WEBVTT

00:01.401 --> 00:05.026
[SPEAKER_03]: dark cast network, indie pods with a dark side.

00:08.393 --> 00:09.574
[SPEAKER_02]: Hey everyone, it's Kona.

00:10.034 --> 00:18.280
[SPEAKER_02]: We don't have a new episode this week, unfortunately, but we do have huge news in a case that we covered back in the beginning of 2024.

00:19.220 --> 00:27.166
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen Fleming was just weeks away from her 28th birthday when she went missing after a night out in her hometown of Parker's birth west Virginia.

00:28.046 --> 00:33.430
[SPEAKER_02]: She was last seen leaving a bar with a man who was laid out identified as 55 year old person Pierce.

00:33.804 --> 00:40.067
[SPEAKER_02]: Pierce is not who she arrived with, and there's no indication that the two had ever met before that night.

00:40.727 --> 00:43.708
[SPEAKER_02]: Gregion also left her purse and herself in behind.

00:44.188 --> 00:57.534
[SPEAKER_02]: Despite the fact that Parker'sburg police quickly identified Pierce as the last person she was seen with, and the fact that he admitted her being in his car that night, he quickly stopped cooperating, and police weren't able to make an arrest.

00:58.114 --> 01:00.055
[SPEAKER_02]: But that all changed on May 15th, 2026.

01:02.501 --> 01:14.045
[SPEAKER_02]: On that day, Preston Pierce, who's now 58, was indicted by a grand jury in Wood County on charges of first-degree murder, felony murder, concealment of a dead body, and kidnapping.

01:14.465 --> 01:21.728
[SPEAKER_02]: Preston Pierce has left West Virginia and was down in Asheville, North Carolina, where he was apprehended by U.S. marshals.

01:22.738 --> 01:26.860
[SPEAKER_02]: He is now sitting in a North Carolina jail awaiting extradition.

01:27.261 --> 01:29.262
[SPEAKER_02]: He had a brief hearing on May 18th.

01:29.582 --> 01:30.963
[SPEAKER_02]: Here's some audio from that hearing.

01:31.283 --> 01:34.065
[SPEAKER_01]: They have up to 90 days to issue a governor for it.

01:35.025 --> 01:37.627
[SPEAKER_01]: The state of West Virginia, which is good counting.

01:38.756 --> 01:42.837
[SPEAKER_01]: has filed a fugitive born demanding that you return to their state.

01:43.477 --> 01:52.060
[SPEAKER_01]: They have up to 90 days to issue a governor's warrant to take you back to their state or you can wave up to tradition and return to their state voluntarily.

01:52.700 --> 01:54.741
[SPEAKER_01]: You have the right to no attorney on this decision.

01:55.181 --> 01:57.641
[SPEAKER_01]: You can represent yourself, you can hire a lawyer.

01:57.982 --> 02:01.683
[SPEAKER_01]: You can ask the court appointing attorney if you're unable to afford an attorney.

02:02.143 --> 02:04.043
[SPEAKER_01]: What would you like to do about an attorney's there?

02:08.068 --> 02:14.251
[SPEAKER_03]: purpose, but at least department has already gotten the attorney there in Harper's or it looks Angela Brutal party.

02:16.692 --> 02:20.174
[SPEAKER_01]: So you're telling the court that you have an attorney in this matter, the extradition?

02:20.194 --> 02:26.296
[SPEAKER_03]: Well, in the case about the extradition correct.

02:26.697 --> 02:29.358
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, the state of North Carolina, you're entitled to an attorney.

02:29.498 --> 02:33.940
[SPEAKER_01]: So if you're telling me that you have an attorney in Virginia, I need to know if you have an attorney in North Carolina.

02:34.953 --> 02:36.814
[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, I don't have enough in North Carolina.

02:36.834 --> 02:40.097
[SPEAKER_01]: What are your plans with regards to North Carolina?

02:40.137 --> 02:41.638
[SPEAKER_03]: Could I get it for one of the turning?

02:42.098 --> 02:43.199
[SPEAKER_01]: Are you currently employed?

02:44.119 --> 02:44.359
[SPEAKER_03]: No.

02:45.280 --> 02:47.041
[SPEAKER_01]: Are you wanting a government assistance, sir?

02:48.202 --> 02:48.402
[SPEAKER_03]: No.

02:49.363 --> 02:50.624
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you own home that you live in?

02:51.824 --> 02:52.025
[SPEAKER_03]: No.

02:52.525 --> 02:54.586
[SPEAKER_01]: The corbal appoints and attorneys represent you.

02:55.327 --> 02:56.908
[SPEAKER_01]: You're currently being held on a bond.

02:56.988 --> 02:58.529
[SPEAKER_01]: They won't be changing your bond.

02:58.569 --> 03:00.190
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm both here from the state of North Carolina.

03:00.210 --> 03:01.191
[SPEAKER_01]: They would like to be heard.

03:05.457 --> 03:07.258
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm leaving you on where it's out with your peers.

03:08.059 --> 03:17.465
[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to give you another court action review in your decision with regards to waving up to addition or fighting at tradition, and that court table me, June 5th and free the year on her.

03:18.346 --> 03:19.947
[SPEAKER_01]: All right, start after next week or date.

03:21.028 --> 03:23.310
[SPEAKER_01]: The public defender's office will make plans to meet with you.

03:25.151 --> 03:25.771
[SPEAKER_03]: June 5th.

03:26.172 --> 03:26.552
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, sir.

03:28.293 --> 03:29.334
[SPEAKER_03]: Any particular time?

03:32.099 --> 03:49.511
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, if you're still in custody, he'll bring you to court, but it starts at 9.30, what starts at 9.30 a.a.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s.s

03:52.311 --> 04:03.117
[SPEAKER_02]: Interestingly, based on North Carolina court records that I was able to find, they list Preston Pierce's address as an address in Parker'sburg, where he apparently used to live.

04:03.758 --> 04:15.584
[SPEAKER_02]: As we stated in our original episode, Preston has apparently spent some time being homeless, so I don't know if that's what's going on with him now, but he doesn't appear to have an address in North Carolina.

04:16.285 --> 04:17.946
[SPEAKER_02]: So why is this all happening now?

04:19.237 --> 04:22.559
[SPEAKER_02]: The answer is because they found Gretchen's body.

04:23.280 --> 04:27.403
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, technically, they found a back in September of 2025.

04:28.424 --> 04:37.790
[SPEAKER_02]: On September 15, 2025, box 8 reported that a squirrel hunter found a human skull in Wart County, West Virginia.

04:38.811 --> 04:44.355
[SPEAKER_02]: The skull was found on an embankment along Courtney Ridge Road in Palestine, according to state police.

04:44.996 --> 04:56.084
[SPEAKER_02]: It apparently took from September of last year to May of this year for DNA results to come back to conclusively identify the remains as grudge and flooding.

04:56.645 --> 05:00.868
[SPEAKER_02]: The location where her body was found is only about 23 miles from where she was last seen.

05:01.400 --> 05:12.036
[SPEAKER_02]: After the remainder positively identified, a grand jury quickly handed down an indictment and as I mentioned, Preston Pierce is now in jail awaiting extradition.

05:12.777 --> 05:15.360
[SPEAKER_02]: His extradition hearing will take place on June 5, 2026.

05:17.383 --> 05:19.805
[SPEAKER_02]: After that, it's going to be a pretty long process.

05:19.845 --> 05:24.428
[SPEAKER_02]: They're going to be myriad other hearings that will take place in West Virginia.

05:25.288 --> 05:28.711
[SPEAKER_02]: This case unfortunately isn't exactly local to us.

05:29.051 --> 05:32.313
[SPEAKER_02]: Parker spurs around four and a half, five hours from where we are.

05:32.433 --> 05:36.736
[SPEAKER_02]: So I won't be able to attend all of the hearings like I can in some of these other cases.

05:37.276 --> 05:41.059
[SPEAKER_02]: But if this does go to trial, I'm definitely going to try to make it down for that.

05:41.859 --> 05:46.701
[SPEAKER_02]: Any time a case is resolved like this, where a body is founded, it's obviously bittersweet.

05:47.661 --> 05:54.284
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen's family has known for quite a while that something terrible happened to her on the night of December 3, 2022.

05:54.964 --> 05:56.645
[SPEAKER_02]: And now they have that confirmation.

05:57.305 --> 06:02.887
[SPEAKER_02]: But fortunately, the man that they believe to responsible is facing charges in her death.

06:03.893 --> 06:06.714
[SPEAKER_02]: We'll keep you updated as this trial progresses.

06:06.955 --> 06:16.699
[SPEAKER_02]: Always remember, I usually post things on TikTok, Instagram, so YouTube, check us out there for smaller updates and any larger updates.

06:16.899 --> 06:20.121
[SPEAKER_02]: We'll of course do a full update episode on Gretchen.

06:20.621 --> 06:26.864
[SPEAKER_02]: But for now, I'm going to leave you with our original episode on Gretchen Fleming from 2024.

06:27.865 --> 06:31.867
[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you for listening and we'll see you next week for a brand new episode.

06:33.605 --> 06:40.669
[SPEAKER_02]: After dealing with the breakup and the sudden loss of her mother, Gretchen Fleming found herself back in her hometown of Parker's Berk West Virginia.

06:41.550 --> 06:45.652
[SPEAKER_02]: She was staying with family as she tried to get herself back together and figure out her next move.

06:46.253 --> 06:52.937
[SPEAKER_02]: On December 3rd, 2022, Gretchen told her family that she wasn't going to be home that night and she headed out to a local bar.

06:53.737 --> 06:57.938
[SPEAKER_02]: After going to a second bar with a friend, Gretchen walked out and was never seen again.

06:58.498 --> 07:03.980
[SPEAKER_02]: Did the friend who later turned in Gretchen's personal phone know something about her disappearance?

07:04.560 --> 07:08.821
[SPEAKER_02]: Or was it the man she was seeing leaving the last bar with who had something to hide?

07:09.501 --> 07:22.505
[SPEAKER_02]: For over a year, the small town of Parker's Berk has been a buzz with theories of what happened that night, and continued to hold out hope that someday soon, they will find out who really knows what happened to Gretchen Fleming.

07:23.305 --> 07:26.427
[SPEAKER_02]: When a person goes missing, there's a special kind of pain in the not-knowing.

07:26.447 --> 07:29.350
[SPEAKER_02]: I want to say the stories of those who never came home.

07:29.870 --> 07:32.712
[SPEAKER_02]: Today, I want to tell you the story of Gretchen Fleming.

07:33.353 --> 07:35.294
[SPEAKER_04]: I'm Kona Gallagher, and I'm Ethan Fook.

07:35.674 --> 07:37.636
[SPEAKER_02]: And this is, and then they were gone.

08:15.768 --> 08:16.709
[SPEAKER_02]: Welcome back, everyone.

08:16.849 --> 08:17.589
[SPEAKER_04]: Welcome back.

08:17.649 --> 08:18.950
[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you for joining us once again.

08:18.970 --> 08:20.471
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm Kona.

08:20.752 --> 08:21.372
[SPEAKER_04]: And I'm Ethan.

08:21.893 --> 08:24.274
[SPEAKER_02]: And where there has been a wife team behind this podcast.

08:24.775 --> 08:28.017
[SPEAKER_02]: Each week I tell you the story of an unsolved missing person's case.

08:28.617 --> 08:35.583
[SPEAKER_02]: Ethan doesn't know anything about the case going into the episode, and he is here to provide his reactions and questions in real time.

08:36.063 --> 08:38.605
[SPEAKER_02]: Hopefully asking some of the same ones you have at home.

08:40.020 --> 08:50.644
[SPEAKER_02]: this week, we're bringing you a case that isn't necessarily bizarre because of the circumstances, but more because of the main person of interest.

08:51.765 --> 08:52.245
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

08:52.565 --> 08:57.887
[SPEAKER_02]: So I don't want to give too much away, but he definitely has a checkered past.

08:58.888 --> 08:59.368
[SPEAKER_04]: Interesting.

08:59.936 --> 09:23.043
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and I mean, there are all sorts of wild rumors about this person, some of which, you know, are pretty well substantiated, others, which are a little more out there, but you know, we'll talk about that and this is a small town case of a missing adult.

09:24.023 --> 09:28.987
[SPEAKER_02]: Which generally, the investigations don't go very well, right?

09:29.007 --> 09:29.927
[SPEAKER_02]: Those situations.

09:30.087 --> 09:30.808
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

09:31.108 --> 09:35.491
[SPEAKER_01]: This is very different from missing adult cases that we typically cover though.

09:36.232 --> 09:41.335
[SPEAKER_02]: Before we get started though, I want to get a shout out to the newest folks who joined us over on Patreon.

09:41.355 --> 09:42.636
[SPEAKER_02]: I haven't done this in a few weeks.

09:42.877 --> 09:49.421
[SPEAKER_02]: So thank you very much to Sydney, Shannon M, Dan W and B, Garza.

09:49.922 --> 09:51.743
[SPEAKER_02]: We really appreciate your support.

09:51.963 --> 09:52.964
[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you all so much.

09:53.870 --> 10:02.333
[SPEAKER_02]: And as a reminder, you can get these episodes at free by subscribing to our Patreon at any level or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts.

10:03.594 --> 10:08.236
[SPEAKER_02]: So with that out of the way, let's get into the story of Gretchen Fleming.

10:08.496 --> 10:08.936
[SPEAKER_04]: Let's do it.

10:09.745 --> 10:18.250
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen Eve Fleming was born on December 24th, 1994 in Warranton, Virginia, and as I was reading this Warranton.

10:18.530 --> 10:19.631
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, which is right by us.

10:19.971 --> 10:28.416
[SPEAKER_02]: But no, but as I was reading this, I just realized that her middle name is Eve and she was born on Christmas Eve.

10:29.577 --> 10:31.798
[SPEAKER_02]: And wonder if that's why they gave her that.

10:32.253 --> 10:32.793
[SPEAKER_04]: What is home?

10:32.813 --> 10:34.374
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, that's so cute.

10:35.495 --> 10:35.695
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.

10:35.875 --> 10:42.259
[SPEAKER_02]: So she was born prematurely, only weighing three pounds, 12 ounces of earth.

10:42.399 --> 10:42.799
[SPEAKER_02]: Great.

10:42.979 --> 10:43.319
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

10:43.339 --> 10:51.864
[SPEAKER_02]: So little, little tiny thing, but she ended up getting healthy, bouncing back, growing up great.

10:52.824 --> 10:54.946
[SPEAKER_02]: And she was the oldest of two children.

10:55.806 --> 10:58.827
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen also has a younger sister named Emma.

10:59.267 --> 11:05.789
[SPEAKER_02]: When she was a child, Gretchen's parents divorced, and Gretchen and her sister went to live with her father, David.

11:06.489 --> 11:09.530
[SPEAKER_02]: When Gretchen was about 14, her father met a woman named Jennifer.

11:10.410 --> 11:20.493
[SPEAKER_02]: At first, Gretchen wasn't thrilled about the idea of her dad having a girlfriend and kind of acted in a typical teenage fashion, which reading between the wines, you know,

11:26.188 --> 11:35.370
[SPEAKER_02]: But David and Jennifer ended up getting married, which quickly changed the entire family dynamic as Jennifer had three-year-old twins.

11:36.530 --> 11:36.630
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh.

11:37.210 --> 11:37.511
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.

11:38.631 --> 11:45.572
[SPEAKER_02]: And it wasn't long before Jennifer and David had a child of their own, making Gretchen the oldest of five.

11:46.733 --> 11:48.613
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, that's a dramatic shift.

11:48.908 --> 11:54.152
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and it sounds like there's a pretty big age difference, even between Gretchen and her sister.

11:54.272 --> 11:58.215
[SPEAKER_02]: So, Gretchen was oldest by many years, it sounds like.

11:58.576 --> 12:01.278
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen was smart, athletic, and beautiful.

12:01.678 --> 12:06.282
[SPEAKER_02]: Her bubbly personality drew people to her, and she never had trouble making friends.

12:07.162 --> 12:12.607
[SPEAKER_02]: In high school, she loved girft shopping, and always were clothes that made a statement.

12:13.692 --> 12:20.816
[SPEAKER_02]: Though she always had a book in her hands, by the time high school was ending, Gretchen didn't really know what she wanted to do with her life.

12:21.717 --> 12:27.580
[SPEAKER_02]: What she did know is that she wanted to get out of Parker'sburg and moved to a big city.

12:27.780 --> 12:32.203
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, she just had dreams of, you know, being a city girl, basically.

12:32.783 --> 12:37.886
[SPEAKER_02]: So when she graduated high school, Gretchen moved to the Raleigh North Carolina area.

12:38.466 --> 12:45.968
[SPEAKER_02]: She quickly gathered a great group of friends and worked just a series of jobs as she figured out what to do with her life.

12:46.908 --> 12:56.831
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, she'd never really nail down a career, it sounds like, and just kind of work jobs to make money and to get enough to live and, you know, didn't worry about it.

12:57.291 --> 13:03.913
[SPEAKER_02]: David describes his daughter as a free spirit who wasn't in a rush to settle down or find some corporate job.

13:04.553 --> 13:15.260
[SPEAKER_02]: But while she was in North Carolina, Gretchen Metaman and the two started dating, the pair quickly grew serious and according to Jennifer, even began talking about marriage.

13:15.901 --> 13:22.826
[SPEAKER_02]: They ended up moving to Charleston, West Virginia, but went their separate ways after about a year of dating.

13:23.523 --> 13:39.466
[SPEAKER_02]: Now around this time, and again, like I don't know the exact timeline of all of this like what water, everything happened in, but around the time of the breakup and you know, her moving to Charleston and everything, Gretchen was hit with the tragedy when her mom died unexpectedly.

13:41.245 --> 13:55.113
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, that's difficult, obviously, for any daughter to deal with, but according to David on an episode of Disappeared about his daughter's case, Gretchen and her mother had had a strange relationship for most of her life.

13:56.354 --> 14:02.497
[SPEAKER_02]: But Gretchen was also her closest relative, and so she was the

14:08.277 --> 14:09.458
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh my god, that's so heavy.

14:09.858 --> 14:10.239
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

14:11.459 --> 14:15.202
[SPEAKER_02]: So really difficult for somebody in their 20s.

14:15.362 --> 14:18.364
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, at any age, I mean, that's all to have to deal with.

14:18.604 --> 14:22.607
[SPEAKER_02]: But yeah, she was in her 20s and had to make that decision.

14:23.268 --> 14:25.109
[SPEAKER_04]: That's just like insanely tough.

14:25.742 --> 14:31.547
[SPEAKER_02]: So I think a combination of all of those, you know, the fact that she had this breakup, her mother died.

14:31.687 --> 14:36.130
[SPEAKER_02]: She was in Charleston, West Virginia, which like she had no reason to be in.

14:36.771 --> 14:42.655
[SPEAKER_02]: I think all of that led her back to Parker'sburg to basically regroup.

14:43.396 --> 14:44.237
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, that makes sense.

14:45.117 --> 14:54.425
[SPEAKER_02]: Instead of moving back in with her dad, stepmother and all of their kids, Gretchen decided on the quieter environment of her grandparents' house.

14:55.682 --> 14:59.323
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, definitely don't blame her there.

14:59.483 --> 14:59.764
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

15:00.784 --> 15:09.167
[SPEAKER_02]: She got a job at an H&M clothing store at the local mall and pretty much just spend her time working and hanging out with friends at local bars.

15:09.907 --> 15:17.670
[SPEAKER_02]: It may not seem as though a free spirited 27-year-old woman would enjoy living under her grandparents' roof, but the arrangement seemed to work for them.

15:18.350 --> 15:22.453
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen didn't have a car and her grandmother would often drive her to work.

15:22.913 --> 15:31.199
[SPEAKER_02]: She was obviously free to do whatever she wanted, you know, at night or whenever, but her grandparents did have their limits.

15:31.979 --> 15:38.003
[SPEAKER_02]: They locked the door at, I think, 10 p.m. And if Gretchen wasn't home, then she wasn't home.

15:39.584 --> 15:42.246
[SPEAKER_03]: Okay.

15:42.266 --> 15:46.069
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, they didn't want her coming in at all hours, disturbing their sleep.

15:48.807 --> 15:53.332
[SPEAKER_02]: If you're going to live in an old people's house, you got to keep an old people's schedule or go somewhere else.

15:54.012 --> 15:56.635
[SPEAKER_02]: So that was fine with Gretchen though.

15:56.735 --> 16:00.018
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, according to Jennifer, she did not mind that at all.

16:00.559 --> 16:04.463
[SPEAKER_02]: And if she was putting up staying out late, she would just make arrangements to stay with friends.

16:05.375 --> 16:06.316
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, makes sense.

16:06.336 --> 16:11.519
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, she's in her 20s, like in her late 20s, like, yeah.

16:11.679 --> 16:15.161
[SPEAKER_02]: So I mean, it really truly was not a big deal for her at all.

16:15.761 --> 16:18.783
[SPEAKER_02]: And she would just carry basically no overnight bag with her.

16:19.584 --> 16:24.567
[SPEAKER_02]: And so that if she was out, she could just, you know, have her some stuff stay not a big deal.

16:25.347 --> 16:37.355
[SPEAKER_02]: And it wasn't uncommon for her to even be gone like a couple of days at a time, you know, like she just didn't really have responsibilities, you know, like she had her job and stuff, but she was a free spirit.

16:37.375 --> 16:39.557
[SPEAKER_02]: She just kind of did what she wanted to do.

16:40.889 --> 16:46.572
[SPEAKER_04]: all of which I'm assuming adds to a convoluted timeline when she goes missing.

16:46.872 --> 16:47.752
[SPEAKER_04]: Exactly.

16:48.453 --> 16:53.855
[SPEAKER_02]: So on Saturday, December 3rd, 2022, Gretchen's grandmother Louise drove her to work.

16:54.596 --> 17:00.278
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen told her grandmother that she was going out after her shift and she was just going to stay somewhere else that night.

17:00.358 --> 17:02.179
[SPEAKER_02]: So like, you know, don't worry about it.

17:02.399 --> 17:03.360
[SPEAKER_02]: Not coming home tonight.

17:03.820 --> 17:04.521
[SPEAKER_02]: I'll catch you later.

17:05.302 --> 17:09.385
[SPEAKER_01]: And again, this was very common for Gretchen, so Louis was like, all right, great.

17:09.586 --> 17:09.926
[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.

17:09.986 --> 17:10.386
[SPEAKER_01]: Love you.

17:10.907 --> 17:11.407
[SPEAKER_01]: See you later.

17:11.668 --> 17:16.792
[SPEAKER_02]: So Gretchen didn't come home that night, but she had already told her grandmother that she didn't play.

17:16.812 --> 17:17.813
[SPEAKER_02]: And I'm coming home that night.

17:17.953 --> 17:19.415
[SPEAKER_02]: So, you know, it was fun.

17:20.702 --> 17:27.484
[SPEAKER_02]: She didn't come home for a few more days, but again, that was pretty typical, and Gretchen was nearly 28 years old.

17:27.504 --> 17:35.047
[SPEAKER_02]: So again, this is December 3rd, she turned 28 on December 24th, so like literally weeks before her 28th birthday.

17:35.647 --> 17:48.072
[SPEAKER_02]: Family members, you know, have been trying to re-church during this period, but it wasn't unusual for Gretchen to either let her phone die, or to take a day or two to respond to a text.

17:48.677 --> 17:53.998
[SPEAKER_02]: However, by December 11th, Gretchen's grandmother started to get worried.

17:54.159 --> 18:00.460
[SPEAKER_02]: So like, it's been a week or so at this point, and she has not heard from Gretchen, and that is unusual.

18:01.080 --> 18:07.122
[SPEAKER_02]: Like a day or two here there is whatever, but I mean, this has been a week and it was getting weird.

18:07.602 --> 18:17.125
[SPEAKER_02]: So Louie's went over to David and Jennifer's house and told them that that she had not seen or heard from Gretchen since she dropped her off at work on December 3rd.

18:18.693 --> 18:22.659
[SPEAKER_01]: And they hadn't heard from her either, but again, she's almost 28 years old.

18:22.960 --> 18:28.388
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, I think there are a lot of 28 year olds in the world who will go a week without talking to their parents.

18:29.113 --> 18:36.635
[SPEAKER_04]: Well, yeah, and especially bad and step mom who now have a full litter of new kids, essentially.

18:36.875 --> 18:48.798
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, you know, I can't imagine aside from visiting just to be the older sister or whatever, like, can't imagine she spends a whole lot of time over there just hanging out in general.

18:48.978 --> 18:51.498
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, it doesn't sound like she did at all.

18:51.538 --> 18:52.719
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, you're absolutely right.

18:52.799 --> 18:57.760
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, they were a relatively close family, but yeah, she was an over there every day or anything like that.

18:58.700 --> 19:06.823
[SPEAKER_02]: before Louise came to their house, David and Jennifer had no inkling that anything was a mess with Gretchen whatsoever.

19:07.383 --> 19:15.647
[SPEAKER_02]: But obviously, once they heard that she hadn't been heard from her scene since the third, they're like, okay, yeah, that's not great.

19:15.827 --> 19:19.008
[SPEAKER_02]: They obviously tried calling her and texting her and, you know, got nowhere.

19:19.508 --> 19:20.929
[SPEAKER_02]: So David decided that day,

19:21.928 --> 19:33.157
[SPEAKER_02]: that they were going to jump in the car and go around to the places that they knew she would like hang out, right, and just see if anybody had seen her because that's the other thing about this.

19:34.017 --> 19:34.678
[SPEAKER_02]: She's 28 years old.

19:36.446 --> 20:02.580
[SPEAKER_02]: And though she grew up there, like, a lot of her friends from high school, like, we're gone, you know, so she had kind of made new friends and like her parents and have their numbers or anything like that, like they didn't know her friends, so it's not like they could just start calling people necessarily like they had to just physically jump in the car and just like go to places where she hung out and just see what was going on.

20:02.780 --> 20:03.661
[SPEAKER_02]: So that's what he did.

20:04.372 --> 20:07.933
[SPEAKER_04]: But at the same time, probably not a very large town.

20:08.173 --> 20:08.833
[SPEAKER_04]: No, not at all.

20:09.394 --> 20:09.974
[SPEAKER_04]: So, yeah.

20:10.234 --> 20:12.835
[SPEAKER_04]: There's probably not a whole lot of spots for them to go.

20:12.955 --> 20:13.775
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, exactly.

20:13.795 --> 20:16.716
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, it was like a limited number of places.

20:17.116 --> 20:20.857
[SPEAKER_02]: So, they had a good idea of where to look.

20:20.917 --> 20:25.819
[SPEAKER_02]: But they didn't have specific people necessarily to go to, you know?

20:26.359 --> 20:29.082
[SPEAKER_02]: so they ended up at a local bar called the front row.

20:29.702 --> 20:35.388
[SPEAKER_02]: They went inside and asked the bartender of the new Gretchen and the bartender's like, oh yeah, no, I totally know Gretchen.

20:35.848 --> 20:37.710
[SPEAKER_02]: She was actually in here last week.

20:38.051 --> 20:42.435
[SPEAKER_02]: The bartender also told them that they had Gretchen's purse.

20:54.902 --> 21:07.847
[SPEAKER_02]: Apparently, Gretchen had been at the front row on December 3rd with a guy who is referred to as John on that episode of Disappeared, but according to Facebook is actually a man named Jason Pepe.

21:08.427 --> 21:14.810
[SPEAKER_02]: So I don't know if like Jason's middle name or I mean his first name and he goes by John or you know whatever, I don't know.

21:14.930 --> 21:16.750
[SPEAKER_02]: We'll just call him John slash Jason.

21:17.471 --> 21:19.511
[SPEAKER_02]: But from what I've been

21:23.870 --> 21:45.008
[SPEAKER_02]: you know, like they knew each other from around, they didn't necessarily like hang out outside of the bar, like he's apparently married and, you know, they were both at the front row that night, they hung out and after a while they decided to go to another bar called my way lounge.

21:45.529 --> 21:49.713
[SPEAKER_02]: It was karaoke nights and apparently Gretchen wanted to go for that.

21:50.433 --> 21:57.635
[SPEAKER_02]: So she didn't have a car, remember, and so John's last Jason was like, yeah, cool, like we can go over there.

21:57.835 --> 22:03.516
[SPEAKER_02]: And so he gave her a ride and the two of them went over to my way lounge.

22:04.176 --> 22:08.397
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, according to John's last Jason, they got to my way in, you know, hung out.

22:08.937 --> 22:12.658
[SPEAKER_02]: They were friends, but they weren't like together, you know.

22:13.418 --> 22:17.039
[SPEAKER_02]: So they were both often in different sections of the

22:20.780 --> 22:28.404
[SPEAKER_02]: He said that when he was about ready to head out, he went to the bathroom, but once he got out, he didn't see Gretchen.

22:28.884 --> 22:32.406
[SPEAKER_02]: He walked outside to see shoes out there, but didn't see her.

22:33.126 --> 22:41.571
[SPEAKER_02]: So apparently he hadn't paid the tab, and so he like went back in, paid up, went back outside, still didn't see her.

22:42.791 --> 22:45.834
[SPEAKER_02]: and was a little worried because again he knew she didn't have a car.

22:45.854 --> 22:47.996
[SPEAKER_02]: He didn't see her leave the bar.

22:48.016 --> 22:50.297
[SPEAKER_02]: He had no idea what was going on.

22:50.798 --> 22:58.604
[SPEAKER_02]: So he said he got into his car and started driving around to see if she had just like decided to walk.

22:59.205 --> 23:04.969
[SPEAKER_02]: So he got in the car drove around kind of drove to the downtown area, which was very close to the bar.

23:05.970 --> 23:06.651
[SPEAKER_02]: Didn't see her.

23:07.131 --> 23:10.514
[SPEAKER_02]: Then he went back to the bar to see if she had

23:12.075 --> 23:28.280
[SPEAKER_02]: When back inside the bar and then didn't see her, the problem with this other than the fact that, you know, he was supposed to give her a ride home and couldn't find her, was that once he had gotten into his car, he realized that her purse and cell phone were in his car.

23:29.060 --> 23:37.003
[SPEAKER_02]: She had left both of those items in her car when he was driving her from the front row to my way.

23:37.945 --> 23:45.388
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay, so do we have anybody that can corroborate whether she was actually there?

23:46.389 --> 23:47.569
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, we're going to get to that.

23:47.709 --> 23:47.990
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

23:48.450 --> 23:48.670
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.

23:49.070 --> 23:50.010
[SPEAKER_02]: So this is just, you're right.

23:50.050 --> 23:52.331
[SPEAKER_02]: Because this is just his version of the story right now.

23:52.592 --> 23:55.813
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, and automatically this seems fishy.

23:56.253 --> 23:57.094
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, absolutely.

23:57.614 --> 24:05.998
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, went to the bathroom, came out didn't see or so I immediately started looking for and got in my car and drove around town looking for, you know,

24:07.366 --> 24:15.839
[SPEAKER_02]: that and she left her personal phone in my car and never took them into the second bar it all didn't realize she didn't have so.

24:15.859 --> 24:16.981
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, no, absolutely.

24:17.642 --> 24:20.787
[SPEAKER_04]: So there is a witness that saw her in the second bar.

24:20.967 --> 24:22.209
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, we will get to all of that.

24:23.113 --> 24:27.155
[SPEAKER_02]: So after he drives around a little bit, looks for a dozen finer goes back to the bar.

24:27.935 --> 24:29.416
[SPEAKER_02]: Still, she's not back there.

24:29.636 --> 24:32.557
[SPEAKER_02]: And so he's like, well, you know, at this point, he doesn't know what to do.

24:33.497 --> 24:35.258
[SPEAKER_01]: It's late, like late late.

24:35.758 --> 24:43.861
[SPEAKER_02]: And so he's just like, okay, well, I guess I'll go home because he just literally doesn't know what else to do in this situation.

24:44.462 --> 24:47.523
[SPEAKER_02]: He goes home, you know, gets some sleep and then the next day,

24:48.283 --> 24:59.009
[SPEAKER_02]: He has her person or cell phone, and so he takes it back to the front row, which is the first bar, and it's a place where he knows that she goes a lot.

24:59.829 --> 25:02.471
[SPEAKER_02]: And so he doesn't have her address.

25:02.531 --> 25:05.413
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, they're not outside friends, you know.

25:05.593 --> 25:06.873
[SPEAKER_02]: He doesn't know where she lives.

25:07.334 --> 25:09.975
[SPEAKER_02]: He has her cell phone, so he obviously can't call her.

25:10.575 --> 25:11.836
[SPEAKER_02]: So he doesn't know where else to take it.

25:11.856 --> 25:14.758
[SPEAKER_02]: So he just takes it back to the bar, and he assumes that like,

25:15.438 --> 25:22.703
[SPEAKER_02]: Whenever she wakes up from wherever it is she went, she'll go, oh shit, where's my purse, and then hopefully go back to the first bar to look for it.

25:23.184 --> 25:24.685
[SPEAKER_02]: So like that's his thought process.

25:25.465 --> 25:33.611
[SPEAKER_02]: Cut to December 11th when Dave goes to the bar and the bartender's like, oh yeah, we've had her purse.

25:33.631 --> 25:37.054
[SPEAKER_02]: She was in here and we've had her purse like all week and she never came to get it.

25:37.954 --> 25:41.337
[SPEAKER_02]: Dave immediately knew that's something it happened because, you know,

25:41.937 --> 25:45.502
[SPEAKER_02]: Nobody leaves their person or cell phone sitting at a bar for a week.

25:45.742 --> 25:45.982
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

25:46.323 --> 25:46.483
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

25:46.563 --> 25:48.245
[SPEAKER_02]: That's not a thing that people do.

25:48.365 --> 25:49.927
[SPEAKER_02]: So he's like, okay, this is bad.

25:50.568 --> 25:57.817
[SPEAKER_02]: And so obviously his suspicions went right to this dude who turned in her person or cell phone because I mean, I'm still suspicious of him.

25:57.977 --> 26:00.539
[SPEAKER_02]: Right, and David didn't know him.

26:01.059 --> 26:03.500
[SPEAKER_02]: They're like, oh, yeah, it's this guy, you know, John or whatever.

26:03.741 --> 26:05.722
[SPEAKER_02]: And he's like, okay, I don't know this person.

26:05.782 --> 26:08.243
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, why did he have my daughter stuff?

26:08.283 --> 26:10.105
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, why did he turn it into this bar?

26:10.145 --> 26:11.505
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, what is happening?

26:11.806 --> 26:14.007
[SPEAKER_02]: He ended up contacting him.

26:14.027 --> 26:15.488
[SPEAKER_02]: David ended up contacting him.

26:16.328 --> 26:23.511
[SPEAKER_02]: And the story that I just laid out is the story that John Slash Jason told David.

26:23.792 --> 26:28.874
[SPEAKER_02]: So that's kind of how we get this first rough timeline of events of that night.

26:29.733 --> 26:31.254
[SPEAKER_02]: This is all happening on the 11th.

26:31.574 --> 26:36.218
[SPEAKER_02]: And once they get her stuff back to the house, they plug in her phone.

26:36.618 --> 26:45.465
[SPEAKER_02]: And again, I don't know if they do this before they end up getting a hold of John slash Jason or after, but either way, it's all happening around the same time.

26:46.005 --> 26:49.748
[SPEAKER_02]: But they plug in her cell phone because it's dead, obviously, by this point.

26:50.688 --> 26:55.712
[SPEAKER_02]: And they look through her calls and texts and everything because apparently in 2022, this woman

26:59.916 --> 27:03.339
[SPEAKER_02]: Which is like, while to me, I didn't even know you could do that on a phone anymore.

27:03.919 --> 27:07.662
[SPEAKER_04]: But yeah, I didn't know that you can either.

27:07.882 --> 27:10.825
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I don't know, but on the episode of Disappeared, that's what they said.

27:10.905 --> 27:15.629
[SPEAKER_02]: So regardless, they got into the phone and they were able to look at her calls and text and everything.

27:15.669 --> 27:20.092
[SPEAKER_02]: And, you know, I'm sure they were able to open like Facebook and, you know, all of those apps, right?

27:21.053 --> 27:25.917
[SPEAKER_02]: And what they saw was that everything from her stopped on December 3rd.

27:27.837 --> 27:29.919
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, you know, they're, I'm sure we're incoming.

27:30.299 --> 27:31.900
[SPEAKER_02]: Carl's a dress, but no, I don't know.

27:31.920 --> 27:39.466
[SPEAKER_02]: Nothing, no host, yeah, nothing, like no social media, no text, nothing from her after December 3rd.

27:39.806 --> 27:44.750
[SPEAKER_02]: So by this point, they're like, okay, like, this is obviously, it's really not a good sign.

27:44.790 --> 27:49.454
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and so on December 12th, Gretchen's family reported her missing.

27:49.794 --> 27:58.457
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, because of the alarming circumstances surrounding her disappearance, Parker'sberg police did not waste any time with she's an adult she can stay out of she wants to.

27:58.477 --> 28:00.218
[SPEAKER_04]: Well, that's good.

28:00.658 --> 28:00.878
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

28:01.618 --> 28:11.822
[SPEAKER_02]: They immediately started an investigation, though they were obviously hindered by the fact that it had been like, you know, nine or 10 days since she was last seen.

28:11.842 --> 28:12.282
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

28:13.025 --> 28:17.386
[SPEAKER_02]: But they started their investigation by retracing her steps on the night of December 3rd.

28:18.126 --> 28:29.350
[SPEAKER_02]: So they spoke to people of both bars, and everybody, you know, bartenders, whoever, basically corroborated the story that John Slash Jason had told her family.

28:29.370 --> 28:29.970
[SPEAKER_04]: OK.

28:30.530 --> 28:36.891
[SPEAKER_02]: they were also able to further corroborate his story by pulling surveillance footage from my way.

28:37.651 --> 28:38.331
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, okay.

28:38.531 --> 28:42.512
[SPEAKER_02]: So my way apparently had several cameras.

28:42.772 --> 28:51.114
[SPEAKER_02]: They were actually working and they actually still had the footage like, you know, things that you often don't see in these cases.

28:51.874 --> 28:55.174
[SPEAKER_02]: So that was a huge help to the investigation.

28:55.194 --> 28:58.655
[SPEAKER_02]: Again, because they were starting, you know, a week and a half after the

28:59.268 --> 28:59.468
[SPEAKER_04]: Right.

28:59.488 --> 29:03.432
[SPEAKER_04]: With only this guy's weird story.

29:03.812 --> 29:04.152
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

29:04.432 --> 29:06.154
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, it's still doesn't make any sense.

29:06.174 --> 29:07.015
[SPEAKER_04]: corroborated or not.

29:07.075 --> 29:08.396
[SPEAKER_04]: It does not make any sense.

29:08.456 --> 29:09.717
[SPEAKER_02]: It's still weird story for sure.

29:10.277 --> 29:18.605
[SPEAKER_02]: But once they pulled the surveillance footage, police were also able to uncover an important new clue.

29:19.819 --> 29:20.699
[SPEAKER_02]: a second man.

29:21.139 --> 29:38.065
[SPEAKER_02]: Parker'sburg police have been keeping the specifics of their investigation pretty close to the best, but after they pulled the footage from the bar, my way's owners contacted David directly and asked him if you wanted to come in and take a look at the footage.

29:38.845 --> 29:43.107
[SPEAKER_02]: So like, they gave the police everything that they had, but they're like, hey,

29:43.727 --> 29:46.049
[SPEAKER_02]: like we know your daughter's listening to you want to like see it too.

29:46.069 --> 29:47.310
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh wow.

29:47.530 --> 29:58.120
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, so here's like yes, obviously, and he described what he saw on that episode of disappeared and I want to play that just so you can hear it in his words.

29:59.135 --> 30:02.737
[SPEAKER_00]: and he was talking to a couple other people when she was kind of just sitting there by herself.

30:03.057 --> 30:11.301
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, then comes in the picture, from the man out of the gambling room, he stands beside her and ends up bringing her a drink.

30:11.881 --> 30:18.545
[SPEAKER_00]: Then they end up talking and they get back into the gambling room together probably for about a half hour, 45 minutes.

30:18.805 --> 30:24.968
[SPEAKER_00]: And then they come out of the gambling room and the man begins up locking out the door and she's walking right behind him.

30:26.000 --> 30:32.327
[SPEAKER_00]: John ends up going to the bathroom, said when Gretchen comes out of the gambling room, to leave, he was actually in the bathroom.

30:32.407 --> 30:33.788
[SPEAKER_00]: So he didn't see her weave.

30:34.309 --> 30:42.217
[SPEAKER_00]: So he comes out of the bathroom and then the bars get ready to close down there and he's looking for him, can't find her, because he was going to give her a ride home.

30:43.298 --> 30:48.103
[SPEAKER_00]: And then the, but it genuinely shows Gretchen leaving with the man and his car driving away.

30:49.372 --> 30:52.874
[SPEAKER_04]: So gambling man comes out, starts talking to her.

30:53.874 --> 30:56.615
[SPEAKER_04]: Then they leave together.

30:57.276 --> 30:57.816
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, you break.

30:57.856 --> 31:02.898
[SPEAKER_02]: So he comes out of the gambling room, gives Gretchen a drink.

31:03.579 --> 31:03.919
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

31:04.627 --> 31:07.828
[SPEAKER_02]: he and Gretchen then go into the gambling room together.

31:08.848 --> 31:13.589
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, I don't know if there was a camera in the gambling room or not.

31:13.669 --> 31:19.230
[SPEAKER_02]: It kind of sounds like there isn't, because we don't have any details about what was that on there.

31:19.350 --> 31:19.750
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

31:20.150 --> 31:24.931
[SPEAKER_02]: But it sounds like Gretchen have been drinking a lot throughout the night already, right?

31:25.371 --> 31:28.291
[SPEAKER_02]: So I would assume, and I do not know this.

31:28.331 --> 31:30.212
[SPEAKER_02]: This is purely my assumption

31:31.932 --> 31:39.935
[SPEAKER_02]: If he gave her drink and then they're in the gambling room for another 30 to 45 minutes, I would guess as she probably had at least one more drink during that period.

31:41.075 --> 31:50.218
[SPEAKER_02]: And then the camera shows them coming out of the gambling room, and John's last Jason is, in fact, in the bathroom.

31:51.599 --> 31:54.660
[SPEAKER_02]: They leave, or it should be, it should be said,

32:02.115 --> 32:06.898
[SPEAKER_04]: The surveillance footage shows them getting into his car.

32:07.358 --> 32:11.120
[SPEAKER_02]: No, so what it shows is them leaving.

32:11.880 --> 32:17.663
[SPEAKER_02]: But because of where his car was parked, it does not show either of them getting into his car.

32:18.884 --> 32:23.526
[SPEAKER_02]: But then an outside camera does pick up his car driving away.

32:24.260 --> 32:24.520
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

32:24.880 --> 32:25.921
[SPEAKER_04]: So we know what kind of car.

32:26.361 --> 32:26.681
[SPEAKER_04]: Yes.

32:26.901 --> 32:27.121
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes.

32:27.562 --> 32:38.047
[SPEAKER_02]: We know the car police identified it like they're certain that they see his car on the footage leaving directly after he left the bar.

32:38.747 --> 32:43.930
[SPEAKER_02]: But they don't physically have video of Gretchen or him entering the car.

32:43.950 --> 32:44.890
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

32:45.451 --> 32:51.474
[SPEAKER_02]: What this sounds like is that a single 27 year old woman hit it off of the man at the bar and went home with them.

32:51.594 --> 32:51.814
[SPEAKER_02]: Sure.

32:52.539 --> 32:55.521
[SPEAKER_02]: I promise you, I promise you.

32:56.421 --> 32:57.822
[SPEAKER_04]: She left her person self in there.

32:58.602 --> 33:03.845
[SPEAKER_02]: Right, but beyond that, because you could think, okay, she's drunk, she forgot her better person's self in.

33:04.685 --> 33:06.926
[SPEAKER_02]: Whatever, best case scenario.

33:07.627 --> 33:10.008
[SPEAKER_02]: She's just like, really like, I'm gonna go home with this dude.

33:10.108 --> 33:12.349
[SPEAKER_01]: I promise you that is not what happened here.

33:13.149 --> 33:20.353
[SPEAKER_02]: It was quickly determined that the man Gretchen was seen leaving with was 55 year old Preston Pierce.

33:21.068 --> 33:25.591
[SPEAKER_02]: Preston is and was well known around Parker'sburg and not for anything good.

33:26.111 --> 33:42.722
[SPEAKER_02]: I usually don't like go and start disparaging people's like looks and stuff on the show, but to anyone listening who has ever been out in public, especially at a bar, and you've gotten hit on by a creepy old white guy,

33:43.819 --> 33:48.182
[SPEAKER_02]: Like whoever you're picturing, that's what Preston Pierce looks like.

33:48.282 --> 33:49.342
[SPEAKER_02]: 120%.

33:49.963 --> 33:54.625
[SPEAKER_02]: He is the type of dude that you see and you immediately know something weird is gonna happen.

33:55.366 --> 33:59.008
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, when I say he's well known, he wasn't necessarily known by name, right?

33:59.849 --> 34:05.872
[SPEAKER_02]: But when people see him, it's more of an, oh, that guy, kind of a thing.

34:05.892 --> 34:06.492
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

34:06.973 --> 34:11.876
[SPEAKER_02]: Part of the reason he's not known by name is because, you know, he didn't always live in Parker'sburg.

34:12.968 --> 34:14.650
[SPEAKER_02]: and his name wasn't always Preston Pierce.

34:26.662 --> 34:29.544
[SPEAKER_02]: Preston Pierce was born Daryl Eugene Watt.

34:30.345 --> 34:33.248
[SPEAKER_04]: That's... that's quite a name change.

34:33.708 --> 34:34.029
[SPEAKER_02]: Indeed.

34:35.378 --> 34:47.650
[SPEAKER_02]: Details on his background are sketchy, but he was allegedly a police officer in several different small towns in West Virginia, including Ravenswood, Williams town, and Vienna.

34:48.311 --> 34:57.881
[SPEAKER_02]: I've also seen several different people say that he was actually chief of police in Bellington, West Virginia, but I have not been able to independently verify that.

34:58.321 --> 35:05.903
[SPEAKER_02]: I actually called the town of Belington right before we recorded this because their website lists the current chief of police.

35:06.864 --> 35:13.746
[SPEAKER_02]: And so I called and asked if there was anywhere that had a list of past chiefs of police.

35:14.426 --> 35:18.647
[SPEAKER_02]: And the lady I spoke with is like, no, this is our first website.

35:19.227 --> 35:19.988
[SPEAKER_02]: We just got it.

35:21.368 --> 35:21.628
[SPEAKER_02]: Okay.

35:22.108 --> 35:31.492
[SPEAKER_02]: And she's like, you could try to call the current chief of police tomorrow, but call after nine because he does school drop off before that.

35:31.572 --> 35:32.132
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, Jesus.

35:32.673 --> 35:32.953
[SPEAKER_04]: Okay.

35:33.313 --> 35:43.137
[SPEAKER_02]: So anyway, I was not, I've not been able to independently verify whether or not press and peers slash Dural, what was ever chief of police there.

35:43.597 --> 35:49.482
[SPEAKER_02]: but it has been independently verified that he was a police officer in several towns in West Virginia.

35:49.883 --> 35:53.546
[SPEAKER_02]: His law enforcement career spanned over 12 years.

35:54.306 --> 36:04.635
[SPEAKER_02]: Now hopping back to unofficial sources, he allegedly shuffled around so much because of basically sexual harassment issues.

36:05.496 --> 36:13.180
[SPEAKER_02]: All of this took place several decades ago, though, and police agencies aren't exactly like forthcoming with Officer Miss Conduct.

36:13.840 --> 36:16.882
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, yeah, they're not forthcoming with Officer Miss Conduct.

36:17.002 --> 36:19.303
[SPEAKER_04]: Now, let alone decades ago.

36:19.403 --> 36:20.604
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, in small towns.

36:20.644 --> 36:25.286
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's not like, you know, they're like, there weren't newspaper articles right now about this.

36:32.290 --> 36:33.331
[SPEAKER_04]: asked to resign.

36:33.511 --> 36:34.371
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly, right?

36:34.472 --> 36:39.435
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's like I wasn't able to again independently verify.

36:39.455 --> 36:40.535
[SPEAKER_04]: There's no paper drill on it.

36:40.736 --> 36:40.996
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

36:41.116 --> 36:41.396
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

36:41.836 --> 36:43.017
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, I want to make that clear.

36:43.077 --> 36:45.679
[SPEAKER_02]: So like all of this, please take with a grain of salt.

36:45.799 --> 36:51.943
[SPEAKER_02]: Like many different people have said that this is true, but again, not independently verified.

36:52.443 --> 37:05.653
[SPEAKER_02]: But I bring it up, not to spread rumors, but because it does seem credible based on more recent interactions that the public has had with him.

37:06.233 --> 37:18.943
[SPEAKER_02]: In addition to this whole police officer things, switching jobs or whatever, you know, as you picked up on, he changed both his first and last name, just not a common thing for people to do at all.

37:19.063 --> 37:21.425
[SPEAKER_04]: And it's a very drastic change

37:22.065 --> 37:35.180
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh yeah, like it's nothing close to his given name, so that does fit in with the story of like he's a disgrace police officer and really just went into like cut ties with the whole thing and start over, you know?

37:36.208 --> 37:40.109
[SPEAKER_02]: So he went from Daryl Lot to Preston Pierce sometime around 2007.

37:40.849 --> 37:47.811
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, in recent years, he's lived in Parker'sburg, and has worked as a delivery driver for different companies, including DoorDash.

37:48.631 --> 37:56.513
[SPEAKER_02]: Since he's been named as the last person who is with Gretchen Fleming, people in Parker'sburg have come out and shared their experiences with him.

37:57.313 --> 38:03.195
[SPEAKER_02]: Mostly his customers to whom he delivered food, but also his co-workers in other jobs that he's held.

38:03.635 --> 38:15.358
[SPEAKER_02]: In the Gretchen Fleming West Virginia TCR Facebook group, someone gathered over 40 screenshots of different people posting their horror stories of interactions with Preston Pierce.

38:16.098 --> 38:17.478
[SPEAKER_02]: And here are just a few examples.

38:18.058 --> 38:23.900
[SPEAKER_02]: Quote, he followed me and a friend from front row to my way to my home without my knowledge.

38:24.500 --> 38:29.421
[SPEAKER_02]: Thankfully, my friend was very alert and noticed he followed us, and my boyfriend was told

38:34.142 --> 38:38.844
[SPEAKER_02]: Now I find this interesting because it's the same two bars front row in my way.

38:38.984 --> 38:40.184
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, it's the same path.

38:40.504 --> 38:45.006
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and this was apparently a couple of years before Gretchen went missing.

38:45.366 --> 38:47.846
[SPEAKER_04]: Does that pattern come up again?

38:48.387 --> 38:49.047
[SPEAKER_02]: The two bars?

38:49.087 --> 38:49.207
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

38:49.947 --> 38:52.808
[SPEAKER_02]: Nothing I saw mentioned those two bars specifically.

38:52.848 --> 39:00.030
[SPEAKER_02]: There's another place called Corral that he would have allegedly go and play pool and a lot of people had run ends with him there as well.

39:00.150 --> 39:01.931
[SPEAKER_02]: But that was only when I saw that mentioned these two

39:03.525 --> 39:08.911
[SPEAKER_04]: I was just wondering whether that particular behavior or path of travel was predatory.

39:09.471 --> 39:10.192
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I don't know.

39:10.893 --> 39:13.816
[SPEAKER_02]: But my way is only about two miles from his house.

39:14.397 --> 39:17.540
[SPEAKER_02]: OK. Or where he was living at the time of Gretchen's disappearance.

39:17.600 --> 39:20.924
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know if he was living in that place when this first incident happened.

39:20.944 --> 39:23.386
[SPEAKER_02]: But yeah, at the time he lived two miles away.

39:24.619 --> 39:33.081
[SPEAKER_02]: So another person said quote, before COVID hit in 2020, he was my door-dash driver one night when I ordered food to the little gambling place I worked at.

39:33.801 --> 39:38.342
[SPEAKER_02]: He came back hours later to tell me I was beautiful and set up my bar.

39:39.062 --> 39:42.323
[SPEAKER_02]: I was so creeped out that a door-dash driver would do that.

39:42.903 --> 39:47.024
[SPEAKER_02]: I texted my boss to see if she would come down and sit with me so I wasn't alone with him.

39:47.724 --> 39:51.305
[SPEAKER_02]: We had to tell him to leave because he sat way past closing time.

39:52.085 --> 39:58.247
[SPEAKER_02]: He found me on Facebook the same freaking night and would message me all the time to find out if I was working.

39:58.968 --> 40:01.448
[SPEAKER_02]: He would come and sit in the parking lot toilet left.

40:02.108 --> 40:08.751
[SPEAKER_02]: My boss ended up coming back at closing time every night for a week straight to make sure I got safely to my car and stuff.

40:09.411 --> 40:12.752
[SPEAKER_02]: And then COVID shut the bar down for a while and I never saw him again.

40:13.572 --> 40:19.798
[SPEAKER_02]: I got such bad vibes from him then, so this is blowing my mind that other people went through the same thing."

40:20.299 --> 40:20.699
[SPEAKER_02]: End quote.

40:21.921 --> 40:25.504
[SPEAKER_04]: She doesn't name the bar, but she references gambling.

40:25.844 --> 40:26.165
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

40:27.726 --> 40:30.869
[SPEAKER_04]: I have no idea what the prevalence of gambling in West Virginia is.

40:30.889 --> 40:35.294
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it's pretty, it's pretty prevalent, so it could be any place, honestly.

40:35.534 --> 40:37.196
[SPEAKER_04]: Sure, but again, we're talking about...

40:38.057 --> 40:39.739
[SPEAKER_04]: Peter's bird, which is a small town.

40:39.759 --> 40:40.620
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, exactly.

40:40.640 --> 40:44.825
[SPEAKER_04]: There's probably only a few bars that have gambling.

40:45.986 --> 40:49.430
[SPEAKER_04]: So, decently, likely, hood, that it's my way.

40:49.710 --> 40:51.232
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, very well could be.

40:52.394 --> 40:52.754
[SPEAKER_02]: And so,

40:53.915 --> 41:00.838
[SPEAKER_02]: There were several people who also posted screenshots of messages that Preston Pierce had sent them.

41:01.418 --> 41:10.783
[SPEAKER_02]: And it's like, there's one that was like, the text that you'd get from DoorDash, like, I just picked up your order and like, your orders on your way, like those types of generated.

41:10.923 --> 41:20.247
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and then it goes to, hey, I didn't want to say anything, but you're really beautiful, like, you know, like stuff like that.

41:20.547 --> 41:20.787
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

41:22.348 --> 41:23.569
[SPEAKER_02]: creepy creepy stuff.

41:24.330 --> 41:29.214
[SPEAKER_02]: And so yes, there are many more just like this in worse, much worse.

41:30.051 --> 41:45.264
[SPEAKER_02]: Even in the episode of Disappeared, Jennifer, Gretchen Stuttmother, says that she had a friend who saw Preston Pierce out at the bar one night, and then woke up in his house the next day and had no idea how she had gotten there.

41:45.444 --> 41:51.308
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, I was, I had thought when you originally described the interaction.

41:51.328 --> 41:53.030
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, him bringing her drink.

41:53.270 --> 41:56.813
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, that maybe he had slipped something into her drink.

41:57.257 --> 41:57.517
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

41:57.638 --> 42:00.721
[SPEAKER_02]: And that's the prevailing theory.

42:00.741 --> 42:01.682
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

42:01.702 --> 42:07.668
[SPEAKER_02]: That's exactly what happened because, you know, according to everyone, Gretchen had already been drinking that night.

42:07.849 --> 42:12.954
[SPEAKER_02]: So she was already probably drunk, honestly, you know, again, which is fine.

42:13.054 --> 42:14.316
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, totally fine.

42:14.776 --> 42:18.378
[SPEAKER_02]: you can go out to a bar and you can get drunk like that is absolutely okay.

42:18.878 --> 42:26.743
[SPEAKER_02]: The theory is that he probably did slip her something and then somehow convinced her to like go out to his car.

42:27.423 --> 42:33.907
[SPEAKER_02]: Either he was going to take her home, he was going to help her find her purse, you know, like whatever it was.

42:34.127 --> 42:34.347
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

42:34.842 --> 42:36.263
[SPEAKER_02]: but that's why she left with them.

42:36.843 --> 42:43.308
[SPEAKER_02]: I mentioned earlier that police aren't releasing a ton of details about the actual evidence in this case.

42:44.129 --> 42:48.212
[SPEAKER_02]: They have confirmed that Gretchen was seen leaving by way directly behind pairs.

42:48.612 --> 42:51.874
[SPEAKER_02]: And that's mainly, I think, because David had seen the video.

42:52.075 --> 42:57.418
[SPEAKER_02]: And so when they did, yes, and when they did the episode of Disappeared Day, it's like, yeah, this is exactly what happened.

42:57.559 --> 43:00.240
[SPEAKER_02]: And so the detective who was interviewed was like,

43:01.101 --> 43:03.262
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, that, that is what happens.

43:04.623 --> 43:16.430
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, I mean, I'm not going to fault the cops on not really seeing anything at this point, because it seems as though they haven't narrowed down to one suspect, which makes sense.

43:16.510 --> 43:16.831
[SPEAKER_04]: Right.

43:16.891 --> 43:28.478
[SPEAKER_04]: Last person to be seen with her, if they're trying to gather more evidence on him, or whatever, like at that point, they're building a case against him, so they need to keep a

43:29.338 --> 43:29.799
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.

43:29.959 --> 43:34.383
[SPEAKER_02]: And from what it seems they started building a case against him very early on.

43:34.703 --> 43:35.284
[SPEAKER_04]: Which makes sense.

43:35.964 --> 43:39.648
[SPEAKER_04]: I'm assuming they interviewed him at some point but are probably not really seeing any of that.

43:40.083 --> 43:40.503
[SPEAKER_02]: Correct.

43:40.723 --> 43:55.027
[SPEAKER_02]: So, yeah, because of the video evidence and honestly probably because of his reputation as well, police were comfortable enough to quickly name him as a person of interest in the case, though they didn't publicly name him as a person of interest.

43:55.507 --> 44:04.409
[SPEAKER_02]: So basically by December 15th, three days into the investigation, they were telling reporters that, yes, we have a person of interest.

44:04.909 --> 44:06.870
[SPEAKER_02]: They just didn't say that it was pressed in pairs.

44:07.250 --> 44:07.470
[SPEAKER_04]: Sure.

44:08.010 --> 44:13.632
[SPEAKER_02]: But by that point three days in, they also executed their first search warrant for his home.

44:14.172 --> 44:22.535
[SPEAKER_02]: On December 29th, Parker'sburg police lieutenant James Stahlmacher told Fox News digital, quote, We know she left with him.

44:22.835 --> 44:25.416
[SPEAKER_02]: We believe that she traveled back to his residence with him.

44:25.956 --> 44:27.997
[SPEAKER_02]: He's given inconsistent statements.

44:28.657 --> 44:35.600
[SPEAKER_02]: Through his own admission, she was at one point in his vehicle, but he's claiming she didn't make it to his house.

44:36.300 --> 44:39.564
[SPEAKER_02]: There's no indication they knew each other prior to this night.

44:40.105 --> 44:40.566
[SPEAKER_02]: And quote.

44:41.246 --> 44:42.768
[SPEAKER_04]: She didn't make it to his house.

44:43.269 --> 44:49.297
[SPEAKER_02]: So... Yeah, so according to him, he dropped her off somewhere downtown.

44:51.086 --> 44:51.846
[SPEAKER_04]: at three in the morning.

44:52.027 --> 44:56.849
[SPEAKER_04]: Yes, just just some somewhere talking random street corner downtown.

44:56.969 --> 45:00.351
[SPEAKER_04]: Basically, yes, without a person without a cell phone correct.

45:01.692 --> 45:01.912
[SPEAKER_04]: Sure.

45:02.332 --> 45:02.573
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

45:03.053 --> 45:08.436
[SPEAKER_02]: And again, you know, they weren't naming him at this time because and they said, you know, we are not naming him.

45:08.456 --> 45:09.797
[SPEAKER_02]: He hasn't been charged with the crime, right?

45:09.817 --> 45:09.957
[SPEAKER_02]: Sure.

45:11.107 --> 45:18.350
[SPEAKER_02]: The name eventually did come out, and by the time the episode disappeared came out, it was already public.

45:18.890 --> 45:23.592
[SPEAKER_02]: And this was that episode came out like a little under a year after her disappearance.

45:24.593 --> 45:35.257
[SPEAKER_02]: And the interesting thing about his story, other than it just being stupid, is that no security cameras ever caught any of that happening.

45:35.757 --> 45:36.557
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

45:36.577 --> 45:42.400
[SPEAKER_02]: And John slash Jason said that he actually drove down down.

45:42.500 --> 45:42.860
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

45:43.440 --> 45:47.822
[SPEAKER_02]: Shortly after she would have left with this dude and didn't see her.

45:47.842 --> 45:48.443
[SPEAKER_04]: Right.

45:48.663 --> 45:50.063
[SPEAKER_02]: Again, it's a small town.

45:50.283 --> 45:51.084
[SPEAKER_02]: She was on foot.

45:51.144 --> 45:55.186
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, if he had randomly dropped her off, somebody would have seen her.

45:55.206 --> 45:56.046
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

45:56.568 --> 46:03.095
[SPEAKER_02]: By the time this December 29 article came out, police confirmed that they had executed multiple search warrants related to Preston Pierce.

46:03.856 --> 46:11.144
[SPEAKER_02]: There was the December 15th warrant to search his home, but also warrants for his car, electronic devices and phone records.

46:11.765 --> 46:15.069
[SPEAKER_02]: They also said that there are awaiting results of forensic testing.

46:16.105 --> 46:17.967
[SPEAKER_04]: of his car house.

46:17.987 --> 46:22.093
[SPEAKER_02]: State in specify, probably both, all of the above, you know.

46:22.853 --> 46:27.159
[SPEAKER_02]: Parker'sburg police chief told WCHS quote, things have been collected.

46:27.900 --> 46:30.943
[SPEAKER_02]: See, yeah, like real, you know, real official.

46:31.144 --> 46:31.484
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.

46:32.365 --> 46:36.966
[SPEAKER_02]: As standard, sent to the state laboratory for analysis and just awaiting results there.

46:37.546 --> 46:44.807
[SPEAKER_02]: That's commonplace in a lot of investigations, and when that comes back, hopefully that proves fruitful, but in the meantime, this is not a waiting game.

46:45.427 --> 46:51.308
[SPEAKER_02]: Our detectives are still following leads because, as I keep reiterating, the community really stepped up.

46:52.009 --> 46:56.049
[SPEAKER_02]: The leads, the tips, the info, the phone calls, the Facebook messages, the emails.

46:56.509 --> 46:58.230
[SPEAKER_02]: Every one of them is getting vetted.

46:58.250 --> 46:59.210
[SPEAKER_02]: End quote.

46:59.930 --> 47:20.605
[SPEAKER_02]: By December 30, police were telling reporters that their person of interest, too, we now know to be pressed in pairs, had stopped cooperating, and they urged Parker'sberg residents to comb through their own surveillance footage from December 4th and 5th to see if they had captured his car, which again was a black Nissan Rogue.

47:21.186 --> 47:28.571
[SPEAKER_02]: In early February, multiple tips led police joined by a mountaineer area rescue group to undertake a search for Gretchen in Mountwood

47:29.832 --> 47:39.734
[SPEAKER_02]: Mountwood Park is located 12 miles east to Parker's Burg and contains more than 50 miles of hiking and biking trails, campgrounds, a 50 acre lake, and wooded picnic areas.

47:40.775 --> 47:43.195
[SPEAKER_02]: Hundreds of civilian volunteers joined in this search.

47:44.195 --> 47:51.137
[SPEAKER_02]: Police ended up taking a number of items into evidence, but it doesn't sound like anything was determined to be related to Gretchen.

47:52.037 --> 47:54.858
[SPEAKER_02]: The next month in March, another search was held at

47:59.799 --> 48:04.926
[SPEAKER_02]: By mid-February, police said that they had executed 10 search warrants in Gretchen's case.

48:05.686 --> 48:18.362
[SPEAKER_02]: While there was a lot of criticism about what the public perceived as a slow investigation, Gretchen's family had nothing but praise for investigators saying that they had been working very hard on her case.

48:19.239 --> 48:29.889
[SPEAKER_02]: In May 2023, Detective James Zimmerman told WTAP that they were still waiting on results of DNA and other forensic testing from the West Virginia State Crime Lab.

48:30.209 --> 48:34.553
[SPEAKER_02]: He also said that they were continuing to make progress on the case and hope to have more answers soon.

48:35.014 --> 48:44.282
[SPEAKER_02]: By July, Gretchen's family was still positive and was praising Parker's Bergpolis' decision to outsource some of the testing and other parts of the investigation.

48:45.283 --> 48:52.586
[SPEAKER_02]: David Fleming told WDTV, quote, we started bringing in some outside agencies now that are going to be involved in looking at this case.

48:53.326 --> 48:55.327
[SPEAKER_02]: So I think that's a very positive move, too.

48:55.787 --> 49:03.610
[SPEAKER_02]: I can't talk about in detail what they're doing, but they are outside agencies that are now going to be involved, and I think this is a very positive step.

49:04.210 --> 49:04.350
[SPEAKER_04]: Wow.

49:05.015 --> 49:08.456
[SPEAKER_02]: Parkers Park Police is obviously a very small police force, right?

49:09.116 --> 49:11.336
[SPEAKER_02]: But they got right on the case.

49:11.376 --> 49:15.157
[SPEAKER_02]: They didn't dilly dally with their nonsense about her being an adult.

49:15.937 --> 49:18.038
[SPEAKER_02]: They quickly identified a person of interest.

49:18.078 --> 49:20.658
[SPEAKER_02]: They quickly executed search warrants.

49:20.718 --> 49:23.479
[SPEAKER_02]: They sent in forensic evidence for testing.

49:24.099 --> 49:27.700
[SPEAKER_02]: They vetted every lead that came in.

49:27.840 --> 49:30.641
[SPEAKER_02]: They stayed in constant contact with the family.

49:30.741 --> 49:31.141
[SPEAKER_04]: Right.

49:32.601 --> 49:37.293
[SPEAKER_04]: That's a huge thing for me is that they involve the family.

49:37.685 --> 49:38.546
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, absolutely.

49:38.746 --> 49:44.689
[SPEAKER_02]: And I mean, the family has said that, I mean, they hear from them like weekly, still, basically.

49:45.009 --> 49:51.994
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, they've never not been able to get a hold of investigators, you know, they've had all of their questions answered.

49:52.014 --> 49:56.156
[SPEAKER_02]: It does not sound like there's, you know, obviously, yes.

49:56.276 --> 50:02.380
[SPEAKER_02]: Like they went the case solved, you know, in an ideal world, they would have made an arrest immediately.

50:02.640 --> 50:06.263
[SPEAKER_04]: But that's just, you, not always the case.

50:06.283 --> 50:07.744
[SPEAKER_04]: So you have to get the evidence first.

50:07.944 --> 50:12.767
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and unfortunately, the evidence wasn't readily apparent.

50:13.268 --> 50:18.912
[SPEAKER_02]: They had enough as evidence to lead them in a very specific direction, but not enough to make an arrest.

50:19.773 --> 50:22.294
[SPEAKER_02]: And that's really just what it has come down to.

50:23.135 --> 50:44.180
[SPEAKER_02]: The thing about this, too, is that like police said, I mean, the community is heavily invested in this, and they have a lot to say, so, you know, John slash Jason is still considered a suspect by people in the community, but David went on that episode to disappear.

50:44.220 --> 50:47.160
[SPEAKER_02]: They're like, listen, I don't think he had anything to do with it.

50:47.780 --> 50:49.481
[SPEAKER_02]: He was so upset.

50:50.381 --> 50:51.161
[SPEAKER_02]: about the whole thing.

50:51.241 --> 50:54.983
[SPEAKER_02]: He felt terrible because, you know, he felt responsible, honestly.

50:55.023 --> 50:57.765
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, he is the one who brought Gretchen there.

50:58.105 --> 50:59.665
[SPEAKER_02]: She was supposed to leave with him.

50:59.685 --> 51:03.247
[SPEAKER_02]: He lost track of her, and she hasn't been seen.

51:03.307 --> 51:04.828
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, something happened to her.

51:05.468 --> 51:08.810
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, according to David, he just feels terrible about it.

51:09.810 --> 51:13.296
[SPEAKER_02]: David has no suspicions toward him whatsoever.

51:13.937 --> 51:21.388
[SPEAKER_02]: He has also been very clear on social media about who he does think is responsible for his daughter going missing.

51:21.569 --> 51:21.809
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

51:22.490 --> 51:23.732
[SPEAKER_02]: That doesn't mean that he's right.

51:24.113 --> 51:24.754
[SPEAKER_02]: We don't know.

51:25.154 --> 51:25.354
[SPEAKER_04]: Right.

51:25.894 --> 51:31.115
[SPEAKER_04]: But we do know that surveillance footage has cleared Jason.

51:31.755 --> 51:32.575
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, John.

51:33.175 --> 51:33.456
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

51:33.636 --> 51:36.056
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it definitely appears that that's the case.

51:36.076 --> 51:39.157
[SPEAKER_04]: I wouldn't say cleared, but yeah, I mean, I think clear it is too much.

51:39.237 --> 51:43.337
[SPEAKER_04]: Collaborates his crazy cock and Amy story.

51:44.598 --> 51:48.458
[SPEAKER_04]: But I mean, I mean, but I mean, hey, it corroborates it.

51:48.638 --> 51:50.259
[SPEAKER_04]: So it wasn't a crazy story.

51:50.319 --> 51:52.319
[SPEAKER_04]: It was what actually happened.

51:52.619 --> 51:52.919
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

51:54.733 --> 52:04.625
[SPEAKER_02]: It seems very bizarre to me, his behavior, but... Well, and I think that's part of what people are having a hard time with, right, because they're like this.

52:04.645 --> 52:06.227
[SPEAKER_04]: Well, didn't you say he's also married?

52:06.992 --> 52:07.492
[SPEAKER_02]: That's my fur.

52:07.512 --> 52:09.053
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

52:09.093 --> 52:09.273
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

52:09.293 --> 52:28.041
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, whatever, bar friends, I get that, like, we have a small shitty bar retail dispute for us that, like, there's people that you where I would run into at that bar that we would never go and hang out with, but we might talk to at that bar.

52:28.101 --> 52:28.341
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

52:29.317 --> 52:37.720
[SPEAKER_04]: I don't know whether I would necessarily cart him around from one bar to the next, but you know, I mean, that's it's different talent, different circumstances, whatever, so I can definitely like see that.

52:38.380 --> 52:48.343
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, it's just that a story seems crazy to just at real react the way that he did, not finding her.

52:49.004 --> 52:52.485
[SPEAKER_04]: But again, there's surveillance footage that corroborates

52:53.158 --> 52:53.518
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

52:53.758 --> 53:00.903
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, the part that I have trouble with is that she seemingly didn't realize that she didn't have her purse or her cell phone with her.

53:01.524 --> 53:04.866
[SPEAKER_02]: The entire time she was at the bar, which seems like it was a long time.

53:05.307 --> 53:08.749
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, but as you said, she was drinking.

53:08.769 --> 53:09.189
[SPEAKER_04]: Yes.

53:09.209 --> 53:10.150
[SPEAKER_04]: This is late at night.

53:11.031 --> 53:12.532
[SPEAKER_04]: It's closing time.

53:12.572 --> 53:13.873
[SPEAKER_04]: So two, three in the morning.

53:13.893 --> 53:14.393
[SPEAKER_02]: It was three.

53:14.433 --> 53:14.673
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

53:14.693 --> 53:18.696
[SPEAKER_04]: Three in the morning and potentially she had been slipped something.

53:19.229 --> 53:19.709
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.

53:20.049 --> 53:21.310
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, some time earlier.

53:21.410 --> 53:28.253
[SPEAKER_02]: So yeah, you know, I mean, absolutely like it all ends up making sense, but not at least not on the surface.

53:28.273 --> 53:29.253
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, not at all.

53:29.473 --> 53:29.733
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

53:29.833 --> 53:34.295
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, though legit if if if there wasn't video footage.

53:34.615 --> 53:38.257
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, proving John slash Jason's story.

53:39.037 --> 53:41.378
[SPEAKER_04]: Like he'd been a number one.

53:41.758 --> 53:47.163
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, yeah, because in what world does the guy who has the person, the cell phone, right?

53:47.223 --> 53:52.348
[SPEAKER_02]: Of the woman who isn't missing, like, not being involved, like, that's not how that works, you know?

53:52.368 --> 53:57.533
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, no, like, everybody police included would be like, oh, you did come up, man.

53:57.713 --> 54:03.999
[SPEAKER_04]: Like, like, be fucking real, like, like, like your person, cell phone, wearing your car.

54:04.219 --> 54:04.559
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

54:05.520 --> 54:09.324
[SPEAKER_04]: But, I mean, there's evidence there.

54:09.945 --> 54:17.893
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, that she left with somebody different, and not only somebody different, but somebody with a very long history.

54:18.293 --> 54:19.575
[SPEAKER_04]: A being sketchy as fuck.

54:19.855 --> 54:20.175
[SPEAKER_04]: Yes.

54:20.596 --> 54:20.756
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.

54:21.100 --> 54:28.506
[SPEAKER_02]: December 2023, it was the one year anniversary of Gretchen's disappearance, and not much had changed since the summer.

54:29.547 --> 54:40.616
[SPEAKER_02]: Pierce is still a person of interest, but by this time he had moved out of the rented home that police believe he took Gretchen to in the early hours of December 4, 2022.

54:41.517 --> 54:46.721
[SPEAKER_02]: He's apparently been moving around the state of West Virginia, and apparently I don't know.

54:51.236 --> 55:03.445
[SPEAKER_02]: He was recently seen back in Parker'sburg at a fast food restaurant and like, I mean, people are keeping an eye out for him, like they were taking pictures of him posting it on Facebook, like the sky's back in town, hydrochids, basically.

55:04.045 --> 55:08.929
[SPEAKER_02]: Parker'sburg West Virginia has been deeply affected by Gretchen Fleming's disappearance.

55:09.509 --> 55:17.334
[SPEAKER_02]: Facebook and other online forums are full of active discussions about her, Preston Pierce, and the other people involved in this case.

55:18.235 --> 55:21.296
[SPEAKER_02]: she's very much cared for and very much missed.

55:21.796 --> 55:32.858
[SPEAKER_02]: The last update that we've had on the forensic testing was in May of 2023, so we don't know if they've received all the results or if there's anything that's still outstanding.

55:33.398 --> 55:42.580
[SPEAKER_02]: Parker'sburg police have said that they're methodically running down leads and they're asking the public for any help or information that they may be able to offer.

55:43.200 --> 55:51.322
[SPEAKER_02]: While investigators and Gretchen's family don't know exactly what happened to her or where she is now, they know that whatever happened was not her decision.

55:52.102 --> 55:53.022
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen was taken.

55:53.963 --> 55:57.463
[SPEAKER_02]: Now they're all searching for answers and hopefully for justice.

56:16.890 --> 56:21.675
[SPEAKER_02]: Gretchen Fleming has been missing from Parker's Burg West Virginia since December 4th, 2022.

56:22.336 --> 56:24.579
[SPEAKER_02]: She is a white female with brown hair and brown eyes.

56:24.919 --> 56:29.845
[SPEAKER_02]: She is approximately 5 foot two and 125 pounds at the time of her disappearance.

56:30.866 --> 56:32.588
[SPEAKER_02]: She was 27 when she was missing.

56:33.008 --> 56:33.629
[SPEAKER_02]: She would be 29 today.

56:34.870 --> 56:57.629
[SPEAKER_02]: Anyone with information regarding Gretchen Fleming's disappearance is asked to call lead detective James Zimmerman at 304-424-1072 or the police department's mainline at 304-424-844-4 You can see all the sources for this episode along with photos and videos at our website and then they're gone.com

56:58.187 --> 57:05.670
[SPEAKER_04]: and be sure to follow us on social, and then they were gone pod on Facebook and at ATTWG pod on Instagram and TikTok.

57:06.290 --> 57:10.691
[SPEAKER_04]: If you like what we're doing, please subscribe and consider leaving a five star of you on Apple Podcasts.

57:11.192 --> 57:12.632
[SPEAKER_04]: It will help new listeners find us.

57:13.172 --> 57:16.573
[SPEAKER_04]: And the more people that listen, the more chances we have of bringing someone home.

57:17.474 --> 57:19.935
[SPEAKER_02]: And we'll see you here next week for a brand new episode.

57:20.135 --> 57:20.875
[SPEAKER_02]: See you next week.

57:21.879 --> 57:27.867
[SPEAKER_02]: And then they were gone as hosted by Kona Gallagher and Ethan Flick, while research writing and editing is done by me, Kona Gallagher.

57:28.528 --> 57:30.651
[SPEAKER_02]: The music is the Stork by Katza.

57:31.212 --> 57:36.599
[SPEAKER_02]: Additional music is provided by Kai Engel, and then they were gone is a little monster production.

