WEBVTT

00:05.887 --> 00:08.289
[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to that said, I am Michael Zelden.

00:08.970 --> 00:14.514
[SPEAKER_00]: On today's show, we'll be speaking with David Margulic about his new book when Caesar was king.

00:15.215 --> 00:29.967
[SPEAKER_00]: How Sid Caesar reinvented American comedy, which chronicles the life and times of Sid Caesar, who essentially invented sketch comedy for television with his shows, your show of shows, and the Caesar's hour in the 1950s.

00:31.168 --> 00:35.792
[SPEAKER_00]: As Melbrook said, without Sid Caesar,

00:36.295 --> 00:43.765
[SPEAKER_00]: David Margallick is a longtime contributing editor at Vanity Fair, where he writes about culture, media, and politics.

00:44.346 --> 00:52.056
[SPEAKER_00]: He served as the National Legal Affairs Editor at the New York Times, where he wrote the Weekly At the Bar column for seven years.

00:52.636 --> 00:53.798
[SPEAKER_00]: He lives in New York City.

00:54.419 --> 00:55.740
[SPEAKER_00]: David Margallick?

00:55.760 --> 00:56.622
[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to that said.

00:57.082 --> 00:57.903
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, Michael.

00:58.043 --> 00:59.265
[SPEAKER_01]: It's nice to be with you.

00:59.735 --> 01:12.951
[SPEAKER_00]: This book, when Caesar was King, how Sid's Caesar reinvented American comedy is just a wonderful book and I'm looking very much forward to talking about it with you, but before we do, can you tell us a little bit about yourself.

01:13.927 --> 01:25.761
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I've been a journalist and writer for the past 40 something years, most of that was spent as a newspaper and magazine writer.

01:25.782 --> 01:34.552
[SPEAKER_01]: I went to law school and sort of was that was my area of expertise.

01:34.652 --> 01:43.343
[SPEAKER_01]: So I went into legal journalism out of law school, worked for a couple of legal publications,

01:43.323 --> 01:53.519
[SPEAKER_01]: Then went to cover law for the New York Times for 15 years and branched out from there in divinity fair where I wrote for another 15 years.

01:54.200 --> 02:00.529
[SPEAKER_01]: And since then, I've been spending most of my time working on books, working on longer projects.

02:00.589 --> 02:10.024
[SPEAKER_01]: I've gotten more of her boasts or loquacious or something over the years, which is not an unusual evolution for a writer.

02:10.645 --> 02:11.406
[SPEAKER_01]: You know,

02:12.668 --> 02:26.017
[SPEAKER_01]: paint on, and you want your stuff to last a bit longer, and it's more likely to, if it's more substantial and more original and you have an easier chance to do that with a larger canvas.

02:26.638 --> 02:31.048
[SPEAKER_01]: So I've been spending most of my time in the last several years writing books.

02:31.923 --> 02:46.978
[SPEAKER_00]: I want to come back to that theme a little bit later on because it reminds me of Mel Brooks telling Sid Seaser don't do television do movies at last longer yeah longer format the exact same point that you're making yeah.

02:47.077 --> 02:47.457
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

02:47.518 --> 02:48.018
[SPEAKER_01]: That's right.

02:48.439 --> 02:51.001
[SPEAKER_01]: And also a more permanent format.

02:51.022 --> 02:56.528
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, newspapers are famously, you know, pooper scoopers or wrapping fish.

02:56.628 --> 03:02.715
[SPEAKER_01]: Then, you know, that, that very day and books theoretically at least have a longer shelf life.

03:03.396 --> 03:09.923
[SPEAKER_01]: So we're all looking for a form of immortality, you know, and books seem to be a more reliable way to find it.

03:10.804 --> 03:15.970
[SPEAKER_01]: And more something,

03:16.287 --> 03:30.160
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and as we'll discuss, that was the case with movies versus television in Sincers case, which is perhaps an explanation for why he vanished from our collective memory, but that's a topic that we'll get to in a few minutes.

03:30.361 --> 03:32.085
[SPEAKER_00]: Why did you write this book?

03:33.533 --> 03:40.982
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I was asked to write about a historic figure for a Jewish biographical series.

03:42.144 --> 03:47.370
[SPEAKER_01]: And I had written a lot of Jewish, even though it wasn't part of my beat.

03:47.490 --> 03:52.196
[SPEAKER_01]: I had written a lot of Jewish theme stories over the years.

03:52.216 --> 03:54.479
[SPEAKER_01]: I gravitated naturally to that.

03:54.519 --> 03:59.625
[SPEAKER_01]: It was an area of great interest in passion and emotion for me.

03:59.605 --> 04:29.612
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, an awful lot of Jewish history is not very pleasant, and I thought that here was a chance to write about something Jewish that would make me laugh, something more light-hearted, so that I should pick a comic rather than, you know, write about just this brand ice or, or, or, or, you know, or, um, some other figure, and it turns out that

04:29.592 --> 04:34.720
[SPEAKER_01]: because the editor of the series was there at something I attended.

04:35.561 --> 04:40.889
[SPEAKER_01]: I originally thought about Groucho Marx, but somebody else had already taken him for this series.

04:41.651 --> 04:43.774
[SPEAKER_01]: And Sid Seasor was just out there.

04:43.834 --> 04:48.241
[SPEAKER_01]: Somebody who was famous for being famous in a way.

04:48.261 --> 04:50.925
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, everybody knew who he was.

04:50.905 --> 04:58.158
[SPEAKER_01]: And people talked about his enormous contribution to comedy, but he'd become a remote figure.

04:58.219 --> 05:07.716
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that no one had ever properly summarized his life or described exactly how enormous his impact had been.

05:07.696 --> 05:13.521
[SPEAKER_01]: And I just thought it was a fitting subject for a biography.

05:13.781 --> 05:18.905
[SPEAKER_01]: I had also been to a testimonial dinner for him a few years earlier.

05:19.406 --> 05:21.608
[SPEAKER_01]: Mel Brooks was the speaker that night.

05:22.428 --> 05:37.281
[SPEAKER_01]: And he was clearly worshiped by people like Brooks, and the whole evening was a celebration of him, Carl Reiner and Larry Gilbard, both of whom had been associated with

05:37.261 --> 06:02.847
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I had some familiarity with him even though I didn't know his story, and he was kind of a wreck of a man that night, the night that he was honored, and spoke almost non-sensically, didn't he really, he was really hard to understand until he lapsed into his familiar double talk, you know, speaking gibberish.

06:02.827 --> 06:26.792
[SPEAKER_01]: in French and Italian in German, and that sort of thing for which he was famous, and I walked away scratching my head from from that occasion, wondering what what the fuss was about him and how this man had been so influential, and then how he'd come to his present sort of precarious state the night that I saw him.

06:26.772 --> 06:46.157
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I could see that there was a great double-prong story here about the rise of somebody who shaped early television profoundly, and then fell precipitously, and so there were two elements to classic elements of a great story.

06:47.118 --> 06:54.568
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, and there was also the the the

06:54.734 --> 07:01.726
[SPEAKER_01]: as somebody once said to me, it doesn't matter what the topic of your book is, you write the book that's in you.

07:01.766 --> 07:19.257
[SPEAKER_01]: And Sid Seaser was as good a vehicle as any for writing about the status of Jews in post-war America and New York City after World War II and Jewish humor, and there were all kinds of themes

07:19.237 --> 07:27.849
[SPEAKER_01]: Jews after the Holocaust, all of this stuff could be wrapped around and stuffed into a story about Sid Caesar.

07:27.909 --> 07:31.514
[SPEAKER_01]: And I could take it in any direction that I wanted.

07:32.035 --> 07:33.537
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was what I wanted to do.

07:33.617 --> 07:36.000
[SPEAKER_01]: And it enabled me to do all of those things.

07:36.481 --> 07:39.024
[SPEAKER_01]: So it turned out to have been a very wise choice.

07:39.104 --> 07:44.552
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I stumbled into it in a way, but it worked out very nicely, at least for me.

07:44.971 --> 07:54.483
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's a great book, and as a person who grew up with Sid Caesar, his son and I went to Hebrew school together.

07:54.523 --> 07:55.644
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, right.

07:56.285 --> 08:07.259
[SPEAKER_00]: I was so happy to see a book about him and that praised him in the way that you did you write of him and it reminds me of what you just said about the testimonial.

08:07.539 --> 08:14.067
[SPEAKER_00]: You said in essence that as a performer, he was a genius as a human being, he was clueless.

08:14.468 --> 08:17.291
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, after human being, he was also a cipher.

08:17.371 --> 08:24.098
[SPEAKER_01]: He's just an enormous challenge for a writer, a historian, I don't call myself a historian, really.

08:24.158 --> 08:38.533
[SPEAKER_01]: I think of myself as a journalist, rather than a historian, or a scholar, but Sid Seaser was a formidable challenge because he was enigmatic, even to the people who worked with him, even to the people who knew him well.

08:39.094 --> 08:42.838
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, there's a story in one of his interviews, Carl Reiner,

08:42.818 --> 08:57.621
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, who's an absolutely crucial part of the Sit Caesar story said that he and, you know, he, he and the, and the various writers and co-stars with Caesar during his influential decade in the 1960s.

08:58.362 --> 09:07.476
[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes when he wasn't around, they would, they would just sit talking with one another and ponder who this mysterious guy was.

09:07.456 --> 09:13.024
[SPEAKER_01]: and what made him tick, even the people who worked very closely with him didn't really get him.

09:13.906 --> 09:24.381
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, there's a quote from Larry Gelbart, the great Larry Gelbart in the book, who was one of Caesar's writers later on saying, you know, as a personality, he was nothing.

09:24.722 --> 09:29.989
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's really a challenge for a biographer to write about somebody, you know, who's nothing.

09:30.029 --> 09:34.476
[SPEAKER_01]: That actually, Mel Brooks's first wife said the same thing to me.

09:34.456 --> 09:51.312
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, she said, why aren't you writing about Mel, you know, and of course she had stories to tell about Mel, but that wasn't my book, although there's a lot of Mel Brooks in my book because, you know, Mel sort of takes over any story that he's in.

09:51.393 --> 09:52.674
[SPEAKER_01]: He's sort of like Kudzu.

09:52.694 --> 09:57.358
[SPEAKER_01]: He takes over for whatever other growth is around and strangles it.

09:57.799 --> 10:02.083
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's a lot

10:02.063 --> 10:04.831
[SPEAKER_01]: discovered Mel Brooks and made Mel Brooks.

10:05.754 --> 10:14.942
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's not a coincidence in a way that Mel Brooks has really the first word and the almost the last word in my book on Sid Seaser.

10:15.412 --> 10:16.053
[SPEAKER_00]: It's interesting.

10:16.093 --> 10:35.610
[SPEAKER_00]: You mentioned Carl Reiner saying something about Sid Cesar, and he has a quote, you have a quote in your book, which says, I never heard Caesar tell a joke, and the only character that Caesar couldn't play was himself for a simple reason.

10:36.051 --> 10:38.736
[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't know who Sid Cesar was.

10:38.716 --> 10:53.755
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and you could see this very graphically at the beginning of every episode of your show of shows when Sid came out to introduce the guest host to say good evening, everyone, and introduce the guest host.

10:53.895 --> 10:56.178
[SPEAKER_01]: And he always stumbled over those lines.

10:56.298 --> 10:59.182
[SPEAKER_01]: It was very difficult for him to get through them.

10:59.783 --> 11:02.226
[SPEAKER_01]: Eventually, they got huge downs.

11:02.206 --> 11:32.061
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, to spare Caesar from that shore, and if you watch, you know, the, the, the, the episode, if you watch your show of shows, and I watched almost every episode, um, you, you see the ritual, the, the, the torture that Sid went through at the beginning of every program, and then after he would manage to get through that, which took him only a minute or so, he would run off the stage, and I say in the book that he ran off the stage for two reasons,

11:32.041 --> 11:39.612
[SPEAKER_01]: One was that the sketch was starting, I mean, the show was done live and he had to run and get into costume and get ready to perform.

11:39.672 --> 11:51.349
[SPEAKER_01]: But the other is that he could run away from himself and run into a character, which was really very found himself and other people in other characters and the characters that he was playing.

11:51.953 --> 12:04.866
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so the book starts with three epigraphs and I'd like you to read them because they I think are telling about Why this book is so important and who said Caesar was and wasn't

12:05.420 --> 12:13.094
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I'm glad that you're giving me this chance, Michael, because I'm very proud of the epigraphs in this book.

12:13.675 --> 12:19.106
[SPEAKER_01]: And I kept coming across quotes that I liked, and I didn't know which one to choose.

12:19.186 --> 12:23.273
[SPEAKER_01]: There were three of them, and I thought, what the hell, I'm just going to go with all three.

12:24.015 --> 12:25.217
[SPEAKER_01]: Because

12:25.197 --> 12:37.227
[SPEAKER_01]: each of them makes a point about Caesar or about the book or about me, and this is, you know, this is just the right of an author to sort of lay it all out at the beginning.

12:37.888 --> 12:40.675
[SPEAKER_01]: The first is from Mel Brooks, as I said.

12:40.655 --> 12:43.562
[SPEAKER_01]: and it was just to give a little bit of background.

12:44.043 --> 12:52.362
[SPEAKER_01]: I had too long interviews with Mel Brooks in person at his office at the Culver Studio at the Old Culver Studios.

12:53.224 --> 12:56.672
[SPEAKER_01]: And he was very generous with his time.

12:56.922 --> 13:04.913
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think it's because he's sort of a historian by nature, and he likes talking about comedy, and he likes talking about himself.

13:05.714 --> 13:08.238
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's one reason he was so generous.

13:09.079 --> 13:12.523
[SPEAKER_01]: The other is that he felt he owed a debt to Sid Caesar.

13:12.543 --> 13:18.071
[SPEAKER_01]: As I say, I mean, Mel Brooks at Mel has said many times, no Sid Caesar, no Mel Brooks.

13:18.572 --> 13:20.955
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's the whole story about

13:20.935 --> 13:29.169
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid sort of plucking Mel out of obscurity, he said when he, when he first met Mel, Mel was living underneath a hover.

13:30.290 --> 13:39.846
[SPEAKER_01]: One of the few one-line, great-one liners did ever got off because as you say, he wasn't one for one liners or for telling jokes.

13:40.487 --> 13:47.078
[SPEAKER_01]: But the other reason was that Mel felt that

13:47.058 --> 13:50.002
[SPEAKER_01]: but that Sid had been historically forgotten.

13:50.522 --> 13:59.693
[SPEAKER_01]: And here was somebody, me, David Marklick, writing a book about Sid Caesar, a serious writer, somebody was gonna be conscientious about it.

14:00.514 --> 14:08.003
[SPEAKER_01]: And here was a chance from Mel to help rehabilitate Sid, bring him back into the public mind.

14:07.983 --> 14:23.865
[SPEAKER_01]: And for that reason, he was very generous with his time, and this was a phenomenon that I discovered throughout my reporting that all of the people who had worked with Sid who were still around, Carl Reiner.

14:23.845 --> 14:28.770
[SPEAKER_01]: Woody Allen who wrote for Sid later on near the end of Caesar's reign.

14:28.810 --> 14:33.615
[SPEAKER_01]: All of them were very generous talking about Sid for that reason.

14:33.695 --> 14:40.282
[SPEAKER_01]: They felt they owed him a debt and they wanted to help restore him to the position that they felt he deserved.

14:40.403 --> 14:47.410
[SPEAKER_01]: And that also applied to anybody who would watch Sid as a kid and was influenced by him.

14:47.430 --> 14:53.076
[SPEAKER_01]: And that included Conan O'Brien and Billy Crystal and lots of younger comics.

14:53.056 --> 14:57.581
[SPEAKER_01]: who were very quick to pay homage to him and to honor him.

14:57.601 --> 15:12.497
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was the beneficiary of that because they were willing to talk about them without my feeling in the way that one often does in talking to over-interviewed celebrities that you're double parking when you're talking to them.

15:12.917 --> 15:16.021
[SPEAKER_01]: And they can't wait to get you off the phone.

15:16.501 --> 15:20.906
[SPEAKER_01]: Another person who sort of fits this description was Rob Reiner.

15:20.966 --> 15:22.067
[SPEAKER_01]: I interviewed him

15:22.047 --> 15:31.484
[SPEAKER_01]: Rob Reiner had a unique position on Sid Seasor because not only did his father write for Sid, but Rob grew up with Caesar's kids.

15:31.985 --> 15:34.509
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, Rob went to Caesar's house.

15:34.529 --> 15:37.554
[SPEAKER_01]: Rob learned to swim and Caesar's swimming pool.

15:38.676 --> 15:42.503
[SPEAKER_01]: So anyway, that's just a preamble to the quote from Mel.

15:42.483 --> 15:45.873
[SPEAKER_01]: or a phila buster or something that I know that went on for a while.

15:46.335 --> 15:51.310
[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, so I interviewed Mel in 2008 and then again in 2014.

15:51.811 --> 15:54.118
[SPEAKER_01]: This was in the second interview.

15:54.158 --> 15:56.104
[SPEAKER_01]: He said,

15:57.282 --> 16:19.600
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm proud of you, and I'm going to interrupt myself one more time to say that I didn't even pick this up the first time I went back and listened to the interview, but the second time by which point I had developed a pretty sophisticated understanding of Sid's rise and fall, it really jumped out at me and I was amazed at it and amazed that I had missed it.

16:20.141 --> 16:21.383
[SPEAKER_01]: I'll start again.

16:21.734 --> 16:22.816
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm proud of you.

16:22.856 --> 16:30.367
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, you know, you really know you really understood the show referring to your show of shows.

16:31.088 --> 16:38.398
[SPEAKER_01]: Now you're going to do this book and people are going to say, gee, this is really good and really interesting.

16:38.819 --> 16:42.144
[SPEAKER_01]: Just one question, David, who is Sid Caesar?

16:42.184 --> 16:44.087
[SPEAKER_01]: You're going to get that.

16:44.547 --> 16:46.290
[SPEAKER_01]: Who was Sid Caesar?

16:47.232 --> 17:02.997
[SPEAKER_01]: So that, you know, in one phrase, Mill Brooks was laying out the challenge that I had as an author to tell people who this man was and why he was consequential.

17:02.977 --> 17:06.583
[SPEAKER_01]: At, in fact, it's a challenge that has lived to this very moment.

17:06.783 --> 17:24.610
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, the challenge in marketing a book like this and getting it out, particularly to younger people and younger editors, you know, is to convince people that this is a story that matters and, you know, it's become more remote in the time that it took me to write.

17:25.372 --> 17:30.840
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's a kind of what the challenge that Mel made out from me is

17:31.158 --> 17:34.523
[SPEAKER_01]: lives on in any book about any historical figure.

17:34.864 --> 17:36.486
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's the first epigraph.

17:37.227 --> 17:40.372
[SPEAKER_01]: The second is from Norman Mailer.

17:41.354 --> 17:56.878
[SPEAKER_01]: I was writing independently about Norman Mailer recently, and this came out of an interview that Norman Mailer gave to his first biographer Peter Manso.

17:57.449 --> 18:05.036
[SPEAKER_01]: To be Jewish is to harbor a psychic defect, and thereby be gifted with instincts for transcendence.

18:05.656 --> 18:07.979
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a blessing and a curse to be a Jew.

18:08.559 --> 18:09.900
[SPEAKER_01]: You take to your choice.

18:11.202 --> 18:24.874
[SPEAKER_01]: And to me, this was, this was maleer in an unguarded moment talking about the distinct experience of being a Jew and the distinctiveness of Jews.

18:25.445 --> 18:46.491
[SPEAKER_01]: two topics that are generally shunned by Jews who don't like to talk to, particularly, about themselves or call attention to themselves or suggest that we're in any way different.

18:46.910 --> 18:59.454
[SPEAKER_01]: I welcomed mayor broaching that subject in as I say an unguarded moment when he couldn't imagine that anybody would be, would pluck it out and there it was where he was confronting.

19:00.136 --> 19:03.923
[SPEAKER_01]: What for me is a Jew and a Jewish writer is the elephant in the room.

19:03.903 --> 19:05.064
[SPEAKER_01]: What is it about us?

19:05.445 --> 19:10.830
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's a question that's always asked about, in particular, about Jews and comedy.

19:10.890 --> 19:16.536
[SPEAKER_01]: Why, you know, why are so many comedians Jews and why are so many Jews comedians?

19:16.917 --> 19:32.813
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's an issue that I had to address in the book, particularly because it was for a Jewish book series, where I had a license to explore a question like this.

19:32.793 --> 19:36.858
[SPEAKER_01]: as a keynote quote for the book as one of the epigraphs.

19:37.158 --> 19:46.429
[SPEAKER_01]: And the third one, I was reading about, I was reading about a book by Ben Hect, who interested me.

19:46.469 --> 19:59.003
[SPEAKER_01]: And this comes from an interview that Ben Hect had with a Zionist leader named Shimario Livin, who said to Ben the young Ben Hect,

19:59.253 --> 20:02.038
[SPEAKER_01]: My boy, you will someday write about Jews.

20:02.900 --> 20:05.104
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I ask you to remember this advice.

20:05.745 --> 20:09.872
[SPEAKER_01]: When you write about Jews right with humor, make jokes.

20:10.974 --> 20:16.063
[SPEAKER_01]: And I thought that also addressed the, I thought that was a very poignant and moving quote.

20:16.985 --> 20:20.772
[SPEAKER_01]: And underlying it to me is a kind of sadness.

20:21.022 --> 20:39.267
[SPEAKER_01]: and sort of the sadness of being a Jew, and the sadness of Jewish history and how it needs to be leavened with humor, and that also addressed the whole question of why Jews are comics and why so much of comedy and American comedy and American television comedy.

20:39.247 --> 20:40.028
[SPEAKER_01]: is Jewish.

20:40.669 --> 20:45.957
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar, of course, was a very important part in a development of that tradition.

20:46.678 --> 20:49.722
[SPEAKER_01]: And here's this quote that framed that too.

20:50.043 --> 20:54.189
[SPEAKER_01]: So anyway, that's why those three quotes are at the very beginning of the book.

20:54.970 --> 20:55.351
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

20:55.371 --> 20:57.614
[SPEAKER_00]: And they really frame it very nicely.

20:57.654 --> 20:58.135
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.

20:58.355 --> 21:00.238
[SPEAKER_00]: We're giving us the the backstory on them.

21:00.278 --> 21:02.842
[SPEAKER_01]: So, well, thank you for giving me the chance to read them.

21:02.862 --> 21:04.444
[SPEAKER_01]: That's really

21:04.947 --> 21:18.050
[SPEAKER_00]: So since these are at 10,000 foot level, is TV's initial homegrown star without the long apprenticeship in Vodville and radio like Nottenboro before him.

21:18.771 --> 21:21.235
[SPEAKER_00]: He's also the first great victim.

21:21.215 --> 21:24.479
[SPEAKER_00]: of TV suffering its most precipitous fall.

21:25.179 --> 21:31.947
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's I want to be a one flesh out with you, but before we do David, can you give us the beginning?

21:32.167 --> 21:32.708
[SPEAKER_00]: Who was he?

21:32.748 --> 21:34.189
[SPEAKER_00]: What was his childhood like?

21:34.209 --> 21:35.050
[SPEAKER_00]: How did he become?

21:35.471 --> 21:36.352
[SPEAKER_00]: Who he is?

21:36.412 --> 21:39.415
[SPEAKER_00]: Because we all come, you know, childhoods fall into the man's stuff.

21:40.276 --> 21:42.078
[SPEAKER_00]: Bloods went into it, cheers, taught us that.

21:42.759 --> 21:44.100
[SPEAKER_00]: So tell us about his childhood.

21:44.080 --> 21:46.503
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, he grew up in Yonkers, New York.

21:48.045 --> 22:05.970
[SPEAKER_01]: Kind of an unusual Jewish childhood, not the classic Lower East Side Childhood where everybody in your universe seemed to be a Jew, except the Italian and Irish kids who were beating you up.

22:05.950 --> 22:13.120
[SPEAKER_01]: He grew up instead in a working-class polyglot community, where he was regularly mixing with other people.

22:14.822 --> 22:30.743
[SPEAKER_01]: That accounts for his facility with foreign language gibberish, because his parents had a greasy spoon restaurant where all the working men came in and sat by ethnicity at different tables and

22:30.723 --> 22:51.533
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, would wait on Italian speakers or German speakers or French speakers or Russian speakers or Polish speakers, and he had this kind of musical ear and he picked up foreign languages very quickly of the sound of foreign languages, the musical, the musicality of foreign languages.

22:51.513 --> 22:56.520
[SPEAKER_01]: which, and that became a crucial part of his comedy, double talk, you know, you could perform.

22:56.560 --> 23:15.985
[SPEAKER_01]: He could play characters in all these different languages, and that was something that stuck with him as entire career, even to the point where when he barely could, when he could barely function or in all, in every awkward situation, he would fall back into it because it was a lifeline to him.

23:15.965 --> 23:31.628
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, Sid was kind of a maladjusted young boy, um, he was the fourth son, and the sort of afterthought son in his family, and, um, was slow to learn to speak.

23:31.608 --> 23:43.023
[SPEAKER_01]: kind of a loner and somebody who just really wasn't terribly well adjusted and came up with his own devices for dealing with the world.

23:43.483 --> 24:01.446
[SPEAKER_01]: Language was one, music was another because somebody had left a saxophone in one of the rooms upstairs, one of the borders staying in one of the rooms upstairs from the cafeteria, left a saxophone and Sid took to that and sort of sheltered

24:01.426 --> 24:28.581
[SPEAKER_01]: uh... in music to music was another kind of escape for him so he became i mean he was he was sort of uh... didn't have a he didn't have a lot of friends and sort of found shelter in other in other ways and was maladjusted and that was that was the way in which he came to comedy comedy was sort of another way to distance himself from everybody else and to the watch

24:28.561 --> 24:32.047
[SPEAKER_01]: watch the human race as an observer.

24:32.067 --> 24:35.373
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, almost in the way that a journalist would do.

24:35.954 --> 24:37.597
[SPEAKER_01]: So he wasn't a hail fellow.

24:37.657 --> 24:46.011
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, Matt, he was a hard person to talk to his teachers and school thought that he was thought that there was something wrong with him.

24:46.071 --> 24:48.696
[SPEAKER_01]: He was an angry kid.

24:48.676 --> 25:05.672
[SPEAKER_01]: He later said that it was a good thing that that border had left behind a saxophone rather than a shotgun because there's no telling what he would have turned into if he'd been playing with that, and he might have turned to a life of crime.

25:05.652 --> 25:20.742
[SPEAKER_01]: So he went to high school, he never got, he didn't get beyond high school like most of the people in Caesar's circle, but he got into music and music brought him to the cat skills where he was playing in a band.

25:20.722 --> 25:38.815
[SPEAKER_01]: But as I say, he had this sort of way of studying human nature and people could see that he was funny in his own way, not in a slapsticky kind of way, not in a wise guy's one line or joke telling kind of way.

25:38.795 --> 25:53.848
[SPEAKER_01]: But he could do, for instance, long, soniloquies with sounds and light, at accents and stuff like that, that's really where he made his comedic name in the Coast Guard during the war.

25:53.928 --> 25:56.410
[SPEAKER_01]: He performed in various Coast Guard shows.

25:57.130 --> 26:08.700
[SPEAKER_01]: One of them was turned into a movie called Tars and Spars, which was a showcase for him where he did one of the early classic Caesar sketches.

26:08.680 --> 26:34.941
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and a very characteristic sketch where he, he did a, he performed a solo act where he did a, he, it was a movie about a dogfight during World War I and aviators, you know, going trying to shoot one another down and he played the German aviator, he played the American

26:34.921 --> 26:38.686
[SPEAKER_01]: He put, but all the planes had their own sounds.

26:38.766 --> 26:40.849
[SPEAKER_01]: The German planes sounded one way.

26:41.310 --> 26:44.594
[SPEAKER_01]: The French, the English planes sounded another way.

26:44.875 --> 26:46.597
[SPEAKER_01]: The German planes snarled.

26:47.478 --> 26:49.301
[SPEAKER_01]: The American plane occurred.

26:49.641 --> 26:51.844
[SPEAKER_01]: The pilots all sounded very different.

26:52.125 --> 26:54.047
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar played the bombs falling.

26:54.388 --> 26:57.352
[SPEAKER_01]: And the bombs exploding, making all of these noises.

26:57.893 --> 27:01.738
[SPEAKER_01]: And in this otherwise, silly, sapy movie.

27:01.718 --> 27:13.684
[SPEAKER_01]: They gave him, they gave him this part where he could do all of this, and everybody in the business went to see this movie, including many of the people who later wrote for Sid.

27:13.984 --> 27:22.242
[SPEAKER_01]: Larry Gilbard, Neil Simon, Mel Tolkien, Carl Reiner, they all saw Sid in this movie, and they thought,

27:22.222 --> 27:28.609
[SPEAKER_01]: as Larry Gilbart later said, here is a, his talent was extra planetary.

27:28.989 --> 27:41.181
[SPEAKER_01]: It was unique and it was something that no one at energetic and required great stamina and sensory perception and nobody had ever seen it before.

27:41.201 --> 27:43.904
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the question was, how did deploy him?

27:43.944 --> 27:47.588
[SPEAKER_01]: And he, he perfected a

27:47.568 --> 27:59.974
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and there were a couple other movies that he did, and that moved that moved him directly into television, which started his television career, started at 1949.

28:00.865 --> 28:06.554
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so I want to ask you one question or two, and then we'll take our break, and then we'll turn to television.

28:07.035 --> 28:17.292
[SPEAKER_00]: You mentioned previously about anger and rage, and you write that comedy, all comedy, and much of comedy stems from rage.

28:18.013 --> 28:27.008
[SPEAKER_00]: But Caesar was more conspicuously angry than others, and he, Caesar, you quote in the book saying of his childhood,

28:26.988 --> 28:34.603
[SPEAKER_00]: that if his parents had beaten him with baseball bats, they couldn't have hurt me half as much.

28:35.004 --> 28:38.311
[SPEAKER_00]: So talk about that a bit, because... Well, as a boy, his behavior.

28:38.431 --> 28:39.594
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, no, that's right.

28:39.974 --> 28:43.782
[SPEAKER_01]: And I've always wondered whether that was, you know,

28:44.268 --> 28:45.630
[SPEAKER_01]: an exaggeration.

28:45.690 --> 28:57.410
[SPEAKER_01]: It was such a, you know, such a brutal way of describing the childhood, but I think it's stemmed from they're not really knowing what to do with this youngest son who'd come along.

28:57.871 --> 29:06.546
[SPEAKER_01]: He just assumed that his parents did not get along with one another and he just

29:06.526 --> 29:09.730
[SPEAKER_01]: long after they ever expected to have another child.

29:09.790 --> 29:14.576
[SPEAKER_01]: And he was sort of isolated and they didn't know what to do with him.

29:14.616 --> 29:19.041
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, there was a story of his that he told about.

29:19.702 --> 29:27.572
[SPEAKER_01]: And when when his parents were fighting once, they just put him on a train to go down to New Jersey.

29:27.552 --> 29:42.985
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and he wrote it as a, as a, as a kitty wrote on this train and then the moment it pulled in his, the train, there was a train carrying his mother that was pulling them out and you know, it was just one more brutalizing experience.

29:43.205 --> 29:47.755
[SPEAKER_01]: So I think that, you know, I think that I think the rage stemmed from that.

29:49.034 --> 29:52.358
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you add that he felt driven to comedy.

29:52.378 --> 29:58.144
[SPEAKER_00]: And particularly his type of comedy, by a need to express your vote to, I'll say it again.

29:58.965 --> 30:03.890
[SPEAKER_00]: You add that Caesar felt driven to comedy by a need to express emotions.

30:03.990 --> 30:07.494
[SPEAKER_00]: He couldn't do in everyday life.

30:07.534 --> 30:11.418
[SPEAKER_00]: He said of himself that comedy became the way to reveal feelings.

30:11.939 --> 30:14.822
[SPEAKER_00]: He couldn't otherwise safely show.

30:15.477 --> 30:20.243
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but well, that's actually I don't want to tuten my own horn, but that sounds pretty good to me.

30:20.664 --> 30:24.950
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think that I think that summarizes it, you know?

30:25.811 --> 30:38.768
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so let's take our first break and then we're going to come back and turn to 1949.

30:40.486 --> 30:41.067
[SPEAKER_00]: We're back.

30:41.347 --> 30:46.073
[SPEAKER_00]: We're talking with David Margulick about his wonderful book when Caesar was king.

30:46.613 --> 31:07.118
[SPEAKER_00]: House-sid Caesar reinvented American comedy where we left off was we had silent Sydney, a little kid who barely spoke until essentially age three, who was a great mimic and pantomime who could double-talk languages if he was saying the words, but was just gibberish.

31:08.060 --> 31:25.317
[SPEAKER_00]: He gets a saxophone, learns to play the saxophone, goes to the cat skills, they realize he's got humor in him and that ultimately leads to the invitation to be on television in 1949, which was pretty early.

31:26.078 --> 31:31.824
[SPEAKER_00]: I think only Milton Burrell had a comedy show starting for 48 or something, isn't it?

31:31.844 --> 31:32.785
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

31:32.765 --> 31:34.147
[SPEAKER_01]: So tell us about it.

31:34.248 --> 31:37.253
[SPEAKER_01]: I think Burl had like a year-head start on Caesar.

31:37.734 --> 31:39.597
[SPEAKER_00]: But they were very different comics anyway.

31:40.118 --> 31:41.220
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, totally different.

31:42.061 --> 31:56.747
[SPEAKER_00]: So Caesar arrives on television in 49 and tells us about the show and how he shaped television and television in a way shaped him too.

31:57.149 --> 32:27.072
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, the show was called the Admiral Broadway Review, and really was invented, was devised at Camp Tammament, the famous Camp Tammament in the Polkanos, for which Mac a guy named Max Leebman was the social director for many years, and was really the minor league for

32:27.170 --> 32:37.737
[SPEAKER_01]: um... that had a very active theatrical program and and they would put on shows every week um... for the campers

32:37.852 --> 32:48.234
[SPEAKER_01]: And these were variety shows featuring comedy, dance, music, just the whole works.

32:49.076 --> 32:58.155
[SPEAKER_01]: And people would attend this camp specifically because the shows were so entertaining and so sophisticated.

32:58.135 --> 33:03.383
[SPEAKER_01]: And this was a hallmark of a Max Lee men show.

33:03.423 --> 33:08.371
[SPEAKER_01]: And they were confined to this summer camp.

33:10.134 --> 33:21.392
[SPEAKER_01]: But when television came along and had a voracious appetite for material and was desperate to fill all of these empty hours,

33:21.372 --> 33:24.157
[SPEAKER_01]: Max Leedman had already formula for them.

33:24.197 --> 33:32.152
[SPEAKER_01]: He had a program that could be sort of imported from Tamaman and sort of locked in the television.

33:33.134 --> 33:38.183
[SPEAKER_01]: And so the story is that Sylvester Pat Weaver,

33:38.163 --> 33:54.771
[SPEAKER_01]: uh... who was the head of NBC went down to watch one of max leaveman shows this is so gurney weaver's father uh... went down and watched a max leaveman show and said and and said can we do this on television and can you do it every week

33:55.207 --> 34:01.378
[SPEAKER_01]: And leave men had said that he was doing television without before television, really.

34:01.759 --> 34:04.805
[SPEAKER_01]: He was doing television without the television cameras.

34:05.266 --> 34:09.553
[SPEAKER_01]: And he had this ready product that could just be shipped up to New York.

34:09.634 --> 34:11.477
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what he did.

34:11.457 --> 34:14.662
[SPEAKER_01]: That's where Imaging Koka first had performed.

34:14.702 --> 34:17.646
[SPEAKER_01]: She was part of the operation at Tama Mint.

34:18.267 --> 34:30.406
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's where the writers who worked for Sid Seaser and worked for the Admiral Broadway review and went on to work for him on your show of shows, Lucy, O'Cowlan, and Mill Tolkien got their starts.

34:31.347 --> 34:36.435
[SPEAKER_01]: So, Leaveman and Leaveman, I should just to go back

34:37.664 --> 34:41.609
[SPEAKER_01]: Leaveman had directed the Coast Guard show that Sid Caesar was in.

34:41.649 --> 34:45.414
[SPEAKER_01]: So it was, it was, Sid was never in the Polkanos.

34:46.095 --> 34:49.499
[SPEAKER_01]: As I say, he was in the Catskills, but Leaveman was the one.

34:49.519 --> 34:52.403
[SPEAKER_01]: The Yiddish word is Shiddach, the match.

34:52.764 --> 34:57.550
[SPEAKER_01]: Leaveman made the match between Sid Caesar and the Tamaman tradition.

34:58.171 --> 35:03.958
[SPEAKER_01]: And sort of married the two of them and brought them to Pat Weaver.

35:03.938 --> 35:09.358
[SPEAKER_01]: And Pat Weaver's response was, do you want 30, 60, or 90 minutes a week?

35:09.980 --> 35:13.684
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what, that's the situation that television was in.

35:13.724 --> 35:21.412
[SPEAKER_01]: They had to fill the time and they had to, I mean, now television time is incredibly costly and valuable.

35:21.792 --> 35:30.661
[SPEAKER_01]: Back then, it was a problem for television because they didn't know what to do with all the time that they had and Max leave and gave them a solution.

35:30.781 --> 35:33.684
[SPEAKER_01]: So, he started the Admiral Broadway review.

35:33.704 --> 35:37.708
[SPEAKER_01]: It was this primitive pastiche, very primitive.

35:37.688 --> 35:39.191
[SPEAKER_01]: from production values.

35:39.251 --> 35:43.701
[SPEAKER_01]: It was basically a show that was with television cameras.

35:43.761 --> 35:48.891
[SPEAKER_01]: It was the staging was very unsophisticated, but it was a start.

35:49.413 --> 35:52.539
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was a live show on television once a week.

35:53.341 --> 35:57.790
[SPEAKER_01]: And it lasted for half a season.

35:58.073 --> 36:04.986
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, but it was the, it was the, it was the, the introduction of Sid Cesar to a national television audience.

36:05.567 --> 36:19.272
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was a victim of its own success because it was such a hit that admiral began to sell so many television shows that they needed additional factory capacity in order to produce the shows and meet the demand.

36:19.252 --> 36:22.259
[SPEAKER_01]: and they really couldn't afford to sponsor a show anymore.

36:22.339 --> 36:33.042
[SPEAKER_01]: They were too busy making the televisions that Sid Caesar and Imaging Coco were selling for at for the admiral company, so they canceled the show.

36:33.612 --> 36:41.921
[SPEAKER_01]: And that led, I mean, they didn't know, Caesar and Lee men and everybody weren't sure what was going to happen.

36:41.981 --> 36:48.268
[SPEAKER_01]: But by that point, Imaging Coca and Caesar were already almost national institutions.

36:48.789 --> 36:51.932
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was just a matter of how the show would be repackaged.

36:52.053 --> 37:03.265
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was when the famous, the legendary, your show of shows was born.

37:03.245 --> 37:11.654
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's now we're 1950 and February of 1950 that started, so we're marking the anniversary just about just about now.

37:12.435 --> 37:31.817
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was, you know, that was the beginning of your show of shows starring Sid Cesar Imaging Coca and later on Howard Morris came on and Howard Morris had been a bit actor on the Admiral Broadway review and then critically Carl Reiner joined the show.

37:31.797 --> 37:33.439
[SPEAKER_01]: slightly down the road.

37:33.479 --> 37:49.563
[SPEAKER_01]: And so by the first full season of your show of shows, before some, the famous for some, Caesar's famous for some, Reiner, Coca, Howard Morris, and Caesar himself on your show of shows was fully underway.

37:50.004 --> 37:57.214
[SPEAKER_01]: And that lasted for the next, that lasted for four and a half seasons until the spring of 1954.

37:58.308 --> 38:07.564
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, it's so interesting about the show of shows and they all are available on YouTube and hopefully people Yeah, I just I'll just correct you.

38:07.744 --> 38:08.405
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not in Michael.

38:08.826 --> 38:11.250
[SPEAKER_01]: They're not all available on YouTube.

38:11.491 --> 38:17.481
[SPEAKER_01]: And in fact, watching them all as I did are watching most of them and most of them do exist.

38:17.461 --> 38:47.029
[SPEAKER_01]: there's a lot of what Caesar called derisively jumping and screaming that is dancing and singing that didn't interest him at all but it was part of the mix and you couldn't do comedy live for 90 minutes so they needed a break so I you know what in watching these shows I was on fast forward a lot because there was a lot of stuff that I didn't need to see but a lot of the

38:47.009 --> 38:53.157
[SPEAKER_01]: both from your show of shows and Caesar's Hour, which we'll talk about, which followed your show of shows.

38:53.197 --> 38:57.362
[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of the classic sketches are on YouTube.

38:58.023 --> 39:04.712
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm happy to talk about some of them or direct people to them because they're great in them.

39:04.732 --> 39:06.454
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a great pleasure watching them.

39:06.494 --> 39:08.156
[SPEAKER_01]: They really blow you away.

39:08.237 --> 39:09.338
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you can

39:09.318 --> 39:32.524
[SPEAKER_01]: You can see Caesar's genius on full display in them, and again, we're getting, I'm getting ahead of your story in a way, but Caesar disappeared from television for many years for various reasons that we can discuss, and YouTube helped resurrect him, and now is a great way to take in, as I say, his brilliance.

39:32.774 --> 39:35.516
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and that's what I meant to say, which is on YouTube.

39:35.536 --> 39:39.900
[SPEAKER_00]: You can see many of the sketches, and we'll talk about them in a few minutes.

39:39.940 --> 39:46.366
[SPEAKER_00]: But I wanted you to just anchor or listening audience in what they were performing.

39:46.426 --> 39:48.468
[SPEAKER_00]: Because at the time, there are a lot of these.

39:48.788 --> 39:57.155
[SPEAKER_00]: Take my wife, please, comics, the Borshbelt Catskill, one-liner type of comics.

39:57.715 --> 40:01.819
[SPEAKER_00]: He was not performing jokes.

40:03.233 --> 40:09.428
[SPEAKER_00]: cinematic parodies, mocking European films, high culture, melodrama, middle class.

40:09.448 --> 40:20.736
[SPEAKER_00]: Someone said, the problem with Sid Seasers show was you had to be able to think, you had to be able to stay at what he was parading in certain measure.

40:20.716 --> 40:29.850
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it was a very unusual and distinctive comic mix unlike anything else on television at that time.

40:30.551 --> 40:42.269
[SPEAKER_01]: And really, unlike anything ever since, um, and as Carl Reiner said, and as you quoted him saying, Caesar couldn't, couldn't, could never have done stand up.

40:42.850 --> 40:47.517
[SPEAKER_01]: He was literally incapable of doing it.

40:47.497 --> 40:49.640
[SPEAKER_01]: So the comedy was very different.

40:50.221 --> 40:53.366
[SPEAKER_01]: The show would start usually with a domestic scene.

40:54.648 --> 41:15.040
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar and Koka as the Hickenlupers as they eventually became known, which was a proto sitcom, you know, various interesting domestic situations, you know, dealing with confounding technology or remodeling their apartment or going out to eat or stuff like that.

41:15.020 --> 41:32.775
[SPEAKER_01]: So there were, you know, that these were early, early innovative domestic sketches, then there would be pantomime, Caesar's solo standing on the stage with no, you know, just pantomimeing in a way that he was for which he was never formally trained.

41:32.755 --> 41:41.833
[SPEAKER_01]: But quite brilliant, or Caesar doing a saliloquy, Caesar playing some inanimate object like a gumball machine.

41:42.113 --> 41:49.768
[SPEAKER_01]: And sort of talking as a gumball machine being abused in the subway, or Caesar playing an animal.

41:49.748 --> 42:12.718
[SPEAKER_01]: an animal in the zoo or a Caesar playing a baby being manhandled by his proud parents and relatives, and then there'd be longer, more ambitious sketches of takeoffs on movies,

42:12.698 --> 42:41.338
[SPEAKER_01]: movies like on the waterfront from here to eternity, foreign movies, like the bicycle thief or grand illusion, even Japanese movies later on, all these different varieties of comedy, much more sophisticated and catering, I mean, we really should say that the television audience,

42:41.318 --> 42:43.120
[SPEAKER_01]: was highly sophisticated.

42:44.061 --> 42:53.412
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a mix, but there were lots of smart people watching in a way it was more like a public television audience or a cable television audience.

42:53.912 --> 43:02.622
[SPEAKER_01]: Why, because television was limited, the reach of television didn't go beyond mostly urban areas in the Northeast.

43:02.682 --> 43:05.566
[SPEAKER_01]: Television had not spread throughout the country yet.

43:06.046 --> 43:11.072
[SPEAKER_01]: So there were a lot of educated viewers

43:11.052 --> 43:14.416
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's show was the smart person's show.

43:14.897 --> 43:25.130
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's show was the show that convinced a lot of people who thought the television was trash and television was basically wrestling matches and silly things.

43:25.551 --> 43:29.496
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar was the person who convinced a lot of people to buy TVs.

43:30.417 --> 43:40.030
[SPEAKER_01]: He was there just a vacation because, you know, he was sophisticated and he was smart and he was entertaining.

43:40.010 --> 43:48.545
[SPEAKER_01]: was Newton Minno, Newton Minno famously called television when he was John F. Kennedy's FCC director, commissioner.

43:48.886 --> 43:51.190
[SPEAKER_01]: He called television the vast wasteland.

43:51.390 --> 43:58.903
[SPEAKER_01]: This was in the early 1960s, a phrase that many people remember, a phrase for which Minno was very famous.

43:59.584 --> 44:03.351
[SPEAKER_01]: And I called Newton Minno,

44:03.989 --> 44:15.067
[SPEAKER_01]: And I said, did you watch, said Caesar, and it turned out that when Caesar was in his heyday, middle and his wife had argued about whether or not to buy a television.

44:15.127 --> 44:19.114
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar was the reason that they bought their first television.

44:19.174 --> 44:20.496
[SPEAKER_01]: He was one of them.

44:20.476 --> 44:22.441
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, Isaac Asimov was another.

44:22.501 --> 44:24.726
[SPEAKER_01]: There were a lot of people in this category.

44:24.786 --> 44:33.567
[SPEAKER_01]: And, and, and, you know, it, what as he explained it to me, he, you know, he called television a vast wasteland.

44:33.747 --> 44:36.173
[SPEAKER_01]: Only after Caesar was off of it.

44:37.047 --> 44:44.415
[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't initially a vast wasteland, and the reason that it wasn't was that it was catering to a sophisticated audience.

44:45.036 --> 44:55.408
[SPEAKER_01]: And we can get into the day-new mall of that story, which is how, when Caesar was finally driven off the air a few years later, it was by Lawrence Welk.

44:55.928 --> 45:06.480
[SPEAKER_01]: And nothing better encapsulated the changing, growing, evolving television audience than

45:06.460 --> 45:15.210
[SPEAKER_01]: by a kind of capillary action into the rest of the country, into the hinterlands, and they preferred Lawrence Welch to Sid Seaser.

45:15.250 --> 45:23.959
[SPEAKER_01]: They're not only like Welch's music and stick better than Seasers, but dislike Seaser.

45:24.540 --> 45:30.747
[SPEAKER_01]: Seaser was too high-brow for them, and they felt that Seaser was in a way talking down to them.

45:30.727 --> 45:35.334
[SPEAKER_01]: And so when Caesar was done in, he was done in by Lawrence Welk.

45:35.854 --> 45:38.939
[SPEAKER_01]: And he knew, he knew that, I mean, it's funny.

45:39.059 --> 45:43.866
[SPEAKER_01]: And Lawrence Welk was on ABC, which was then really and also ran network.

45:44.306 --> 45:47.290
[SPEAKER_01]: So it shows how fundamentally television was changing.

45:47.691 --> 45:56.143
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar and Mel Brooks and Caesar's writers knew that Lawrence Welk of all people, this corny,

45:56.123 --> 46:03.070
[SPEAKER_01]: this corny musician from South Dakota was an existential threat to what they all were doing.

46:03.110 --> 46:12.879
[SPEAKER_01]: And so there are Caesar in one amazing stretch spoofed Lawrence Welch show three times in four programs.

46:13.540 --> 46:20.126
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar's humor for reasons that we can also get into, Caesar's humor was generally very gentle.

46:20.706 --> 46:22.468
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a political

46:22.448 --> 46:34.963
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a political because Caesar, politics didn't interest Caesar, and politics in the McCarthy era was dangerous for Caesar, and dangerous for some of Caesar's writers.

46:35.484 --> 46:46.397
[SPEAKER_01]: So Caesar's comedy was very gentle and very rarely pointed or hurtful to anyone, but the sketches that he did

46:46.377 --> 46:48.220
[SPEAKER_01]: are absolutely brutal.

46:48.360 --> 46:52.485
[SPEAKER_01]: And those for some reason I think have been hidden really for many years.

46:52.626 --> 47:00.496
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sure that I was the first person to watch them in 60 years and they have never migrated to YouTube.

47:00.516 --> 47:10.630
[SPEAKER_01]: Those you have to go to the Paley Center in New York or the Library of Congress or

47:11.690 --> 47:12.511
[SPEAKER_00]: It's so interesting.

47:12.551 --> 47:14.855
[SPEAKER_00]: I remember, you know, you and I about the same age.

47:15.375 --> 47:25.670
[SPEAKER_00]: So when he was on the air in 50 to 54, 54 to 57 that range, we were just too young to be watching it.

47:25.710 --> 47:29.175
[SPEAKER_00]: But I do remember Lawrence Welk with the bubbles and

47:29.155 --> 47:29.796
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah.

47:29.816 --> 47:30.037
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

47:30.057 --> 47:31.380
[SPEAKER_00]: So like polka music.

47:31.721 --> 47:32.422
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's right.

47:32.442 --> 47:32.723
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

47:32.843 --> 47:33.104
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

47:33.665 --> 47:33.765
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

47:33.785 --> 47:34.487
[SPEAKER_00]: Right.

47:34.507 --> 47:36.531
[SPEAKER_00]: Mindless mindless show.

47:37.213 --> 47:37.714
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

47:37.734 --> 47:46.573
[SPEAKER_01]: And, and, and, and one of the odd things is that for a time there, Lawrence,

47:46.705 --> 48:10.924
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, many, many years later, although, one of the things that I write in the book is that PBS, I think, may be to this day, but in any case, for many years, whenever they were having one of their fundraisers, they trotted out old-sid Caesar sketches and offered them as bonuses to people giving money because they knew that many of their viewers

48:10.904 --> 48:20.273
[SPEAKER_01]: had been said Caesar viewers decades earlier, and so he was a sure fire appeal, you know, when they were went when they were out in protruding.

48:20.590 --> 48:29.798
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I know from your book that Albert Einstein wanted to meet since he said, yeah, you know, that was one of these stories.

48:29.858 --> 48:41.288
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, when you do a book like this, there are a lot of apocryphal stories and, and, and, and, you know, I never really believed that, you know, I, I sort of believed it, but, you know, I didn't have any proof of it.

48:41.969 --> 48:49.095
[SPEAKER_01]: But that, yeah, the story, it was a story from Sid himself, who said that one day they were in the middle of rehearsals,

48:49.075 --> 48:57.703
[SPEAKER_01]: and his secretary came in and said Albert Einstein is on the line and he said, what are you joking?

48:57.764 --> 49:04.070
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, what are you know, we're in the middle of rehearsal, stop bothering me and she said no, you know, Einstein is on the line.

49:04.110 --> 49:08.614
[SPEAKER_01]: That's how we told the story in some version or Einstein's secretary is on the line.

49:08.995 --> 49:14.560
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar took the call and I guess it was

49:14.540 --> 49:23.317
[SPEAKER_01]: Albert has figured out the physical, the physics equation, but not the human equation, and he wants to talk to you about that.

49:23.858 --> 49:29.629
[SPEAKER_01]: I think this in other versions of the story, it's Oppenheimer who tells Caesar this.

49:29.609 --> 49:38.943
[SPEAKER_01]: because Caesar, who was a great student of physics among other things, ran into often hymer once, and it was often hymer who conveyed that message.

49:39.443 --> 49:52.883
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar agreed to go down to Princeton, and not only agreed to, was eager to go down to Princeton and meet the great man Albert Einstein, but before it happened Einstein died, and that was the story.

49:52.863 --> 49:56.348
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, it was one of these stories that I was very happy to repeat.

49:56.388 --> 50:06.181
[SPEAKER_01]: There was no way of ascertaining whether it was true, but it was almost, it was too good to leave out, and I would very happily have included it in the book.

50:06.822 --> 50:20.760
[SPEAKER_01]: But later, I found another interview, the contemporaneous interviews are always the best ones, not after things are encrusted or

50:20.740 --> 50:28.528
[SPEAKER_01]: to a reporter from North from New Hampshire, I think, in 1959 or so, where he told the same story.

50:28.588 --> 50:30.850
[SPEAKER_01]: So this story had legs.

50:31.050 --> 50:35.074
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, in other words, this was a story with a provenance in a way.

50:35.114 --> 50:41.160
[SPEAKER_01]: And when he was talking to her, he pulled out a ragged old phone message.

50:41.200 --> 50:46.866
[SPEAKER_01]: You remember those pink slips that, you know, while you were out, these, you know, a message,

50:46.846 --> 50:54.695
[SPEAKER_01]: that actually contained the message from, it was Albert Einstein's original message, you know, Einstein called.

50:55.055 --> 50:57.478
[SPEAKER_01]: And she described how Caesar unfolded it.

50:57.899 --> 51:02.524
[SPEAKER_01]: It was clearly something that he carried around with him and was very worn.

51:02.924 --> 51:07.409
[SPEAKER_01]: And that to me was documentary evidence that this story was true.

51:07.469 --> 51:12.415
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'll bet you that Einstein did not reach out to Lawrence Wilk.

51:12.530 --> 51:17.216
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's right, and the story was that Einstein liked them on other things.

51:18.137 --> 51:32.935
[SPEAKER_01]: The famous German professor character, that's Caesar played, and that was one more feature of your show of shows where he played this shambolic professor in a battered top hat and a ratty coat.

51:32.915 --> 51:39.563
[SPEAKER_01]: who would just arrive from Vienna at LaGuardia Airport, the newly opened the name LaGuardia Airport.

51:39.924 --> 51:58.307
[SPEAKER_01]: And Carl Reiner, the roving reporter, would interview him, this professor, who always had preposterous names relevant to his various fields of expertise, you know, Professor Jet Von Propulsion, you know, was the expert on aerial dynamics, and that sort of thing.

51:58.748 --> 52:02.112
[SPEAKER_01]: And Reiner would interview him,

52:02.092 --> 52:03.674
[SPEAKER_01]: about his expertise.

52:04.035 --> 52:07.961
[SPEAKER_01]: And these were apparently Einstein like these.

52:08.242 --> 52:17.656
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he liked the idea of a German professor, a ridiculous German professor, sort of spouting all this bogus expertise.

52:18.297 --> 52:23.205
[SPEAKER_01]: And for people who are students of Mel Brooks,

52:23.185 --> 52:34.117
[SPEAKER_01]: It's absolutely a treasure trove of Mel Brooks' humor because he wrote these sketches, and there are many, many of them, including some of them on YouTube.

52:34.877 --> 52:40.383
[SPEAKER_01]: And they're really, they're precious little objects.

52:40.744 --> 52:48.852
[SPEAKER_01]: And I just say one more thing about the German accent, and Caesar's German accent, and his sketches involving Germans.

52:48.912 --> 52:50.374
[SPEAKER_01]: There are lots of them.

52:50.354 --> 53:08.760
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a, the famous sketch that he did with Howard Morris, where Caesar's playing an ostensible German general being dressed and Howard Morris is his valet and the general is barking out orders and the valet is very, very secretly taking care of him.

53:09.120 --> 53:10.662
[SPEAKER_01]: This is also on YouTube.

53:11.003 --> 53:16.851
[SPEAKER_01]: It's clearly one of the five or six most famous sketches that Caesar ever did.

53:16.831 --> 53:34.249
[SPEAKER_01]: And one of the things that I discovered in doing the book and one of the liberties that I had as an author writing a book for a Jewish book series and an author caring about Jewish themes was that among Caesar's fans.

53:34.229 --> 53:36.233
[SPEAKER_01]: We're Holocaust survivors.

53:36.453 --> 53:49.156
[SPEAKER_01]: I spoke to the children of three of them, all of whom told me how Caesar was very special in their households, households that didn't otherwise have a lot of laughter in them.

53:49.637 --> 53:50.719
[SPEAKER_01]: And why was that?

53:51.320 --> 53:55.528
[SPEAKER_01]: One of the reasons was that he did a lot of pantomime.

53:55.508 --> 54:07.967
[SPEAKER_01]: And if you didn't speak English well, if you were fresh off the boat and newly arrived in America, a lot of comedy would have been inaccessible to you, but pantomime was not.

54:08.728 --> 54:20.166
[SPEAKER_01]: And so Caesar was appealing to their parents, and they described watching their parents rolling with laughter, something as I said that they didn't know we see in their houses.

54:20.146 --> 54:26.071
[SPEAKER_01]: And the other reason that he was appealing to them was that he was making fun of Germans.

54:26.632 --> 54:33.598
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was a source of humor and comfort to them to see an American comic making fun of Germans.

54:34.279 --> 54:40.504
[SPEAKER_01]: And even realizing that this was freshly after the war that it was okay to make fun of Germans.

54:40.564 --> 54:50.153
[SPEAKER_01]: And it wasn't dangerous to make fun of Germans.

54:50.133 --> 54:58.585
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it's interesting when I was thinking about Sid Caesar and watching some of the YouTube shows and reading and rereading your book.

54:59.106 --> 55:04.814
[SPEAKER_00]: It struck me that Caesar almost is in a direct line from Chaplin.

55:05.415 --> 55:14.408
[SPEAKER_00]: That at least was my take, and I want the question I'm going to ask you, because it seems that they both had, as you called it, a radar for truth in comedy.

55:14.608 --> 55:15.870
[SPEAKER_00]: There had to be,

55:15.850 --> 55:21.099
[SPEAKER_00]: truth and that Caesar had perfect pitch about the human conditions.

55:21.139 --> 55:25.427
[SPEAKER_00]: He put on essentially, you say, many plays about mankind.

55:25.567 --> 55:31.277
[SPEAKER_00]: I always think of the Trump as this doing life.

55:31.257 --> 55:31.898
[SPEAKER_00]: comedy.

55:32.659 --> 55:33.961
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you see it in my role?

55:33.981 --> 55:38.808
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, well, for you mean, for you, I think you're really onto an important point there, Michael.

55:38.908 --> 56:00.741
[SPEAKER_01]: That, I mean, Caesar was very influenced by Charlie Chaplin and all of these silent comics, Caesar, again, as part of his kind of lonely child, who had spent a lot of time in the theater and going from one showing to another

56:00.721 --> 56:05.091
[SPEAKER_01]: existing in this darken room watching these guys on the screen.

56:05.211 --> 56:13.891
[SPEAKER_01]: And he often talked about watching chaplain and Laurel and Hardy and Buster Keaton and being very, very influenced by them.

56:13.931 --> 56:16.958
[SPEAKER_01]: And he talked about how Charlie Chaplin

56:16.938 --> 56:22.866
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm sure it was true for Keaton and Laurel and Hardy, maybe not to quite the same extent.

56:23.948 --> 56:25.790
[SPEAKER_01]: We're to both sides of the street.

56:26.171 --> 56:30.296
[SPEAKER_01]: That was his phrase for Charlie Chaplin, that he made you laugh.

56:30.396 --> 56:41.832
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he talked about the Chaplin comedy where Ian counters the blind flower girl

56:41.812 --> 56:44.056
[SPEAKER_01]: it really chokes me up even to think about it.

56:44.237 --> 56:50.909
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, the combination of humor and poignancy and Charlie Chaplin's comedy.

56:51.450 --> 56:57.441
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was something that Caesar, that Caesar sees upon an identified with.

56:57.421 --> 56:59.948
[SPEAKER_01]: And there is a lot of that.

57:00.028 --> 57:02.174
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's not not quite to the same.

57:02.936 --> 57:09.334
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar doesn't make you cry in the same way the Charlie Chaplin did, but he was very sensitive to that.

57:09.595 --> 57:12.443
[SPEAKER_01]: And I am just last night.

57:12.423 --> 57:13.584
[SPEAKER_01]: I watched.

57:13.604 --> 57:20.532
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar was not only a great student of silent films, but a great recreator of them.

57:20.632 --> 57:24.696
[SPEAKER_01]: There are several silent film sketches on Caesar's shows.

57:24.756 --> 57:31.083
[SPEAKER_01]: There's one called the sewing machine girl taking place in the garment district.

57:31.604 --> 57:39.392
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, where it caral

57:39.372 --> 57:58.535
[SPEAKER_01]: garment worker and Caesar is her protector, and there's a lot of poignions, a lot of humor in that sketch, but there's a lot of poignions seeing it too, and there's another sketch also on YouTube called a drunk there was, and this is an overpowering sketch.

57:58.655 --> 58:02.980
[SPEAKER_01]: I watched it again last night, and it choked me up all over again.

58:03.080 --> 58:05.683
[SPEAKER_01]: Every time I see it, it chokes me up.

58:05.663 --> 58:14.879
[SPEAKER_01]: by the end of Caesar's run on Caesar's hour when he was running his own show and out from under Max Lee Mid's control.

58:14.939 --> 58:24.094
[SPEAKER_01]: He had the luxury of doing very long sketches, and one was a sketch that was modeled after the film Stella Davos.

58:24.074 --> 58:32.022
[SPEAKER_01]: And it features a father trying to protect his daughter and his daughter's prospects.

58:32.823 --> 58:44.556
[SPEAKER_01]: And the father is a drunk, and the father stops drinking, and it records his struggles with alcohol, and a very funny way in everybody's laughing with it, and all of that.

58:45.016 --> 58:49.761
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's particularly poignant because Caesar himself was an alcoholic.

58:49.741 --> 58:55.108
[SPEAKER_01]: and we can get into that Caesar was a heavy drinker and it had a profound effect on his career.

58:55.168 --> 59:00.134
[SPEAKER_01]: But he wasn't afraid to portray alcoholics on screen.

59:00.154 --> 59:06.061
[SPEAKER_01]: And to me, it's an act of great courage on Caesar's part to do something.

59:06.081 --> 59:17.976
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, his audience did not know what was going on, but Caesar, these are autobiographical sketches that Caesar went into willingly and even eagerly.

59:17.956 --> 59:27.986
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, Lake Stella Dallas, he realizes that, you know, his own limitations are going to are going to cloud his daughter's prospects.

59:28.607 --> 59:42.141
[SPEAKER_01]: And so what he arranges to do is have her, and she's going to marry a high school graduate, which was a great prestigious thing in those days, a man who was a high school graduate, Carl Reiner.

59:42.121 --> 59:44.866
[SPEAKER_01]: believe it or not, a high school graduate.

59:45.287 --> 01:00:02.498
[SPEAKER_01]: And in order to guarantee her prospects, he has to arrange for his rich boss to adopt her so that she's the daughter of a wealthy father than an alcoholic, whose scandals will be smirch her and extend or over into her.

01:00:02.518 --> 01:00:06.205
[SPEAKER_01]: And the last scene in this sketch,

01:00:06.185 --> 01:00:09.894
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, is Ryan are watching their wedding in the rain.

01:00:09.954 --> 01:00:22.303
[SPEAKER_01]: He's outside standing in the rain and he can look through the window into the fancy mansion and watch your being, uh, watch your wedding ceremony and it really, it blows you away.

01:00:22.283 --> 01:00:37.708
[SPEAKER_01]: So when that's, you know, this is a long way around to say that Caesar was influenced by chaplain and the silent film stars and emulated them in some of his best sketches and that sketch, that sketch is just astonishing.

01:00:37.748 --> 01:00:47.604
[SPEAKER_01]: And what you have to realize and watching it is, it was done live, it was done live and, and it has all of the earmarks.

01:00:47.704 --> 01:00:48.966
[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't,

01:00:48.946 --> 01:00:50.568
[SPEAKER_01]: It was done respectfully.

01:00:50.668 --> 01:00:55.673
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, Caesar respected silent films and has not a caricature of a silent film.

01:00:55.973 --> 01:00:58.676
[SPEAKER_01]: This was something that greatly impressed Woody Allen.

01:00:59.036 --> 01:01:07.505
[SPEAKER_01]: Woody Allen said to me that, you know, Caesar wasn't making fun of silent films and, you know, moving around ridiculously and all of that.

01:01:08.065 --> 01:01:16.894
[SPEAKER_01]: This is a great homage to silent films and Caesar placed himself willingly and eagerly in that tradition.

01:01:17.414 --> 01:01:39.034
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the thing that was interesting to me about that sewing machine sketch, for example, is that and why Jews in particular would be taken by it, was it's not all that long after the triangle shirt-waste factory fire that infamous fire, where I lost a great ant in that fire.

01:01:39.014 --> 01:01:44.442
[SPEAKER_00]: Jewish, Italian seamstresses being shut in and burned.

01:01:44.462 --> 01:01:46.545
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, well, that's right.

01:01:46.965 --> 01:01:48.688
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I noticed the same thing.

01:01:48.828 --> 01:01:50.150
[SPEAKER_01]: I thought the same thing.

01:01:50.170 --> 01:01:54.035
[SPEAKER_01]: And they were not very far removed from that world.

01:01:54.095 --> 01:01:56.799
[SPEAKER_01]: That, in fact, they were still in that world.

01:01:56.859 --> 01:02:03.148
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's actually, it's a very, you raise, it's a very important point.

01:02:03.382 --> 01:02:16.167
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's writers' rooms were very famous, and they were later depicted in the film My Favorite Year, and in the play, after in the 23rd floor, both of which I don't like at all.

01:02:16.688 --> 01:02:19.433
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't like the first because I think that it

01:02:19.413 --> 01:02:26.084
[SPEAKER_01]: It libeled Caesar's writers' room at Karakadshur did and turned it into a shambles, which it never was.

01:02:26.725 --> 01:02:32.013
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's writers' room was an emotional place, but it was a disciplined place, too.

01:02:32.034 --> 01:02:33.055
[SPEAKER_01]: They had work to do.

01:02:33.456 --> 01:02:36.381
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar's shows were very disciplined.

01:02:36.401 --> 01:02:39.986
[SPEAKER_01]: They weren't thrown together, like Saturday night live.

01:02:40.047 --> 01:02:43.412
[SPEAKER_01]: That later scandalized Caesar when he was...

01:02:43.392 --> 01:02:51.966
[SPEAKER_01]: asked to guest host an episode of Saturday Night Live, but my favorite year is unfair to Caesar because his show was never like that.

01:02:52.347 --> 01:02:57.916
[SPEAKER_01]: The show with Peter O'Toole flying around on the trapeze and everything falling apart on the set.

01:02:58.336 --> 01:03:01.241
[SPEAKER_01]: Even though Caesar's shows were live, they were never like that.

01:03:02.082 --> 01:03:09.855
[SPEAKER_01]: They were rigorously scripted and they were pulled off week after week.

01:03:09.835 --> 01:03:22.558
[SPEAKER_01]: They were also, that his writer's room was never the frolic and the kind of gentle, the gentle, collegial kind of thing that Neil Simon later depicted.

01:03:22.959 --> 01:03:24.442
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a difficult world.

01:03:24.622 --> 01:03:26.325
[SPEAKER_01]: And these people,

01:03:26.305 --> 01:03:50.963
[SPEAKER_01]: They were living on the edge there, and there were vivid descriptions, courtesy of people who wrote about it at the time, rather than later on, once it was sent to mentalized, about how brutal it was to be in Caesar's writers' rooms, because they were very competitive, and why were they competitive, because the shadow of the garment district hung over all of these guys, they were first generation,

01:03:50.943 --> 01:04:00.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, they were first generation American Jews, I mean, their parents were all immigrants and the specter that haunted them was the garment district.

01:04:00.356 --> 01:04:05.784
[SPEAKER_01]: That's where they were all going to end up if they didn't make it in show business.

01:04:05.884 --> 01:04:13.575
[SPEAKER_01]: Mel Brooks talks about that in many of his interviews that he always thought he was going to be pushing a card around the garment district.

01:04:13.555 --> 01:04:28.057
[SPEAKER_01]: So long after the Triangle shirt was fired, the garment district still haunted Jewish culture, and it was the shadow that was hanging over all of the people who worked in Caesar's world.

01:04:28.157 --> 01:04:29.860
[SPEAKER_01]: It was still very relevant.

01:04:30.110 --> 01:04:38.325
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and you call the writer's room door Winnie and only the funniest ideas survived.

01:04:38.426 --> 01:04:42.654
[SPEAKER_00]: And in fact, my books was being paid by Caesar personally.

01:04:42.774 --> 01:04:45.599
[SPEAKER_00]: He couldn't even make it onto the table.

01:04:45.659 --> 01:04:49.266
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's a whole other story because

01:04:49.246 --> 01:04:58.841
[SPEAKER_01]: Mill, as I said, Caesar's writers on your show, Caesar's writers' room, the famous writer's room was for Caesar's hour and not your show of shows.

01:04:59.402 --> 01:05:12.081
[SPEAKER_01]: So anybody going to West 56th Street to city center and looking at the plaque saying, here was where Caesar's famous writer's room once was, should be advised that the plaque is wrong.

01:05:12.061 --> 01:05:21.714
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, and that's not where the famous writers room was, because because Caesar's writers room for your show of shows was an empty, a relatively empty place.

01:05:21.774 --> 01:05:24.998
[SPEAKER_01]: There are only three writers on your show of shows.

01:05:25.379 --> 01:05:32.308
[SPEAKER_01]: For most of your show of shows, there was Lucille Katlin, one of the first women comedy writers in television.

01:05:32.648 --> 01:05:37.174
[SPEAKER_01]: If not the first, Mel Tolken, who later worked on your

01:05:37.154 --> 01:05:39.982
[SPEAKER_01]: all in the family and Mel Brooks.

01:05:40.002 --> 01:05:43.513
[SPEAKER_01]: The first two came from Tamaman and were Max Lee men's people.

01:05:44.155 --> 01:05:45.679
[SPEAKER_01]: Mel just showed up.

01:05:46.553 --> 01:05:48.836
[SPEAKER_01]: Uh, Max Lee men hated him.

01:05:49.377 --> 01:05:55.725
[SPEAKER_01]: Mel was the young Mel Brooks you can imagine was a very aggressive and irritating guy.

01:05:55.745 --> 01:06:10.924
[SPEAKER_01]: He was exactly the kind of Jewish as Mel's first wife described to me that Max Lee men who was a man craving respectability was running away from more a borst belt kind of guy than a polcanoes kind of guy.

01:06:10.904 --> 01:06:20.874
[SPEAKER_01]: And he just was always chewing mell away trying to get rid of him, but Sid saw mell's genius and Sid liked mell's take on things.

01:06:21.535 --> 01:06:27.561
[SPEAKER_01]: And so Sid brought him in and he's kept him around despite everybody else's objections.

01:06:27.902 --> 01:06:30.604
[SPEAKER_01]: And yes, paid for him out of his own pocket.

01:06:31.425 --> 01:06:38.953
[SPEAKER_01]: And eventually eventually mell insinuated his way into the show and into the credits, but it took

01:06:39.710 --> 01:06:48.440
[SPEAKER_00]: So your show of shows is the almost in some sense that which Caesar is remembered for.

01:06:48.720 --> 01:06:52.545
[SPEAKER_00]: If anyone remembers Caesar, they'll say, oh, yes, your show shows.

01:06:52.985 --> 01:07:03.878
[SPEAKER_00]: But the room fractures, the series ends, the new show that you just referenced the Caesar's hour runs from 54

01:07:03.858 --> 01:07:12.309
[SPEAKER_00]: to 57 until, ultimately, it's undone in its competition with the Lawrence Wilk show.

01:07:12.850 --> 01:07:15.493
[SPEAKER_00]: But you write to me, it's interesting, which I'd like you to talk about.

01:07:15.533 --> 01:07:24.725
[SPEAKER_00]: You say that Caesar's hour never took hold the way your show shows had or generated the same passion and affection.

01:07:25.466 --> 01:07:28.870
[SPEAKER_00]: But in the history of television, this is your writing again.

01:07:28.850 --> 01:07:32.598
[SPEAKER_00]: History of television, its death is the real milestone.

01:07:33.119 --> 01:07:47.448
[SPEAKER_00]: The moment when TV showed its cards, the experiment with live, sophisticated entertainers was terminated, you write that it's end marked the death of the delusion that merit mattered.

01:07:47.929 --> 01:07:49.272
[SPEAKER_00]: Great stuff, so talk about that.

01:07:49.252 --> 01:07:49.693
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:07:49.733 --> 01:07:50.954
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's, yeah.

01:07:50.974 --> 01:07:51.715
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's true.

01:07:52.356 --> 01:07:54.178
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was startling to me.

01:07:54.198 --> 01:08:09.538
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, the first point to make just to reiterate something that you just said, Michael, is that people think about your show of shows and the eight year span, well, one plus four and a half plus three, whatever that is, the span of

01:08:09.518 --> 01:08:17.989
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's run is always called your show of show is even by some of the participants, but in fact, they were three components to it.

01:08:19.130 --> 01:08:22.655
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar's hour started just to go back momentarily.

01:08:22.675 --> 01:08:28.603
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid shaved under Max Lee men's influence and wanted to run his own operation.

01:08:29.323 --> 01:08:32.508
[SPEAKER_01]: That explains why your show of show is broke up.

01:08:33.028 --> 01:08:35.652
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid was the one that wanted to break it up.

01:08:35.672 --> 01:08:37.534
[SPEAKER_01]: Later he tried to...

01:08:37.514 --> 01:08:48.735
[SPEAKER_01]: to revise that history and say that it was NBC that just wanted to exploit, wanted to break it into three and give him a show and Coca a show and leave him his own show.

01:08:49.075 --> 01:08:50.879
[SPEAKER_01]: But it was Sid who was behind it.

01:08:51.159 --> 01:08:53.143
[SPEAKER_01]: He wanted his own show.

01:08:53.123 --> 01:09:03.022
[SPEAKER_01]: And one of the elements in his own show, he wanted to get rid of most of the singing and dancing and do more ambitious sketches.

01:09:04.144 --> 01:09:10.255
[SPEAKER_01]: And so as I say, the sketches on Caesar's hour are much more ambitious.

01:09:10.235 --> 01:09:13.880
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caesar also wanted to bulk up his writing team.

01:09:14.340 --> 01:09:21.950
[SPEAKER_01]: And so that's why, as I say, the famous writer's room was on Caesar's hour, that's when you had them amazingly, really.

01:09:21.970 --> 01:09:26.175
[SPEAKER_01]: You had Millbrook's Larry Gilbard and Neil's master.

01:09:26.355 --> 01:09:27.436
[SPEAKER_01]: He's of mesh fame.

01:09:27.757 --> 01:09:30.400
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, of mesh fame and twitchy fame.

01:09:30.801 --> 01:09:39.111
[SPEAKER_01]: You had all of them writing for Caesar at the same time, along with several other people,

01:09:39.091 --> 01:09:40.795
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, Neil Simon and his older brother.

01:09:41.256 --> 01:09:44.062
[SPEAKER_01]: And well, Neil Simon and his older brother, briefly.

01:09:44.102 --> 01:09:49.574
[SPEAKER_01]: Neil was the one that Caesar really wanted, not the older brother, Danny Simon.

01:09:50.977 --> 01:09:55.868
[SPEAKER_01]: So many of the greatest Caesar sketches

01:09:55.848 --> 01:10:13.519
[SPEAKER_01]: are on that show and some of them took up almost the entire show because Caesar now was not limited and he could he could have sketches that were 30 or 40 minutes long including the silent film sketch that I mentioned before.

01:10:13.499 --> 01:10:25.838
[SPEAKER_01]: And television was changing, as I said, with Lawrence Welk, and Caesar was changing because the show was taking all weekly shows, weekly live shows.

01:10:26.419 --> 01:10:32.048
[SPEAKER_01]: It was all taking a toll on Caesar, and his performance has started to falter.

01:10:32.028 --> 01:10:35.776
[SPEAKER_01]: and his alcoholism started to show and his pill popping.

01:10:36.317 --> 01:10:51.387
[SPEAKER_01]: The tranquilizers he was taking to sort of get to sleep at night and turn off the news reel, which is how he described what was going on in his head, thinking about the next show and doing postmortems of the previous show.

01:10:51.367 --> 01:10:52.389
[SPEAKER_01]: and all of that.

01:10:53.330 --> 01:10:59.700
[SPEAKER_01]: It was finally taking its toll and if you watch Caesar's later performances, they start to falter.

01:10:59.740 --> 01:11:07.412
[SPEAKER_01]: And so the writing was greater than ever on Caesar's hour, but the performances were not and television was changing.

01:11:08.193 --> 01:11:10.557
[SPEAKER_01]: But television, there was, you know,

01:11:10.537 --> 01:11:23.954
[SPEAKER_01]: as I described it as you read, there was still a naivete about television, and people still thought that why isn't it enough that quality matters?

01:11:24.014 --> 01:11:25.558
[SPEAKER_01]: Who gives a damn about it?

01:11:25.538 --> 01:11:26.259
[SPEAKER_01]: ratings.

01:11:26.359 --> 01:11:28.663
[SPEAKER_01]: Why should ratings dominate everything?

01:11:29.004 --> 01:11:32.029
[SPEAKER_01]: And why should we care about what advertisers think?

01:11:32.390 --> 01:11:35.014
[SPEAKER_01]: We like this and there are lots of us out there.

01:11:35.375 --> 01:11:38.319
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, there was a guy is very poignant away.

01:11:38.380 --> 01:11:51.141
[SPEAKER_01]: There was a guy that when Caesar's show was canceled, who placed ads of a fan, a lawyer in Queens placed ads in the

01:11:51.121 --> 01:11:53.424
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, how can you cancel the guy?

01:11:53.725 --> 01:11:57.610
[SPEAKER_01]: He started an organization called, um, what was it called?

01:11:57.650 --> 01:12:01.576
[SPEAKER_01]: Something like Citizens for Caesar's longevity or something like that.

01:12:02.116 --> 01:12:08.085
[SPEAKER_01]: And there are these little ads that he paid for himself and in the New York City newspapers.

01:12:08.465 --> 01:12:16.116
[SPEAKER_01]: So there was still this belief that quality mattered and, you know, what was more important than quality?

01:12:16.096 --> 01:12:34.071
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, you know, there was, there was one, one of the rare gaps on the show was Misha Elman was playing a violin solo and something wasn't timed perfectly and they had to cut them off in the middle of the piece because it was time for a moths apple juice commercial.

01:12:34.051 --> 01:12:40.801
[SPEAKER_01]: and everybody was scandalized why couldn't the sketch have gone on a little bit longer who gives us shit about the commercial?

01:12:41.182 --> 01:12:46.089
[SPEAKER_01]: That was still, you know, as I say in the book television was still young.

01:12:46.470 --> 01:12:52.539
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's hard to believe that people would have even thought that now, how inconceivable would it be?

01:12:52.599 --> 01:13:00.531
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, every, you know, even in television comedy, Johnny Carson, or whatever, we got to take a break now, we'll be right back.

01:13:00.511 --> 01:13:05.338
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, you stop, you know, television stops for a commercial.

01:13:05.959 --> 01:13:10.786
[SPEAKER_01]: But back then, that wasn't automatically the case or automatically what people assumed.

01:13:12.168 --> 01:13:19.359
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's take our second break and then I want to come back to what is known as the 20 year lost weekend.

01:13:19.679 --> 01:13:20.781
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, okay.

01:13:29.806 --> 01:13:30.407
[SPEAKER_00]: We're back.

01:13:30.788 --> 01:13:34.634
[SPEAKER_00]: We're talking with David Margulick about his book when Caesar was king.

01:13:34.714 --> 01:13:37.739
[SPEAKER_00]: How said Caesar reinvented American comedy?

01:13:38.620 --> 01:13:47.455
[SPEAKER_00]: We've gone through your show of shows and the Sid Caesar hour he gets cancels as we've just talked about.

01:13:47.515 --> 01:13:50.700
[SPEAKER_00]: And he's essentially

01:13:50.680 --> 01:13:55.249
[SPEAKER_00]: either squeezed himself off or been squeezed off of television.

01:13:56.290 --> 01:13:58.535
[SPEAKER_00]: So what was he then?

01:13:58.935 --> 01:14:13.262
[SPEAKER_00]: What was his life like you talked about pills and alcohol and he referred to it as a 20-year lost weekend, but tell us about it because I have to say I loved this book, but in the end,

01:14:14.204 --> 01:14:21.020
[SPEAKER_00]: I was like you perhaps left sort of laughing and sad at the same time.

01:14:21.701 --> 01:14:28.477
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's, you know, in fact, one of my old editors at the times had that same reaction.

01:14:28.497 --> 01:14:29.900
[SPEAKER_01]: He said, I never laughed so much.

01:14:30.000 --> 01:14:32.466
[SPEAKER_01]: It's over so sad a story.

01:14:32.446 --> 01:14:36.192
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, there are both, I mean, it goes back to Charlie Chaplin again.

01:14:36.212 --> 01:14:48.530
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, when you write it, when you depict real life, you know, whether in a silent film or in a biography of sorts like this book, you're going to have the bitter and the sweet.

01:14:48.671 --> 01:15:01.390
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, they're always, there are always parts of any story and there's a lot of that

01:15:01.690 --> 01:15:09.302
[SPEAKER_01]: most of the book is about Caesar's glory years, and the last 50 years of his life I cover in two chapters.

01:15:10.283 --> 01:15:12.166
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm pretty quick about it.

01:15:12.787 --> 01:15:21.100
[SPEAKER_01]: And on the one hand, I'm faulted by some critics for not spending enough time on the sad years.

01:15:21.080 --> 01:15:30.609
[SPEAKER_01]: And on the other hand, I'm criticized by people for being for writing a downer and not concentrating enough on the good years.

01:15:31.129 --> 01:15:48.285
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I mean, I just noticed a comment on Amazon from somebody saying, I couldn't put this book down at first, but then Margulic keeps going into Caesar's problems at the end and you know, he gave me three stars because of that.

01:15:48.265 --> 01:15:48.766
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.

01:15:48.786 --> 01:16:11.797
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you had to cover both parts of the story, but I thought I gave them that I accorded to each the appropriate proportion, which is that most of it celebrates what Caesar is really significant before, which is his work and his contribution to television, and the last part of the story could be told with relative dispatch.

01:16:12.618 --> 01:16:16.163
[SPEAKER_01]: And that story is that

01:16:16.143 --> 01:16:20.834
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar was really crippled for almost 20 years.

01:16:20.894 --> 01:16:32.380
[SPEAKER_01]: He became sort of a ghost-like figure sticking around in his home, rarely going out, eventually moving to Los Angeles.

01:16:32.360 --> 01:16:50.491
[SPEAKER_01]: later than a lot of other people, but realizing that the television business was leaving New York, Carl Reiner, Mel Brooks, all these other people, certainly the comedy business was leaving New York, and he better get out there too, so he moved to Los Angeles.

01:16:51.272 --> 01:16:56.140
[SPEAKER_01]: But he wasn't seen very much, he would be on television occasionally.

01:16:56.120 --> 01:17:11.935
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, one's striking thing about his story going back to the debt that people felt to him was that everybody lots of people in the industry, including people he had been competing with took pity on him.

01:17:11.915 --> 01:17:18.343
[SPEAKER_01]: because he was really just a shell of the man that he continued to drink and he was still very impaired.

01:17:18.764 --> 01:17:21.828
[SPEAKER_01]: But everybody tried to prop them up and keep them out there.

01:17:22.188 --> 01:17:30.619
[SPEAKER_01]: Jackie Gleason would give him almost a couple of instances and give him almost an entire show to do is what were his tired old axe.

01:17:30.639 --> 01:17:33.923
[SPEAKER_01]: He didn't sort of replenish what he was doing.

01:17:33.903 --> 01:17:38.170
[SPEAKER_01]: didn't have the energy or the imagination or the capacity to do that.

01:17:38.210 --> 01:17:52.975
[SPEAKER_01]: He was doing the same old stuff, Dick Cavatt, who was a great fan of Sid Seasor, who'd been inspired to go into comedy because of Sid Seasor had him on his show many times and sort of prompt him up.

01:17:52.955 --> 01:18:04.011
[SPEAKER_01]: for interviews where Sid couldn't really answer questions and cavit would ask him, you know, coach him and ask him leading questions that he new Caesar could answer in double talk.

01:18:04.051 --> 01:18:10.902
[SPEAKER_01]: For instance, Johnny Carson had Caesar on his show many times, but he really couldn't perform.

01:18:10.962 --> 01:18:21.898
[SPEAKER_01]: That, you know, there was an Esquire did a cover story on Sid in 1972 or 1973

01:18:22.402 --> 01:18:24.185
[SPEAKER_01]: on television on television.

01:18:24.867 --> 01:18:27.772
[SPEAKER_01]: But in fact the answer was he couldn't have been on television.

01:18:27.812 --> 01:18:29.074
[SPEAKER_01]: He was too impaired.

01:18:29.796 --> 01:18:32.841
[SPEAKER_01]: So for many years he was just really sideline.

01:18:33.262 --> 01:18:37.049
[SPEAKER_01]: We know you and I Michael because, you know, we're contemporary.

01:18:37.109 --> 01:18:39.033
[SPEAKER_01]: He was he was in a few movies.

01:18:39.694 --> 01:18:43.060
[SPEAKER_01]: He was in it's a mad mad, mad, mad world.

01:18:43.158 --> 01:18:51.067
[SPEAKER_01]: which I thought was a bororiously funny when I saw it when I was a kid and couldn't sit through when I saw it as an adult, it's just an awful movie.

01:18:51.527 --> 01:18:55.572
[SPEAKER_01]: And sit as terrible in it because sit is really playing himself.

01:18:55.952 --> 01:18:59.736
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid was crazed at that point and he's playing a crazed character.

01:18:59.796 --> 01:19:09.267
[SPEAKER_01]: He was still drinking William Demeris who was also in the cast said, you should be ashamed of yourself showing up on the set drunk.

01:19:09.247 --> 01:19:29.633
[SPEAKER_01]: And Stanley Cramer who directed, it said, you know, I had been warned about Sid Seaser and how difficult he was to work with, but, you know, he was really, he was, it was no picnic dealing with him, then he was on, in Greece many years later, which is how many people younger people know of Sid Seaser.

01:19:29.673 --> 01:19:31.235
[SPEAKER_01]: He's just the coach and Greece.

01:19:31.695 --> 01:19:33.378
[SPEAKER_01]: They don't know the whole backstory.

01:19:33.418 --> 01:19:34.579
[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway,

01:19:34.559 --> 01:19:36.741
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid finally gets his act together.

01:19:36.801 --> 01:19:43.427
[SPEAKER_01]: He has this come to Jesus' moment where he's performing and sass catch one in a Neil Simon play.

01:19:43.487 --> 01:19:46.110
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the depth to which he had sunk.

01:19:47.031 --> 01:19:53.016
[SPEAKER_01]: And he for just literally forgot all of his lines and couldn't come out after intermission.

01:19:53.577 --> 01:19:59.623
[SPEAKER_01]: And then he realized as he later wrote in his first memoir that he was really going down the tubes.

01:19:59.703 --> 01:20:02.085
[SPEAKER_01]: He was going to kill himself if he didn't clean up.

01:20:02.065 --> 01:20:06.240
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's when he cleaned up and stopped drinking and went cold turkey on pills.

01:20:06.963 --> 01:20:08.488
[SPEAKER_01]: And then he bounced back some.

01:20:08.528 --> 01:20:14.269
[SPEAKER_01]: That's when he was asked to guest host Saturday night live, which was a disaster because Sid...

01:20:14.755 --> 01:20:43.868
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid couldn't help himself, and Sid found the whole operation it's Saturday night live, scandalously shotty, and later said so, they were very nice to him on the show, and it's touching to watch when he first comes out, Julie and Louis Dreyfus and Eddie Murphy are on in the cast, then it's in the Lauren Michaels interregnum when Dick Ebersall was doing the

01:20:43.848 --> 01:20:52.764
[SPEAKER_01]: Julia Louis Dreyfus and Eddie Murphy start gesturing, telling everybody in the audience to stand up, when this man walks in the room stand up.

01:20:53.706 --> 01:20:54.788
[SPEAKER_01]: He's entitled to it.

01:20:54.808 --> 01:20:55.810
[SPEAKER_01]: He's that important.

01:20:55.850 --> 01:21:00.378
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was, that was the way that comedy may have been felt about Sid Seaser.

01:21:00.879 --> 01:21:03.544
[SPEAKER_01]: The rest of the world had forgotten about him.

01:21:03.524 --> 01:21:20.845
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's really, you know, I mean, he got, he got sharper and wiser and more functional and more verbal and more public and more effective in a way later on because he wasn't abusing himself anymore.

01:21:21.485 --> 01:21:23.107
[SPEAKER_01]: But he was no longer funny.

01:21:23.127 --> 01:21:31.978
[SPEAKER_01]: He lost his funny body and he'd also thin

01:21:31.958 --> 01:21:36.028
[SPEAKER_01]: It was depressing for people who knew him well to look at him.

01:21:36.515 --> 01:21:38.477
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, only kale wrote about that.

01:21:38.517 --> 01:21:39.979
[SPEAKER_01]: He's not the funny looking guy.

01:21:40.340 --> 01:21:45.907
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it would be like if Oliver Hardy suddenly got thin or Jackie Gleason got thin.

01:21:46.007 --> 01:21:55.498
[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, you know, I saw the late Jackie Gleason once, you know, many years later in the last years of his life and he was not funny anymore.

01:21:55.899 --> 01:21:57.901
[SPEAKER_01]: He was an angry bitter old guy.

01:21:57.941 --> 01:22:02.607
[SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, Sid became more sociable later on.

01:22:02.587 --> 01:22:29.860
[SPEAKER_01]: And when I interviewed him, my interview him on consecutive days in 2008, I had a good interview with him, and he said a lot of interesting things, and it was better than I thought it would be, and it turned out I didn't, it was early in the process of my doing the book, and I'm sorry there were lots of things I wasn't smart enough yet to ask them, but it was a good interview.

01:22:29.840 --> 01:22:33.965
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that, you know, I think Sid's final years were happier years.

01:22:35.567 --> 01:22:36.768
[SPEAKER_00]: Although, it's interesting.

01:22:37.329 --> 01:22:41.273
[SPEAKER_00]: I remember being in the United Lounge in some airport.

01:22:42.034 --> 01:22:48.082
[SPEAKER_00]: And security is bringing in a celebrity as they were want to do.

01:22:48.662 --> 01:22:49.503
[SPEAKER_00]: And it was Sid Seaser.

01:22:50.264 --> 01:22:55.290
[SPEAKER_00]: And the room was pretty empty was just Sid Seaser and me and a few other people.

01:22:56.401 --> 01:22:59.325
[SPEAKER_00]: And I said to him, do you mind if I ask you a question?

01:22:59.345 --> 01:23:00.427
[SPEAKER_00]: He said, yeah, sure what.

01:23:00.587 --> 01:23:02.129
[SPEAKER_00]: And I said, how's Ricky?

01:23:02.369 --> 01:23:04.292
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the, you saw him, right?

01:23:04.312 --> 01:23:04.412
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

01:23:04.432 --> 01:23:05.654
[SPEAKER_00]: I went to him and he was going with.

01:23:05.674 --> 01:23:09.159
[SPEAKER_00]: And he lights up and he says, you know, Ricky?

01:23:09.379 --> 01:23:12.423
[SPEAKER_00]: And I said, yeah, you know, Teflon Manuel, you lived on East Shore Road.

01:23:12.443 --> 01:23:13.805
[SPEAKER_00]: You had to see what high holidays.

01:23:14.446 --> 01:23:16.469
[SPEAKER_00]: And he couldn't have been more charming.

01:23:17.170 --> 01:23:19.573
[SPEAKER_00]: But the sad part to me was,

01:23:20.212 --> 01:23:21.574
[SPEAKER_00]: nobody knew who he was.

01:23:21.635 --> 01:23:33.135
[SPEAKER_00]: He was unrecognized in that lounge and we were on the same flight and I regret to this day, not asking the person who was seated next to if they would change seats with me because that guy didn't know who said Caesar was.

01:23:33.195 --> 01:23:34.057
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

01:23:34.818 --> 01:23:43.333
[SPEAKER_00]: And I guess it invites the question

01:23:44.410 --> 01:23:44.891
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:23:45.131 --> 01:23:49.638
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you know, your situation.

01:23:49.698 --> 01:23:53.503
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it really, we're back to where we started.

01:23:53.583 --> 01:24:13.793
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you know, you discovered the reality that that mill Brooks brought up with me, you know, which is that people don't people had stopped knowing who he was and that was, you know, that was the, that was the challenge that I had in writing the book and

01:24:13.958 --> 01:24:42.261
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that the problem for Sid was that he peaked early, which is always a mistake from a career standpoint, and that he worked in an ever-nessent medium television, which didn't have much of a memory, and as Mell warned him early on, he was working in a way that he was working in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in a way that he worked in

01:24:42.680 --> 01:24:59.541
[SPEAKER_01]: In material, his work was going on to material that was not going to last, it was more impermanent, I mean, his shows were on kinoscopes, they weren't done on film, although I don't think that was the fatal thing.

01:24:59.521 --> 01:25:04.007
[SPEAKER_01]: Because, as I say, you can watch them on YouTube and they're much degraded.

01:25:04.068 --> 01:25:08.814
[SPEAKER_01]: They're much better on DVDs when they've been cleaned up and they look beautiful.

01:25:10.236 --> 01:25:15.865
[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't think that's what did amend, but they weren't fit-com.

01:25:15.905 --> 01:25:20.972
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid refused to do sitcoms, which he thought were very artificial.

01:25:20.952 --> 01:25:41.477
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and I understand that feeling because he was doing real life, and there is something artificial and, and phony about sitcoms, and he refused to do them, um, he refused to go the root of Isle of Lucy or the Honey Mooners or Sergeant Bilco or the Dick Van Dykes show.

01:25:42.057 --> 01:25:48.445
[SPEAKER_01]: And all of those were done on film in convenient bite-sized half hour chunks,

01:25:48.425 --> 01:25:51.808
[SPEAKER_01]: that could be easily syndicated, unlike Sid's stuff.

01:25:52.649 --> 01:25:57.134
[SPEAKER_01]: And so when you and I were growing up in ever since, I love Lucy was on.

01:25:58.735 --> 01:25:59.937
[SPEAKER_01]: Never went off the air.

01:26:01.558 --> 01:26:03.801
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, this is thanks to Desi Arnez.

01:26:04.361 --> 01:26:10.227
[SPEAKER_01]: Todd Purrnam writes about all of this and is booked about this new, interesting book on Desi Arnez.

01:26:11.308 --> 01:26:17.014
[SPEAKER_01]: And so all of those shows had a kind of permanence that Caesar's work didn't.

01:26:16.994 --> 01:26:18.557
[SPEAKER_01]: I mentioned it in the book.

01:26:18.637 --> 01:26:29.316
[SPEAKER_01]: I interviewed one of Jackie Gleason's writers about Sid because he knew Sid, all of the writers for all of the other shows were in all of Caesar's writers.

01:26:29.396 --> 01:26:31.299
[SPEAKER_01]: That was the job that you wanted.

01:26:31.359 --> 01:26:42.158
[SPEAKER_01]: Whether you worked for Gleason or Steve Allen or anybody else, it was the highest and most prestigious job was to write for Sid Caesar.

01:26:42.138 --> 01:27:00.800
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, and, and so that's why I interviewed one of, one of, one of, one of Gleason's writers, um, and when I interviewed him, let it stern, when I interviewed him, I could repeat to him, every line from every honeymooners episode that he wrote.

01:27:01.221 --> 01:27:02.582
[SPEAKER_01]: And he was amazed.

01:27:03.063 --> 01:27:10.592
[SPEAKER_01]: He was amazed because he looked up to Caesar and Caesar's operation was the one that they all admired.

01:27:10.572 --> 01:27:22.383
[SPEAKER_01]: But they achieved an immortality as writers, and the show achieved an immortality as a show that Caesar's never did, simply as a matter of technology, really.

01:27:22.884 --> 01:27:26.353
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's really one of the reasons that Caesar disappeared.

01:27:26.333 --> 01:27:31.398
[SPEAKER_01]: And the other is that he didn't take care of himself and he didn't reinvent himself.

01:27:31.858 --> 01:27:47.133
[SPEAKER_01]: He didn't, you know, he wasn't like somebody like Shelley Burm and went on curb your enthusiasm and Jerry Stiller went on, you know, went on too and they found other roles for themselves and Sid never managed to do that.

01:27:47.193 --> 01:27:49.315
[SPEAKER_01]: He never repackaged himself.

01:27:49.675 --> 01:27:52.358
[SPEAKER_01]: He never became the serious actor.

01:27:52.338 --> 01:28:15.443
[SPEAKER_01]: that Marlon Brando among other people told him he could have been because Marlon Brando spotted the truthfulness and authenticity of Caesar's performances and told him once in this amazing radio interview of that I got courtesy of Jane Claim at the Paley Center when Marlon Brando and Sid Caesar on the text.

01:28:15.423 --> 01:28:31.710
[SPEAKER_01]: McCreary and jinx falcon bird show once Marlon Brando is saying why don't you know why don't you why don't you go into serious acting because that's what you're all about I mean you're you're a great actor and you know Jackie Gleason played Minnesota Fats

01:28:31.690 --> 01:28:36.436
[SPEAKER_01]: Since he's never had a role like that, so he didn't repackage himself.

01:28:36.857 --> 01:28:39.561
[SPEAKER_01]: Sid talked to the people who did shears.

01:28:40.061 --> 01:28:51.216
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think it was a serious job interview, but he at least theoretically had a shot of a role on shears, and he thought it was a cardboard show, another sitcom, and you didn't want to do it.

01:28:51.737 --> 01:28:56.503
[SPEAKER_01]: And as I say, he badmouthed the people on Saturday night live after they gave him a shot.

01:28:57.104 --> 01:28:59.908
[SPEAKER_01]: So Sid also sabotaged himself.

01:28:59.888 --> 01:29:17.408
[SPEAKER_01]: There's one more, I don't know how this fits in exactly, but there's one more story about Sid that, you know, I think fits into all of this, which is Woody Allen, Sid, one of the, well, I, I, it fits in this way, that's Sid and Imaging.

01:29:17.388 --> 01:29:19.651
[SPEAKER_01]: were really strangers to one another.

01:29:19.731 --> 01:29:21.794
[SPEAKER_01]: They were telepathic on stage.

01:29:22.254 --> 01:29:24.838
[SPEAKER_01]: But they were strangers to one another off stage.

01:29:25.238 --> 01:29:30.926
[SPEAKER_01]: And yet they were wedded to one another in the public mind for the rest of their careers.

01:29:30.986 --> 01:29:38.856
[SPEAKER_01]: And everybody wanted to see them together because they had such, you know, they were so, they were, they were beloved in the, in the community.

01:29:38.836 --> 01:29:55.984
[SPEAKER_01]: of early television viewers and they did, so they chored them out together as awkward as they were and really as much as they disliked one another in a way or misunderstood one another and they performed them on other places at Michael's Pub.

01:29:55.964 --> 01:30:08.846
[SPEAKER_01]: And one time Woody Allen, and I really didn't describe what Woody Allen worked on a couple of specials for Sid Seaser near the end of his run, and was very much shaped by them, and very grateful to Sid.

01:30:09.287 --> 01:30:15.778
[SPEAKER_01]: Woody Allen and Dick Cavitt went to see Coco and Seaser together at Michael's Pub.

01:30:15.758 --> 01:30:24.390
[SPEAKER_01]: And afterward, they went backstage, this is described in the book, they went backstage to tell Sid how much they enjoyed the show.

01:30:25.011 --> 01:30:27.474
[SPEAKER_01]: And Sid said to Woody, isn't it funny?

01:30:27.975 --> 01:30:30.338
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm going to be a footnote in your career.

01:30:30.398 --> 01:30:34.624
[SPEAKER_01]: And Woody Allen said, what are you talking about?

01:30:35.265 --> 01:30:36.307
[SPEAKER_01]: What are you saying?

01:30:36.547 --> 01:30:41.614
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean,

01:30:41.662 --> 01:30:57.270
[SPEAKER_01]: And that, you know, that just showed, um, it was a reflection of the kind of disappearing act that Sid had gone through, but the enduring legacy and respect that he left behind and that people still had for him.

01:30:57.731 --> 01:31:02.539
[SPEAKER_01]: That's sort of summarized the situation that Sid found himself in later in his life.

01:31:03.042 --> 01:31:09.515
[SPEAKER_00]: John Stewart said on his death that we all lost our grandfather.

01:31:09.996 --> 01:31:10.477
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:31:10.877 --> 01:31:12.340
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's just a great quote.

01:31:12.761 --> 01:31:14.124
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, last this.

01:31:15.086 --> 01:31:15.346
[SPEAKER_00]: Sorry.

01:31:15.867 --> 01:31:16.849
[SPEAKER_01]: No, go ahead.

01:31:18.010 --> 01:31:34.671
[SPEAKER_00]: The last question I have for you is that his funeral in 2014, Mel Brooks in his eulogy says Caesar was born to interpret humanity and send it back to us in delicious and different forms.

01:31:35.372 --> 01:31:36.133
[SPEAKER_00]: Is that pretty much it?

01:31:36.454 --> 01:31:37.735
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's pretty much it.

01:31:38.116 --> 01:31:47.528
[SPEAKER_01]: And Mel said Mel also said

01:31:47.896 --> 01:31:49.498
[SPEAKER_01]: He managed to lift up.

01:31:50.759 --> 01:31:54.323
[SPEAKER_01]: So it wasn't, it was Caesar was not just a function of his writers.

01:31:54.383 --> 01:31:57.247
[SPEAKER_01]: Caesar elevated whatever his writers gave him.

01:31:58.108 --> 01:32:02.833
[SPEAKER_01]: And yes, I mean, his specialty was really humanity, human nature.

01:32:02.853 --> 01:32:09.181
[SPEAKER_01]: And that was, that was endure, that was durable, that was enduring, that doesn't change.

01:32:09.861 --> 01:32:17.430
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why the appeal of Caesar's comedy lives on because there are themes that

01:32:17.663 --> 01:32:23.856
[SPEAKER_00]: You said the writers would write their stuff, give it to Caesar, and he would Caesarize it.

01:32:24.177 --> 01:32:25.019
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's right.

01:32:25.259 --> 01:32:29.428
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and by instinct, he just had that knack.

01:32:30.623 --> 01:32:38.810
[SPEAKER_00]: The book is, when Caesar was King, House did Caesar reinvented American comedy, David Margalec, thank you so much for spending all this time with me.

01:32:38.930 --> 01:32:45.116
[SPEAKER_00]: I really appreciate it, and love this book, and can't wait to see the music movie adaptation of it.

01:32:45.456 --> 01:32:46.497
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, thank you, Michael.

01:32:46.577 --> 01:32:48.479
[SPEAKER_00]: I appreciate your appreciation.

01:32:49.020 --> 01:33:00.630
[SPEAKER_00]: Join us next week when we speak with Elliott Williams about his new book, Five Bullets, which explores the riveting events surrounding the shooting of four black teenagers by

01:33:00.610 --> 01:33:12.103
[SPEAKER_00]: That said, is produced by Compro and the Museum of Public Relations, and is a proud member of the MSW Media Network, theme music by Sam Post.

01:33:12.784 --> 01:33:16.869
[SPEAKER_00]: Please address any comments to that said, zeldon at gmail.com.

01:33:17.589 --> 01:33:25.038
[SPEAKER_00]: If you enjoy this podcast, please rate and review us on your favorite podcast app to help more people find us.

01:33:25.619 --> 01:33:27.681
[SPEAKER_00]: For that said, I'm Michael Zeldon.

