starting at 11 or 12, before there's any real, really experienced to compare it against.

19:03.112 --> 19:21.480
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, that's a developmental issue, if you're first several hundred impressions of sex arrive before, yeah, held anybody's hand, like that material is not competing with reality, it's just establishing like a baseline and that baseline just go even if you're wanting eventually.

19:22.781 --> 19:32.729
[SPEAKER_00]: That's very well said, and I think going back to the point, we keep bringing up about this idea that, you know, safeguards don't replace a conversation, but I think it actually is even broader.

19:33.009 --> 19:39.014
[SPEAKER_00]: We're looking to replace just one single conversation with an ongoing discussion between trusted adults and young people, right?

19:39.034 --> 19:41.676
[SPEAKER_00]: Because young people have questions about sex.

19:41.696 --> 19:42.677
[SPEAKER_00]: That's natural and normal.

19:42.717 --> 19:43.637
[SPEAKER_00]: Their bodies are changing.

19:43.677 --> 19:44.338
[SPEAKER_00]: They have hormones.

19:44.358 --> 19:46.860
[SPEAKER_00]: They're trying to learn what's going on.

19:46.980 --> 19:50.283
[SPEAKER_00]: And if they don't have a trusted adult, they can go to with these

19:50.843 --> 20:15.540
[SPEAKER_00]: these questions in an ongoing way as things come up then they will search it online and they will seek out answers from something that even if they can determine okay this is a little far-fetched it still can have that impact as you mentioned which can affect I mean sexual templates affect relationships for years to come without being able to have that kind of real world tangible conversation with the trusted adult to help guide them through these things as well.

20:16.421 --> 20:22.963
[SPEAKER_03]: Yes agreed and it's all the more reason why you start those conversations early rather than later.

20:23.003 --> 20:37.027
[SPEAKER_03]: I think there's a temptation like oh my kids not ready yet, but right the it's actually easier than a lot of ways to talk to young kids it's a little less embarrassing than talking to a teen more like the it's just kind of I mean it might not have a ton of questions for you but they

20:39.009 --> 20:55.388
[SPEAKER_03]: they are genuinely interested and I think more going to hear you out and hear like your point of view as a parent or trusted adult or whoever you are to that child about like what is realistic and what's not realistic and kind of what your values are because that conversation and I can feel cringy when you're a teen.

20:56.349 --> 20:57.350
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

20:57.550 --> 21:05.035
[SPEAKER_00]: And we often hear that adults are less comfortable with the conversation than teens actually, because teens do want answers to questions they have.

21:05.115 --> 21:08.578
[SPEAKER_00]: And so it's something that it takes a lot of work on all parts.

21:08.618 --> 21:12.201
[SPEAKER_00]: And we have some wonderful discussion guides on how to have healthy conversations about pornography.

21:12.221 --> 21:14.302
[SPEAKER_00]: There are lots of other resources out there as well.

21:14.902 --> 21:21.607
[SPEAKER_00]: But that is something to remember that the earlier those age-appropriate conversations can start kind of the better when it comes to these

21:22.748 --> 21:34.497
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, since your earlier research on teens and pornography, generative AI has made it possible for young people, not only to consume explicit content, but to create it, which is something you kind of mentioned earlier.

21:34.617 --> 21:36.739
[SPEAKER_00]: How significant is that shift?

21:37.979 --> 21:39.460
[SPEAKER_03]: It's a pretty significant shift.

21:39.600 --> 21:40.940
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, it's a different thing, right?

21:40.960 --> 21:49.544
[SPEAKER_03]: So you now you have a person in image who never agreed, never participated, may have no idea it exists if it's a real person, a representation of a real person.

21:50.004 --> 21:53.745
[SPEAKER_03]: Their contribution might have been just the posting of a photo with their face and some other context.

21:54.786 --> 21:57.767
[SPEAKER_03]: And the barrier to doing or creating this content is gone, right?

21:57.807 --> 21:59.627
[SPEAKER_03]: Does this not require skill or equipment?

22:00.268 --> 22:02.889
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, all you need is like a few minutes on a phone here to do this.

22:03.809 --> 22:13.081
[SPEAKER_03]: And we had a boy in one of our studies, you know, when we were talking to them, and you basically just said, you know, with no hurdles or anything you have to jump over, you can just do it right there, right?

22:13.101 --> 22:14.783
[SPEAKER_03]: You just see knowledge is how easy it was.

22:15.384 --> 22:20.751
[SPEAKER_03]: So you have a different risk profile, every teenager who

22:22.284 --> 22:27.868
[SPEAKER_03]: has ever posted a picture of their face is now potentially the subject of pornography.

22:28.769 --> 22:33.232
[SPEAKER_03]: And on the other side, a 14 year old can commit a very serious legal offense.

22:33.732 --> 22:39.676
[SPEAKER_03]: Regenerating a sexual image of a minor, like a classmate or something, like that's child sexual abuse material.

22:39.736 --> 22:40.297
[SPEAKER_03]: It's a felony.

22:40.937 --> 22:44.600
[SPEAKER_03]: So, and you can do that in about the time it takes to send a text.

22:44.920 --> 22:46.681
[SPEAKER_03]: You know, when you're thinking that you're doing a company prank.

22:47.002 --> 22:48.383
[SPEAKER_03]: So, it's a shift, right?

22:49.203 --> 22:53.846
[SPEAKER_03]: It's like a different category almost, and it's a new way that it's going to hurt each other.

22:53.866 --> 22:55.387
[SPEAKER_03]: They may not even know what they're doing.

22:56.267 --> 22:56.567
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

22:57.048 --> 23:05.633
[SPEAKER_00]: And in your latest research, what did it reveal about how teens are encountering and engaging with AI-generated pornography and sexual content?

23:06.608 --> 23:08.869
[SPEAKER_03]: So this was a nationally representative survey.

23:08.889 --> 23:20.477
[SPEAKER_03]: So over 1,300 kids between the ages of 13 to 17, of those more than 1,000 kids, 44% of teens said that they had seen sexual content, they believe was AI-generated.

23:20.757 --> 23:30.023
[SPEAKER_03]: And I say sexual content because there's a lot of material out there that's not necessarily, there's not involved either sexual, like explicit nudity, but it might just be sexual in nature.

23:30.543 --> 23:30.723
[SPEAKER_03]: Right.

23:30.763 --> 23:36.489
[SPEAKER_03]: And it could involve like, you know, putting somebody in very skimpy clothing or in compromising situations like that.

23:36.549 --> 23:38.851
[SPEAKER_03]: So 44% I think seen that kind of sexual content.

23:39.572 --> 23:42.815
[SPEAKER_03]: For most of them, they didn't seek it out, similar to our last survey.

23:43.075 --> 23:52.524
[SPEAKER_03]: So 79% of those who had seen that AI-generated content said it came across their came across and then mostly accidentally mostly in their social media feeds.

23:53.345 --> 24:00.754
[SPEAKER_03]: And then among teams who said they've seen this content about a quarter said that they had at some point either seen it to picking themselves or someone they know personally.

24:01.976 --> 24:05.820
[SPEAKER_03]: And again, among those who had seen it more than one in ten had seen it themselves.

24:06.321 --> 24:10.526
[SPEAKER_03]: So this wasn't just like deep thanks of celebrities, like those other people in your school.

24:13.053 --> 24:16.435
[SPEAKER_03]: I think the other thing here is that it's not just a receiving thing, it's also a creation thing.

24:17.215 --> 24:24.098
[SPEAKER_03]: So 8% of the teams in our survey said that they personally created AI-generated sexual content.

24:24.458 --> 24:27.440
[SPEAKER_03]: And 13% of teams said that they know somebody who had.

24:27.940 --> 24:29.241
[SPEAKER_03]: So you can call it one in five.

24:30.281 --> 24:39.188
[SPEAKER_03]: we're inside that circle one way or another, and all of those about two thirds say the concept depicted someone, someone they knew or depicted themselves.

24:39.769 --> 24:42.371
[SPEAKER_03]: So you know, a lot of people are creating this as well.

24:43.732 --> 24:46.114
[SPEAKER_03]: So yeah, it's a lot.

24:46.814 --> 24:54.140
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and boys were more likely than girls to report creating AI-generated pornography, what do we know about what's driving that difference?

24:56.447 --> 25:01.370
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, I could just probably separate out what we can measure from what we can reasonably infer.

25:01.390 --> 25:06.253
[SPEAKER_03]: Well, we measured as that boys are more likely to be seeking sexual content generally.

25:06.894 --> 25:09.795
[SPEAKER_03]: So there are already closer to the tools and the spaces where the circulates.

25:10.296 --> 25:18.301
[SPEAKER_03]: I think what we'd infer from interviews that we've done in the mother research is that, you know, a lot of this doesn't necessarily feel like harm to the kid doing it.

25:18.521 --> 25:20.282
[SPEAKER_03]: Like it kind of gets framed as like messing around.

25:20.302 --> 25:21.042
[SPEAKER_03]: That's like a joke.

25:21.623 --> 25:21.783
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

25:21.803 --> 25:24.685
[SPEAKER_03]: It's a thing you do to get a reaction to group chat.

25:25.465 --> 25:39.896
[SPEAKER_03]: And then there's this for some kids, there's like the it's not real logic gives you a bit of like a moral escape hatch because a quarter of kids who've seen this content told us they think it's less harmful then real pornography because nobody gets hurt.

25:42.190 --> 25:43.811
[SPEAKER_03]: And there's a gender dimension here as well.

25:43.971 --> 25:53.700
[SPEAKER_03]: Girls are noticeably more worried about getting targeted by AI-generated pornography, and they are more likely to say strongly that creating this without permission should be illegal.

25:54.180 --> 25:56.502
[SPEAKER_03]: So there's a bit of a gender gap here as well.

25:57.468 --> 26:14.920
[SPEAKER_00]: And we do know the idea that nobody gets hurt is just that it's an idea because there are certainly real world impacts to those who are victims of this type of content and when something is perceived as real by so many and the impacts that that could have we spoken with many survivors of issues like that as well.

26:14.980 --> 26:25.888
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's certainly complex and and worth continuing to take a look at how we can mitigate this it's it's exploitative and nature and how we can mitigate that.

26:26.628 --> 26:31.211
[SPEAKER_00]: and help better educate young people so they really understand what those impacts are.

26:32.932 --> 26:40.757
[SPEAKER_00]: According to research, teens seem fairly aware that AI, sexual content can influence how their peers think about bodies, sex, consent, and relationships.

26:41.138 --> 26:47.882
[SPEAKER_00]: Were you surprised by that level of awareness and does recognizing the influence seem to change how teens engage with the content?

26:49.577 --> 26:52.538
[SPEAKER_03]: I was surprised that they see it, but I'm struck by how consistent it all is.

26:53.038 --> 27:09.742
[SPEAKER_03]: So yeah, about two-thirds of the teams all teams say that this content shapes how kids are age, things about, think about what bodies you're looking like, and about what sex and consent are about what to expect from a romantic partner and whether you can trust a video.

27:10.302 --> 27:11.623
[SPEAKER_03]: Can you trust a video or a video at all?

27:12.423 --> 27:16.904
[SPEAKER_03]: But you know, if you try to notice the wording of what kids are agreeing to, they're telling us that it,

27:18.064 --> 27:20.046
[SPEAKER_03]: effects teams their age, right?

27:20.146 --> 27:21.147
[SPEAKER_03]: So not necessarily themselves.

27:21.948 --> 27:24.210
[SPEAKER_03]: And psychologists call that a third person effect.

27:25.131 --> 27:28.715
[SPEAKER_03]: People readily see media influence on everybody else, not as much on themselves.

27:29.115 --> 27:31.597
[SPEAKER_03]: So I mean, I read this as like, this is, oh, awareness.

27:32.118 --> 27:32.618
[SPEAKER_03]: It's real.

27:32.719 --> 27:33.399
[SPEAKER_03]: It's partial.

27:33.439 --> 27:35.401
[SPEAKER_03]: I think they have accurate insight into the phenomenon.

27:35.801 --> 27:39.125
[SPEAKER_03]: Maybe some blind spots about their own exposure, how it affects them.

27:40.270 --> 27:44.714
[SPEAKER_03]: But like for the question of like, how does awareness change behavior?

27:44.734 --> 27:46.536
[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know, probably not much.

27:46.796 --> 27:55.105
[SPEAKER_03]: I think that's an important finding, because among teams who encounter this content, the most common response as well, and I just try to forget about it and move on.

27:55.885 --> 28:00.169
[SPEAKER_03]: And only 30% of people are actually reporting this content to the platform.

28:01.070 --> 28:18.915
[SPEAKER_03]: And when we ask about lesson focus groups, you know, kids who say like, oh, it's just like a time consuming the council's gonna come back anyway, so, you know, maybe it's just easier to just not think too much about it right almost accepting it as an inevitability of living in this time rather than as something that can be changed.

28:19.934 --> 28:20.354
[SPEAKER_03]: That's right.

28:20.434 --> 28:20.815
[SPEAKER_03]: Yes.

28:20.915 --> 28:25.578
[SPEAKER_03]: It feels like a little, you feel a little helpless, I think, with the odds or circumstances too.

28:26.279 --> 28:26.579
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

28:27.179 --> 28:33.204
[SPEAKER_00]: Among teens who had seen AI-generated sexual content, 60% said it makes it harder to know what real bodies look like.

28:33.604 --> 28:44.753
[SPEAKER_00]: And we've talked for years about unrealistic bodies in traditional pornography, but what changes when those bodies don't have to exist at all because it's AI-generated.

28:45.333 --> 28:59.316
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, so with conventional pornography, that was kind of always a distorted sample in the sense of like you select a people with real lighting, real editing, but there's a real human body underneath it and human bodies have limits.

28:59.756 --> 29:05.557
[SPEAKER_03]: So whatever it was comparing themselves to, it existed somewhere, but yeah, it does not have that constraint, right?

29:05.597 --> 29:09.178
[SPEAKER_03]: Because the image does not have to be achievable by anybody, because there's no body.

29:10.158 --> 29:14.939
[SPEAKER_03]: It's just an aggregate of what a model has learned about people and what they find appealing.

29:15.459 --> 29:18.940
[SPEAKER_03]: So it's not really even like a biological ceiling to this.

29:21.621 --> 29:25.302
[SPEAKER_03]: So we had a girl in one of our studies who we were talking to her about this.

29:25.342 --> 29:28.603
[SPEAKER_03]: She said, it sets a standard that isn't realistic.

29:29.523 --> 29:33.504
[SPEAKER_03]: When I see an AI-generated photo of a perfect body, well, there is no perfect body.

29:34.726 --> 29:45.930
[SPEAKER_03]: was also interesting is that we tend to assume that this is a girl's issue that maybe they are more affected by the unrealistic bodies, but I think boys also feel it.

29:45.950 --> 29:51.972
[SPEAKER_03]: 65% of teens said that this content affects how much they trust photos and videos in general.

29:52.412 --> 29:54.133
[SPEAKER_03]: So it's not only just what body should look like.

29:54.173 --> 30:00.235
[SPEAKER_03]: It's also just a erosion of what an image is telling you about anything true at all.

30:00.695 --> 30:02.156
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's kind of a big thing to lose when you're

30:03.757 --> 30:04.518
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely.

30:05.038 --> 30:13.083
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, we're entering a world where someone can generate sexual content tailored to virtually any person, scenario, or preference.

30:13.123 --> 30:16.065
[SPEAKER_00]: What concerns or questions does that raise for you?

30:17.400 --> 30:17.720
[SPEAKER_03]: a few.

30:18.661 --> 30:20.742
[SPEAKER_03]: The first is consent, right?

30:20.762 --> 30:21.843
[SPEAKER_03]: That's probably the most concrete.

30:22.283 --> 30:28.247
[SPEAKER_03]: When content can be made of any specific person, a photo of your face is just raw material.

30:29.087 --> 30:34.190
[SPEAKER_03]: And there's the kids in the survey said that they were worried about being depicted without their consent.

30:34.551 --> 30:36.072
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's affecting the real world behavior.

30:36.092 --> 30:38.113
[SPEAKER_03]: So they're trying to adjust their lives around it.

30:38.713 --> 30:40.594
[SPEAKER_03]: So because so many kids feel like they might be

30:41.775 --> 30:54.768
[SPEAKER_03]: depicted with other consent about two and five of them say they are more careful about what they post about a third had made their accounts private, private, many are posting fewer pictures on themselves, you're just deleting their accounts entirely.

30:55.849 --> 31:00.193
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's, you know, that's maybe maybe withdrawing from online life as a defensive measure.

31:01.274 --> 31:04.516
[SPEAKER_03]: maybe involuntarily, not that they were like something they were happy to do.

31:04.976 --> 31:14.761
[SPEAKER_03]: And you could argue about like maybe that's actually better in the long run, but hard to say, because some kids, you know, they need that social health at specific ways.

31:15.782 --> 31:18.744
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think the other thing is, you know,

31:19.584 --> 31:33.112
[SPEAKER_03]: Conventional pornography, the constitutional pornography, it was a, it was a mass product, like your gavel was made, it wasn't about you, but all this infinitely customizable content is different and it shaped around one specific person's preferences.

31:33.592 --> 31:41.977
[SPEAKER_03]: There's no friction, there's no negotiation, nobody else needs to be in the frame, and that is the opposite of the skill set that actual intimacy with other people.

31:42.477 --> 31:43.038
[SPEAKER_03]: requires.

31:43.718 --> 31:52.267
[SPEAKER_03]: And I don't have data on this, it's a certain word about leads, but I, and I would be suspicious of anybody who said they do, but I suspect that that's not, that's not a good thing.

31:52.567 --> 31:53.247
[SPEAKER_03]: So, yeah.

31:53.708 --> 31:54.048
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

31:54.589 --> 32:05.800
[SPEAKER_00]: And, you know, looking across everything you've learned about young people through your research, what do you think parents and other trusted adults most need to understand about what teens are navigating right now?

32:07.310 --> 32:13.132
[SPEAKER_03]: Number one, your kid is almost on the encounter this, and it probably wasn't their fault.

32:13.192 --> 32:19.695
[SPEAKER_03]: Like I said, most kids have already seen pornography in this age group, and a good chunk of them have seen AI-generated sexual content.

32:20.355 --> 32:21.836
[SPEAKER_03]: Most of that exposure was accidental.

32:22.336 --> 32:30.700
[SPEAKER_03]: So if you're going into that conversation looking just for a culprit or somebody to blame, you may have already kind of lost the room with the kids.

32:32.341 --> 32:37.828
[SPEAKER_03]: The second thing is it's okay to be in that conversation and many kids want you in that conversation, but don't know how to start it.

32:38.489 --> 32:45.517
[SPEAKER_03]: So only 20% of kids said they had ever talked to a trusted adult about AI sexual content.

32:46.419 --> 32:49.462
[SPEAKER_03]: A third more said that they'd like to, but they don't know how to.

32:50.523 --> 32:51.064
[SPEAKER_03]: So that's there.

32:51.084 --> 32:56.449
[SPEAKER_03]: There's a third of the American teenagers who are like waiting for that conversation but they told us what would make it easier.

32:56.790 --> 33:01.774
[SPEAKER_03]: So things like knowing an adult would understand and they wouldn't be blamed, right?

33:01.795 --> 33:07.020
[SPEAKER_03]: They're going into this with an open mind and not looking to like blame or embarrassed kids like that's good to be really important.

33:07.140 --> 33:12.085
[SPEAKER_03]: And those are the both things that you can can say out loud in advance before you have that conversation.

33:13.039 --> 33:21.725
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think the third thing is that this isn't only about protecting your kid from harm, and it's about making sure your kid doesn't cause it.

33:22.365 --> 33:32.873
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, a kid who generates a nude image of a classmate has not only potentially really hurt somebody deeply personally, but in the eyes of the law produced child sexual abuse material.

33:33.513 --> 33:35.674
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's a real legal issue.

33:35.695 --> 33:37.216
[SPEAKER_03]: A lot of kids don't know that.

33:37.996 --> 33:42.100
[SPEAKER_03]: Telling them is a short conversation and definitely not one to skip.

33:42.140 --> 33:46.845
[SPEAKER_03]: As you mentioned earlier, it's not one conversation like this can be a series of one minute conversations.

33:46.885 --> 33:48.647
[SPEAKER_03]: It doesn't have to be a sit down for 20 minutes.

33:48.767 --> 33:48.967
[SPEAKER_03]: Right.

33:49.327 --> 33:50.849
[SPEAKER_03]: Talk about pornography conversation.

33:51.149 --> 33:54.472
[SPEAKER_03]: So lots of short awkward those dates ones over years.

33:54.612 --> 33:54.993
[SPEAKER_03]: That's fine.

33:56.664 --> 34:01.267
[SPEAKER_00]: And we hear that all of the time, how much more effective that is, that how much more comfortable that is for everyone.

34:01.687 --> 34:07.951
[SPEAKER_00]: And it really just opens that door to young people know, they can come to you when something comes up and you will be approachable.

34:08.071 --> 34:20.359
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that is key, especially with how rapidly technologies advancing, you could have all of the conversations you want right now, but next year, what are all of the new things that are going to become relevant that need,

34:21.279 --> 34:36.029
[SPEAKER_00]: to be addressed, and if that door is just open once and then closed, it doesn't really allow for that safe space other than for a young person to go search on the internet, which we know is not a safe space more often than not with regard to these topics.

34:37.410 --> 34:42.813
[SPEAKER_00]: Is there anything you've learned from teens themselves that gives you hope as you continue to do this work?

34:44.184 --> 34:46.986
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, I think their moral instincts are pretty good.

34:47.266 --> 34:55.731
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, by far, the majority of teens, 82% of teens, who've seen those kind of AI content, say, creating it without somebody's permission should be illegal.

34:56.131 --> 34:59.393
[SPEAKER_03]: I'm glad that there was none of the percent of teens who don't say that, and that does concern me.

34:59.933 --> 35:02.715
[SPEAKER_03]: But by far, the majority do.

35:03.115 --> 35:09.979
[SPEAKER_03]: And also, lots of kids say that most teens don't really understand the implications of what they're doing, so there's a runway here to make improvements.

35:11.417 --> 35:17.823
[SPEAKER_03]: And I think they're also thoughtful in a way that probably surprises people when we were doing focus groups.

35:18.684 --> 35:24.049
[SPEAKER_03]: And we brought, you know, we actually took the data after we'd run it and brought it back to them to ask them about what they made of those data.

35:24.469 --> 35:28.833
[SPEAKER_03]: And they really sharp about the mechanics of all this.

35:28.873 --> 35:30.235
[SPEAKER_03]: More than a lot of adults, I think, maybe.

35:30.715 --> 35:51.320
[SPEAKER_03]: You know, we had a 17 year old who was explaining the kind of dopamine loop that keeps kids engaged and maybe also like, you know, the friction that's involved in not why they don't report content, you know, kids are telling us like it's just really my year to assume that anybody hasn't been exposed, it's so easy and so accessible and also feels pushed.

35:51.980 --> 35:54.140
[SPEAKER_03]: And that was a phase they actually used, it says, it feels pushed.

35:54.460 --> 36:03.882
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's a really good description of, I think the modern internet and kind of the pornographic landscape, then lots of like other analysis that I've read.

36:04.382 --> 36:06.602
[SPEAKER_03]: So I think they're not missing judgment or intelligence.

36:06.622 --> 36:07.503
[SPEAKER_03]: They're missing information.

36:08.143 --> 36:15.324
[SPEAKER_03]: They're missing maybe some backup, like some people backup, adult backup, prostitutes, adult backup.

36:16.104 --> 36:20.045
[SPEAKER_03]: So, you know, I think the hopeful version of this is like, it's already for this conversation.

36:22.889 --> 36:47.488
[SPEAKER_03]: and young things I've already shared like the honestly the things that that used to get to me is like just kind of like how us do they are when they talk about it like this is something like they are they're in mesh already like they have plenty of background knowledge so like when you are starting this conversation you're not starting this conversation is from a place of like where kids have had nothing to bring to the table like they will already have questions opinions and thoughts about this topic

36:48.268 --> 37:06.193
[SPEAKER_00]: which if I may interrupt is so important to note because we hear from so many parents who say well I'm worried that by by having this conversation I will make them curious about it and I will make them learn about something they didn't know about and and what you're saying is the exact opposite they already know about this they already have information so you're not

37:07.093 --> 37:09.794
[SPEAKER_00]: likely going to be the one to introduce them to this topic.

37:09.874 --> 37:32.678
[SPEAKER_03]: That's I just had a conversation with a parent who was telling me that they had not yet had just kind of a general sex conversation with a There's an upper elementary school kid, which you know everyone parents should respect their values through it at your own pace But there is a danger that like if you don't say something somebody else will So including you want to be the first person to bring up that conversation You know that is something that I think parents need to think about

37:33.778 --> 37:34.719
[SPEAKER_00]: without so well said.

37:35.380 --> 37:54.897
[SPEAKER_00]: I could talk to you about this research for hours because it's truly something that we're so, so grateful for the work of Common Sense Media and as a nonprofit that primarily focuses on reaching teens because they're the ones experiencing this issue in ways that no other generation has before and then their support systems, parents, educators,

37:56.298 --> 38:04.022
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it's really, really important that we, we are hearing from teens themselves and that they have a voice in, in helping us understand what's going on.

38:04.102 --> 38:12.847
[SPEAKER_00]: So I know we're just about at time, but is there anything else that feels really important to share on this topic or from your research that you want to be sure to mention today?

38:12.867 --> 38:19.891
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, I think we're, I've said it a few times, but like I think parents are afraid that their kids are going to just shut down.

38:19.911 --> 38:19.971
[SPEAKER_03]: So.

38:21.928 --> 38:22.349
[SPEAKER_03]: expect that.

38:22.789 --> 38:29.858
[SPEAKER_03]: And don't really just tell you, you know, teams often told us straight out they do not want to drag adults into their problems necessarily.

38:30.319 --> 38:33.022
[SPEAKER_03]: So the fortune might be at the fault setting for some kids.

38:34.094 --> 38:52.564
[SPEAKER_03]: Uh, I think, you know, based on other research and conversations with other groups that you do this work, it can help maybe to do this as a side by side conversation rather than a face-to-face conversation, you know, if you'll say like, do it in the car, on a walk, do it in dishes somewhere with an eye contact, right, and go in with a low bar.

38:52.604 --> 38:53.585
[SPEAKER_03]: That is totally fine.

38:53.605 --> 38:57.907
[SPEAKER_03]: Like your goal for a conversation with your kids should be, um, it's to just be on record

38:59.728 --> 39:02.870
[SPEAKER_03]: what they have to say without judgment and without losing it, right?

39:03.090 --> 39:03.531
[SPEAKER_03]: That's a win.

39:03.551 --> 39:04.131
[SPEAKER_03]: You be for child.

39:04.151 --> 39:05.132
[SPEAKER_03]: There's just kind of crunching at you.

39:06.032 --> 39:06.252
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

39:06.973 --> 39:20.402
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's such a key part of what you've mentioned throughout this conversation is just trying to go in without losing it, trying to go in without looking for someone to blame, trying to go in as a resource to help your child

39:24.805 --> 39:31.048
[SPEAKER_00]: It was maybe something that they encountered by accident or if they have questions about you want that door to stay open.

39:31.088 --> 39:37.572
[SPEAKER_00]: So really making sure to try to find a way to navigate these conversations in that healthy space.

39:38.092 --> 39:42.815
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and me had one more thing because, you know, there's a temptation to treat all this is one conversation.

39:43.855 --> 39:48.358
[SPEAKER_03]: like one kind of conversation, but there's obviously there's an age gradient chair.

39:48.878 --> 39:56.623
[SPEAKER_03]: So the conversation you have with the eight-year-old is not going to be the one that you have with the 15-year-old, because the version you have from eight-year-old might not even necessarily be about pornography.

39:57.183 --> 40:04.248
[SPEAKER_03]: It might be about, hey, sometimes things pop up on your screen that are weird or gross, but then involved like naked people, that is not your fault.

40:04.868 --> 40:06.589
[SPEAKER_03]: Come tell me, you're not going to be in trouble.

40:06.889 --> 40:08.610
[SPEAKER_03]: Like, you know, I have to over explain everything.

40:08.631 --> 40:09.351
[SPEAKER_03]: You're just kind of installing

40:12.693 --> 40:24.397
[SPEAKER_03]: You know, like you can name pornography or pornography with any issues by middle school and by high school, you're probably talking about more about AI and consent among the law says, you know, so it's okay to like age it up as you go.

40:25.217 --> 40:33.099
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, very well said and inappropriate even to to start small and and in age appropriate ways and then silly built in.

40:33.460 --> 40:34.340
[SPEAKER_00]: I'll children are different.

40:34.360 --> 40:39.982
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, your child best and so just being able to be the safe adult to have those conversations is so, so important.

40:41.342 --> 40:44.965
[SPEAKER_00]: Dr. Michael Robb, thank you again so much for joining us on Consider Before Consuming.

40:45.005 --> 40:50.128
[SPEAKER_00]: We will certainly link to common sense media's research in the show notes of this episode.

40:50.428 --> 41:01.476
[SPEAKER_00]: It's something, again, we reference often and we look forward to the future of the work that you're doing and to continuing to see the way that young people are experiencing, you know, these issues today.

41:02.276 --> 41:02.756
[SPEAKER_03]: My pleasure.

41:02.776 --> 41:03.577
[SPEAKER_03]: Thank you for having me on.

41:09.755 --> 41:12.457
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for joining us on this episode of Consider Before Consuming.

41:13.038 --> 41:15.960
[SPEAKER_01]: Consider Before Consuming is brought to you by Fight The New Drug.

41:16.501 --> 41:33.435
[SPEAKER_01]: Fight The New Drug is a non-religious and a non-legislative organization that exists to provide individuals the opportunity to make an informed decision regarding pornography by raising awareness on its harmful effects using only science, facts, and personal accounts.

41:33.995 --> 41:36.858
[SPEAKER_01]: Check out the episode notes for resources mentioned in this episode.

41:37.378 --> 41:40.902
[SPEAKER_01]: If you find this podcast helpful, consider subscribing and leaving a review.

41:41.343 --> 41:42.484
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks again for listening.

41:42.985 --> 41:45.027
[SPEAKER_01]: We invite you to increase your self-awareness.

41:45.367 --> 41:46.248
[SPEAKER_01]: Look both ways.

41:46.889 --> 41:47.950
[SPEAKER_01]: Check your blind spots.

41:48.491 --> 41:50.193
[SPEAKER_01]: And consider before consuming.

