WEBVTT

00:00.031 --> 00:09.145
[SPEAKER_01]: You're on team human, conscious intervention in the machine, a replacement of crypto's proof of work with the artists' proof of care.

00:09.686 --> 00:13.892
[SPEAKER_01]: The genius of individuality with the seniors of collective creativity.

00:14.493 --> 00:19.441
[SPEAKER_01]: We can imagine our way out of this mess if we accept the invitation to play.

00:20.081 --> 00:23.727
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Douglas Rushkoff, and I'm on team human.

00:23.707 --> 00:37.127
[SPEAKER_01]: Playing for team human today, the man who helped the world take its focus off the figure and onto the ground, off the ending and onto new beginnings, away from the certainty of victory and into the delight of surrender.

00:37.848 --> 00:40.872
[SPEAKER_01]: Meet my role model, Brian Eno.

00:40.852 --> 00:50.513
[SPEAKER_01]: He's just published an extraordinarily deep, yet accessible book what is art for with collaborator Betta Adrianse.

00:51.115 --> 00:54.121
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm going to engage with him about that and a lot more.

00:54.582 --> 00:57.388
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks for being on team human.

00:57.709 --> 00:58.431
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, Douglas.

00:58.511 --> 01:00.936
[SPEAKER_01]: That was a very, very nice introduction.

01:00.916 --> 01:12.011
[SPEAKER_01]: It means so much to me to be in your extended scene, yes, you know, your work, your art has been really important to me for a long time.

01:12.051 --> 01:14.034
[SPEAKER_01]: And people say it to me sometimes.

01:14.114 --> 01:17.879
[SPEAKER_01]: I go, go on their podcast and now I get what they mean.

01:17.899 --> 01:23.807
[SPEAKER_01]: So first, thanks for inviting all of us to play in new ways.

01:24.408 --> 01:25.489
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Douglas.

01:25.469 --> 01:32.219
[SPEAKER_01]: All right, so let's start, I mean, with that, I guess, with what is art, what is art for?

01:32.940 --> 01:47.983
[SPEAKER_01]: And when you talk about art, it's very similar to all those sort of theorists that I had read about play.

01:47.963 --> 01:48.644
[SPEAKER_01]: applied.

01:48.965 --> 01:57.018
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, the quote from your book is, um, the art engagement begins where functional engagement ends.

01:58.160 --> 02:02.768
[SPEAKER_01]: Which is really a fun, a fun way to look at it.

02:03.028 --> 02:04.230
[SPEAKER_01]: So I hear you made the shoe now.

02:04.370 --> 02:06.073
[SPEAKER_01]: Why'd you put that extra flourish on it?

02:06.294 --> 02:06.935
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the art.

02:07.596 --> 02:08.337
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, exactly.

02:08.898 --> 02:11.963
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think a very good example of

02:13.090 --> 02:17.596
[SPEAKER_00]: the difference between art and non art is surgical instruments.

02:18.157 --> 02:24.346
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, if you're making scalples, for example, you really don't want any art in the blade.

02:24.847 --> 02:28.652
[SPEAKER_00]: You want it to be a sharp and as durable and as reliable as possible.

02:29.434 --> 02:34.261
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't want to engrave it with some pretty little pattern because that might weaken it.

02:35.202 --> 02:40.870
[SPEAKER_00]: So you really don't want to disturb the function

02:40.850 --> 02:58.566
[SPEAKER_00]: On the other hand, if you're making spoons, for instance, you might be able to afford to have some flourishes and even to make quite extraordinarily complicated spoons just for the sake of the pleasure of those complications.

02:59.348 --> 03:01.272
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you're a sculptor,

03:01.252 --> 03:13.043
[SPEAKER_00]: If you decide that actually the most important thing about your spoon is the amount of art it can hold Then you may you might make a spoon that is perforated has holes all the way through it.

03:13.063 --> 03:30.499
[SPEAKER_00]: It can't actually lift any liquid at all But that would be alright if if you were calling it art So I think I'm trying to make this distinction in people's minds between Things that can only be done in one way or in a very limited number of ways

03:30.479 --> 03:35.326
[SPEAKER_00]: or circumstances in which you can take all sorts of liberties and freedoms.

03:36.648 --> 03:42.877
[SPEAKER_00]: And those latter circumstances are the ones that I think of as occasions for art.

03:43.238 --> 03:56.537
[SPEAKER_01]: The part that always gets tricky for me, and this is as someone who's had to defend the humanities against the sciences and defend the arts against the practical clinical fields,

03:56.517 --> 04:05.054
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like as the art crowd, we often get caught in trying to justify those flourishes on the spoon.

04:05.414 --> 04:07.499
[SPEAKER_01]: So we'll say, oh, they're beautiful.

04:07.839 --> 04:14.132
[SPEAKER_01]: And also we found that with good flourishes on a spoon, people's digestion actually improves.

04:14.492 --> 04:14.973
[SPEAKER_01]: You know?

04:14.993 --> 04:16.416
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.

04:16.396 --> 04:24.967
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so I think that's always a problem when things get translated into simple terms that we can understand.

04:25.728 --> 04:42.150
[SPEAKER_00]: Another example of that is when environmentalists think they can defend forests, for example, by saying that a forest actually produces in terms of human well-being,

04:42.839 --> 04:49.356
[SPEAKER_00]: The problem with doing that is if you get people to think, well, the only point of having forests is to increase GDP.

04:50.419 --> 04:52.324
[SPEAKER_00]: Then you will end up with no forest at all.

04:53.507 --> 04:58.300
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't want it to be put into those translatable terms.

04:58.280 --> 05:01.644
[SPEAKER_00]: because eventually it will be replaced by just those terms.

05:03.446 --> 05:17.982
[SPEAKER_00]: In the way that if you create examinations to test people's skill or understanding of something, eventually what you do is produce people who are good at those examinations, rather than people who are good at those subjects.

05:19.704 --> 05:23.528
[SPEAKER_00]: So you have to be very careful about what metrics you put on things, I think.

05:23.508 --> 05:37.126
[SPEAKER_00]: So in the book we've avoided doing that, we've avoided trying to make an argument for the arts on the basis that they might be part of the economic health of a country or an individual.

05:37.947 --> 05:43.174
[SPEAKER_00]: And we're saying, just take it for what it is and see what the value of that is.

05:44.656 --> 05:48.742
[SPEAKER_00]: So we're trying to really discuss what humans make out for.

05:49.483 --> 05:51.366
[SPEAKER_00]: What are they getting when they do that?

05:51.406 --> 05:53.228
[SPEAKER_00]: What are they doing?

05:53.208 --> 05:57.851
[SPEAKER_00]: What do they expect to happen to other people as a result of them doing that?

05:57.871 --> 06:01.429
[SPEAKER_00]: So those I think are interesting questions.

06:01.679 --> 06:30.387
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I know you're technically an atheist, but you obviously see the enchantment and the sanctity of existence all at the same time, and, you know, and while I do want to get into the sort of the psychological or even social, civilizational benefits of art, for this, you know, and you talk about the ability to dream different realities and test things and strategize,

06:30.367 --> 06:39.800
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm sort of refusing to seed any ground that with none of that, it's still fucking enough.

06:40.080 --> 06:43.905
[SPEAKER_01]: It's enough that we've had this sacred experience.

06:43.965 --> 06:47.210
[SPEAKER_01]: And I go to a hoisinger, the Dutch play theorist.

06:47.250 --> 06:49.954
[SPEAKER_01]: He wrote this book called Homologans, Man in the Player.

06:50.474 --> 06:55.761
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, beautiful book where he said, dogs don't play in order to practice for the hunt.

06:55.982 --> 06:58.365
[SPEAKER_01]: They hunt in order to have the energy

06:58.345 --> 07:14.397
[SPEAKER_01]: To play, to chase each other around, and that that's the the highest function is the purposeless one that if if you feel free to engage in purposeless aesthetic joy, it means that our existence matters

07:14.377 --> 07:17.222
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes, that's that's beautifully put.

07:18.163 --> 07:40.519
[SPEAKER_00]: I started collecting videos of animals playing because I well I think it's so fantastic because we've always been told that animals are sort of purely functional in stictual creatures and that therefore they couldn't really play at least in the

07:40.499 --> 07:55.034
[SPEAKER_00]: But I saw a year ago, I saw this film of a dog on a snowy hill, dragging a tray, a plastic tray up the hill in his teeth, who's walking up the hill backwards, dragging this tray.

07:55.395 --> 08:05.565
[SPEAKER_00]: He gets to the top of the hill, jumps on the tray and then slides down and then at the bottom, jumps off and repeats the operation.

08:06.226 --> 08:10.050
[SPEAKER_00]: And I thought there is no functional explanation of that.

08:10.030 --> 08:17.662
[SPEAKER_00]: there's no way of saying the dog was practicing to bring down wolves or whatever else people might say.

08:18.283 --> 08:28.039
[SPEAKER_00]: He was playing and I saw another one of a a pig and a chicken I think it was chasing each other round of a bond.

08:28.019 --> 08:37.238
[SPEAKER_00]: with all of the, the funny sort of jobs up in surprise when one comes behind the other, you know, I thought they're playing.

08:37.959 --> 08:40.965
[SPEAKER_00]: And so it may be think that playing is something that

08:42.380 --> 08:43.541
[SPEAKER_00]: every creature does.

08:44.402 --> 09:01.583
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, I recently read that even what we would think of very primitive creatures compared to us also play, I think it was a study of worms actually, worms play, who would have known.

09:01.623 --> 09:09.552
[SPEAKER_00]: So I started thinking that, well, I think one of the premises of the book

09:10.072 --> 09:12.257
[SPEAKER_00]: art is a variety of play.

09:14.041 --> 09:26.308
[SPEAKER_00]: So I say in the book that we completely accept that children learn through playing, not nobody would argue with that now that

09:26.288 --> 09:41.310
[SPEAKER_00]: the things that a child does when they're playing become their important life skills, not only the physical things like learning to move around well and so on and understanding the their strengths and limitations as physical beings,

09:41.290 --> 09:47.923
[SPEAKER_00]: But also, being able to imagine things, you know, so much of children's play is about, let's pretend.

09:48.624 --> 09:51.770
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's imagine I'm listening to you all that, aware in this place.

09:52.672 --> 10:03.973
[SPEAKER_00]: And, well, it turns out that, you know, about the age of 11, we think children should start getting serious, so we start to encourage formal kinds of learning.

10:03.953 --> 10:12.364
[SPEAKER_00]: and often at the expense of playing, but I don't think people stop learning or stop needing to play at the age of 11.

10:12.384 --> 10:16.470
[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's something you'd need to do throughout your whole life.

10:17.151 --> 10:23.920
[SPEAKER_00]: And my feeling is that the way you do that or one of the ways you do that is by making art.

10:23.900 --> 10:33.870
[SPEAKER_00]: art is really a sophisticated adult form of play, and so the question then comes, well, why do we do that?

10:33.890 --> 10:37.354
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think we do it for exactly the same reason that children do it.

10:37.934 --> 10:38.895
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a way of learning.

10:39.396 --> 10:49.806
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a way of internalizing and re-experiencing things and being able to think

10:49.786 --> 10:56.233
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm thinking of when I was reading the book actually, I was reminded of the movie Quest for Fire.

10:56.253 --> 10:59.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you remember that about the caveman?

10:59.396 --> 11:12.229
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a great movie about it from, you know, I forgot probably the 80s about these cavemen in one tribe and they they lose they don't know how to make fire, but they have fire and their little original seed fire goes out.

11:12.309 --> 11:16.553
[SPEAKER_01]: So they send two or three

11:16.533 --> 11:30.880
[SPEAKER_01]: and their regular, you know, cavemen in little, uh, loincloths at all, and they come upon, um, Ray Dawn Chong, who's playing, uh, cave woman from another tribe, and her body is painted with,

11:31.855 --> 11:34.438
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, like bone designs or something.

11:35.199 --> 11:41.648
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know immediately that because her body is painted, she's from a more advanced civilization.

11:42.229 --> 11:43.510
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, they've done that.

11:43.671 --> 11:54.505
[SPEAKER_01]: And I remember thinking as a high school kid, whenever watching this, oh, the reason we know she's more advanced is because she's done something with ostensibly no practical purpose.

11:54.586 --> 11:59.053
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes, yes, so that's that's a very good measure of civilization.

12:00.736 --> 12:16.982
[SPEAKER_00]: I came up with this little idea once it's a pun really where I said civilization is an evening out and I meant that in both senses of that phrase and evening out doing something recreational just for the pleasure of it.

12:16.962 --> 12:36.338
[SPEAKER_00]: But also, civilization is an evening out of what nature tends to do to us, so we don't have to experience extreme cold or extreme temperature because we have civilisational technologies that enable us to flatten the landscape in some ways.

12:36.318 --> 12:39.704
[SPEAKER_01]: Of course, it's always the danger, right, that you even it out too much.

12:39.784 --> 12:53.128
[SPEAKER_01]: You create too much control and well, you lose access to the more natural rhythms of nature and the things that keep us alive, but you can get obsessed with control and safety to the extinction of life itself.

12:53.108 --> 12:58.935
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, which might be why, because we're in danger of doing that, that might be one of the reasons that we want art.

13:00.156 --> 13:14.593
[SPEAKER_00]: So we can create simulations effectively where we are still able to experience the feelings of danger and need and love and all of the other things that happen to any normal human.

13:14.573 --> 13:25.244
[SPEAKER_00]: So on the one hand, we want to defend ourselves from change, disruptive change, but on the other hand, we want change as well.

13:25.324 --> 13:32.972
[SPEAKER_00]: We have an appetite for it, we love novelty, but we want novelty that isn't completely life-threatening.

13:33.994 --> 13:38.218
[SPEAKER_00]: So art is sort of non-life-threatening novelty.

13:38.198 --> 13:38.739
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

13:39.119 --> 13:39.340
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

13:39.400 --> 13:53.942
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a way of, I mean, a simplest level, you know, even an Aristotle level, you know, creating these situations where you can get catharsis without having to actually murder people or die or have those things in real life, kind of like a kids going on a roller coaster.

13:54.023 --> 14:03.597
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, we live in such a safe civilization that people experience their threat at Disneyland rather than, you know, on the streets, which is, yeah, beautiful.

14:03.637 --> 14:05.961
[SPEAKER_01]: And I guess we need it on,

14:06.785 --> 14:07.607
[SPEAKER_01]: on some level.

14:07.667 --> 14:22.988
[SPEAKER_01]: But then, you know, when you do talk about art as a don't play, it's really this exercise of our imaginative skills gives us the ability to then.

14:23.187 --> 14:27.775
[SPEAKER_01]: really conjure other realities that we might then choose to inhabit.

14:28.096 --> 14:29.057
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, exactly.

14:29.658 --> 14:33.405
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's a, it's a simulator essentially.

14:33.425 --> 14:46.528
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I've been in a simulator once and I was actually trying to land a 747 with 400 people on it and unfortunately crashed.

14:46.508 --> 15:05.301
[SPEAKER_00]: But the feeling of doing that, even knowing full well at every moment that this is a simulation, nonetheless I ended up sweating and completely exhausted from this attempt to do something that was really only happening in a bunch of code on a screen in front of me.

15:07.124 --> 15:08.787
[SPEAKER_00]: But the

15:08.767 --> 15:15.580
[SPEAKER_00]: It's an amazing fact about human beings that we can so strongly inhabit fictions like that.

15:16.301 --> 15:18.726
[SPEAKER_00]: And that, of course, is what art depends on.

15:19.548 --> 15:26.100
[SPEAKER_00]: Novels are only interesting because they can engage our emotions in such a strong and powerful way.

15:26.080 --> 15:30.967
[SPEAKER_00]: And we can kind of think for a while that we're living through those situations.

15:31.568 --> 15:36.795
[SPEAKER_00]: And we can ask ourselves the questions, oh my God, why does that feel so dangerous?

15:37.156 --> 15:38.338
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, why do I love this?

15:39.379 --> 15:44.927
[SPEAKER_00]: It tells you a lot about yourself without you ever having to leave an armchair.

15:45.328 --> 15:50.535
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I don't want to do a career retrospective because it's people have done it.

15:50.515 --> 15:53.558
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's not, it's, and you're, you're in the moment.

15:53.578 --> 15:58.564
[SPEAKER_01]: But this feels like some, another green world was, what was that?

15:58.704 --> 16:01.267
[SPEAKER_01]: But, but what you're talking about now?

16:01.647 --> 16:04.871
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you know, I mean, you're, you're, you're work.

16:05.091 --> 16:07.253
[SPEAKER_01]: What's the generative art that you've been doing?

16:07.573 --> 16:11.017
[SPEAKER_01]: But practicing this, this note, you talk about it in the book.

16:11.037 --> 16:13.800
[SPEAKER_01]: You say, you know, as artists, we don't finish it.

16:13.820 --> 16:14.741
[SPEAKER_01]: We start it.

16:14.761 --> 16:17.224
[SPEAKER_01]: It goes on to have a life without us.

16:17.404 --> 16:20.067
[SPEAKER_01]: A life we didn't predict.

16:20.367 --> 16:22.850
[SPEAKER_01]: What's closer to that?

16:23.030 --> 16:26.594
[SPEAKER_01]: What you're talking about today, then the generative art you were doing 40 years ago?

16:26.934 --> 16:28.235
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, so this is...

16:30.938 --> 16:36.664
[SPEAKER_00]: When I was young, the first art that I liked was art that looked like things.

16:37.846 --> 16:44.993
[SPEAKER_00]: And then I met the work of Mondrian when I was quite young then, as well, I was 10 or 11, I guess.

16:45.594 --> 16:49.378
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was suddenly completely bold over by

16:50.405 --> 16:59.919
[SPEAKER_00]: art that still was beautiful but didn't look like anything, you know, Mondrian doesn't look like anything except possibly now a bit of furniture copying a Mondrian.

17:01.862 --> 17:06.510
[SPEAKER_00]: But I remember thinking, this is amazing.

17:06.750 --> 17:08.573
[SPEAKER_00]: And why do I think that's amazing?

17:08.633 --> 17:11.277
[SPEAKER_00]: The two feelings coexisted for me.

17:11.798 --> 17:14.261
[SPEAKER_00]: I love this thing and I have no idea why.

17:14.281 --> 17:16.024
[SPEAKER_00]: I couldn't

17:17.489 --> 17:30.710
[SPEAKER_00]: stopped being fascinated by the mystery of I was so powerfully affected by something that actually I could make, you know, after I first saw Mondrian I made lots of Mondrian paintings.

17:32.032 --> 17:42.349
[SPEAKER_00]: That was Mondrian and Candinsky was sort of the two artists that made me want to be a painter,

17:43.443 --> 17:48.051
[SPEAKER_00]: very early on I was asking myself the question, but why do we like things like that?

17:48.452 --> 17:52.259
[SPEAKER_00]: Why do I like this particular arrangement of shapes and colours?

17:53.000 --> 17:53.741
[SPEAKER_00]: And not that one.

17:54.563 --> 17:55.324
[SPEAKER_00]: What's the difference?

17:55.585 --> 18:04.320
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, if you showed them to a Martian, they would look identical just like if you played every known string quartet in the classical repertoire.

18:04.300 --> 18:10.446
[SPEAKER_00]: to a computer, it would have a very hard job telling you what the difference was between them.

18:12.228 --> 18:24.780
[SPEAKER_00]: That would be a very interesting question for an AI wouldn't it to play fake and not very good string quartets alongside famous great ones.

18:25.340 --> 18:33.548
[SPEAKER_00]: And to see whether there was any objective distinction between them.

18:34.591 --> 18:36.313
[SPEAKER_00]: Well I wonder, what do you think it would be?

18:36.373 --> 18:43.221
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, what would, I suppose, what would define a really bad one?

18:44.462 --> 18:52.872
[SPEAKER_00]: And if we, if we know about this, why the fuck hasn't AI been able to expigate itself with all the shit it produces?

18:53.492 --> 19:02.262
[SPEAKER_01]: I know, well, it did create the number one country song in America for many weeks, did it with a, with a vocalist and everything.

19:02.302 --> 19:02.843
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

19:03.970 --> 19:07.135
[SPEAKER_00]: Really, really, what was that song I need to do?

19:07.155 --> 19:08.356
[SPEAKER_01]: I forgot what it was called.

19:08.416 --> 19:08.957
[SPEAKER_01]: It was sort of it.

19:08.977 --> 19:16.168
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a gospely sounding man, gravelly, mid-voice man, country song, and the whole thing was generated.

19:16.688 --> 19:21.055
[SPEAKER_01]: So, at least they've in a pop way.

19:21.075 --> 19:23.498
[SPEAKER_01]: They've been able to capture

19:23.950 --> 19:24.471
[SPEAKER_01]: something.

19:24.491 --> 19:27.960
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, whether we want to call it art or not, I guess it's something else.

19:28.061 --> 19:34.417
[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm sure at the height of the Beatles and AI could have created something Beatles like.

19:35.299 --> 19:37.044
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, interesting to know that.

19:37.064 --> 19:38.989
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, first of all,

19:40.657 --> 19:46.147
[SPEAKER_00]: If you said to an A, can you make me a bad string quartet, please?

19:48.431 --> 19:58.168
[SPEAKER_00]: In a way to find the rules that make something bad, it's just as difficult, possibly even more difficult than the ones that make it good.

19:58.188 --> 20:04.639
[SPEAKER_00]: I have done very little research in this as you can tell, but I wonder

20:05.851 --> 20:11.707
[SPEAKER_00]: I wonder whether anyone thinks that's worth looking into, probably because you can't make billions of dollars doing it.

20:11.908 --> 20:14.796
[SPEAKER_00]: Nobody will look into it for quite a long time.

20:15.337 --> 20:18.145
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, this country song is called, it's great.

20:18.165 --> 20:19.489
[SPEAKER_01]: God, walk my walk.

20:21.798 --> 20:48.632
[SPEAKER_01]: walk my walk billboards number one country song yeah you know so it's even it even uh... the song is is even uh... human you know it's not it's not an abstraction that goes very much in the body to it's interesting that way but you know so it's them simulating set them simulating us which is sweet and it's way but the the other the the great

20:48.781 --> 21:11.903
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, one of the great possible purposes of art is this imagining futures not to be so again, so applied, but doing simulations of disasters, of solutions of, you know, we can sort of think through something other than fascism and violence, maybe.

21:11.883 --> 21:13.265
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.

21:13.986 --> 21:21.698
[SPEAKER_00]: And that thinking through actually is done not only by thinking, but in fact, mostly by feeling.

21:22.419 --> 21:23.721
[SPEAKER_00]: It's feeling first.

21:23.782 --> 21:26.726
[SPEAKER_00]: What art offers you is not information.

21:26.746 --> 21:27.868
[SPEAKER_00]: It offers you feelings.

21:28.889 --> 21:31.333
[SPEAKER_00]: So it sort of says, here's a scenario.

21:32.395 --> 21:33.176
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this person.

21:33.196 --> 21:34.017
[SPEAKER_00]: There's that person.

21:34.478 --> 21:36.962
[SPEAKER_00]: They interact in this way.

21:36.942 --> 21:41.674
[SPEAKER_00]: And what you take from that is not something about people.

21:41.834 --> 21:50.074
[SPEAKER_00]: It's something about your feelings, your sense of, oh, that offends me or that excites me or that makes me angry.

21:51.397 --> 21:54.124
[SPEAKER_00]: This is always what happens when you experience art that you

21:54.104 --> 21:57.290
[SPEAKER_00]: you take in feelings.

21:57.931 --> 22:07.469
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, feelings are the first and tenay that we have, your first reactions to things are feeling reactions.

22:08.050 --> 22:17.007
[SPEAKER_00]: And then very quickly we can pretend we didn't feel something because we've now found a way of rationalizing those feelings and saying,

22:16.987 --> 22:20.612
[SPEAKER_00]: I thought about it, but we don't think first.

22:21.533 --> 22:37.574
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, and very often there are certain things we never really think about, like I think most people who are born into a religion and who continue living in that religion probably don't ask the fundamental questions of that religion that the outsiders might.

22:38.155 --> 22:42.100
[SPEAKER_00]: They just accept that that's how things are.

22:42.080 --> 22:59.327
[SPEAKER_00]: Like most of us accept all sorts of things like I accept that I'm a white, older, white male and most of the time I don't I'm not carrying in mind what that implies about how I will interact with the world.

23:00.469 --> 23:05.978
[SPEAKER_00]: And so what often happens in art I think is that your first rule suddenly reminded

23:05.958 --> 23:19.490
[SPEAKER_00]: who you are, where you come from, and you're reminded that you make judgments on the base of feelings, not on the basis of rationality.

23:20.112 --> 23:23.680
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, most of the very important things that you decide in your life,

23:25.634 --> 23:28.458
[SPEAKER_00]: are not decided analytically.

23:29.459 --> 23:34.005
[SPEAKER_00]: They're decided emotionally, like who do you end up marrying or living with?

23:35.127 --> 23:36.528
[SPEAKER_00]: What job do you end up doing?

23:37.570 --> 23:55.033
[SPEAKER_00]: If you sat down with a spreadsheet, probably we would all end up trying to be, I don't know, financial technologists or whatever the fuck those people who make a lot of money for doing nothing.

23:55.537 --> 24:03.769
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and the feelings it's interesting because you talk about a work of art as a relic from another universe.

24:04.269 --> 24:10.137
[SPEAKER_01]: And as if it's, you know, HPS of art is an artifact from this whole other reality.

24:10.318 --> 24:14.303
[SPEAKER_01]: As if we've got, oh, here's a piece of evidence from this universe that we could make.

24:14.664 --> 24:21.674
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and of course, to toy manufacturers build on that, they'll take the toy and they go, oh, gee, I Joe wants a GI Joe universe.

24:21.694 --> 24:24.177
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll build that and sell that to people,

24:24.157 --> 24:37.038
[SPEAKER_01]: the idea that being a relic from another universe, it's not that we look at this piece of art and then intellectually extrapolate what sort of economy would this world have?

24:37.118 --> 24:38.541
[SPEAKER_01]: What sort of, you know?

24:38.561 --> 24:49.118
[SPEAKER_01]: It's more this feeling that it's this portal to much more almost quantum parallel universe

24:49.098 --> 25:12.270
[SPEAKER_00]: uh uh experiential wonder yes I mean you see this in fashion a lot where somebody can put on one garment or one type of shoe or an earring or something like that and it can just be one thing but it sort of tells you that this person is connected to another way of thinking about things.

25:12.250 --> 25:33.702
[SPEAKER_00]: this person has a doorway to another world and I think world making is what artists do you know when you when you make something what you're really saying to somebody is welcome to as Jim Reeves said welcome to my world come into this world and see how that feels

25:33.682 --> 26:01.225
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, because it's safe, because it's out, because nothing is going to happen to you, that it's dangerous, you can afford to enter into quite extreme worlds, so you can enter a totalitarian world in 1984, you can enter a world of occult horror, you can enter a world

26:01.205 --> 26:08.195
[SPEAKER_00]: You can enter any of these worlds and if it gets too much for you, you just shut the book.

26:08.796 --> 26:11.760
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, you leave the cinema or you switch the TV off.

26:12.341 --> 26:18.910
[SPEAKER_00]: So when I say to artists sometimes, well, the value of art is that it's safe.

26:20.830 --> 26:29.241
[SPEAKER_00]: they sometimes think that's a kind of dismissal of art because they can't relate safe to serious.

26:30.163 --> 26:33.467
[SPEAKER_00]: I get the same thing in the reaction to the word play as well.

26:35.350 --> 26:37.152
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, so you think it's only play.

26:38.133 --> 26:50.550
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I think play is so central and important that I would never see it's only

26:54.209 --> 27:04.261
[SPEAKER_00]: you want a safe space to be able to rehearse certain kinds of feelings, to practice how you feel about those feelings.

27:05.022 --> 27:10.709
[SPEAKER_00]: You want a safe space, you don't want to have to have those feelings for real all the time.

27:11.550 --> 27:12.652
[SPEAKER_00]: They're too awful.

27:13.313 --> 27:16.116
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, the safe space is to do the most dangerous

27:16.501 --> 27:17.022
[SPEAKER_01]: things.

27:17.342 --> 27:18.743
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, that's academically.

27:18.783 --> 27:28.033
[SPEAKER_01]: I got so discouraged when we had to create the safe space in our seminars because what they meant by safe space is a space where we don't talk about dangerous things.

27:29.094 --> 27:30.976
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

27:30.996 --> 27:34.420
[SPEAKER_01]: That was exactly that was scary.

27:34.961 --> 27:39.886
[SPEAKER_01]: But the problem I've had and I think I'm finally over it.

27:40.026 --> 27:45.512
[SPEAKER_01]: But I was even asking a lot of times I would have artists on

27:45.965 --> 27:52.615
[SPEAKER_01]: It is my feeling of kind of guilt for not engaging with the real.

27:52.975 --> 27:54.858
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I'm supposed to be an activist.

27:54.898 --> 28:03.191
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm supposed to be engaging with the actual on the ground suffering of, you know, children in Gaza right now.

28:03.571 --> 28:06.235
[SPEAKER_01]: And here I am instead taking my time.

28:06.215 --> 28:11.524
[SPEAKER_01]: to talk with Brian Eno about art and simulation.

28:11.824 --> 28:16.892
[SPEAKER_01]: In other words, I'm not asking you to justify it, but sort of like, why is this okay?

28:16.952 --> 28:21.760
[SPEAKER_01]: Why is it okay that we're not right now spending every,

28:22.330 --> 28:25.435
[SPEAKER_01]: ounce of our of our being on the suffering.

28:25.455 --> 28:29.141
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a very good question and it's one that I'm always asking myself as well.

28:29.742 --> 28:40.440
[SPEAKER_00]: So in my case it's what balance should I make because I don't intend to give up either my activism or my art.

28:40.420 --> 28:47.618
[SPEAKER_00]: But it's worth deciding what proportion of my time they each take.

28:48.540 --> 28:56.860
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think one of the things I would say is that having spent quite a lot of time last year involved in activism.

28:59.017 --> 29:03.886
[SPEAKER_00]: I realize that I run out of steam after a while, I need some art.

29:05.007 --> 29:12.721
[SPEAKER_00]: I need to be reminded that humans are also beautiful, and they make, they can make beautiful things.

29:13.502 --> 29:17.329
[SPEAKER_00]: I need to be reminded of the value of humans.

29:17.309 --> 29:31.464
[SPEAKER_00]: when a lot of the time I spend now looking at the horrors they can create, so that's one thing, but maybe that's just because I'm weak and can't face the reality of life, but so be it.

29:33.446 --> 29:45.679
[SPEAKER_00]: But I feel also that there's such a complicated ecosystem between all of the different things

29:47.279 --> 29:59.144
[SPEAKER_00]: one has to be a little bit careful of being that kind of person who says, well, you know, what use the trees, why don't just cut them down and put housing estate there or plant crops there.

30:00.386 --> 30:05.457
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, those are useful and we can immediately see the problem is, of course, we

30:06.517 --> 30:30.752
[SPEAKER_00]: We know which things are really useful to us, or we know some of them, so we place a very high value on those, and we're willing to sacrifice other stuff that might be valuable, we just don't know how, but we'll sacrifice it anyway for the things that we can measure and quantify.

30:30.732 --> 30:42.323
[SPEAKER_00]: art and, in fact, in not only art, but spirituality or all the other non-translatable inter-dollars things that humans do.

30:44.966 --> 31:00.621
[SPEAKER_00]: If you try to justify it by saying, but they give us these benefits, then you're kind of saying, the ones that don't give me those benefits shouldn't be maintained.

31:00.601 --> 31:01.302
[SPEAKER_00]: they use this.

31:01.743 --> 31:01.923
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

31:02.003 --> 31:14.282
[SPEAKER_01]: And the people who don't and same for the people who don't have immediate utility value to the purpose of our market or civilization while they're expendable, you know, because they're not making AI.

31:14.342 --> 31:16.545
[SPEAKER_01]: They're not getting us off the planet.

31:16.585 --> 31:19.890
[SPEAKER_01]: They're not, you know, so they're they're wasted life.

31:20.191 --> 31:22.474
[SPEAKER_01]: Which, you know, brings me to one of the one of the,

31:22.454 --> 31:37.678
[SPEAKER_01]: the the last purposes of art that you bring up which I I love in the face of crypto which has this whole proof of work proof of this proof of work proof of stake is proof of care and I think you you kind of she

31:37.658 --> 31:40.822
[SPEAKER_01]: but kind of a little almost a Georgia O'Keefe picture there.

31:41.402 --> 31:42.944
[SPEAKER_01]: Uh, uh, are a mock-up of one.

31:43.284 --> 31:45.367
[SPEAKER_01]: I see, look at this flower.

31:45.807 --> 31:56.019
[SPEAKER_01]: How it looks like a female, you know, a human, uh, that, that what Georgia O'Keefe was doing by taking these, by making these large portraits of flowers was proof of care.

31:56.379 --> 31:57.841
[SPEAKER_01]: I care about this.

31:57.961 --> 32:02.586
[SPEAKER_01]: I want you to see it with the same love and attention that I do.

32:02.566 --> 32:04.690
[SPEAKER_01]: not that it's proving it's worth.

32:04.850 --> 32:08.777
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just proving my care for it as a human being.

32:09.057 --> 32:10.279
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes.

32:10.299 --> 32:11.181
[SPEAKER_00]: That's well put.

32:11.301 --> 32:14.226
[SPEAKER_00]: I think, yeah, that proof of casting.

32:14.266 --> 32:15.768
[SPEAKER_00]: I was pleased with that idea.

32:16.349 --> 32:17.892
[SPEAKER_00]: And I thought,

32:19.745 --> 32:27.601
[SPEAKER_00]: actually one of the things that art does over and over again is it draws your attention to something and says, do you know what?

32:27.822 --> 32:28.844
[SPEAKER_00]: This could be valuable.

32:30.146 --> 32:33.052
[SPEAKER_00]: To you, this could be something that means something to you.

32:33.313 --> 32:36.319
[SPEAKER_00]: You may not have noticed it before, but perhaps it does.

32:36.860 --> 32:40.808
[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean so much of the art that I like.

32:40.788 --> 32:41.990
[SPEAKER_00]: really is doing that.

32:42.090 --> 32:59.735
[SPEAKER_00]: It's reminding me that there are things in the world that I haven't noticed and that somebody else has noticed and has looked at closely and I look at it through their eyes or through their art and I say, oh yeah, that really is beautiful and it works the other way.

32:59.775 --> 33:01.497
[SPEAKER_00]: There are things that

33:01.477 --> 33:08.611
[SPEAKER_00]: are cruel and unpleasant that other artists have noticed and said, what do you think of this?

33:08.671 --> 33:10.194
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you think it should be like that?

33:11.096 --> 33:17.528
[SPEAKER_00]: When you look at the towards the end of the times of slavery,

33:19.010 --> 33:38.039
[SPEAKER_00]: or rather to the time of the abolition of slavery, not that it's actually ended, you suddenly saw a lot of art coming up which showed African slaves and made you realize what a horrible life they had.

33:38.059 --> 33:45.270
[SPEAKER_00]: Now that was possible because we suddenly started to realize, read about,

33:45.250 --> 34:13.232
[SPEAKER_00]: 1806 apparently that those other things were also human beings like us and not only did they have the same physical structure as us but they probably had the same mental structure in the sense that they could also feel pain and humiliation and shame and joy and everything else and as soon as you accept that then you can't keep slaves any longer.

34:13.212 --> 34:24.289
[SPEAKER_00]: you have to say, this is cruelty and, you know, everyone makes fun of, um, that Harriet Beach of Stoberg, Uncle Tom's cabin.

34:26.011 --> 34:33.803
[SPEAKER_00]: But I think it was a very significant book because the message of that book was this elderly black man,

34:35.200 --> 34:45.635
[SPEAKER_00]: living a kind of fairly excluded life was a thinking and feeling human being like you are dear reader.

34:46.676 --> 34:51.122
[SPEAKER_00]: And so a lot of art is doing that.

34:51.202 --> 34:54.627
[SPEAKER_00]: It's saying, see value where you didn't see it before.

34:54.758 --> 35:11.265
[SPEAKER_01]: And it also, you know, when I think about like industrial music and I'm Genesis Purege or even, you know, Andy Warhol taking, you know, a soup can or something from from life, they, they were taking things.

35:11.245 --> 35:15.870
[SPEAKER_01]: that were in some ways oppressive, you know, or some ways ever present.

35:15.971 --> 35:30.688
[SPEAKER_01]: And say, well, this is construction sound, but rather than feeling assaulted by it, let's put it into, let's listen, really listen to it, you know, it's sort of get, get behind it, or Warhol taking a soup can saying, yes, this is just in the grocery store.

35:30.708 --> 35:38.637
[SPEAKER_01]: But let's look at it in

35:38.617 --> 35:41.300
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes, I think it is.

35:41.680 --> 35:51.551
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a way of saying where you thought there was nothing, there is something, and that something has can engage your feelings.

35:52.172 --> 35:53.754
[SPEAKER_00]: You can feel about this.

35:54.795 --> 36:04.185
[SPEAKER_00]: We always use the phrase, you can think about something, but you can also say you can feel about something, because most of the

36:05.498 --> 36:16.853
[SPEAKER_00]: as we move through our life, we don't really feel about them, you know, I'm sitting here as I'm looking at it, and there's a sort of packing case and some wiring and a plug board on the floor.

36:17.293 --> 36:20.337
[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't really feel about them.

36:21.358 --> 36:26.545
[SPEAKER_00]: But if I decided to sit here and say, okay, I'm going to look at that as a sculpture.

36:28.027 --> 36:45.765
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to look at that as I would look at something if I saw it in a gallery, so just the act of framing something, of putting a rectangle round and saying somebody thought about this, somebody chose this, somebody made this.

36:45.745 --> 37:00.608
[SPEAKER_00]: then you start thinking, oh well as I am thinking now, I like the way the white cable and the black cable are intertwined and I like those curves against these straight, you know all the kinds of things I would do looking at a picture I suppose.

37:02.351 --> 37:08.260
[SPEAKER_00]: So we constantly do that, humans are just fascinated by

37:09.927 --> 37:15.033
[SPEAKER_00]: finding novelty by finding things that they didn't know they could have feelings about.

37:15.053 --> 37:24.565
[SPEAKER_00]: It's the thrill of sort of saying to yourself, actually I'm quite ingenious.

37:26.387 --> 37:32.695
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm quite good at noticing things at finding things with just a little prompt.

37:32.978 --> 37:43.090
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, and that's why I want us to be, and it's hard because we're all cynics, but I want us to be more forgiving, more open to things that look simple.

37:43.130 --> 37:45.993
[SPEAKER_01]: Like so many people, I know they look at art and they're, oh, I could have made that.

37:46.634 --> 37:50.958
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, yeah, of course you could, let's get over that, whether they're there's a technique that you couldn't do.

37:51.299 --> 37:54.843
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, someone took a little square and tilted it a little bit to the side.

37:54.863 --> 37:56.725
[SPEAKER_01]: That's their art.

37:56.705 --> 37:57.787
[SPEAKER_01]: Why would they do that?

37:57.827 --> 37:58.628
[SPEAKER_01]: What did they see?

37:58.768 --> 37:59.709
[SPEAKER_01]: What are they saying?

37:59.810 --> 38:04.637
[SPEAKER_01]: What's theness that they're trying to give us?

38:05.418 --> 38:10.385
[SPEAKER_01]: And that it's such a great training also for moving through the world.

38:12.448 --> 38:13.510
[SPEAKER_01]: What people care about?

38:13.530 --> 38:24.045
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, there's a trick that I use myself sometimes when I'm sort of stuck thinking about something.

38:26.118 --> 38:33.809
[SPEAKER_00]: I find a random object, I have various ways of doing that, but just take it for me, it's a random object.

38:34.730 --> 38:39.797
[SPEAKER_00]: And I see this is somehow the solution to the problem I'm thinking about.

38:41.540 --> 38:53.256
[SPEAKER_00]: And sometimes it's very obscure, the connection I make between the object and the problem, but in trying to make that connection, I'm actually thinking about the problem.

38:53.236 --> 38:57.641
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a little bit like, it's how all articles work really.

38:58.502 --> 39:07.253
[SPEAKER_00]: When you throw the eye chain and it says, window over water or whatever it says, and then you read that wind, what does wind mean?

39:07.333 --> 39:09.996
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, it means it's water means that, so what does that mean?

39:10.056 --> 39:12.359
[SPEAKER_00]: Wind over water in relation to the situation?

39:12.459 --> 39:15.042
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean at the moment that I'm asking questions about it.

39:15.022 --> 39:29.166
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, of course, all of that is a way of getting you to take this stuff out of your muddled up conscious bundle of feelings and thoughts that you have and to sort of lay it out on some kind of schema.

39:29.416 --> 39:30.838
[SPEAKER_00]: And you think, oh, yes, okay.

39:30.878 --> 39:32.680
[SPEAKER_00]: So, so that relates to that.

39:32.900 --> 39:33.261
[SPEAKER_00]: I see.

39:33.701 --> 39:35.744
[SPEAKER_00]: And this, oh, yes, yes, okay.

39:35.764 --> 39:36.324
[SPEAKER_00]: It's beautiful.

39:36.565 --> 39:39.889
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like a faith-based form of the oblique strategies deck.

39:40.289 --> 39:53.365
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, you don't need Brian, you know, to tell you this then going like phrase is going to help just look out at anything in your room and pick it up and trust that there's an oblique strategy relationship to your problem.

39:53.345 --> 40:18.154
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, that's the thing, and you have to trust that, and you have to try to work it through, because what some people do when they use a bleak strategy is all any other form of Oracle, is that they pick a card, I don't like that one, and the one they invent end up liking is the one that requires least cognitive effort on their part.

40:18.134 --> 40:27.405
[SPEAKER_00]: it's the one that most obviously applies and of course the interesting ones are the ones where you have to stretch to to make the connection.

40:27.786 --> 40:45.407
[SPEAKER_00]: So I always say to people just take one card just like with the I Ching you just do one reading you don't or with the taro whatever you're talking about you know you don't say to the guy who's the lady who's reading your taro sorry I didn't like that one can you try another one

40:45.387 --> 40:46.068
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

40:46.329 --> 40:47.410
[SPEAKER_01]: That doesn't really relate.

40:47.430 --> 40:49.113
[SPEAKER_01]: There's no woman in my life like that.

40:49.173 --> 40:51.176
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, just wait, then what does woman mean?

40:51.256 --> 40:52.238
[SPEAKER_01]: What does that mean?

40:52.398 --> 40:56.164
[SPEAKER_01]: It's working through that.

40:56.585 --> 41:04.037
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, on a personal level, it's what makes one, you know, pliable and alive and responsive.

41:04.017 --> 41:33.838
[SPEAKER_01]: And dimensional, then I'm thinking then on a societal level that all of this activity, whether you're demonstrating care for things that aren't being cared about, whether you're simulating new possibilities, whether you're just playfully celebrating the non-utility

41:33.818 --> 41:41.813
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm glad you use that phrase, no fascism is a word that we really ought to be using quite regularly now.

41:43.196 --> 41:49.347
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm giving a talk tonight and one of the things that I want to say is that

41:49.327 --> 41:54.475
[SPEAKER_00]: We've got to stop using these phrases far right or authoritarian politics.

41:55.236 --> 41:59.942
[SPEAKER_00]: That does exist, but actually fascism is what we're really talking about.

42:02.206 --> 42:12.581
[SPEAKER_00]: And using the term far right politics, kind of mutes the reality, because it says, oh, this is just part of the game of politics.

42:12.601 --> 42:18.169
[SPEAKER_00]: There's left and there's right, and we argue about things, and we come to a consensus, eventually.

42:18.149 --> 42:23.720
[SPEAKER_00]: Fascism has no interest whatsoever in coming to a consensus.

42:24.561 --> 42:26.946
[SPEAKER_00]: Fascism wants to absolutely dominate.

42:27.006 --> 42:29.972
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not a democratic process.

42:30.613 --> 42:36.985
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, fascism always uses the processes of democracy in order to destroy democracy.

42:36.965 --> 42:40.649
[SPEAKER_00]: So it destroys it and then that's the end of democracy.

42:40.689 --> 42:43.473
[SPEAKER_00]: Don't play that game any longer after that.

42:44.294 --> 43:04.457
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a great writer, Turkish writer called AJ Tamal Karan, who wrote a beautiful book about eight years ago called How to lose a country and it's sort of the story of how Turkey slid into

43:05.990 --> 43:11.308
[SPEAKER_00]: The reason nobody calls it fascism is because if you call it that you have to do something about it.

43:13.060 --> 43:20.830
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, if you call it far-right politics, then it's just part of the rich display of human right, to debate with it.

43:21.391 --> 43:21.651
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.

43:22.512 --> 43:26.658
[SPEAKER_00]: If you call it fascism, you have to bloody get off your arse and do something about it.

43:28.060 --> 43:30.923
[SPEAKER_00]: Or ass, I should say, since I've talked to America.

43:31.264 --> 43:32.185
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's very global.

43:32.626 --> 43:38.393
[SPEAKER_01]: But the doing art feels like one of the great

43:38.930 --> 43:58.457
[SPEAKER_01]: ways of doing something about fascism because the way we're talking about art now is it defies the inevitable that it creates wiggle room, you know, it's like it's like art the way we're talking about it is one big what if and what if is the enemy of fascism.

43:58.437 --> 44:02.124
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes, yes, that's that's a beautiful sentence.

44:02.144 --> 44:03.667
[SPEAKER_00]: I hope you've written that down somewhere.

44:04.688 --> 44:07.033
[SPEAKER_01]: We recorded it.

44:07.053 --> 44:08.255
[SPEAKER_00]: No, that's that's really good.

44:08.796 --> 44:14.286
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, one of these things I was thinking about the other day, which I think is related to this is, um,

44:16.173 --> 44:23.786
[SPEAKER_00]: the interesting fact that people fascists don't have very good sense of humour.

44:26.210 --> 44:31.279
[SPEAKER_00]: They don't make jokes, or if they do, they only kind of jokes, they seem to make a

44:31.259 --> 44:34.744
[SPEAKER_00]: sort of based on Schadenfreude, they're based on somebody else.

44:35.185 --> 44:37.909
[SPEAKER_00]: He's having a bad time, humiliation, yes.

44:38.570 --> 44:42.936
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean Trump is a classic example of that kind of humor.

44:43.877 --> 44:59.680
[SPEAKER_00]: I remember reading one about Mithrodates, you-per-tour, the Mesopotamian, I guess, Emperor, who was only recorded laughing once in his life

45:01.600 --> 45:07.529
[SPEAKER_00]: That was the only thing he thought was funny and he's laughing, seeing some other creature in pain.

45:09.212 --> 45:14.861
[SPEAKER_00]: But it's interesting that if you look at comedians, there are very few right-wing comedians.

45:17.144 --> 45:23.254
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I would love to know whether there's any statistical evidence for that.

45:23.314 --> 45:27.861
[SPEAKER_00]: But I don't every comedian we see in England.

45:28.988 --> 45:31.693
[SPEAKER_00]: with, I think, two exceptions that I can think of.

45:32.615 --> 45:39.909
[SPEAKER_00]: They're essentially sort of left-of-center progressives, liberals, if you like.

45:40.770 --> 45:51.891
[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't make them, I'm not saying that, therefore, they're much better people, but it's interesting to me that humour, which is really the ability to enjoy being surprised by a different perspective.

45:51.871 --> 45:54.735
[SPEAKER_00]: That's what humour comes down to, doesn't it?

45:54.795 --> 45:59.983
[SPEAKER_00]: You're led into a context where you expect something or other to happen.

46:00.583 --> 46:01.945
[SPEAKER_00]: And then something else happens.

46:02.466 --> 46:09.496
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, so often that's what jokes are that you realise, oh my gosh, yes, if you look at it from that angle, that's very funny.

46:11.439 --> 46:15.665
[SPEAKER_00]: But I think that fascists don't want to look at it from another angle.

46:16.286 --> 46:19.330
[SPEAKER_00]: They don't want to be surprised by another point of view.

46:19.310 --> 46:28.253
[SPEAKER_00]: I just read a fantastic book, incredibly long, 980 pages long.

46:29.196 --> 46:31.141
[SPEAKER_00]: Sounds like it's not done of everything, is it?

46:31.763 --> 46:33.808
[SPEAKER_00]: No, that's the, do you mean the Greybub book?

46:33.974 --> 46:58.682
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I love that book, no this this is a novel it's a novel and it's it's written from the point of view of an SS an SS officer through the Second World War so he he sees all the various horrors and ends up in a room with Hitler.

47:00.856 --> 47:08.284
[SPEAKER_00]: But the most interesting thing about the depiction of this person is his inability to

47:10.289 --> 47:12.973
[SPEAKER_00]: have any easy way of shifting perspective.

47:13.554 --> 47:14.576
[SPEAKER_00]: The kindly ones.

47:15.116 --> 47:15.898
[SPEAKER_00]: The kindly ones.

47:16.018 --> 47:16.659
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the book.

47:16.679 --> 47:17.200
[SPEAKER_00]: Well done.

47:18.502 --> 47:19.003
[SPEAKER_00]: Well done.

47:19.043 --> 47:21.847
[SPEAKER_00]: That's that's exactly the book.

47:22.007 --> 47:27.335
[SPEAKER_00]: It was had either very bad reviews or very good reviews.

47:28.037 --> 47:29.018
[SPEAKER_00]: They're always interesting.

47:29.038 --> 47:29.599
[SPEAKER_00]: Those books.

47:31.181 --> 47:38.052
[SPEAKER_00]: But what's fascinated me was being inside of a mind

47:41.373 --> 47:43.763
[SPEAKER_00]: uncertainty as the biggest danger.

47:43.823 --> 47:46.936
[SPEAKER_00]: There was terrified of uncertainty.

47:48.563 --> 47:50.893
[SPEAKER_00]: One of the things I think I say in the book.

47:52.173 --> 47:53.295
[SPEAKER_00]: We're upset somewhere anyway.

47:53.755 --> 48:05.653
[SPEAKER_01]: You say, if we don't learn to make a balance between control and surrender, if we only know how to control, we end up in a world shrunk into the bits that we can still control.

48:05.953 --> 48:11.802
[SPEAKER_01]: The raw, wild world develops and leaves us behind, playing solitaire on our phones.

48:11.782 --> 48:15.888
[SPEAKER_01]: That was good, wasn't it?

48:15.908 --> 48:34.237
[SPEAKER_01]: But that's what you said at the agency, the fascists and the tech bro, the certain kind of tech bro, the scientists and scientists are in the same trap, the trap from Francis Bacon forward of the only parts of the world they want to keep are the ones that they can control.

48:34.297 --> 48:38.363
[SPEAKER_01]: But the interesting difference between your perspective on an in mind,

48:38.343 --> 48:47.052
[SPEAKER_01]: was that my fear, not fear, but the way I looked at it was, oh, the tech pros are going to build all this science stuff and stuff they can control.

48:47.512 --> 48:52.137
[SPEAKER_01]: And then take off and leave us behind, upload and leave us behind.

48:52.418 --> 48:54.840
[SPEAKER_01]: But what you're saying is, oh, no, no, no, no.

48:54.860 --> 49:06.392
[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to leave them behind because we are in the rewilding, that they're stuck in their little virtual cubicle.

49:06.372 --> 49:20.327
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, they what they lack is an ability to improvise because improvisation requires first of all embarking on an uncertain project that doesn't have goals.

49:20.407 --> 49:24.872
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't you don't know what the goals are you're proceeding step by step.

49:24.952 --> 49:35.383
[SPEAKER_00]: So so that's the first thing about improvisation

49:37.355 --> 49:41.622
[SPEAKER_00]: a few days ago, went into hospital in Switzerland for surgery.

49:44.546 --> 49:45.948
[SPEAKER_00]: The surgeon made a mistake.

49:47.050 --> 50:05.539
[SPEAKER_00]: Actually, my friend is all right now, but for a couple of days, it looked like he might lose the use of his right leg, because of a slip of the scalpel.

50:07.730 --> 50:10.596
[SPEAKER_00]: sort of went completely bonkers for a little while.

50:12.479 --> 50:16.267
[SPEAKER_00]: Couldn't face the fact that something had gone wrong.

50:16.627 --> 50:29.873
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a major Swiss hospital specialising in that kind of surgery and with lots of machines and it was one of the machines that went wrong.

50:29.853 --> 50:40.846
[SPEAKER_00]: And the extremity of his reaction made me think of, well, he's never really had many things go wrong in his life, has he?

50:41.587 --> 50:59.809
[SPEAKER_00]: He's never had to deal with a situation that was fuzzy at the ages where you had to poke it and see and try something and see how that worked and then go onto the next step, which you had to invent from the first step, you know?

50:59.789 --> 51:18.186
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't, in any way, disdain the, that kind of expertise and knowledge, but if it isn't linked at all to the ability to improvise to think on your feet in a situation in the terms of that situation.

51:18.166 --> 51:24.959
[SPEAKER_00]: rather than bringing on another set of terms that worked in other situations that don't properly fit this one.

51:25.860 --> 51:28.606
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, then you haven't really got an expertise.

51:29.868 --> 51:31.251
[SPEAKER_00]: You've just got a bag of tricks.

51:31.671 --> 51:40.528
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you wonder though, in a society so built on specialization, you know, airplanes with automatic pilots and all, you know,

51:40.508 --> 51:49.686
[SPEAKER_01]: How does one, I forgot where I was taking a trip back from somewhere very far away and feeling a little older, I guess, than I used to.

51:49.746 --> 51:55.598
[SPEAKER_01]: And so all the people at the computers, you know, at the airport, they all look like children to me for some reason.

51:55.578 --> 51:59.543
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know how that sometimes happens because you get over 60, it's like everyone looks like a child.

51:59.883 --> 52:05.350
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm sure they were in their 20s, but I'm thinking, here's all these children operating these machines.

52:05.530 --> 52:11.177
[SPEAKER_01]: Each one knows how to operate what they're doing, but none of them understand the system.

52:11.238 --> 52:15.943
[SPEAKER_01]: When the computers go down, they're just completely stuck.

52:15.963 --> 52:19.628
[SPEAKER_01]: And I started to feel that way as a civilization, you know, yeah.

52:20.587 --> 52:22.450
[SPEAKER_01]: who can fix the elevators?

52:22.731 --> 52:27.940
[SPEAKER_01]: Who has any holistic sense of any of the things that we're using?

52:28.481 --> 52:29.823
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, this is absolutely right.

52:29.984 --> 52:39.741
[SPEAKER_00]: When I lived in New York, which was in the late 70s, early 80s, I remember in one week, two people died, they were very significant deaths.

52:40.422 --> 52:42.105
[SPEAKER_00]: The first one,

52:42.592 --> 52:46.896
[SPEAKER_00]: was the last man who understood the whole of the American tax system.

52:48.238 --> 52:50.340
[SPEAKER_00]: He died in 1979, I think.

52:50.780 --> 52:56.346
[SPEAKER_00]: He was the only person who still had a who'd kept up with it and had a grasp of the whole system.

52:56.906 --> 53:06.776
[SPEAKER_00]: After that, no single person understood, or indeed, of course, now even fewer people understand the whole of the tax system had worked.

53:07.137 --> 53:10.540
[SPEAKER_00]: So that was one person who died and the other

53:10.520 --> 53:19.973
[SPEAKER_00]: head of the translations department at the UN, who was apparently fluent in 56 languages or something like that.

53:20.071 --> 53:29.947
[SPEAKER_00]: extraordinary breadth of knowledge and language and he died and suddenly there was this huge hole in the translation service.

53:30.307 --> 53:34.894
[SPEAKER_00]: He was the one who could be addressed about a lot of difficult problems.

53:35.475 --> 53:43.648
[SPEAKER_00]: And so it occurred to me that this must always be happening that there are bits of human knowledge that we're losing.

53:43.628 --> 53:46.673
[SPEAKER_00]: because nobody can be a generalist anymore.

53:46.693 --> 53:49.017
[SPEAKER_00]: There's too much stuff to be a generalist about.

53:49.198 --> 53:58.614
[SPEAKER_01]: And under fascism, you know, even the fascism of the Renaissance kings, they wanted to wipe out that wholeism.

53:58.914 --> 54:08.050
[SPEAKER_01]: We do have memory holes, the way that a fascist or fascist style

54:08.030 --> 54:16.687
[SPEAKER_01]: clean out the competency of institutions is the, get rid of the people who know how the things work is real.

54:16.947 --> 54:24.722
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and as if, as if to pray, degrade the, the memory project of civilization.

54:24.702 --> 54:25.002
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

54:25.563 --> 54:27.905
[SPEAKER_00]: And in fact, that's exactly what I think it's for.

54:28.025 --> 54:29.106
[SPEAKER_00]: You want to clean slate.

54:29.647 --> 54:31.369
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't, you don't want memories.

54:31.409 --> 54:36.614
[SPEAKER_00]: The fascist wants to start again having designed it from the ground up sort of thing.

54:36.694 --> 54:37.855
[SPEAKER_00]: This is their theory, of course.

54:38.135 --> 54:38.756
[SPEAKER_00]: You never do it.

54:38.776 --> 54:45.963
[SPEAKER_01]: And the tech bro theory too, to new ideas, new adventure, my thing, you know, that there's no legacy in it.

54:46.904 --> 54:54.051
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the thing

54:56.917 --> 55:03.906
[SPEAKER_00]: It has an attraction that is deadly, and the attraction is this attraction of certainty.

55:04.606 --> 55:12.556
[SPEAKER_00]: The feeling that if we could only get rid of that and have these instead, everything would be fine.

55:13.117 --> 55:23.650
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, it never ever works, because humans are constantly changing and new possibilities are arising, not even necessarily with anyone intending them to.

55:23.630 --> 55:29.957
[SPEAKER_00]: That's just how we are, we are inquisitive creatures who keep making things.

55:30.017 --> 55:36.023
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, or even the most powerful disinfectant you can find for your kitchen or your bathroom look.

55:36.043 --> 55:39.587
[SPEAKER_01]: 99.9% of bacteria will be killed.

55:39.627 --> 55:47.495
[SPEAKER_01]: It means you've never got there, but that's, there's always going to be some unpredictable mess.

55:47.815 --> 55:50.498
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, that's the beauty of it.

55:50.478 --> 55:59.892
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and of course, what intelligent minds do is say, how do we make it so that it isn't a mess?

55:59.932 --> 56:01.114
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's part of things.

56:01.875 --> 56:04.599
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, let's stop trying to eradicate it.

56:04.659 --> 56:06.843
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's invite it in and make that part of.

56:07.404 --> 56:07.984
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

56:08.025 --> 56:13.633
[SPEAKER_01]: How do you build a bridge that can deal with the wobble rather than, yes, stand for him against it?

56:14.221 --> 56:36.668
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, or how do you create health not by constantly feeding people antibiotics, though I have to say antibiotics of saved my life twice, so I'm not anti antibiotic, but I am anti the thoughtless use of them, which just escalates everybody's resistance.

56:36.884 --> 56:37.365
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

56:37.425 --> 56:46.299
[SPEAKER_01]: How do we enhance a person's gut bioman and immune immune system rather than just kill everything that comes that comes close?

56:46.699 --> 56:52.528
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it's like in America, it's like you're on my property, you know, I've got the right to shoot you.

56:52.569 --> 56:56.715
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, well, maybe there's there's easier, easier ways.

56:56.695 --> 57:05.125
[SPEAKER_01]: It's interesting, you talked a lot about civilization as a shared imaginary, you know, and that sort of what art helps us do.

57:05.265 --> 57:08.055
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, fascism.

57:08.913 --> 57:11.877
[SPEAKER_01]: for all its problems is a shared imaginary, isn't it?

57:12.037 --> 57:21.551
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes, it is, but it's one done somehow one feels without very much experience.

57:21.991 --> 57:28.761
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like a sci-fi story that nobody ever wrote to the end of, because fascism,

57:31.002 --> 57:32.404
[SPEAKER_00]: is always temporary.

57:32.564 --> 57:33.906
[SPEAKER_00]: It always ends in flames.

57:34.747 --> 57:39.494
[SPEAKER_00]: And, of course, at some point, some people make a lot from it.

57:40.455 --> 57:43.599
[SPEAKER_00]: Sorry, there's some fireworks going on.

57:43.619 --> 57:44.440
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm just kidding.

57:45.181 --> 57:45.862
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you hear it?

57:46.283 --> 57:47.304
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but it's good.

57:48.065 --> 57:48.906
[SPEAKER_01]: No, we know what it is.

57:49.587 --> 57:51.150
[SPEAKER_01]: It's the right moment for the fireworks.

57:51.710 --> 57:55.896
[SPEAKER_01]: We're coming

57:55.876 --> 58:14.560
[SPEAKER_00]: I'll organize some more, the sense I have more and more is that fascism always evolves in the same context, out of the same context, which is the sense of threat coupled with the sense of powerlessness.

58:15.521 --> 58:21.529
[SPEAKER_00]: The third one is the sense of disengagement that intellectuals feel at times like that.

58:21.509 --> 58:40.279
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the state we're in right now, very much grows out of that feeling that was very common in America and particularly Silicon Valley from the sort of 80s, 70s, perhaps 2000s, which is hey, politics doesn't matter anymore.

58:40.920 --> 58:46.048
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it's tech, tech is the future, it's we don't have to think about.

58:46.028 --> 59:05.176
[SPEAKER_00]: all that boring stuff in committee rooms where people are making deals about laws and tax grades and so on, get rid of all the taxes, get rid of all the laws, and that sort of sunny anarchism which I know about because I was for a while a subscriber to it.

59:06.979 --> 59:12.407
[SPEAKER_00]: So I don't say this out of not understanding the attraction of it, but

59:14.294 --> 59:27.316
[SPEAKER_00]: I know for so long there were people saying we don't do politics and if you tried to raise a political conversation in that context it would be sort of, ah, do you have to talk about that?

59:28.037 --> 59:32.404
[SPEAKER_00]: Just like it's a bit dirty, like talking about laundry or something like that.

59:32.384 --> 59:39.856
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that left a huge gap, because there was still a government.

59:39.876 --> 59:44.804
[SPEAKER_00]: There were some people doing politics, but it wasn't any of the fucking bright ones.

59:45.645 --> 59:48.230
[SPEAKER_01]: And we didn't understand that what we were doing was political.

59:48.290 --> 59:50.313
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I was part of the rave movement.

59:50.473 --> 59:53.498
[SPEAKER_01]: And the early rave movement, we were taking...

59:53.663 --> 59:58.454
[SPEAKER_01]: parking lots and throwing parties that cost no money, not realizing what we're doing.

59:58.474 --> 59:59.817
[SPEAKER_01]: We were confiscating space.

59:59.857 --> 01:00:02.543
[SPEAKER_01]: We were, you know, breaking the economy.

01:00:02.623 --> 01:00:04.908
[SPEAKER_01]: We was, we didn't know.

01:00:05.049 --> 01:00:05.951
[SPEAKER_01]: The early internet.

01:00:05.991 --> 01:00:08.837
[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't realize what a, what a, what a, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh,

01:00:08.817 --> 01:00:25.143
[SPEAKER_01]: kind of anti-establishment, a narkic project it was to leave the mainstream media behind and decide that we were the story now, and because we were really decidedly apolitical, we lost the plot, you know, it became a libertarian, we got overrun.

01:00:25.203 --> 01:00:31.112
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, I used to say when I finally grew out of that period.

01:00:31.092 --> 01:00:37.343
[SPEAKER_00]: I used to say, well, you're lessing other people are fairing, because you know, there's this whole thing of lessing fair.

01:00:37.664 --> 01:00:40.549
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, it's great.

01:00:41.951 --> 01:00:52.189
[SPEAKER_00]: And, you know, the coupled that with the uncertainty of job loss unemployment

01:00:53.553 --> 01:01:02.855
[SPEAKER_00]: incredible concentration of wealth at the top and absolute stasis or worse for the rest of the world.

01:01:05.060 --> 01:01:07.005
[SPEAKER_00]: People started looking around and thinking.

01:01:08.437 --> 01:01:10.941
[SPEAKER_00]: you know what, it's not working in my favor this.

01:01:11.662 --> 01:01:14.126
[SPEAKER_00]: I was watching something actually on YouTube the other night.

01:01:14.166 --> 01:01:15.588
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to see a bit of dancing.

01:01:16.610 --> 01:01:20.817
[SPEAKER_00]: So I looked at an old sole train episode.

01:01:21.798 --> 01:01:22.780
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you remember sole train?

01:01:22.980 --> 01:01:23.561
[SPEAKER_00]: I loved it.

01:01:23.601 --> 01:01:24.402
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

01:01:24.422 --> 01:01:27.627
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, it was so moving to see that again.

01:01:27.687 --> 01:01:29.771
[SPEAKER_00]: It was it was heartbreaking actually.

01:01:29.791 --> 01:01:33.837
[SPEAKER_00]: I was in tears seeing this fantastic dancing.

01:01:33.817 --> 01:01:40.483
[SPEAKER_00]: and knowing that you can only dance like that if you think the future is get it is going to be better than now.

01:01:41.744 --> 01:01:42.845
[SPEAKER_00]: The graph is going up.

01:01:42.925 --> 01:01:57.577
[SPEAKER_00]: It was a sort of there was a joy in it and an abandoned and a lack of defensiveness, a surrender actually, if you like, and you realized these people lived in a different world from what we do.

01:01:58.658 --> 01:02:01.160
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think you could dance like that now.

01:02:01.580 --> 01:02:03.722
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, and the

01:02:04.293 --> 01:02:06.156
[SPEAKER_01]: The world was getting better.

01:02:06.196 --> 01:02:14.290
[SPEAKER_01]: They saw tomorrow is better than today, but it wasn't the way it is today with such a kind of a defined T-Lose.

01:02:14.551 --> 01:02:21.863
[SPEAKER_01]: I look at whether it's the left or the right in this case, and they've got almost a messianic.

01:02:21.843 --> 01:02:22.925
[SPEAKER_01]: vision of the future.

01:02:22.945 --> 01:02:25.209
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, in America, it's explicitly Messianic.

01:02:25.230 --> 01:02:30.520
[SPEAKER_01]: They're telling the troops, you know, go to war, fight Iran, so that Christ will come.

01:02:30.540 --> 01:02:37.433
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and this, there's this end justifies the means, uh, uh, understanding.

01:02:37.493 --> 01:02:39.337
[SPEAKER_01]: You, you talk about it in the book too.

01:02:39.878 --> 01:02:42.062
[SPEAKER_01]: You, you say,

01:02:42.042 --> 01:02:57.340
[SPEAKER_01]: reimagine the human project as being about means rather than ends, about making a mindset and a sense of sensible procedures, rather than designing an ultimate heaven on earth, we will get better results.

01:02:57.400 --> 01:03:11.577
[SPEAKER_01]: We need new means, not old ends, or as I put it in at the end of throwing rocks at the Google Bus, but activism, I said, if you're not doing it in the moment,

01:03:11.557 --> 01:03:12.599
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

01:03:13.059 --> 01:03:13.801
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely right.

01:03:15.343 --> 01:03:20.792
[SPEAKER_00]: I was talking to somebody that I do who said, I've got this job.

01:03:20.832 --> 01:03:22.454
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a very powerful job.

01:03:23.075 --> 01:03:30.547
[SPEAKER_00]: But I'm holding my fire until I'm ready to do something to change the world in some way.

01:03:31.429 --> 01:03:34.273
[SPEAKER_00]: And I said, do you will hold your fire forever?

01:03:35.249 --> 01:03:45.566
[SPEAKER_00]: because people who have that frame of mind, it's never the right moment to risk everything and put all your money on one square on the roulette table.

01:03:46.628 --> 01:03:47.429
[SPEAKER_00]: You just don't do it.

01:03:48.290 --> 01:03:52.257
[SPEAKER_00]: And there are many people who die in disappointment because they never jumped.

01:03:53.038 --> 01:03:54.300
[SPEAKER_00]: They never took the leap.

01:03:55.803 --> 01:04:02.033
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a leap of faith, you know, another thing that H-A-Tamalkarand says is that,

01:04:02.013 --> 01:04:03.094
[SPEAKER_00]: Forget about hope.

01:04:03.775 --> 01:04:06.678
[SPEAKER_00]: Faith is what matters and she doesn't mean religious faith.

01:04:07.199 --> 01:04:13.646
[SPEAKER_00]: She means the sense that there is going to be a better future and to act as though that is the case.

01:04:14.908 --> 01:04:15.568
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the thing.

01:04:16.009 --> 01:04:16.289
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

01:04:16.449 --> 01:04:18.091
[SPEAKER_01]: Hope is speculative.

01:04:18.352 --> 01:04:24.499
[SPEAKER_01]: Hope is speculative and once you're speculative, you're betting on something and then you're looking for probable outcomes.

01:04:25.079 --> 01:04:27.582
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, we're faith.

01:04:27.562 --> 01:04:29.385
[SPEAKER_01]: You don't need your probable outcome.

01:04:29.525 --> 01:04:33.991
[SPEAKER_01]: Faith, you're going to take your surrender to the great thing that's happening.

01:04:34.332 --> 01:04:38.738
[SPEAKER_00]: Yep, you take whatever comes and you know you'll be able to make something from it.

01:04:39.038 --> 01:04:39.539
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

01:04:39.559 --> 01:04:42.583
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so it's interesting.

01:04:42.643 --> 01:04:49.333
[SPEAKER_00]: When she said that, I started thinking, okay, maybe I start to understand faith now.

01:04:49.313 --> 01:04:54.418
[SPEAKER_00]: because when I say I'm an atheist, it's not because I dislike religion actually.

01:04:56.560 --> 01:05:00.624
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, I find that I get on very well with religious people.

01:05:00.744 --> 01:05:07.010
[SPEAKER_00]: I like the fact that they have a different bottom line from everybody else.

01:05:07.471 --> 01:05:09.233
[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, they don't really have a bottom line.

01:05:09.613 --> 01:05:14.798
[SPEAKER_00]: They don't translate into those, they don't translate things into those kinds of values.

01:05:14.778 --> 01:05:21.589
[SPEAKER_00]: So, I've becoming, I've found that I don't believe in God, but I do believe in religion.

01:05:22.510 --> 01:05:26.736
[SPEAKER_00]: I think religious activity is actually very good for people.

01:05:27.397 --> 01:05:31.083
[SPEAKER_00]: And then I started thinking, well, do I do that then?

01:05:32.005 --> 01:05:40.077
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think I do, I think, when I'm working, I'm sort of going through a ritual of some kind.

01:05:40.057 --> 01:05:48.177
[SPEAKER_00]: at the end of which I have made something, but what is actually happening while I'm in that process.

01:05:49.743 --> 01:05:51.906
[SPEAKER_00]: is so mysterious to me, really.

01:05:52.827 --> 01:06:02.761
[SPEAKER_00]: I just start doing it and a few hours later, which sometimes feels like just a few minutes later, I have something new that never existed before.

01:06:03.662 --> 01:06:17.961
[SPEAKER_00]: That's such a thrill that I want to do it every day, but I have to go to a lot of meetings instead,

01:06:17.941 --> 01:06:19.083
[SPEAKER_01]: But it is that faith.

01:06:19.103 --> 01:06:19.383
[SPEAKER_01]: It's funny.

01:06:19.423 --> 01:06:32.424
[SPEAKER_01]: I was thinking back, once we booked this interview, I thought back to sophomore year of college when my friends and I made a party that we called the fourth world.

01:06:32.865 --> 01:06:37.232
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was, we had gotten access to this big house.

01:06:37.313 --> 01:06:41.298
[SPEAKER_01]: uh in in our college town and we could do anything we wanted with it.

01:06:41.878 --> 01:06:46.243
[SPEAKER_01]: So we made each room into a different ambient.

01:06:46.984 --> 01:06:52.971
[SPEAKER_01]: We played the different ambient record in each room and then just improvise what that one meant to us.

01:06:53.031 --> 01:07:05.245
[SPEAKER_01]: Like day of radiance was crayons in this and the other one was for, you know, each one had a whole different thing and people would go, most of them were

01:07:05.630 --> 01:07:12.467
[SPEAKER_01]: And we just had faith that it would unfold, and it's interesting, because I

01:07:13.358 --> 01:07:29.319
[SPEAKER_01]: I love what you did, but for some reason you as pop star person genius behind it was so back I wasn't thinking of you as the human making it.

01:07:29.500 --> 01:07:34.667
[SPEAKER_01]: If anything, it was your concept of it's not the genius, it's the genius.

01:07:34.987 --> 01:07:38.792
[SPEAKER_01]: This is a world, this is a way, this is a process.

01:07:38.772 --> 01:07:53.297
[SPEAKER_01]: that's going to, and it changed how I did theater, it changed because I started to understand the ground rather than the figure, the environment, I mean, that's how I got into McCluin and media environments rather than media, right, because it's the ambience that the media creates.

01:07:53.317 --> 01:08:04.155
[SPEAKER_01]: So it, it set me on a path and I had faith, faith that I now understood how I want

01:08:04.979 --> 01:08:30.295
[SPEAKER_01]: And Lynch did that too, you know, David Lynch's work, did that as well, but then to get to the other end, and when I got the new book, I'll show it later, I got the new book and I go through the whole thing and I get an hour because it can move that fast the first time, and then I'm looking the acknowledgment at the end and see,

01:08:30.275 --> 01:08:43.845
[SPEAKER_01]: You know Douglass Rushcoff team human is in Brian Eno's book as an influence is is it's for me it's not the ego of oh look he it's more

01:08:44.247 --> 01:09:01.589
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm in your sceneous, I'm in your extended sceneous, and that's all any of us, that's all any of us want, is to be in the sceneous with people who respect and admire and are influenced by it to know that it's not just a one-way thing, but that we're influencing each other.

01:09:01.709 --> 01:09:07.816
[SPEAKER_01]: Even if I'm never in a big movie, I know that I've informed the work that I care about.

01:09:08.197 --> 01:09:13.984
[SPEAKER_01]: So it becomes respiratory circulatory,

01:09:13.964 --> 01:09:15.162
[SPEAKER_01]: Uh, together.

01:09:15.608 --> 01:09:16.887
[SPEAKER_00]: You know that's funny because

01:09:20.714 --> 01:09:30.364
[SPEAKER_00]: I hardly ever read reviews, immediately after I've released something, because I noticed that I only pay attention to the bad ones.

01:09:31.826 --> 01:09:41.696
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm very susceptible to the bad reviews, and then they might be only 2% of all the reviews, but those are the ones that stick in my mind.

01:09:42.597 --> 01:09:46.401
[SPEAKER_00]: But then I think about it, and I think, well, who'd...

01:09:46.381 --> 01:09:47.142
[SPEAKER_00]: Why is that?

01:09:47.202 --> 01:09:49.345
[SPEAKER_00]: Why do I care that much?

01:09:50.567 --> 01:09:57.416
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's because when you make something new, just like when you have a little baby, you want everybody to love it.

01:09:57.977 --> 01:10:04.365
[SPEAKER_00]: You want it to be to enter the world and to be looked after and cherished and paid attention to.

01:10:05.207 --> 01:10:05.487
[SPEAKER_00]: And

01:10:07.087 --> 01:10:24.403
[SPEAKER_00]: It's otherwise, it's a little bit like you know, you're out with the push chair walking the new baby for the first time and somebody leans in and says bloody hell he's got a big nose something to that effect and you feel oh is that all you've noticed.

01:10:25.750 --> 01:10:39.203
[SPEAKER_00]: I much more moved by the fact that four or five people who are significant to me like something that I've done than that 200,000 people bought the record or however many it was.

01:10:39.704 --> 01:10:43.207
[SPEAKER_00]: Of course, I'm incredibly grateful to the people who buy the records.

01:10:43.928 --> 01:10:47.011
[SPEAKER_00]: I wouldn't be alive without them, but I don't know who they are.

01:10:47.492 --> 01:10:52.737
[SPEAKER_00]: So their opinion doesn't really make much impression on me, but when somebody who

01:10:52.717 --> 01:10:57.525
[SPEAKER_00]: Who's who I respect like, so I think, oh, good.

01:10:57.585 --> 01:11:00.330
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, maybe I maybe I am on to something there.

01:11:01.672 --> 01:11:08.002
[SPEAKER_00]: I wrote, I had been reading Stafford Beer's work for a few years, the Cybernetician Stafford Beer.

01:11:09.164 --> 01:11:10.827
[SPEAKER_00]: And

01:11:10.807 --> 01:11:22.482
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, I finally wrote to him because I had quoted quite a big chunk from him in something I'd written and it was a dude to be published, so I want to just clear it.

01:11:23.483 --> 01:11:31.073
[SPEAKER_00]: And I, I, I ended letter by saying, um, I'm sorry, you might not have time to reply to this.

01:11:31.173 --> 01:11:37.101
[SPEAKER_00]: And I just be grateful if you say yes or no and blah, blah, blah, blah, and he said,

01:11:39.123 --> 01:11:46.793
[SPEAKER_00]: His latter back to me, opened with the words, would the 10% of the male I received, were 10% as interesting.

01:11:47.795 --> 01:11:52.521
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was, I was high on that for about a month.

01:11:54.484 --> 01:12:07.662
[SPEAKER_01]: It's funny, particularly with social media and influencer culture and the way our media works now, so many young people are striving for this sort of personal fame.

01:12:07.642 --> 01:12:27.709
[SPEAKER_01]: Everyone wants to be famous and get the followers and the thing and I can say this as an old person now, who's experienced something is the the joy of seniors, which would be of being in a scene with people with collaborators is so many more times.

01:12:27.689 --> 01:12:36.061
[SPEAKER_01]: fulfilling and generative and satisfying that the thing that you will be thinking about on your deathbed is not the fame.

01:12:36.141 --> 01:12:55.789
[SPEAKER_00]: It is the seniorist, the puddle of creatives that you that you were with and the companionship of it and the beauty of dropping your stone into the pool and seeing it

01:12:55.769 --> 01:13:06.359
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's important, I think, for people to get, and this is, you know, on the back cover of Team Human, I put fine to the others, you know, the Timothy Leary quote, I've quoted that so many times.

01:13:07.101 --> 01:13:10.791
[SPEAKER_00]: Now that's, that's so important to me that phrase, find the others.

01:13:10.771 --> 01:13:15.657
[SPEAKER_01]: But that's what our listeners are asking for the most.

01:13:16.057 --> 01:13:18.160
[SPEAKER_01]: How do I find the others?

01:13:18.240 --> 01:13:24.547
[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't think it's necessarily by creating, me creating team, human, meetups around the world.

01:13:24.847 --> 01:13:27.550
[SPEAKER_01]: It's more people finding the others.

01:13:27.610 --> 01:13:33.017
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not necessarily even writing to this some musician far away that they know and it mayer.

01:13:33.357 --> 01:13:40.305
[SPEAKER_01]: But how have you seen, seeinguses emerge?

01:13:41.365 --> 01:13:49.799
[SPEAKER_01]: How would we suggest people, even wherever they are in Cincinnati and Athens, Georgia, find that possy?

01:13:50.520 --> 01:14:01.618
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, one thing that people have occasionally said to me was, oh, it's okay for you, your famous and you've got some money and everybody knows who you are, so it's easy for you to.

01:14:01.598 --> 01:14:03.001
[SPEAKER_00]: do things to get things done.

01:14:03.702 --> 01:14:21.700
[SPEAKER_00]: And of course, that's partly true, but I think it starts by finding who is anybody who's doing something that you admire or that you would support and just trying to help them, just thinking, what could I do for that person that would help them along?

01:14:21.680 --> 01:14:29.830
[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't have to be very much, but just start, you just start, and if you start doing it, other things will be attracted.

01:14:30.351 --> 01:14:37.900
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a world full of people who want a need help, companionship, a company in England through whatever journey they're on.

01:14:38.541 --> 01:14:47.873
[SPEAKER_00]: And you can do that, you know, I was talking to a group in the studio, the other night and said,

01:14:47.853 --> 01:14:52.742
[SPEAKER_00]: They said, you know, we're sort of beginning our career and how do you deal?

01:14:52.782 --> 01:14:55.748
[SPEAKER_00]: How can I help with all this stuff that's going on?

01:14:56.590 --> 01:14:58.794
[SPEAKER_00]: And I said, you don't have to think that out.

01:14:59.716 --> 01:15:04.865
[SPEAKER_00]: Find somebody who you think is doing something like the right thing and volunteer.

01:15:05.627 --> 01:15:06.929
[SPEAKER_00]: Just say, what can I do?

01:15:06.949 --> 01:15:09.494
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you need a space to stay in?

01:15:09.514 --> 01:15:10.536
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you need a space to stay in?

01:15:10.516 --> 01:15:15.167
[SPEAKER_00]: room to stay in when you're in London because you live in Edinburgh or something like that.

01:15:15.769 --> 01:15:17.473
[SPEAKER_00]: Can I help you write something?

01:15:18.315 --> 01:15:19.037
[SPEAKER_00]: What do you need?

01:15:19.678 --> 01:15:21.322
[SPEAKER_00]: And see what you can give them.

01:15:21.863 --> 01:15:28.339
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a little bit like the Oracle of just fighting a random object and saying, somehow this is going to be the answer.

01:15:28.319 --> 01:15:29.743
[SPEAKER_00]: do that in your life.

01:15:30.344 --> 01:15:33.733
[SPEAKER_00]: Just say, somehow this is going to be the answer and try to make it the answer.

01:15:34.415 --> 01:15:44.843
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, I would just think I would just a woman, I know in slightly upstate New York, who's calling authors, who's workshe likes, but they're not huge authors.

01:15:45.380 --> 01:15:49.145
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you want an audience of 200 people to hear you and maybe buy your book?

01:15:49.987 --> 01:15:52.250
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not rocket science, you know?

01:15:52.751 --> 01:16:06.190
[SPEAKER_01]: Think about what you have, what you can offer, the people, is there a church, is there a gymnasium, and it's like, it and it begins and you'll be surprised by how fast, how fast it clusters around you.

01:16:07.071 --> 01:16:10.997
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm living proof that it yields results.

01:16:11.057 --> 01:16:14.762
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sitting here talking with Brian, you know, on team human.

01:16:14.742 --> 01:16:22.889
[SPEAKER_00]: So there goes to show what trouble you could get into if you listen to the wrong records.

01:16:25.752 --> 01:16:35.581
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly, and now talk about it and now it's ourselves as anti-fascists at the wrong the exact moron moment in history.

01:16:36.122 --> 01:16:38.023
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my gosh, but it'll be fun.

01:16:38.263 --> 01:16:38.804
[SPEAKER_01]: It'll be fun.

01:16:39.044 --> 01:16:42.167
[SPEAKER_01]: I'll share a cell with you.

01:16:42.147 --> 01:16:43.569
[SPEAKER_01]: Find things to do.

01:16:44.390 --> 01:16:44.891
[SPEAKER_01]: Make up great.

01:16:44.931 --> 01:16:46.794
[SPEAKER_01]: It'll be that sort of that waiting for a good dough.

01:16:47.675 --> 01:16:48.115
[SPEAKER_01]: Brilliant.

01:16:48.176 --> 01:16:49.658
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll come out of us in this out.

01:16:52.181 --> 01:16:56.147
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they might by of course have cut our tongues out by that point.

01:16:56.207 --> 01:16:58.390
[SPEAKER_01]: So we'll knock on the floor.

01:16:58.490 --> 01:16:59.572
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll find ways.

01:16:59.632 --> 01:17:00.433
[SPEAKER_01]: Minimalism.

01:17:00.874 --> 01:17:06.782
[SPEAKER_01]: There's always it's the restrictions and the obstacles that create the great work as we're going to be tested.

01:17:07.102 --> 01:17:09.606
[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to be tested on that.

01:17:09.586 --> 01:17:11.489
[SPEAKER_01]: on all those John Cage assumptions.

01:17:11.850 --> 01:17:14.375
[SPEAKER_01]: They're a little bit different when they're organically enforced.

01:17:15.156 --> 01:17:15.577
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, my God.

01:17:15.657 --> 01:17:17.420
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly, yeah.

01:17:17.440 --> 01:17:17.981
[SPEAKER_00]: Silence.

01:17:18.001 --> 01:17:19.905
[SPEAKER_01]: But, thank you, sir.

01:17:19.925 --> 01:17:20.385
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.

01:17:20.406 --> 01:17:20.566
[SPEAKER_01]: Silence.

01:17:20.586 --> 01:17:21.267
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.

01:17:21.407 --> 01:17:25.114
[SPEAKER_00]: Total silence for 22 years.

01:17:25.094 --> 01:17:43.660
[SPEAKER_01]: at least we're laughing about it from this side, but thank you for everything, all you've done, the music, of course, the collaborations, the modeling and the writing, the movie, which we didn't even talk about.

01:17:43.640 --> 01:17:56.013
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, which everyone, if comes up online occasionally, you can get a live stream, keep aware, you know, for when you, everyone should see that, um, but also everyone should buy what is art for for themselves for anyone.

01:17:56.033 --> 01:17:59.944
[SPEAKER_01]: I would say middle school or above can appreciate it.

01:17:59.924 --> 01:18:05.372
[SPEAKER_01]: and grad school or above can really appreciate it.

01:18:06.273 --> 01:18:07.215
[SPEAKER_01]: So please get that.

01:18:07.255 --> 01:18:07.936
[SPEAKER_01]: What is art for?

01:18:08.697 --> 01:18:11.241
[SPEAKER_01]: With collaborator Betta Andrianse.

01:18:11.341 --> 01:18:13.604
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a beautiful volume.

01:18:13.624 --> 01:18:19.553
[SPEAKER_01]: It's the size that I wanted team human to be, but they wouldn't make it that small, because they were afraid they couldn't get the price point.

01:18:19.533 --> 01:18:38.942
[SPEAKER_00]: but it's exactly right back pocket on the subway on it's it's it's uh this is the size book should be that was exactly the criteria it's got to be able to fit comfortably into pocket so that you could just carry it around and not make a big deal about it pull it out subway quickly read a bit.

01:18:38.922 --> 01:18:39.743
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.

01:18:39.763 --> 01:18:46.091
[SPEAKER_01]: You want it to be in the teenagers pocket like catcher in the rye was, or, or, or, or, or, or heaven has said, though.

01:18:46.332 --> 01:18:47.133
[SPEAKER_01]: It's one of those.

01:18:47.193 --> 01:18:48.414
[SPEAKER_01]: It really is one of those books.

01:18:48.454 --> 01:18:54.643
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't wait for the paper back when it can, can fold, you know, been more easily.

01:18:55.383 --> 01:18:55.484
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:18:55.504 --> 01:18:56.004
[SPEAKER_01]: But great.

01:18:56.185 --> 01:18:57.146
[SPEAKER_01]: But thanks so much.

01:18:57.206 --> 01:19:01.612
[SPEAKER_01]: I know we, we, you've got work to do and play to do.

01:19:01.992 --> 01:19:03.674
[SPEAKER_01]: So I'll leave you, I'll leave you to that.

01:19:03.694 --> 01:19:05.757
[SPEAKER_01]: Next time I'm in England, I will come.

01:19:05.737 --> 01:19:06.358
[SPEAKER_01]: find you.

01:19:06.378 --> 01:19:15.978
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm glad we did this without any jet fuel and still have all the the beauty of a film and studio and next time I have a hug there.

01:19:16.779 --> 01:19:23.693
[SPEAKER_00]: Good, that's lovely to meet you again online and I look forward to meeting in real life soon.

01:19:23.713 --> 01:19:24.615
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, me too.

01:19:25.477 --> 01:19:26.158
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.

01:19:26.341 --> 01:19:31.489
[SPEAKER_01]: Let me say goodbye to everybody, so you've all been on your, you've been on team human.

01:19:32.110 --> 01:19:34.854
[SPEAKER_01]: With Brian Eno, get the book, what is art for?

01:19:35.755 --> 01:19:40.802
[SPEAKER_01]: Go to teamhuman.fm and click on support or patreon.com slash team human.

01:19:41.063 --> 01:19:45.730
[SPEAKER_01]: Support us, click like, heart, do any of those kind of things, but support us.

01:19:46.150 --> 01:19:53.361
[SPEAKER_01]: If you got a thing, a product, a service or whatever you're looking for a place to do like advertising, we could do that too.

01:19:54.455 --> 01:19:58.423
[SPEAKER_01]: All things are welcome, all people are welcome, all ideas are welcome.

01:19:58.443 --> 01:20:04.154
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's play, let's do art, and let's begin a new song here.

01:20:04.815 --> 01:20:05.376
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Take Care.

01:20:05.416 --> 01:20:09.865
[SPEAKER_01]: You've been on team, human, our last best hope for Peeps.

