WEBVTT

00:00.051 --> 00:03.895
[SPEAKER_01]: You're on Team Human Conscious Intervention in the Machine.

00:04.035 --> 00:05.016
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Douglas Rushkoff.

00:05.416 --> 00:18.229
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm here today with Artist, activist, geographer, author, Trevor Paglin, hero of mine for a long time.

00:18.649 --> 00:26.473
[SPEAKER_01]: who I happen to get into a reading for his new book, how to see like a machine.

00:27.133 --> 00:28.374
[SPEAKER_01]: And was, of course, blown away.

00:28.414 --> 00:29.154
[SPEAKER_01]: I knew I'd be blown away.

00:29.174 --> 00:32.315
[SPEAKER_01]: I was pre-conditioned to be blown away, but just to be in the same space.

00:32.335 --> 00:38.999
[SPEAKER_01]: So I made sure I found studio time to actually engage with him about this and everything else that's going on.

00:39.359 --> 00:41.760
[SPEAKER_01]: Good Trevor, thanks for being on team human.

00:41.900 --> 00:46.182
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for having me, Mount Binnett, in a huge fan of your work for a very, very long time.

00:46.802 --> 00:47.143
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you.

00:47.163 --> 00:50.546
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like we've been on parallel Trajector.

00:50.606 --> 01:02.018
[SPEAKER_00]: It's always in my mind like one of these like like super rockstar guys that were just like lived in a different world than I did That's what it was in my mind And I look at you as a Destrocks darn a different world than me.

01:02.438 --> 01:09.825
[SPEAKER_01]: I had this Feeling this maybe it's a conti in feeling since I was a little kid that I'm this

01:10.706 --> 01:35.453
[SPEAKER_01]: Kind of a little consciousness inside this flesh form like getting certain wavelengths of light through my eyes to figure certain wavelengths of sound in my ears and touch But then I'm basically on another level kind of blind-deff and dumb You think this like as as any Lego robot with a couple of sensors on it trying to wander around the thing.

01:35.473 --> 01:35.613
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah

01:35.953 --> 01:59.608
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I thought from the beginning and then I read this thing and you know, I've been programmer, be programmed, take your own consciousness and all that, but I read this and I start to get the experience of not only am I just trying to get through the day and figure out what is happening in three space that there's a multi trillion dollar industry.

02:00.092 --> 02:02.794
[SPEAKER_01]: hacking that apparatus to make me see something else.

02:03.094 --> 02:16.183
[SPEAKER_00]: The book is really about our relationship to images and what images are and kind of how that's changed over the last two decades, but really much more in the last decade.

02:16.863 --> 02:26.946
[SPEAKER_00]: And the argument is that we've undergone two very significant revolutions in a very short amount of time.

02:27.566 --> 02:39.930
[SPEAKER_00]: And each one of those is on par with things like the invention of photography or the invention of perspective, you know, really big moments in terms of how we experience perception or how perception gets altered.

02:40.930 --> 02:52.739
[SPEAKER_00]: And the argument is that the first of those is the rise of computer vision, so the ability to essentially teach computers in cameras, how to see autonomously.

02:53.660 --> 03:01.426
[SPEAKER_00]: And the second of those is what we might call this generative turn, the ability to create photographs without,

03:02.047 --> 03:07.614
[SPEAKER_00]: cameras or without photographers to create texts, without authors, to create artworks, without artists.

03:07.995 --> 03:18.969
[SPEAKER_00]: Like this feels like a real fundamental shift in not only our relationship to media, but by proxy our relationship to reality, because we experience reality through perceptions.

03:19.650 --> 03:36.369
[SPEAKER_00]: right so the first one is like when camera knows how to find a face or something exactly and so this has huge implications like so the computer the computer vision revolution has a lot of implications like first of all let's just talk about what's going on

03:37.049 --> 03:43.812
[SPEAKER_00]: So, historically, in order for an image to exist, really, you need it a human to look at it.

03:44.192 --> 03:44.452
[SPEAKER_00]: Right?

03:44.652 --> 03:47.694
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, if an image is in the forest and nobody sees it, is that an image?

03:47.754 --> 03:48.694
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

03:48.814 --> 03:49.054
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

03:49.094 --> 03:50.495
[SPEAKER_00]: Because that image is that relation.

03:50.655 --> 03:50.995
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

03:51.015 --> 03:51.115
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

03:51.235 --> 03:53.696
[SPEAKER_01]: Audience perception exactly.

03:53.716 --> 03:54.057
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

03:55.157 --> 03:59.240
[SPEAKER_00]: And so with the advent of computer vision, you don't need that anymore.

03:59.340 --> 04:01.201
[SPEAKER_00]: You're building computers that see autonomously.

04:01.662 --> 04:14.491
[SPEAKER_00]: So what you start ending up with is a whole visual culture and a whole sensorium that is machines making images for other machines and humans aren't in the loop.

04:15.071 --> 04:20.195
[SPEAKER_00]: So what you end up with is a whole what I call a kind of substrate of invisible images.

04:20.615 --> 04:27.459
[SPEAKER_00]: And I would say, you know, most of the images in the world now are natively machine readable, but not natively human readable.

04:27.660 --> 04:31.082
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's like the image of me like when I go to the airport and they say look in this thing.

04:31.282 --> 04:32.643
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there's something.

04:32.683 --> 04:34.065
[SPEAKER_01]: That's not just a picture, right?

04:34.125 --> 04:36.026
[SPEAKER_01]: It's going somewhere to these machines.

04:36.287 --> 04:50.899
[SPEAKER_01]: So now they have like a num almost like an MP3 file or a thing that is the way, yeah, the machine readability of my face is like the distance between my pupils or the this or that, which isn't what faces to you or me.

04:51.720 --> 04:52.200
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

04:52.300 --> 04:53.681
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

04:53.701 --> 05:00.504
[SPEAKER_00]: You're seeing the kind of quantification of images, transforming images essentially to math or numbers.

05:00.904 --> 05:03.826
[SPEAKER_00]: Those numbers are machine readable and you can do stuff with them.

05:04.406 --> 05:10.289
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, so that when I'm going to an airport in a ran or something, some other machine can look and go rush cups there.

05:10.449 --> 05:11.789
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.

05:11.809 --> 05:12.690
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

05:13.330 --> 05:15.891
[SPEAKER_00]: So this has like huge implications.

05:16.051 --> 05:16.291
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

05:17.772 --> 05:24.642
[SPEAKER_00]: First of all, there's a kind of G-Wiz implication of the kind of metaphysics of images are just really different now, right?

05:25.383 --> 05:26.445
[SPEAKER_00]: That's kind of one layer.

05:26.465 --> 05:32.013
[SPEAKER_00]: A second layer is when you build computer visions systems, how to see,

05:33.254 --> 05:44.862
[SPEAKER_00]: Every form of seeing is, in the old days, we would call situated, in other words, every form of seeing shows you some things and blinds you to other things.

05:44.882 --> 06:00.592
[SPEAKER_00]: When we think about computer vision systems, if you're going to quantify the squishiness of visual culture, you have to take infinitely buzzing and burbling in squishy world and put it into discrete categories.

06:01.913 --> 06:07.983
[SPEAKER_00]: And so there's a kind of naivete that goes into doing that.

06:08.004 --> 06:08.725
[SPEAKER_00]: So for example,

06:10.287 --> 06:21.114
[SPEAKER_00]: if you build a computer vision system to recognize apples and oranges and bananas or what have you, you know, to look at a picture of an apple and say, that's an apple.

06:21.755 --> 06:25.838
[SPEAKER_00]: And two of the chapters are the book are really sort of playing with that.

06:25.898 --> 06:33.483
[SPEAKER_00]: And the premise of the two chapters is, like, let's point a computer vision system at a painting by Rename Agreed.

06:33.703 --> 06:34.163
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a painting

06:37.165 --> 06:40.408
[SPEAKER_00]: and you show it to the computer vision system and it says, this is an apple, right?

06:40.568 --> 06:42.949
[SPEAKER_00]: So you see that contradiction there exactly.

06:43.690 --> 06:48.313
[SPEAKER_00]: And so we're thinking to through, like, first of all, what's that politics of classification?

06:48.373 --> 06:59.702
[SPEAKER_00]: So at another base level, like, there's no such thing as apples, apples is like a word that we use to describe, you know, some self-similar objects, but they don't exist in nature, like as a thing, right?

07:01.483 --> 07:04.907
[SPEAKER_00]: we can kind of you can quibble about this kind of kind of a thing.

07:04.927 --> 07:08.652
[SPEAKER_01]: To even a squirrel, I think, thinks, ap.

07:09.012 --> 07:15.099
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, but definitely like different animal segment images, kind of like a monkey understands it.

07:15.119 --> 07:15.400
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

07:15.500 --> 07:19.184
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not just culture, but it's cognitive category.

07:19.484 --> 07:21.427
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, nature's just a big squishy.

07:21.907 --> 07:25.088
[SPEAKER_01]: Schmuck, she was just in a big swirl of metabolizing stuff.

07:25.348 --> 07:25.848
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

07:26.128 --> 07:26.569
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

07:27.029 --> 07:28.189
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's a cognitive category.

07:28.749 --> 07:35.872
[SPEAKER_00]: But when you're looking at the migrate painting, for example, or if you look at a renaissance painting, somebody's holding an apple, it's not about produce.

07:36.392 --> 07:36.672
[SPEAKER_00]: Right?

07:36.752 --> 07:36.972
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

07:36.992 --> 07:41.673
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, we use allegory, most of the images that we use are metaphorical.

07:41.693 --> 07:46.535
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, we play with images and we play with language all the time and that's something the computer can't do.

07:47.095 --> 07:53.218
[SPEAKER_00]: So there's a kind of stupidity there, but then there's a political economy to this, right?

07:53.519 --> 08:11.909
[SPEAKER_00]: In other words, when you say this is an apple, the kind of argument that I make is that you don't build computer vision classifiers to tell you that things are apples, you build them in order to tell you that things are apple shape commodities.

08:12.749 --> 08:21.434
[SPEAKER_00]: And what I mean by that is that, you know, if you're going to have something that's measuring apples, you know, that's probably going to be in some kind of industrial agricultural context.

08:21.474 --> 08:28.117
[SPEAKER_00]: And you have, you know, apples coming off of a assembly line and the computer vision systems analyzing, okay, this is a good one.

08:28.157 --> 08:29.758
[SPEAKER_00]: That's a bad one to sort that.

08:30.098 --> 08:32.320
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's part of a circuit of capital.

08:33.060 --> 08:35.602
[SPEAKER_00]: But let's expand that out much more today.

08:36.002 --> 08:41.887
[SPEAKER_00]: If you're a truck driver, there's a really good chance that there is a driver facing camera in your cab.

08:42.287 --> 08:43.468
[SPEAKER_00]: That's watching you drive.

08:44.009 --> 08:48.792
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you eat something, you'll say, oh, well, the driver's eating something, you're going to get dinged, right?

08:48.812 --> 08:50.714
[SPEAKER_00]: If you're smoking cigarette, you're going to get dinged.

08:51.194 --> 08:53.656
[SPEAKER_00]: If your eyes are fluttering, it looks like you're drowsy.

08:53.956 --> 08:56.038
[SPEAKER_00]: You're going to get a call from a supervisor.

08:56.578 --> 09:05.380
[SPEAKER_00]: So what that computer vision system does is create a essentially very intense surveillance system.

09:06.280 --> 09:20.364
[SPEAKER_00]: But when you abstract out what's going on here, what you're seeing is a kind of incursion of capital into places where it was previously far too inefficient to bother with.

09:26.605 --> 09:29.347
[SPEAKER_00]: And I can send that information to health insurance companies.

09:29.988 --> 09:35.672
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, 50 years ago, I could have hired somebody to hang out with you in your house and look at what you eat and yeah, it's not worth it.

09:36.352 --> 09:47.300
[SPEAKER_00]: So what you're seeing then is almost this geographic expansion of capital into new kinds of places, and that's enabled through computer vision.

09:48.020 --> 09:53.283
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's the kind of thing we used to call it tailorism and it happened in a workplace.

09:53.303 --> 09:53.443
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

09:53.724 --> 09:58.426
[SPEAKER_01]: So we're monitoring every on the assembly line, we know how many units they put up on the thing.

09:58.667 --> 10:07.532
[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't even have cameras to do it, but how many caps did she put on the bottles versus this one, this worker's better, putting on more we get rid of this one.

10:07.972 --> 10:12.035
[SPEAKER_01]: So your surveillance apparatus, I mean, that's what you mean by capitalism, can

10:12.875 --> 10:17.278
[SPEAKER_01]: Make money or save money for some other entity.

10:17.418 --> 10:18.539
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

10:19.020 --> 10:19.500
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

10:20.321 --> 10:31.669
[SPEAKER_00]: And so you're seeing, I kind of argue that you're seeing something akin to enclosure happening or to what David Harvey calls accumulation by disposition.

10:32.089 --> 10:38.754
[SPEAKER_00]: You're essentially taking places that were outside of a circuit of capital and bringing them into that.

10:39.094 --> 10:40.335
[SPEAKER_01]: Just by putting in cameras.

10:40.355 --> 10:41.096
[SPEAKER_01]: Just by putting in the camera.

10:41.536 --> 10:43.036
[SPEAKER_01]: which is interesting, right?

10:43.336 --> 10:48.498
[SPEAKER_01]: And because we always just talk about, oh, I'm not going to be worried until they have a camera in my bedroom, right?

10:48.878 --> 11:01.401
[SPEAKER_01]: Because I think we correctly, we as humans have enclosed sex as the last frontier that they can't take from us.

11:01.461 --> 11:02.361
[SPEAKER_01]: And of course they have.

11:02.401 --> 11:03.001
[SPEAKER_01]: Of course.

11:03.321 --> 11:08.843
[SPEAKER_01]: Pills and condoms and loops and courses and worries and advertising.

11:08.883 --> 11:09.423
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, you did it.

11:09.883 --> 11:11.344
[SPEAKER_01]: marriage, you know, they're not.

11:11.384 --> 11:17.026
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's a huge industry to make money or sanctioning sex.

11:17.526 --> 11:25.610
[SPEAKER_01]: But I know what you mean, that once we're in, once we're being watched, it can be commoditized.

11:26.070 --> 11:31.312
[SPEAKER_01]: But just the fact that it can be commoditized is that necessarily change what's happening.

11:31.732 --> 11:34.073
[SPEAKER_01]: My kids are playing in a park one way.

11:34.193 --> 11:35.614
[SPEAKER_01]: And now they're being watched in

11:38.035 --> 11:41.101
[SPEAKER_01]: How does that necessarily change what they get to do?

11:41.638 --> 11:45.320
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, well, I don't know that it's changing what they do from day to day.

11:45.600 --> 11:47.601
[SPEAKER_00]: However, it does add up.

11:47.701 --> 11:52.023
[SPEAKER_00]: So, for example, a lot of new cars have systems built into them.

11:52.244 --> 12:02.349
[SPEAKER_00]: Or, or we have insurance companies that would mandate that you put a system inside of your car that does this kind of driving evaluation and real time as you're driving.

12:02.889 --> 12:07.812
[SPEAKER_00]: And then what they want to do is just like modulate your insurance treatment in real time.

12:08.752 --> 12:24.775
[SPEAKER_00]: based on how you drive right so be like oh you took a risky left turn you know you're insurance premium went up by like five and five oh you just had a big mac you're in exactly sure it goes up 12 cents ago exactly and so like does that affect your everyday life yeah

12:25.795 --> 12:32.217
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, it does because you're thinking about what every gesture that you make, what it's literally going to do.

12:32.237 --> 12:32.597
[SPEAKER_00]: All right.

12:32.877 --> 12:33.077
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

12:33.157 --> 12:42.960
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like it's like the way you're, I mean, the most people know about it and like in your, your FICO score, I get a lot of these emails now from like three different places telling me your credit alert.

12:42.980 --> 12:44.401
[SPEAKER_01]: Your credit score has changed.

12:45.041 --> 12:48.722
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm supposed to go click on things to find out like because it's gonna go up or down.

12:48.762 --> 12:50.663
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm like, I don't care if it went up or down.

12:50.743 --> 12:51.363
[SPEAKER_01]: I really don't.

12:51.524 --> 12:52.424
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't want to borrow money.

12:52.484 --> 12:56.565
[SPEAKER_01]: Fuck all you fuck you, but it's like this metric.

12:56.606 --> 12:58.826
[SPEAKER_01]: But it's the one metric that follows you around.

12:58.846 --> 13:00.127
[SPEAKER_01]: You're sort of creditworthiness.

13:00.767 --> 13:08.530
[SPEAKER_01]: But it's like having this increasingly large real-time report card on me all the time.

13:08.550 --> 13:08.830
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

13:08.890 --> 13:10.151
[SPEAKER_00]: And now it's about everything.

13:10.211 --> 13:13.112
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not just about whether you pay gear, you know credit card bill one time.

13:13.752 --> 13:26.641
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, so the book that I read if yours or I would have to look that of yours that put you on my radar Was this one that had like pictures of surveillance app was yeah invisible.

13:27.241 --> 13:30.803
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, wow That's a old oldie, but yeah, that was the first photo book.

13:30.843 --> 13:42.171
[SPEAKER_01]: I put it right But do you think about because the thing I like because I would just go meta before I was into politics I just like meta So I just liked it from the meta sense of oh you're surveilling on the surveillance state.

13:42.191 --> 13:42.371
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah

13:42.591 --> 13:44.172
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and that to me was fun.

13:44.273 --> 13:46.074
[SPEAKER_01]: I wasn't like I was pre-politic.

13:46.094 --> 13:50.018
[SPEAKER_01]: I wasn't worried about, you know, all the bad stuff that would happen.

13:50.378 --> 13:51.699
[SPEAKER_01]: I was like a little work out.

13:52.039 --> 13:53.881
[SPEAKER_01]: I thought I'd get hoisted on their own guitar.

13:53.941 --> 13:55.242
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not always that karma.

13:55.522 --> 13:57.004
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll get them, you know.

13:57.044 --> 14:02.168
[SPEAKER_01]: But capital seems more powerful than karma so far, at least in the medium term.

14:02.448 --> 14:04.410
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that feels like it for sure.

14:04.730 --> 14:17.257
[SPEAKER_01]: And what we've been doing so far is sort of peeling back the surveillance state, and all the folks we can use that we read about in college, like Foucault or whatever, and the penapticon.

14:17.277 --> 14:20.579
[SPEAKER_01]: But this is like really, really more real.

14:20.599 --> 14:25.282
[SPEAKER_01]: It's more real in every day that you're Samsung or whatever, LG, if I got which TV it is.

14:26.440 --> 14:52.887
[SPEAKER_01]: is taking a picture as soon as screen cap of your TV every eight seconds and something get back to the mothership yeah yeah a lot of these smart TVs they're you know taking screen captures of what you're watching you know it's like Nielsen ratings like gone wild right they used to like literally have to hate people to like self-report that Nielsen ratings used to be judging the TV network and that was a fine at least they weren't judging

14:53.707 --> 15:09.047
[SPEAKER_01]: me right now the surveillance is of me to figure out what edge should we give that person exactly sounds what sites what what do we do and that's where we get to the second place really the the new material in this book yeah is more the the

15:10.928 --> 15:24.004
[SPEAKER_01]: the creation of images by machines, how that untethered us to begin with, and then the agendas behind the creation of the images, which fuck with us.

15:24.224 --> 15:24.705
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

15:24.925 --> 15:27.648
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so that's the second part of the book.

15:27.708 --> 15:28.790
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like looking at that.

15:29.490 --> 15:38.978
[SPEAKER_00]: generative turn, which is, you know, happens in the context of things like recommendation algorithms, like personalized search, personalized ads, whatever.

15:39.418 --> 15:48.385
[SPEAKER_00]: And so you're increasingly living in a media environment where the things that we see are custom tailored to us, right?

15:48.765 --> 15:50.186
[SPEAKER_01]: So I guess we've got to break it down.

15:50.206 --> 15:50.747
[SPEAKER_01]: So, uh,

15:53.137 --> 15:55.942
[SPEAKER_01]: First, the machines are generating images.

15:56.803 --> 16:00.529
[SPEAKER_01]: And machines are generating images from what?

16:00.710 --> 16:02.653
[SPEAKER_01]: Are they generating images from what?

16:04.233 --> 16:12.841
[SPEAKER_01]: imagery that's out there that we made or they using their mathy machine understanding of reality to generate images.

16:13.021 --> 16:14.222
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so both.

16:14.882 --> 16:29.255
[SPEAKER_00]: So the way that generative AI works is essentially what you do is you like suck up all human media in history, you know internet books, what have you anything is

16:31.236 --> 16:33.037
[SPEAKER_00]: And then you build a model out of it.

16:33.258 --> 16:41.843
[SPEAKER_00]: So you kind of create a, people are going to call me out for saying this, but I'll say like a statistical representation.

16:42.043 --> 16:44.205
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, you create a representational space of all that stuff.

16:44.765 --> 16:49.108
[SPEAKER_00]: And then what you can do is you can prompt that model to make images.

16:49.248 --> 16:55.012
[SPEAKER_00]: So you can say, make me a picture of a teddy bear and a astronaut suit swimming in a lake of cheese.

16:55.492 --> 16:58.075
[SPEAKER_00]: right, and it will make that image.

16:58.715 --> 17:15.091
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's synthesizing that image based on visual concepts and linguistic concepts that it is quote unquote learned by ingesting the entire internet and the entirety of culture and putting it into this abstracted mathematical space.

17:15.446 --> 17:18.247
[SPEAKER_00]: and making this thing, yeah, yeah, exactly.

17:18.327 --> 17:22.528
[SPEAKER_00]: So you can prompt the model to make something for you.

17:23.048 --> 17:25.709
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, in real life, most people are not prompting models.

17:26.029 --> 17:30.810
[SPEAKER_00]: People are seeing these kinds of images or media in a feed, right?

17:31.290 --> 17:34.671
[SPEAKER_00]: Or in the Instagram feed, or TikTok feed, or what have you.

17:34.991 --> 17:43.373
[SPEAKER_00]: And so there's another layer that's going on there, which is that feed is kind of trying to optimize what is going to hold your attention.

17:43.913 --> 18:02.124
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, let me show you something where I can harvest something from you, whether I can either manipulate your political beliefs, or I can just get you to look at something for a long time, or I can get you to buy something behind what's what's your intention.

18:02.184 --> 18:11.630
[SPEAKER_01]: The simplest one, even though attention doesn't necessarily create money in the moment, I guess attention is good because you've learned how to get that person's attention.

18:12.106 --> 18:18.751
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you've learned how to get that attention, but it does translate into money, you know, you get into this world of, you know, paying advertisers and that kind of thing.

18:19.011 --> 18:19.312
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

18:19.852 --> 18:37.706
[SPEAKER_01]: So what's the real difference between, you know, Donald Trump hiring me to make him look like Spartacus or Jesus and putting that on Twitter and him getting an AI to do it.

18:39.260 --> 18:44.083
[SPEAKER_00]: There's, I mean, not really a difference, but the Trump thing is super interesting.

18:44.183 --> 18:57.252
[SPEAKER_00]: My intuition is that when you start to be, when you start prompting images like that into reality, that relationship between,

18:58.948 --> 19:03.130
[SPEAKER_00]: prompting a model and prompting reality itself starts to get squishy.

19:04.731 --> 19:14.317
[SPEAKER_00]: In other words, to me, when Trump is tweeting out those AI-generated images,

19:15.918 --> 19:21.643
[SPEAKER_00]: There's something else going on then propaganda, right?

19:21.723 --> 19:33.614
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a propagandistic element to it, but it does seem to me that there's a kind of alteration of our common sense that that induces in society.

19:36.276 --> 19:43.481
[SPEAKER_00]: It feels very much in this kind of post-simulation kind of world.

19:44.021 --> 19:49.625
[SPEAKER_00]: You start to have a society where people have very different facts.

19:50.326 --> 19:56.130
[SPEAKER_00]: People are oriented themselves to reality through very different kinds of images.

19:57.010 --> 20:11.457
[SPEAKER_00]: And because we orient ourselves to reality through images, we're getting more into this world that feels like simulation or chaos magic or these almost kind of theological traditions that where

20:14.358 --> 20:19.282
[SPEAKER_00]: What reality is and what images are so entangled that it's hard to tell them apart.

20:19.302 --> 20:19.422
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

20:19.922 --> 20:25.666
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, I've been writing about memes and media viruses since, you know, 1993 or four.

20:25.686 --> 20:25.786
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

20:26.146 --> 20:38.375
[SPEAKER_01]: And sigils and all, but I never really and I've called memes sigils, but I don't think I ever really meant it

20:40.315 --> 20:41.196
[SPEAKER_01]: until now.

20:42.216 --> 21:03.510
[SPEAKER_01]: And what helped me the most in your book is distinguishing between images as representation, like the meme, it's a picture, it's Bart Simpson on a thing with Trump of the book and memes, and images as activation.

21:04.190 --> 21:11.037
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you know, where, and that end to end, because activation is actually really true to my original injection of a virus.

21:11.157 --> 21:11.817
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

21:12.218 --> 21:17.343
[SPEAKER_01]: But you mean an activation of the, like, the nervous system for the memory play.

21:17.383 --> 21:17.603
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

21:18.103 --> 21:26.331
[SPEAKER_00]: That's one of the other arguments of the book is that in these kind of post-computer vision post-enter of AI moments, how do we think about images?

21:27.052 --> 21:34.578
[SPEAKER_00]: and the argument that I make is that we should stop thinking about them as representations and thinking about them as activations.

21:34.938 --> 21:44.405
[SPEAKER_00]: In other words, like, let's stop thinking about them as things that tell us stories and start thinking about them as things that do things.

21:45.626 --> 21:46.546
[SPEAKER_00]: I'll give you some background.

21:46.586 --> 21:46.727
[SPEAKER_00]: Like,

21:47.407 --> 22:07.507
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I went to art school, when you're on art school, you have to learn how to like quote unquote read images, right, and you read people like role in art and Susan's on tag and it's very much like, Oh, we're looking at this advertisement and you know, here is this story about this person blah, blah, blah, blah, it's kind of an ideological story about.

22:07.707 --> 22:10.889
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, whatever, capitalism, or what?

22:11.109 --> 22:12.730
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

22:12.750 --> 22:14.972
[SPEAKER_01]: They never returns to the conditions on the ground.

22:15.052 --> 22:16.012
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

22:16.112 --> 22:21.015
[SPEAKER_00]: And we have to decode it in another word to say, you know, they're to see the story that the image is really telling.

22:21.756 --> 22:24.798
[SPEAKER_00]: And like for me, that's just like not what's going on with images.

22:24.818 --> 22:29.901
[SPEAKER_00]: Like I'm scrolling on my phone and I'm looking at somebody eating spaghetti and I'm like captivated.

22:29.941 --> 22:31.622
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm like, what the hell is going on here?

22:31.882 --> 22:36.765
[SPEAKER_00]: This is not, you know, like Roland Bart's some kind of, you know, ideological.

22:37.105 --> 22:45.468
[SPEAKER_01]: No, it's like out of the realm of Freud, and into the realm of like, have love and exactly exactly exactly.

22:45.548 --> 23:02.715
[SPEAKER_00]: And so that's the argument that I'm looking at is like, we can think about, you know, a camera on a street corner that is looking for people Jaywalking, it can automatically detect somebody Jaywalking that trigger, that activates a legal system that will issue them a ticket, right?

23:03.175 --> 23:05.198
[SPEAKER_00]: And in the same way, I'm on TikTok.

23:05.218 --> 23:06.699
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm looking at somebody eating spaghetti.

23:07.060 --> 23:12.446
[SPEAKER_00]: That's activating something in me neurologically that is holding my attention.

23:13.047 --> 23:16.671
[SPEAKER_00]: It's doing something to me almost like pre-cognitively or pre-rationaly.

23:16.831 --> 23:17.372
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

23:17.412 --> 23:19.615
[SPEAKER_01]: I know those are two really interesting examples, right?

23:19.895 --> 23:20.916
[SPEAKER_01]: Just when you think about them,

23:22.497 --> 23:24.778
[SPEAKER_01]: almost like poetically, or visually, artistically.

23:25.178 --> 23:36.363
[SPEAKER_01]: One is human body moving through space, being observed and punished for the way it's moved along lines.

23:36.683 --> 23:39.324
[SPEAKER_01]: By a machine that doesn't know what a person is.

23:39.644 --> 23:49.108
[SPEAKER_01]: By a machine that has observed a form that it has labeled as a human body, crossing a line at a particular time when some other thing was there.

23:49.488 --> 23:54.569
[SPEAKER_01]: So it doesn't care, it doesn't even know, right?

23:54.929 --> 24:04.112
[SPEAKER_01]: So there's that going on and that machine because of the algorithm that it's being taught, which is the legal one you're not supposed to cross from the thing, whatever, that's fine.

24:04.212 --> 24:07.633
[SPEAKER_01]: If you sign up for that, is affecting your life.

24:07.653 --> 24:10.834
[SPEAKER_01]: Then you're going to get a thing in the mail for $50 to pay.

24:10.874 --> 24:15.115
[SPEAKER_01]: You've got to work two more hours at the factory, and whatever it is to give money so Donna Trump can

24:15.655 --> 24:16.956
[SPEAKER_01]: Give it to a son and law or something, right?

24:17.516 --> 24:21.039
[SPEAKER_01]: Or whatever he does, whatever he does or give it to a January 6th Protester.

24:21.939 --> 24:22.600
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what's happened.

24:24.021 --> 24:29.705
[SPEAKER_01]: The other one now is the image itself whatever it may be a picture of.

24:30.625 --> 24:32.547
[SPEAKER_01]: The computer doesn't care what it's a picture of.

24:32.827 --> 24:39.792
[SPEAKER_01]: The computer cares that this arrangement of pixels will get you to feel or act in a particular way.

24:40.412 --> 24:41.993
[SPEAKER_01]: and it doesn't matter why.

24:42.253 --> 24:47.556
[SPEAKER_01]: So traditionally it would be, oh, let's make that sandwich look really tasty.

24:47.956 --> 24:51.357
[SPEAKER_01]: So he wants to go to McDonald's or whatever and get that thing.

24:51.377 --> 24:54.359
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, or she wants to eat a mounds bar, right?

24:55.379 --> 25:00.462
[SPEAKER_01]: Now it's more whatever it is, it's going to neurologically

25:02.155 --> 25:05.298
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't care, move that body over to that place.

25:05.378 --> 25:06.559
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly, exactly.

25:07.319 --> 25:11.062
[SPEAKER_00]: And this kind of thing's been around for a long time.

25:11.082 --> 25:16.427
[SPEAKER_00]: And it was set, there's the book in 1959, the Hidden Persuade, which turned out to be fake.

25:16.587 --> 25:17.928
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that was, it turned out to be fake.

25:18.008 --> 25:22.411
[SPEAKER_01]: It was just really, yeah, there was one experiment where they tried once using, but no one was actually putting,

25:23.232 --> 25:44.798
[SPEAKER_00]: flash frames of Coke in the, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah,

25:45.678 --> 25:50.544
[SPEAKER_01]: But that's where they put the little, they put it in the detergent, those little blue or yellow, right?

25:50.624 --> 25:51.965
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

25:52.045 --> 26:06.942
[SPEAKER_01]: And you think blue is a cleaner one, and different kinds of people, like, oh, you know, they'll find out, like, oh, you know, black people, like a yellow dot in their thing, wealthy white people, like a blue one, and middle class white people on a green one, yeah, it's like, what the fuck?

26:07.042 --> 26:08.163
[SPEAKER_01]: fuck, but whatever.

26:08.563 --> 26:16.387
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, but like, those those dynamics have been around for a long time, but they've been really you're you're just been a lot of money to figure that stuff out.

26:16.767 --> 26:23.131
[SPEAKER_00]: And like the in this kind of in the environment that we're in now where you're in a constant feedback loop.

26:23.391 --> 26:29.038
[SPEAKER_00]: with the media that you're consuming, you can, you can individualize that for every single person.

26:29.519 --> 26:32.082
[SPEAKER_00]: You can modulate that in real time, you know what I mean?

26:32.163 --> 26:34.966
[SPEAKER_00]: And you're getting behavioral feedback in real time, right?

26:34.986 --> 26:41.234
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's like that, those kind of dynamics that are crazy and what you end up with, this is much more powerful, like neurological triggers.

26:41.815 --> 26:42.516
[SPEAKER_01]: the Skinner Box.

26:42.536 --> 26:44.637
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you could get there the other way.

26:44.697 --> 26:54.546
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, like Coca-Cola developed a bottle that just, it was a human, but turns out to be like a perfect sexy, wonderful swirling shape.

26:54.886 --> 26:56.527
[SPEAKER_01]: That thing is like the Chrysler building.

26:56.547 --> 26:57.008
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just...

26:57.428 --> 26:58.389
[SPEAKER_01]: the original glasscoat.

26:58.489 --> 26:59.049
[SPEAKER_01]: It's that.

26:59.509 --> 26:59.669
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

26:59.989 --> 27:06.253
[SPEAKER_01]: And now it's almost like industrial branding reached its peak in the 1920 with that bottle.

27:06.933 --> 27:18.399
[SPEAKER_01]: And since then we've been trying to imitate that effect through massive consumer research and like we're not trusting the human soul or heart to come up with that.

27:18.479 --> 27:19.239
[SPEAKER_01]: No, exactly.

27:19.299 --> 27:20.200
[SPEAKER_01]: Using probability.

27:20.440 --> 27:20.640
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

27:21.200 --> 27:27.668
[SPEAKER_00]: and we're like understanding humans to be like neurological systems in a way that our akin to computers.

27:27.688 --> 27:31.313
[SPEAKER_00]: Now I'm not saying that that's what we are, but there are parts of us that are.

27:31.393 --> 27:38.902
[SPEAKER_00]: Like there are parts of our cognitive apparatus is that we have very little control over that do operate purationally.

27:39.042 --> 27:39.283
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

27:39.343 --> 27:39.583
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

27:39.723 --> 27:53.804
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, and you called this, I think you called like the Dorito effect, or anything that Dorito said, right, which is like how you came up with Dorito, we all know Doritos are really just awful and they're not really satisfying, but you'll eat the whole bag if it's there because it's like so does living in

27:54.685 --> 28:05.231
[SPEAKER_01]: A Dorito image landscape, do we end up losing our kind of non- Dorito sensibility?

28:05.411 --> 28:05.712
[SPEAKER_00]: Mm-hmm.

28:06.672 --> 28:08.613
[SPEAKER_01]: Are we not seeing anymore?

28:09.073 --> 28:09.414
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

28:09.714 --> 28:16.138
[SPEAKER_00]: This is where we get into what are the kind of big implications of this stuff.

28:16.978 --> 28:24.162
[SPEAKER_01]: And to many people, the implication I just said was, who gives a shit, where you can get out of the met and appreciate a, you know, tell me or something like that.

28:24.222 --> 28:26.583
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I mean, that's never going to go away.

28:26.623 --> 28:29.625
[SPEAKER_00]: And we were complex things and we're complex societies.

28:29.685 --> 28:37.069
[SPEAKER_00]: And when the book, we're just looking at some tendencies that have, like, gotten a lot of, like, you know, rocket fuel, find them in the last few years.

28:37.169 --> 28:39.470
[SPEAKER_00]: But they're always going to co-exist with other things.

28:40.290 --> 28:40.490
[SPEAKER_00]: But,

28:41.751 --> 28:46.736
[SPEAKER_00]: So there's a bunch of implications of this, like, the deridoification of media.

28:48.237 --> 28:55.443
[SPEAKER_00]: We can, before we kind of go into that, I think one thing is a much, much bigger deal than we think that it is.

28:55.944 --> 29:01.669
[SPEAKER_00]: And that is the creation of images that look like photographs, but that are not.

29:03.190 --> 29:13.657
[SPEAKER_00]: We'll say like, the idea of democracy in my understanding of it is kind of premised on, you know, a modern idea of, with a kind of faith and empiricism.

29:14.078 --> 29:19.741
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, for me, the theory of democracy at the highest level and doesn't ever work this way, but at the highest level.

29:20.642 --> 29:33.951
[SPEAKER_00]: I understand the theory to be that if we have a set of shared facts that we get, are we going to determine through some kind of empirical process, we can look at those and deliberate on them and kind of figure out what we want to do going forward.

29:34.291 --> 29:34.492
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

29:34.852 --> 29:36.913
[SPEAKER_00]: Now again, that's not how it works, but that's the theory.

29:36.953 --> 29:37.193
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

29:37.374 --> 29:37.614
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

29:38.194 --> 29:44.659
[SPEAKER_00]: My intuition is that photography has been a big part of that of the

29:48.461 --> 29:53.483
[SPEAKER_00]: We have lived in a world where the image of the Napalm girl came out.

29:53.543 --> 29:55.363
[SPEAKER_00]: That's what this image is from, obviously.

29:55.423 --> 29:57.344
[SPEAKER_00]: It came out and nobody disputed it.

29:57.384 --> 29:58.965
[SPEAKER_01]: Those things just happened.

29:59.265 --> 29:59.485
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

29:59.945 --> 30:05.227
[SPEAKER_00]: It changes public opinion or at least put something on the table that needs to be addressed.

30:05.487 --> 30:05.687
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

30:05.807 --> 30:07.488
[SPEAKER_00]: Are we really going to torture people?

30:07.668 --> 30:09.528
[SPEAKER_00]: Are we really going to like fire bomb kids?

30:10.009 --> 30:10.349
[SPEAKER_00]: Whatever.

30:10.509 --> 30:10.829
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

30:13.255 --> 30:16.300
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that era might be over.

30:16.540 --> 30:20.306
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, and I'll tell you about a real weird experience I had.

30:20.646 --> 30:24.612
[SPEAKER_00]: And I knew this was coming when I wrote the book, but it hadn't happened completely for me yet.

30:25.613 --> 30:27.296
[SPEAKER_00]: The day after the U.S. started bombing Iran,

30:28.678 --> 30:30.299
[SPEAKER_00]: I was looking at Twitter.

30:30.640 --> 30:32.501
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm trying to figure out what that was going on here.

30:33.162 --> 30:33.563
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, good place.

30:33.583 --> 30:49.199
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no

30:51.068 --> 30:54.049
[SPEAKER_00]: I was trying to find things that might be credible.

30:54.529 --> 30:56.730
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was like, whoa, a flip has happened.

30:56.950 --> 31:02.192
[SPEAKER_00]: Where my default assumption is that everything here is some kind of garbage is trying to manipulate me.

31:02.712 --> 31:06.933
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm looking for a panning for gold in the form of information.

31:07.593 --> 31:15.236
[SPEAKER_00]: And I started calling this moment the indexical flip, where I am assuming that all me is untethered from reality.

31:15.476 --> 31:16.196
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm looking for the,

31:16.856 --> 31:18.798
[SPEAKER_00]: the media moments that are tethered to reality.

31:19.138 --> 31:19.799
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's weird.

31:19.899 --> 31:22.301
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that has huge implications.

31:22.401 --> 31:25.304
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, that's an awful, that's an awful experience.

31:25.324 --> 31:28.967
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that was what I was writing about in a phenomenon like that.

31:29.447 --> 31:36.933
[SPEAKER_01]: And like 95, I did this book called Playing The Future, where I was arguing that attention deficit disorder among kids is a

31:37.694 --> 31:42.896
[SPEAKER_01]: cognitive defense mechanism in a world where someone is trying to program you everywhere you look.

31:43.416 --> 31:58.062
[SPEAKER_01]: So you learn to withhold your attention from anything until there's something that you feel semantically safe enough to gaze upon it because it doesn't want something from you.

31:58.322 --> 32:00.003
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, exactly.

32:00.303 --> 32:07.774
[SPEAKER_01]: but it's odd, but that means we're also moving around in a state of either, you know, cynicism or disorientation.

32:07.834 --> 32:08.035
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

32:08.776 --> 32:15.907
[SPEAKER_01]: It's all, I mean, like, walking, if you're driving and you do not believe the street signs, totally, exactly.

32:16.307 --> 32:17.809
[SPEAKER_01]: That sucks, right?

32:17.869 --> 32:22.273
[SPEAKER_00]: Not only does it suck, but like you're living in a really nihilistic society.

32:22.393 --> 32:22.533
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

32:22.773 --> 32:27.138
[SPEAKER_00]: And what's going to fill that void is raw power, you know what I mean?

32:27.158 --> 32:29.981
[SPEAKER_00]: Like fascism, like bad stuff is going to fill that void.

32:30.581 --> 32:30.841
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

32:30.881 --> 32:34.785
[SPEAKER_01]: Because if you can know if you no longer have the means of deliberation, yep.

32:35.586 --> 32:40.769
[SPEAKER_00]: then let's go full Viking, totally let's go full Viking like where where does that?

32:41.670 --> 32:44.412
[SPEAKER_00]: Where does that sense of reality come from, right?

32:44.472 --> 33:02.063
[SPEAKER_00]: If it's if it's not coming from a pain or not pain, a bingo feels like I or it comes from pain or not pain or I want to believe something or something feels real, you get into this much more kind of affective kind of space,

33:02.623 --> 33:09.364
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, but Spinoza said that the object of the game here is to increase our capacity to affect and be affected by others.

33:09.404 --> 33:09.644
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

33:10.344 --> 33:17.086
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's an affective somatic, almost it's it it's compatible with reason.

33:17.446 --> 33:17.666
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.

33:17.686 --> 33:28.368
[SPEAKER_01]: But it's not depending on reason that it's like, is the answer some kind of more somatic embodied intuitive.

33:28.408 --> 33:28.748
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

33:29.528 --> 33:59.070
[SPEAKER_00]: like obviously that's always been there and that's been like a you know one of the my understanding is like the point like of reason was to be able to get over that and like deliberate from from a higher space like with a different part of your brain like the rest part of your your your cognitive act but the other one has to come along so it's like always we're in a town we're living together the water table basin thing is starting to go down

34:00.651 --> 34:04.114
[SPEAKER_01]: The water basin going down and now we're going to deliberate about it.

34:04.294 --> 34:07.696
[SPEAKER_01]: If I'm still in water basin going down, water basin going, we're not going to be able to do it.

34:07.736 --> 34:10.178
[SPEAKER_00]: No, or like what if your neighbor says it's not going down?

34:10.939 --> 34:11.880
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's even worse.

34:11.920 --> 34:12.920
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what I'm talking about.

34:12.960 --> 34:24.709
[SPEAKER_01]: If they're now right, so you want to disconnect enough from the, not disconnect, but you've got to get through the panic to actually be there metabolize it and breathe it, the water basin going down.

34:26.961 --> 34:27.141
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

34:27.321 --> 34:33.826
[SPEAKER_01]: If you don't even believe that it's going down because we're not there directly looking at the water basin.

34:33.846 --> 34:42.732
[SPEAKER_01]: We're reading a newspaper that's telling us whether it's going down and you're reading the conservative or fake conservative newspaper that's saying, it's actually it's going up.

34:43.213 --> 34:47.916
[SPEAKER_01]: The only reason it looks like it's going down is because Gavin Newsom closed the faucet.

34:47.996 --> 34:48.156
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

34:49.277 --> 34:51.198
[SPEAKER_01]: That should be feeding everybody.

34:52.439 --> 34:53.400
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, oh my

34:56.742 --> 35:09.153
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that the Southern California fires and droughts are caused by news and holding the water right up north like out right so if you don't and and what you're saying.

35:11.075 --> 35:11.275
[SPEAKER_01]: Our.

35:14.392 --> 35:19.476
[SPEAKER_01]: Literacy was supposed to be the tool for enabling democracy.

35:19.536 --> 35:29.945
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, the argument to have public schools in England was so that the coal miners could read a paper at night and vote, yeah, that's one piece of it.

35:30.085 --> 35:35.209
[SPEAKER_00]: And then the other piece of it is the creation of a shared reality through empirical meetings.

35:35.589 --> 35:42.274
[SPEAKER_00]: In other words, we're going to go out and look if the water's going down and we're all going to agree that the water's going down because we measured it.

35:42.455 --> 35:42.715
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

35:43.135 --> 35:52.907
[SPEAKER_01]: And we get experts, we get real scientists with real rulers who know how to measure it, who now people say, oh, the scientists are funded by George Sorrow's Space Lakers, and they're not real.

35:52.927 --> 35:54.028
[SPEAKER_01]: They're aliens, right?

35:54.408 --> 35:55.169
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

35:55.710 --> 35:56.991
[SPEAKER_00]: So this...

35:58.653 --> 35:59.975
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, this has big implications.

36:00.095 --> 36:00.235
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

36:00.295 --> 36:00.576
[SPEAKER_01]: All right.

36:00.816 --> 36:02.178
[SPEAKER_00]: This has really big implications.

36:02.258 --> 36:04.341
[SPEAKER_00]: And so where's this going?

36:04.942 --> 36:15.296
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I don't know, but I'm, but I'm worried about it, but I do feel like that kind of naive take on.

36:17.411 --> 36:20.632
[SPEAKER_00]: like we're going to have to update what we think we're doing here.

36:20.652 --> 36:24.694
[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to have to update the basis through which we conduct politics.

36:25.375 --> 36:30.317
[SPEAKER_00]: If we don't, it's going to be updated through, you know, Trump means of himself as Jesus.

36:30.417 --> 36:36.399
[SPEAKER_01]: But I don't think it's, and I hear from a lot of people, oh, we've got to like upgrade humanity or I don't know.

36:36.479 --> 36:37.660
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think it's that.

36:38.000 --> 36:39.201
[SPEAKER_01]: I think we have

36:45.600 --> 36:57.344
[SPEAKER_01]: developed in the 12th and 13th century by people who didn't even have our best interests and heart, then that are truly obsolete, known workable, in an age of AI and image creation and all.

36:57.804 --> 37:04.986
[SPEAKER_01]: And we created the foundations for a society where sociopaths win.

37:05.246 --> 37:06.267
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

37:06.847 --> 37:07.307
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

37:07.947 --> 37:09.868
[SPEAKER_00]: And so that's, that's the fear.

37:10.209 --> 37:12.578
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, and that's, well, it's not the fear that's the reality.

37:12.598 --> 37:13.561
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the reality.

37:13.742 --> 37:15.529
[SPEAKER_00]: And the irony is

37:17.779 --> 37:36.272
[SPEAKER_00]: At this moment where our relationship to images and media are foreclosing certain older forms of politics, this is a moment when we need some form of politics most in order to figure out what we want our collective relationship to be to this changed present.

37:36.832 --> 37:37.052
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

37:37.272 --> 37:37.473
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

37:37.493 --> 37:40.535
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why I keep going to the extreme local because at least.

37:40.555 --> 37:40.675
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

37:41.235 --> 38:01.404
[SPEAKER_01]: you can kind of believe your eyes there, and it's, I don't mean it in terms of cynicism, but I've done so many sort of monologues where I'll say, look, why don't we take 99% of us, can just be as nice to everyone else as you can, just do that, and we'll assign like 1% even 1% of Americans, is what 4 million people?

38:01.804 --> 38:05.227
[SPEAKER_01]: But 4 million people deliberate on what's actually going on here.

38:05.447 --> 38:07.408
[SPEAKER_01]: It's probably enough, right?

38:07.749 --> 38:19.558
[SPEAKER_01]: And the 3096 million of us, if we do all this other stuff, if we take care of each other, then if FEMA's 15 days late, it won't matter as much, because we know where the sandbags are, and we're more resilient with each other.

38:20.058 --> 38:26.344
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and it's not like a lot of love, but it's like maybe stop worrying about that so much.

38:26.364 --> 38:34.712
[SPEAKER_00]: But there's other policy things you could do, like you could have like comprehensive online privacy legislation that would like really foreclosed a lot of this stuff from happening.

38:34.792 --> 38:36.413
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, you could have, you know what I mean?

38:36.433 --> 38:39.376
[SPEAKER_01]: You could have, but does that, and I guess what does that mean?

38:39.436 --> 38:40.077
[SPEAKER_01]: Does that mean?

38:41.918 --> 38:48.039
[SPEAKER_01]: organizationally that we on podcast or tiny people, let your congressman know that we want this thing.

38:48.059 --> 38:48.539
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

38:49.379 --> 38:57.561
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, to make a list, that's the piece of this that's tricky, is that's like this really needed to have been done in the early 2000s, right?

38:57.641 --> 39:08.963
[SPEAKER_00]: Because we've gone so far, you know, crazy with, you know, data collection, which has enabled things like, you know, the targeted ad industry to go crazy, like they kind of like

39:11.523 --> 39:19.868
[SPEAKER_00]: And honestly, a lot of the AI stuff wouldn't really exist in the same way without the harvesting of, you know, basically everybody's data.

39:20.288 --> 39:20.568
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

39:20.889 --> 39:29.594
[SPEAKER_01]: And now it's like the best you can even think to do is to get, you know, social media companies to use different gentler algorithms on children under 12 or something.

39:29.614 --> 39:29.754
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

39:30.114 --> 39:30.274
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

39:30.314 --> 39:37.078
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, so we're kind of like in, we're in Congress, is it best in the social dilemma phase of this?

39:40.940 --> 39:50.882
[SPEAKER_01]: most of our listeners already believe and understand in the mechanisms through which this happens.

39:50.982 --> 39:58.384
[SPEAKER_01]: So the story of the kitten that's raised in a thing with only vertical lines, then they take them out.

39:58.744 --> 40:00.825
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't see horizontal lines.

40:00.845 --> 40:08.987
[SPEAKER_01]: That we understand these kinds of things, so then as we're raised in increasingly algorithmic landscapes.

40:11.088 --> 40:18.754
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, when I used to write about this, it was so quaint, I wrote about it from the aesthetic perspective.

40:19.035 --> 40:24.279
[SPEAKER_01]: Because I had looked at these experiments that were done on kids in Germany.

40:24.760 --> 40:28.343
[SPEAKER_01]: The kids were raised only listening to digitally recorded music.

40:28.863 --> 40:38.169
[SPEAKER_01]: and then P3s and stuff, and there were orchestral tones and subtleties that they couldn't perceive.

40:38.609 --> 40:38.769
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

40:38.789 --> 40:39.109
[SPEAKER_01]: Any more.

40:39.129 --> 40:43.592
[SPEAKER_01]: So you play like a Deutsche Gramophone record, the 60-year-old can hear, oh yeah, this is different than that.

40:43.912 --> 40:45.553
[SPEAKER_01]: The kids are like sounds exactly the same to me.

40:45.733 --> 41:05.720
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, interesting because they had like always they'd grown up Listen into compressed music so there was like frequencies and things like that that just we're not in the right and Saturdays because because because I'm in the way I used to describe it is that an MP3 is actually not music and MP3 is a

41:10.385 --> 41:17.009
[SPEAKER_01]: digital symbol that's been crafted to make the ears think it's listening to the music.

41:18.169 --> 41:33.278
[SPEAKER_00]: This is like we are very much in the book's territory and here right you know in terms of thinking about how computers make images right they like as you were saying before the computer has no concept of like oh here's a you know a astronaut with a you know eating

41:36.880 --> 41:49.770
[SPEAKER_01]: It's arranging shapes in such a way to make you see that image, which is, as you show, I mean, look at what we learn in first-year film school, is the way the brain works.

41:49.790 --> 41:50.150
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

41:50.170 --> 41:57.016
[SPEAKER_01]: You don't see a fire truck, you see there's red, there's spell, there's ladder, and then my brain assembles.

41:57.476 --> 41:58.097
[SPEAKER_01]: fire truck.

41:58.117 --> 42:00.719
[SPEAKER_01]: Like 90% of that image is coming from me.

42:01.039 --> 42:01.539
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

42:01.819 --> 42:02.280
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

42:02.320 --> 42:13.588
[SPEAKER_00]: And so this is where you get into these whole lineages of like magic and syops and these forms of media that precede from that premise.

42:13.628 --> 42:19.513
[SPEAKER_00]: And like obviously a ton of film was built on that premise too, especially montage techniques and it's like

42:19.713 --> 42:28.656
[SPEAKER_01]: But even regular magic, like we know how the eye sees and also when I do this and I do that, the brain will not see the coin going from this figure to that hand.

42:28.696 --> 42:33.298
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't actually can't see it because I've manipulated your seeing apparatus.

42:33.338 --> 42:33.818
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

42:34.158 --> 42:34.638
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

42:34.938 --> 42:44.241
[SPEAKER_00]: And so those kinds of techniques are really interesting to me because there's a theory of media there that is designed

42:46.842 --> 43:13.543
[SPEAKER_00]: right in other words like that the I'm not telling you a story I'm producing a neurological effect that you're that is going to cause you to perceive reality in a particular way and it feels like that to me is much more the paradigm of what's going on like in an AI system right then author sitting down and trying to tell you a story but just it's called attention to it so because I've been doing my little semantic experience of reality these last few months

43:16.870 --> 43:17.070
[SPEAKER_01]: Why?

43:18.951 --> 43:26.596
[SPEAKER_01]: Because we're not in our shared reality anymore.

43:26.656 --> 43:41.725
[SPEAKER_01]: We're not, I mean, if that I'm sitting here, again, I'm in this body being injected with cues in order to see, but it's a

43:45.327 --> 43:49.648
[SPEAKER_01]: Think, it's like each of us, if it is, each of us is alone, being, it's very matriccy.

43:50.028 --> 43:55.990
[SPEAKER_01]: Being played by this, uh, uh, uh, the by the surround.

43:56.170 --> 44:01.652
[SPEAKER_00]: We'll be, we'll be, we'll be, play with us to the round, but we're also being played by our own cognition.

44:01.692 --> 44:06.033
[SPEAKER_00]: And a lot of what our own cognition wants us to do is be sociable.

44:06.553 --> 44:23.113
[SPEAKER_00]: right so there's enormous parts of your brain like that is just geared to dealing with other people right and reading other people and getting along with other people and being able to function socially you know that's that's that's and then I play that to my AI chat bot trying to you know I can't help it

44:23.613 --> 44:23.813
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

44:24.013 --> 44:24.974
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I wanted to like me.

44:24.994 --> 44:27.955
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, well, this is, this is the, this is the trick.

44:27.975 --> 44:42.023
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, these are, another thing I think is like very predatory and very dangerous about how a lot of AI systems are set up is to mimic those forms of sociology and twist them and use them to manipulate you.

44:42.483 --> 44:45.124
[SPEAKER_00]: For example, you know, you're writing, you know, article or something like that.

44:45.164 --> 44:48.025
[SPEAKER_00]: You might put it in a chatbot and say, like, hey, what do you think about this argument?

44:48.045 --> 44:52.986
[SPEAKER_00]: It'll be like, Doug, this is genuinely groundbreaking ideas you're working with here.

44:53.286 --> 44:55.127
[SPEAKER_00]: And you know, it's bullshitting you.

44:55.487 --> 44:57.167
[SPEAKER_00]: But I guarantee this still feels good.

44:57.667 --> 44:57.887
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

44:58.307 --> 45:00.328
[SPEAKER_00]: If you told this is really, you're really smart, Doug.

45:00.428 --> 45:03.632
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but no, it didn't get the prompt.

45:03.652 --> 45:04.833
[SPEAKER_01]: I've given it at the beginning.

45:05.915 --> 45:09.339
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you have one of your, yeah, that's all right.

45:09.359 --> 45:10.200
[SPEAKER_00]: Put it in this thing.

45:10.240 --> 45:10.940
[SPEAKER_00]: Do not do that.

45:10.960 --> 45:11.381
[SPEAKER_01]: That's all right.

45:11.421 --> 45:12.202
[SPEAKER_01]: Do not do that.

45:12.703 --> 45:13.243
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

45:14.344 --> 45:16.567
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, there is that, there is that, oh, you're right.

45:17.488 --> 45:20.109
[SPEAKER_01]: I was going to get into the greater key of Solomon.

45:20.569 --> 45:23.731
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so some prize to you brought that up.

45:24.911 --> 45:27.373
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, I've been thinking about that, right?

45:27.593 --> 45:35.996
[SPEAKER_01]: So you've kind of traced this lineage from Renaissance visuals and greater key of Solomon to contemporary neural triggers.

45:36.237 --> 45:37.017
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

45:37.297 --> 45:41.459
[SPEAKER_01]: So do you look at contemporary AI developers

45:45.437 --> 45:53.622
[SPEAKER_01]: kind of modern sorcerers, summoning operational forces to bind and bend reality.

45:54.203 --> 45:59.286
[SPEAKER_00]: Not only would I describe them that way, they would describe themselves, though.

45:59.306 --> 46:01.507
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's really weird, like, when you, it's so weird.

46:01.527 --> 46:08.892
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, if you hang out in California a bunch, and you talk to people who are working with cutting-edge technologies.

46:09.513 --> 46:10.473
[SPEAKER_00]: And let's take two examples.

46:10.493 --> 46:13.695
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's take like AI researchers, and we'll take that biotech research, okay.

46:15.136 --> 46:28.671
[SPEAKER_00]: you talk to a biotech researcher, the most rational person you've ever met, your life they're like, this is this and this ends up as going to go here and it's going to trigger this and you know, they're very clear understanding of what they're trying to do and how they're trying to get there.

46:29.552 --> 46:32.195
[SPEAKER_00]: You talk to a AI researcher and they're like,

46:32.896 --> 46:34.057
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't know what's going on.

46:34.077 --> 46:38.300
[SPEAKER_00]: We're just putting data and compute into the cauldron and like demons are coming out.

46:38.680 --> 46:39.921
[SPEAKER_00]: And hopefully they'll be benign.

46:40.221 --> 46:40.401
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

46:40.441 --> 46:42.003
[SPEAKER_00]: That's really the kind of language.

46:42.103 --> 46:42.383
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

46:42.403 --> 46:45.785
[SPEAKER_01]: Which sounds much closer to Grant Morrison than Alan Moore.

46:46.045 --> 46:46.145
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

46:46.165 --> 46:49.308
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a chaos magic of like, yeah, I don't know how it works.

46:49.588 --> 46:50.609
[SPEAKER_01]: But you take the words.

46:50.749 --> 46:51.429
[SPEAKER_01]: You draw them down.

46:51.449 --> 46:51.749
[SPEAKER_01]: You do.

46:51.970 --> 46:53.511
[SPEAKER_01]: You jerk off on it and you burn it.

46:54.332 --> 47:02.877
[SPEAKER_00]: We're just gonna happen, you know, it's like literally like that, like a lot of those guys are like totally into things like chaos magic Right even specifically.

47:02.917 --> 47:06.419
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, there was even a character on Silicon Valley the comedy show.

47:06.659 --> 47:08.200
[SPEAKER_01]: There was that one sort of a couple

47:10.601 --> 47:20.565
[SPEAKER_00]: No, but it was like, it was, it had a bunch of people that are recommending me to read Ramsey Dukes, you know, like SSO, MOTB, you know, that book.

47:20.625 --> 47:22.466
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was like, why are you talking about?

47:22.986 --> 47:26.548
[SPEAKER_00]: And I read it and I was like, well, this is intense.

47:26.588 --> 47:37.052
[SPEAKER_00]: Like the world that these guys are living in, who are on, like, cutting edge, you know, AI development work, because it really is much closer to chaos magic than it is science.

47:37.072 --> 47:39.233
[SPEAKER_01]: But that was supposed to be our world.

47:41.153 --> 48:00.657
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I was mad enough that Trump's using, you know, Norman Vincent Peel and power positive thinking and they did cack and Pepe and all, it's like, and, and, and, and discordianism and pranksterism, it's like that was, our side, Robert Anton Wilson, and, you know, that Paul Crasner, Abby Hoffman, yeah.

48:01.157 --> 48:04.978
[SPEAKER_01]: So on some level, I feel like we kind of started this.

48:10.654 --> 48:12.756
[SPEAKER_01]: but it was part of the objective.

48:13.236 --> 48:27.527
[SPEAKER_01]: Optical illusions and dataism and pranksterism, you loosen people's grip on reality in order to help them see other possibilities, not in order to inject them with

48:29.227 --> 48:31.008
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, no, exactly.

48:31.048 --> 48:33.709
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the kind of irony of this stuff.

48:33.789 --> 48:44.412
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it like, you know, I was in around in the 70s and or the 80s that much, but my understanding of it was that these were ways of trying to

48:46.072 --> 49:07.773
[SPEAKER_00]: unglunk rigid ways of thinking about what society should be and what the possibilities with in society should be and gave rise to things like feminism or queer activism like kind of radically opening up this space of what was possible in terms of like how you wanted to live your life or what counted as, you know, a human

49:08.674 --> 49:11.495
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, no human with rights basically, right?

49:12.195 --> 49:36.205
[SPEAKER_00]: And you do see there is a kind of like other side of that coin, which is, you know, like the the weaponization of that, or like the using that towards the purposes of either conjuring into existence like very dark realities or nihilistic ones, you know, which are kind of very related to each other.

49:36.635 --> 49:43.178
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, once you know that these things aren't really real, denialism sort of the only only place to go.

49:43.198 --> 49:43.699
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

49:43.719 --> 49:45.880
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's the Soviet strategy.

49:45.920 --> 49:46.160
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

49:46.200 --> 49:47.160
[SPEAKER_00]: I want to be there.

49:47.340 --> 49:48.081
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't want to do that.

49:48.441 --> 49:52.443
[SPEAKER_01]: I want to be a weird, happy, strange, experimental baby.

49:52.463 --> 49:55.585
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

49:55.705 --> 49:57.185
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I like that one.

49:57.626 --> 50:02.228
[SPEAKER_01]: So I read the book, I read the PDF of it, and I finally got to wear

50:03.729 --> 50:16.435
[SPEAKER_01]: I thought you were going when you were split you could only talk for half an hour whatever you could do everything but you started to go to this place that reminded me of the impulse I had when I wrote this book program or be programmed.

50:16.795 --> 50:29.921
[SPEAKER_01]: So I was really freaking out about our transition to digital that since about 98, 99 when I saw that we were instead of empowering the collective

50:30.381 --> 50:35.164
[SPEAKER_01]: humanity to dream a more interesting dream and create a new reality together.

50:35.605 --> 50:41.448
[SPEAKER_01]: We were going to use this stuff on people in a feedback loop in order to make humans more predictable.

50:41.588 --> 50:43.149
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and I was oh my god.

50:43.310 --> 50:43.790
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my god.

50:43.930 --> 50:44.991
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my god.

50:45.571 --> 50:46.892
[SPEAKER_01]: And the oh my god part went.

50:48.776 --> 50:52.138
[SPEAKER_01]: This is what the Torah was about, right?

50:52.418 --> 51:00.823
[SPEAKER_01]: So Torah, obviously right now, seemingly may have been a failed effort at developing an ethical code for humanity, but...

51:01.362 --> 51:12.809
[SPEAKER_01]: What they were trying to do, they were looking at, this is a civilization that is transitioning from an oral world to a written world, to a scriptural world.

51:13.309 --> 51:18.072
[SPEAKER_01]: And things are going to get really fucked up if we don't take some real steps here.

51:18.512 --> 51:29.579
[SPEAKER_01]: So you can look at Torah law and the Ten Commandments and all that stuff is saying, okay, in the world that you know, you make a deal with somebody, you agree, Ida, I, and then he's gonna be there next season.

51:30.439 --> 51:39.342
[SPEAKER_01]: Now you're moving into a world where you're gonna write something down on paper and the person you signed it with may be gone and have enforcers there, how's that gonna work out for you?

51:39.582 --> 51:48.425
[SPEAKER_01]: Now you're gonna instead of history being something that a grandmother tells her child, history is gonna be this thing in a book, but you're gonna be able to point to it's how's that gonna work out?

51:48.445 --> 51:53.846
[SPEAKER_01]: So all these things are gonna change when you write things down, you're gonna lose the personal and move into this symbolic thing.

51:53.866 --> 51:56.027
[SPEAKER_01]: You're gonna have these magical pages that

51:56.367 --> 51:56.727
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

51:57.568 --> 51:58.588
[SPEAKER_01]: So you develop a thing.

51:58.868 --> 52:04.652
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was thinking, Oh, well, what's the equivalent of 10 commandments in this transition?

52:04.732 --> 52:08.054
[SPEAKER_01]: This transition to the digital is as big as that one.

52:08.714 --> 52:11.736
[SPEAKER_01]: So I did program, we probably 10 commands for the digital ages.

52:12.636 --> 52:17.759
[SPEAKER_01]: And looking at the equivalent of prohibition on images in the

52:18.800 --> 52:21.861
[SPEAKER_01]: But we weren't actually there yet.

52:22.061 --> 52:27.663
[SPEAKER_01]: In some ways, I wrote that too soon because I was writing it, although it ended up being good enough for now.

52:27.703 --> 52:31.864
[SPEAKER_01]: I just republished it because I was writing about AI without knowing AI.

52:31.944 --> 52:32.544
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

52:32.584 --> 52:39.627
[SPEAKER_01]: I was writing about what is it going to be to live in a world where things are programmed to change based on what you do?

52:39.807 --> 52:42.688
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you know, in the sort of cybernetic feedback loop.

52:42.708 --> 52:43.768
[SPEAKER_01]: And he knew it back then.

52:43.808 --> 52:44.608
[SPEAKER_01]: Norbert Weiner knew it.

52:44.628 --> 52:44.908
[SPEAKER_00]: Totally.

52:45.148 --> 52:45.509
[SPEAKER_01]: This.

52:45.709 --> 52:46.509
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

52:46.889 --> 53:04.993
[SPEAKER_00]: But now, are there things we can pull from their insights back then to apply, yeah, I mean, I think a lot about that second commandment, I think about it through like the Old Testament, but then I also think about it through the Nostics, right?

53:05.233 --> 53:08.734
[SPEAKER_00]: And second commandment being prohibition on images, right?

53:08.834 --> 53:12.555
[SPEAKER_00]: And like people think it's like, oh, don't make idolatrous, that's not what it says.

53:16.956 --> 53:19.758
[SPEAKER_01]: No, you know, I know you we always want to soften it.

53:19.878 --> 53:25.000
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, just something else, but it really is don't put images Yeah, but image not in your skin not in the books, right?

53:25.621 --> 53:26.301
[SPEAKER_00]: Just don't do it.

53:26.361 --> 53:35.366
[SPEAKER_00]: No, no, no, no, graven images or anything that isn't heaven above or the waters beneath the earth or you know Anything they're pretty strict with that pretty strict.

53:35.606 --> 53:42.810
[SPEAKER_01]: They're really afraid that I think they're afraid that images come to life Which they do right they become idols yeah

53:43.310 --> 53:49.955
[SPEAKER_00]: they become idols, they become sigils, they become, they, they affect reality, right?

53:50.155 --> 53:52.737
[SPEAKER_00]: They, they, they alter reality when you make images of it.

53:52.757 --> 53:52.897
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

53:53.557 --> 53:58.581
[SPEAKER_00]: And you know, I mean, we know this, but like it feels super charged to me, right?

53:58.601 --> 54:07.387
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's really interesting to me, you know, I have a whole bit when I do a kind of a performance around the book where I talk about that.

54:07.447 --> 54:08.187
[SPEAKER_00]: Second commandment.

54:09.288 --> 54:17.800
[SPEAKER_00]: higher on the list than murder, but then what is Yahweh do right after that?

54:17.820 --> 54:23.928
[SPEAKER_00]: He's like okay, no images and like here's an image, you know, it's gonna be two qubits by three qubits.

54:23.968 --> 54:25.149
[SPEAKER_00]: It's the arc of the covenant, right?

54:25.189 --> 54:26.070
[SPEAKER_00]: He tells him to make the arc.

54:26.571 --> 54:35.076
[SPEAKER_01]: right, but the arc of the covenant that he wanted for the Israelites had no thing on the top and had two cherubin protecting the empty space on the top.

54:35.096 --> 54:37.578
[SPEAKER_01]: We're usually you'd put a statue of a god up there.

54:37.678 --> 54:38.479
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

54:38.639 --> 54:39.559
[SPEAKER_00]: But there's still cherubin.

54:39.599 --> 54:41.681
[SPEAKER_00]: He says, yeah, the wings and the got to hold hold.

54:41.701 --> 54:42.101
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

54:42.601 --> 54:51.284
[SPEAKER_00]: And what's, I think I find so interesting about that story is that then they make the arc and it works like it first, right?

54:51.304 --> 54:56.586
[SPEAKER_00]: So it like parts the river Jordan, it like tears down the walls of Jericho, right?

54:56.606 --> 55:03.689
[SPEAKER_00]: And the Israelite start thinking that this image is like their, you know, secret weapon, right?

55:03.909 --> 55:06.009
[SPEAKER_00]: And then that goes on for a while.

55:06.029 --> 55:08.750
[SPEAKER_00]: They're in a big war with the Philistines and they're

55:10.471 --> 55:13.353
[SPEAKER_00]: And there's going to be a battle and the Israelites are what we do.

55:13.473 --> 55:15.274
[SPEAKER_00]: It was like, okay, well, we'll bring out the army.

55:15.294 --> 55:16.294
[SPEAKER_00]: Bring out the army.

55:16.495 --> 55:17.155
[SPEAKER_00]: It's interesting.

55:17.235 --> 55:18.076
[SPEAKER_00]: No about the art.

55:18.096 --> 55:18.976
[SPEAKER_00]: They're afraid of it.

55:18.996 --> 55:19.817
[SPEAKER_00]: They're like, oh shit.

55:20.017 --> 55:21.177
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't like what we're going to do.

55:21.878 --> 55:23.399
[SPEAKER_00]: So the Israelites, you didn't, sorry.

55:23.419 --> 55:26.020
[SPEAKER_00]: The Philstein's charge is realized with chariots.

55:26.881 --> 55:28.622
[SPEAKER_00]: And the Israelites raise up the arc.

55:28.642 --> 55:30.303
[SPEAKER_00]: You think, like, so it's going to come out?

55:30.323 --> 55:30.483
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

55:30.503 --> 55:31.663
[SPEAKER_00]: That can Indiana Jones or something.

55:32.524 --> 55:34.505
[SPEAKER_00]: And the Israelites get slaughtered, right?

55:34.525 --> 55:36.686
[SPEAKER_00]: 30,000 people died, but the Battle of Affect.

55:36.726 --> 55:39.408
[SPEAKER_00]: I think 10, 50 BCE, something like that.

55:40.268 --> 56:04.738
[SPEAKER_00]: And to me, that's such a crazy moment, in just theologically, like what's going on here, is this a lesson about not having faith in images to do what you want them to do, is this a lesson about their being a base reality under images that you should not confuse with the world of images.

56:04.758 --> 56:06.059
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, there's all kinds of things.

56:09.260 --> 56:19.229
[SPEAKER_01]: And finally, you know, 600 million people from the Southern continents have made their way to Larry Ellison's fortress.

56:19.669 --> 56:28.017
[SPEAKER_01]: And he's projecting Paramount Yellowstone in the images and they're like, we don't care where we're going to eat you.

56:28.357 --> 56:40.886
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly, or the floods are rising and global warming is like, oh, no, we don't care whether you think that, you know, this virus is real or whether you think that these, you know, like glaciers melting is real.

56:40.966 --> 56:42.688
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm still gonna happen, right?

56:43.228 --> 56:44.549
[SPEAKER_00]: So you get that, but then...

56:46.310 --> 56:54.158
[SPEAKER_00]: You get this whole nostic inflection on that whole story, though, too, which is this, you get the story of the Demi urge, right?

56:54.218 --> 57:01.605
[SPEAKER_00]: And some of the strands of narcissism that God of the Old Testament is a Demiurgical God, right?

57:03.807 --> 57:04.767
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.

57:04.787 --> 57:15.670
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, it's the demyroge is they had other names for it like Samail y'all Daba Oat, but in some of those traditions y'all way is is a demyroge.

57:15.710 --> 57:17.450
[SPEAKER_01]: And a judge as a God means what?

57:17.810 --> 57:25.512
[SPEAKER_00]: The demyroge as a God is a God that is that creates images and then believes that those images are the same things reality.

57:26.252 --> 57:32.793
[SPEAKER_00]: right so it's a basically a god who makes simulations and can and does not distinguish simulation from reality.

57:32.813 --> 57:33.894
[SPEAKER_00]: God makes a heaven and the earth.

57:34.094 --> 57:37.114
[SPEAKER_00]: God made heaven and the earth put God parts the red seat right.

57:37.614 --> 57:53.037
[SPEAKER_00]: God that the demyurgical god can do whatever it wants because reality as we perceive it is an illusion right and the god is in charge of that illusion and so in those traditions the god of the new testament is a different god and you're the point of your

57:56.338 --> 58:01.084
[SPEAKER_00]: world of illusions, and find this higher form of knowledge.

58:01.885 --> 58:03.768
[SPEAKER_00]: This is in lots of different traditions, though, too.

58:03.808 --> 58:11.097
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, this is the concept of Maya from the thing that is in the Vedas is very similar.

58:11.177 --> 58:11.557
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

58:11.597 --> 58:13.279
[SPEAKER_00]: So this is a theme that recurs all along.

58:13.780 --> 58:15.202
[SPEAKER_01]: So that because he's a demi-erge,

58:15.662 --> 58:35.890
[SPEAKER_00]: I've been thinking about the demi-erge a lot because it like Trump feels like a demi-erge to me, you know, a lot of political figures feel like they're applying a demi-ergeical logic to reality and like the arc when it first came out, it does work a bunch of times until it doesn't and then when it doesn't, you're in real big trouble.

58:36.490 --> 58:42.517
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, and AI is a in some ways is a tool for the Demi urge.

58:42.618 --> 58:55.353
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you know AI will make you a novel that nobody wrote AI will make you all the images that you want that have no Relationship to reality if we want to call it that way

58:55.953 --> 59:11.368
[SPEAKER_00]: It is this kind of world of pure simulation that we experience as being real because we've been conditioned for thousands of years to know that if I saw a text, somebody wrote that text.

59:11.388 --> 59:19.336
[SPEAKER_00]: If I saw an image, somebody made that image or a camera made that image and it was tethered to some light that bounced off a sensor somehow.

59:19.876 --> 59:29.678
[SPEAKER_00]: That created a kind of common sense about how to understand reality that has been upended now in ways that I think are quite profound.

59:30.498 --> 59:47.982
[SPEAKER_01]: You've been modeling for me something that I'm trying to do myself, but I feel often conflicted about, which is I'm trying to figure out what's the appropriate path for an artist-writer activist at a moment as dire as this.

59:48.502 --> 59:51.783
[SPEAKER_01]: I sometimes feel like doing the fun art, writing a graphic novel.

59:51.823 --> 01:00:01.966
[SPEAKER_01]: Even if it's going to open 12-year-old kids into what's happening, feels like a self-indulgent diversion in the face of imminent disaster.

01:00:02.746 --> 01:00:05.347
[SPEAKER_01]: It seems to me your answer is to, you mix it up.

01:00:05.387 --> 01:00:10.509
[SPEAKER_01]: You do some activism, you do some intellectualism, you write a book, but then you do a crazy photography project.

01:00:10.569 --> 01:00:14.810
[SPEAKER_01]: And then it is that sort of your, yeah, that's my approach.

01:00:16.133 --> 01:00:21.136
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I think we need a lot of people doing a lot of different things, right?

01:00:21.197 --> 01:00:25.580
[SPEAKER_00]: And so I actually believe in art, I believe in what I do.

01:00:25.600 --> 01:00:26.820
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I have to do that.

01:00:27.061 --> 01:00:30.323
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, sometimes I'm very old-fashioned, you know, but.

01:00:32.123 --> 01:00:57.845
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that those of us who are cultural producers, I think we sometimes poo poo the significance of what we do, but I do think that we are in the business of telling stories, making images, creating ideas that we collectively can use to try to understand the moment in history that we're living in.

01:00:58.265 --> 01:01:01.348
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's actually a really important thing to do.

01:01:01.708 --> 01:01:04.210
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's kind of a different thing than science.

01:01:04.270 --> 01:01:08.453
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's kind of a different thing than party politics.

01:01:08.493 --> 01:01:12.437
[SPEAKER_00]: Or that's even kind of a different thing than some kind of activism as well.

01:01:12.457 --> 01:01:14.378
[SPEAKER_00]: That's certainly a different thing than policy.

01:01:14.799 --> 01:01:20.283
[SPEAKER_00]: But you need all of these things to be talking to each other and working together in order to

01:01:21.564 --> 01:01:29.772
[SPEAKER_00]: First of all, understand the conditions under which we're living and then to imagine the ones that we actually want to exist within and then to implement those.

01:01:30.272 --> 01:01:30.793
[SPEAKER_01]: I like that.

01:01:31.494 --> 01:01:33.956
[SPEAKER_01]: Team Human can have a lot of different kinds of characters.

01:01:33.976 --> 01:01:34.216
[SPEAKER_01]: We have to.

01:01:34.236 --> 01:01:34.597
[SPEAKER_01]: I always get this.

01:01:34.617 --> 01:01:34.717
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:01:34.737 --> 01:01:34.857
[SPEAKER_01]: Great.

01:01:34.877 --> 01:01:34.977
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:01:34.997 --> 01:01:35.057
[SPEAKER_01]: No.

01:01:35.077 --> 01:01:37.259
[SPEAKER_01]: I always feel a little bit bad when people are like, oh, well, this is frivolous and that's not.

01:01:37.279 --> 01:01:46.308
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, like, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what, what,

01:01:47.717 --> 01:01:53.644
[SPEAKER_00]: the beauty of humans as we can do all this stuff, you know, and we kind of need to do all this stuff.

01:01:53.884 --> 01:01:54.124
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

01:01:54.304 --> 01:01:55.085
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why it's great.

01:01:55.105 --> 01:01:56.487
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a whole bunch of us.

01:01:56.967 --> 01:01:59.030
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, thanks for being on team human, man.

01:01:59.090 --> 01:02:00.031
[SPEAKER_01]: It really, it means a lot.

01:02:00.051 --> 01:02:00.612
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a pinnacle.

01:02:00.792 --> 01:02:01.633
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much.

01:02:01.653 --> 01:02:02.514
[SPEAKER_00]: Man, it's been wonderful.

01:02:02.534 --> 01:02:02.914
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

01:02:02.934 --> 01:02:06.278
[SPEAKER_00]: And here and it's been a lifelong dream to be able to talk to you.

01:02:06.738 --> 01:02:28.527
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks, let's be friends now and you everyone in the meantime get this get this how to see like a machine But we're afraid to ask about that's an old reference Trevor Paglin it's short, but that's a good thing not a bad thing don't you wouldn't you rather pay for him to take more time?

01:02:28.827 --> 01:02:30.207
[SPEAKER_01]: to shorten it for you.

01:02:30.327 --> 01:02:35.509
[SPEAKER_01]: It's how many countless hours did he save working those extra hours to shorten this book?

01:02:35.949 --> 01:02:48.933
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a blessedly brief but deeply provocative and ultimately finally reassuring take on our increasing disorientation.

01:02:49.813 --> 01:02:50.994
[SPEAKER_01]: You've been on team human.

01:02:51.154 --> 01:02:51.374
[SPEAKER_01]: You can

01:02:56.115 --> 01:02:57.195
[SPEAKER_01]: do anything you can.

01:02:57.255 --> 01:02:57.656
[SPEAKER_01]: It helps.

01:02:57.696 --> 01:03:00.176
[SPEAKER_01]: Look at us wearing a beautiful studio because it's you.

01:03:00.196 --> 01:03:02.337
[SPEAKER_01]: If you can't do that, click on things.

01:03:02.357 --> 01:03:02.917
[SPEAKER_01]: There's hearts.

01:03:02.937 --> 01:03:03.617
[SPEAKER_01]: There's checks.

01:03:03.637 --> 01:03:04.558
[SPEAKER_01]: There's subscribe.

01:03:05.018 --> 01:03:06.919
[SPEAKER_01]: All these platforms have all these things.

01:03:06.939 --> 01:03:08.099
[SPEAKER_01]: They're watching you.

01:03:09.159 --> 01:03:10.760
[SPEAKER_01]: Sorry, but click on them anyway.

01:03:11.640 --> 01:03:12.440
[SPEAKER_01]: I do love you.

01:03:13.041 --> 01:03:18.522
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Douglas Rushcoff, team members produced by Joshua Chaplin and edited by Luke Robert Mason.

01:03:18.762 --> 01:03:18.922
[SPEAKER_01]: You've

