WEBVTT

00:00.351 --> 00:19.541
[SPEAKER_02]: So, this is obviously going to be a few weeks old by the time this episode comes out because peak behind the curtain we're just post-dating a few of our recordings that's going to change soon now that we're doing a bi-weekly schedule, but please allow us to be somewhat redundant.

00:20.041 --> 00:24.063
[SPEAKER_02]: Anacronistic, I don't know, out of date, for a few minutes.

00:28.825 --> 00:32.609
[SPEAKER_01]: I didn't, I haven't heard that much about it, but I'm nosy, and I want to know, so tell me.

00:33.289 --> 00:35.211
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, well, you know who Shane Gillis is.

00:35.752 --> 00:36.572
[SPEAKER_01]: Kind of, tell me more.

00:37.073 --> 00:44.580
[SPEAKER_02]: Shane Gillis is a comedian that my brother loves, and I know most of you don't know my brother, but it's a- It's a bit of a giveaway.

00:45.140 --> 00:47.503
[SPEAKER_01]: The word brother was so laced and loaded.

00:49.104 --> 00:50.045
[SPEAKER_02]: I love my brother.

00:50.065 --> 00:50.985
[SPEAKER_02]: We love brother.

00:51.785 --> 00:55.347
[SPEAKER_02]: We have very different senses of humor.

00:55.367 --> 00:59.549
[SPEAKER_02]: Like very, very, very, very different senses of humor.

00:59.569 --> 01:00.649
[SPEAKER_01]: Ham is brother.

01:00.689 --> 01:03.070
[SPEAKER_01]: I've known for 10 years and thinks my name is Aisha.

01:04.071 --> 01:04.671
[SPEAKER_01]: And I love him.

01:04.751 --> 01:06.612
[SPEAKER_01]: I think I just like, that's totally cool.

01:06.812 --> 01:07.452
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm fine with it.

01:07.872 --> 01:10.854
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, he texted me to be like, sorry, tell like,

01:11.894 --> 01:21.941
[SPEAKER_02]: He was trying to say talk tell my yeah, I'm sorry about that, but he's spell not that you have an easy name to spell, but it's it's for letters But it's a fake.

01:22.001 --> 01:22.481
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a fake.

01:22.501 --> 01:22.862
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a fake

01:26.944 --> 01:29.645
[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, oh, what is this?

01:29.665 --> 01:30.926
[SPEAKER_01]: How did you even come up with that?

01:31.286 --> 01:39.849
[SPEAKER_01]: Ever since I found out that my name is fake, I'd like all of my friends now can make fun of it because before they thought it was tied to some sort of cultural thing to do with me being Indian, turns out it's just fake.

01:40.009 --> 01:43.290
[SPEAKER_01]: And this is something my parents still deny, but I've realized it's true.

01:43.970 --> 01:45.031
[SPEAKER_01]: And now everyone makes fun of me.

01:46.413 --> 01:57.858
[SPEAKER_02]: I like sweated to people of like, oh, my friend her name is Maya and they're like, oh, where's she from and I'm like, well, she's half guy and needs but it's like has nothing to do with that.

01:57.878 --> 02:00.639
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I don't think I do with that, but like my whole family would deny it.

02:00.879 --> 02:06.442
[SPEAKER_01]: But now that all my friends have like total impunity to make fun of my vaguely ethnic name, like, I kind of regret telling everyone that it's fake.

02:07.102 --> 02:07.502
[SPEAKER_02]: I love it.

02:07.542 --> 02:08.623
[SPEAKER_02]: Your name is New Age.

02:09.168 --> 02:09.708
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, totally.

02:09.948 --> 02:33.957
[SPEAKER_02]: But yeah, shangles is a comedian who had previously been hired on SNL and then fired from SNL because within like five days of his hiring, someone unfailed old podcast clips where he used like a slur against Chinese people, that one, but feels like racism of the 90s.

02:35.097 --> 02:48.460
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, then he was like, oh, they were taking out of context because they were like talking about New York and he was like talking about Chinatown in New York and then he was doing like a mimicking like East Asian accent and then, yeah, use that word.

02:48.880 --> 02:50.220
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, who the fuck is short?

02:50.681 --> 02:54.161
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, yeah, there were other clips, but the thing is he's not dime-squary.

02:54.321 --> 02:59.282
[SPEAKER_02]: Like the Chinatown thing feels like a bit of a red herring because he's I saw someone know.

02:59.342 --> 03:01.443
[SPEAKER_02]: I think that's just like old school male comedian.

03:01.743 --> 03:03.084
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, yeah, exactly.

03:03.324 --> 03:06.726
[SPEAKER_01]: I remember there was like, I've been watching this stop for those healthiest.

03:09.488 --> 03:12.470
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm coming out of someone who listens to his podcast Davies world.

03:12.550 --> 03:13.911
[SPEAKER_01]: Something about him is so charming.

03:14.531 --> 03:16.792
[SPEAKER_02]: She's locked into Stavvy's world.

03:16.832 --> 03:21.555
[SPEAKER_02]: Can I just say though, like, bad actor, I hate when he shows up in the movie.

03:21.595 --> 03:24.557
[SPEAKER_01]: He's not, no, no, he's good.

03:25.158 --> 03:25.358
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.

03:25.378 --> 03:26.438
[SPEAKER_02]: No, he's not.

03:26.458 --> 03:26.879
[SPEAKER_02]: He's not.

03:27.299 --> 03:27.839
[SPEAKER_02]: No, he's good.

03:28.220 --> 03:28.500
[SPEAKER_02]: He's...

03:29.476 --> 03:45.027
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, but sometimes we'll have like old white dude comedians on and there was like one where like stalkers is a little like he's he's like a little Chappo trap like you know he's from come town so it's not like he's like doing polite some antics anything like that But those boys are like actually kind of soft wokey boys in there.

03:45.047 --> 03:47.209
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, well, well, they're like yeah, they're

03:47.609 --> 03:58.777
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I don't have a chronic stimulus, but like he'll have these like old heads on and the difference even between like strawberries and these guys, like how far these guys will take it.

03:58.817 --> 04:04.702
[SPEAKER_01]: Like I remember one guy calling in being like, hey, I'm a white dude who has a black girlfriend and black guys really hit on my girlfriend in front of me.

04:05.062 --> 04:07.444
[SPEAKER_01]: He was like just kind of trying to unpack the racial dynamics of that.

04:07.944 --> 04:11.785
[SPEAKER_01]: And this guy just like would not stop making like the most right.

04:11.825 --> 04:17.146
[SPEAKER_01]: He's a pretty famous community I don't remember his name now, but he's super famous He came up with like pretty some Neil.

04:17.186 --> 04:17.967
[SPEAKER_01]: It's confusing.

04:18.267 --> 04:30.590
[SPEAKER_01]: I think because he came up with pictures on Neil who was a black community and like he has just been going to the most racist joke So the point that like Star Wars kept having a jump in and be like please chill Anyways, it's just like so classic old head white dude comedian

04:30.890 --> 04:35.754
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, except Shane goes, he's new head, he's like the same age as all those come down guys.

04:35.894 --> 04:43.240
[SPEAKER_01]: He's just like, yeah, but there's like a grass fed type from like other parts of America that aren't like, it's worth what metropolitan.

04:43.700 --> 04:44.521
[SPEAKER_01]: Like Theo Vaughn.

04:44.801 --> 04:49.585
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, they are friends, they were staying at like Joe Rogan's like compound together.

04:49.605 --> 04:57.110
[SPEAKER_02]: There's an episode of 30 Rock where they're like, we need new talent for the show and we need to like make more appealing to like middle America.

04:57.190 --> 04:59.232
[SPEAKER_02]: So we like can't hire anyone who's like

05:00.673 --> 05:17.228
[SPEAKER_02]: so they go into like some little town and they're like let's find yeah like this grass fed comedian type and then remember you have to get corn food corn fed sorry I don't remember now I'm confused okay grass fed is beef corn fed isn't people oh yeah

05:20.059 --> 05:23.942
[SPEAKER_01]: God this whole liberal year over here.

05:24.162 --> 05:25.623
[SPEAKER_01]: You said that was so much convection.

05:25.643 --> 05:29.606
[SPEAKER_02]: It doesn't know the difference between grass and corn, beef and people.

05:31.487 --> 05:35.389
[SPEAKER_01]: You're all mean to me at the end of the night, mm-hmm, I really

05:39.490 --> 05:42.273
[SPEAKER_02]: Anyways, I actually don't need to sub-rise at old 30 rock-up.

05:42.353 --> 05:45.135
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, you love doing that, this is your favorite.

05:45.776 --> 05:53.182
[SPEAKER_02]: Basically, the joke is that this humble comedian, they go and then he's really misogynistic and rude and horrible.

05:53.602 --> 05:53.862
[SPEAKER_02]: Right.

05:54.203 --> 05:55.984
[SPEAKER_02]: Yes, the real America.

05:56.745 --> 05:59.647
[SPEAKER_02]: But no, Shane goes, yeah, one of those types.

06:00.168 --> 06:07.034
[SPEAKER_02]: So he got fired from SNL for racism, and then has now hosted three times, because he blew up.

06:07.394 --> 06:12.519
[SPEAKER_02]: he broke the Guinness World Record for most attendees of like a comedy show.

06:13.040 --> 06:15.862
[SPEAKER_02]: He has a show on Netflix, which Stavros is actually on.

06:16.523 --> 06:22.108
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's like, yeah, very much of this ilk of like a few, Theo Vaughn, like, bro humor.

06:22.909 --> 06:27.573
[SPEAKER_02]: Basically, all of his monologues, he's like, said pretty offensive things, but in this most recent one, he...

06:28.414 --> 06:29.334
[SPEAKER_02]: He was ripping on himself.

06:29.374 --> 06:32.616
[SPEAKER_02]: He's like, look, I'm out of shape, like I've gotten fat.

06:33.016 --> 06:43.700
[SPEAKER_02]: So I started going to the gym again, and I didn't realize this, but like women are just dressing like hordes now, which in light of like all the stuff going on with Cory Now has obviously caused

06:44.190 --> 06:47.292
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, I think it probably would have called controversy in a matter of what, but like, right now.

06:47.312 --> 06:53.037
[SPEAKER_01]: No, but I think there's always a moment where something somewhat related is happening and everyone's like extra heated about it.

06:53.057 --> 06:53.557
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.

06:54.418 --> 07:07.148
[SPEAKER_02]: So that is basically sparked controversy, because even glass your Lauren Michaels went on to say, like a documentary that he wasn't the reason Shane Gillis got fired, he wanted to keep him, but like he was pressure from,

07:07.848 --> 07:09.409
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, like network executives.

07:10.110 --> 07:13.011
[SPEAKER_02]: So I think it's just sort of like, I don't know.

07:13.111 --> 07:16.294
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, is how relevant is SNL today?

07:16.394 --> 07:18.115
[SPEAKER_02]: Anyways, is another question?

07:18.135 --> 07:22.818
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, they're having an interesting model where they've been really like hiring internet comedians.

07:23.438 --> 07:28.521
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, for on like, it's like, I was a Toronto, a homegrown Canadian woman.

07:29.042 --> 07:30.303
[SPEAKER_01]: How do I keep talking about people being homegrown?

07:30.323 --> 07:30.823
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if I can.

07:30.957 --> 07:33.679
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, as she grass fed, is she free range?

07:34.099 --> 07:34.679
[SPEAKER_02]: She's free range.

07:35.180 --> 07:36.180
[SPEAKER_01]: Fuck you.

07:36.821 --> 07:41.003
[SPEAKER_01]: But they've been hiring a lot of these younger kind of like with it comedians.

07:41.023 --> 07:46.147
[SPEAKER_01]: And then what they'll do is like post clips from the show and have the comedians collab on the post.

07:46.727 --> 07:50.529
[SPEAKER_01]: Colab post is like completely changed the landscape of branded Instagram.

07:50.549 --> 07:51.190
[SPEAKER_01]: Let me tell you.

07:51.370 --> 07:53.731
[SPEAKER_01]: But I wonder how that's gonna work for it.

07:53.751 --> 07:55.552
[SPEAKER_01]: And like honestly, some of the skits seem pretty.

07:56.613 --> 07:57.974
[SPEAKER_01]: pretty with it, I'd say.

07:58.194 --> 08:03.095
[SPEAKER_01]: So I'm interested to see what direction it goes in, but I am still like I do think Asynelle kills your aura a little bit.

08:03.495 --> 08:06.697
[SPEAKER_02]: I think that Asynelle right now is like incredibly topical.

08:06.797 --> 08:07.937
[SPEAKER_02]: Like do you remember when they did that?

08:08.417 --> 08:11.018
[SPEAKER_02]: There was a sketch or like dulypa.

08:11.498 --> 08:16.560
[SPEAKER_02]: It was a challengeers parody between a guy and dulypa's like sunny angels.

08:17.060 --> 08:22.242
[SPEAKER_02]: And I was like, wow, you know that they just have like a bunch of Gen Z people working on this now.

08:22.942 --> 08:38.592
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, it's also like really tapped into like internet culture and a lot of gay culture like it feels I don't know I feel like this like sometimes I will watch it and it does feel like it's tapped into an extent I don't know way that I would

08:39.892 --> 08:53.423
[SPEAKER_02]: I, sometimes I'm like, if I was like someone over the age of 35 and, you know, yeah, not like a cocerly, if I was a grass-fed middle-aged man, it's not just that I wouldn't find these jokes funny.

08:53.483 --> 08:56.025
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't think I would understand what anyone was saying.

08:56.865 --> 08:59.507
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but I think that's kind of the point is to start bringing in.

08:59.787 --> 09:04.811
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, yeah, they're they're not fully honoring I guess maybe they're they're audience who is like my parents who watch it.

09:04.931 --> 09:10.715
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, I think it's hard because like the young people don't watch TV like live TV.

09:10.735 --> 09:12.076
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, now they're for live show.

09:12.697 --> 09:19.502
[SPEAKER_02]: It's all about what can be clipped and so of course it's like then they're taking like Busy like internet things so that you can have like a

09:19.742 --> 09:33.591
[SPEAKER_01]: a funny five-second clip out of like a But remember that also a lot of the clips you're seeing weren't actually aired like a lot of the clips you're seeing or leftovers Like that's kind of the model as well and then they'll have like the digital shorts and I don't know I'm interested to see what happens.

09:33.671 --> 09:41.917
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean like there's there's a community named Joe Sunday who I follow and I think she's like really funny And she writes for them now and I'm like I'm always like where you behind this when I see something funny

09:42.329 --> 09:42.609
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

09:42.929 --> 09:44.150
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm interested to see what happens.

09:44.630 --> 09:45.891
[SPEAKER_02]: I like the direction they're going in.

09:46.892 --> 09:47.772
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's interesting.

09:47.832 --> 09:55.537
[SPEAKER_02]: I will say like every time I've watched a clip that has like Jane Wicklin or something like the Good One with the piano, which I think herself is funny.

09:55.577 --> 09:56.177
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like weird.

09:56.698 --> 10:02.881
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like comments from so many people being like, God, get her off the show, get her off the show, get her off the show.

10:02.941 --> 10:04.903
[SPEAKER_02]: I think there's just like a real sort of like,

10:05.963 --> 10:28.643
[SPEAKER_02]: uh miss yeah communication between like yeah what they're trying like trying to attract younger people who don't really like see it as relevant versus the people who like for them it's an institution whereas I think we're somewhere in the middle where like I did have the experience of like staying up to 1130 to watch it when I was like in middle school and like do have this at least like

10:29.163 --> 10:33.066
[SPEAKER_02]: Attachment to it even if like I don't always love what it's putting out.

10:33.086 --> 10:35.027
[SPEAKER_02]: We have a team of fairer Like we had a good.

10:35.647 --> 10:36.188
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, Chris.

10:36.208 --> 10:39.510
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's it's that was good times, but

10:40.419 --> 11:02.008
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, oh, well, okay, this is what I heard was that apparently he swore on live tv, which is like absolute no no like you can't do that at all He swore and it was like a big upset and he was kind of like, oh like when he did it I don't think he's gonna get invited back Maybe it was like really like a controversy Which I'm like oh my god fucking This is why I don't watch television Have you ever seen a senel UK?

11:02.568 --> 11:04.029
[SPEAKER_01]: Literally did not know that existed no offense

11:04.659 --> 11:08.602
[SPEAKER_02]: People have been like talking about it a bit more because it's, it's, you know, it started last year.

11:08.622 --> 11:10.243
[SPEAKER_02]: It's a trigger.

11:10.264 --> 11:23.974
[SPEAKER_02]: It's a tricky, and they're also like, they have more bite to them, like, which feels more in part with original SNL like they, they were going viral because they had like a good bit about like Ed Sheeran after that whole controversy.

11:24.655 --> 11:26.897
[SPEAKER_02]: British elevisions also had more of an edge than we have.

11:26.917 --> 11:28.858
[SPEAKER_01]: It's why I have such a soft spot for those guys.

11:29.079 --> 11:29.459
[SPEAKER_01]: They're funny.

11:29.859 --> 11:30.640
[SPEAKER_01]: Whereas we are not.

11:34.197 --> 11:43.441
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Ayya, and I'm Hannah, and this is Rehash, a podcast about the social media phenomenon that strike a nerve in our culture only to be quickly forgotten, but we think are due for a revisiting.

11:44.021 --> 11:48.403
[SPEAKER_01]: We upload on a bi-weekly schedule now, so you can catch us here every other Monday.

11:49.163 --> 11:57.967
[SPEAKER_01]: If you like our show and want to hear more from us, you can support us on Patreon at patreon.com-rehash podcast, where we have bonus episodes and early access to our regular programming.

11:58.287 --> 12:02.949
[SPEAKER_01]: If you don't want to join the Patreon, feel free to rate and review us on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

12:03.570 --> 12:05.034
[SPEAKER_01]: Minga's that helps a lot

12:37.812 --> 12:38.693
[SPEAKER_01]: little content warning.

12:39.153 --> 12:44.737
[SPEAKER_01]: In about 30 seconds, I'm going to be discussing the context surrounding someone suicide.

12:45.297 --> 12:51.841
[SPEAKER_01]: If you don't want to hear this, I'd say either skip the episode or skip about five minutes ahead in this recording because we don't talk about it.

12:52.482 --> 12:53.642
[SPEAKER_01]: Basically for the rest of the episode,

12:54.803 --> 13:01.728
[SPEAKER_01]: So, on June 20th, 2025, a woman named Michaela Reigns was found dead in her home from an apparent suicide.

13:02.268 --> 13:11.615
[SPEAKER_01]: Michaela was the founder and CEO of a Minnesota non-profit animal sanctuary called Save a Fox Rescue, which had a mission of rescuing foxes from local fur farms.

13:12.175 --> 13:15.657
[SPEAKER_01]: She started the sanctuary when she was 22 in 2017 and by 2019 it was the largest fox rescue in the U.S.

13:19.580 --> 13:28.166
[SPEAKER_01]: Sabifox's Instagram account went viral pretty often and Michaela ended up amassing a large online following where she'd document her work.

13:28.706 --> 13:35.110
[SPEAKER_01]: She was also quite beautiful and she had an only fans as well where I'm assuming that she was making supplemental income.

13:35.850 --> 13:46.057
[SPEAKER_01]: Michaela also had a number of haters both in real life from other animal rescues and frenemies in her personal life and she also had haters online.

13:47.077 --> 13:54.899
[SPEAKER_01]: Online, there was a subreddit called Save a Fox snark, which was dedicated to discussing all of the perceived issues with Michaela's organization.

13:55.419 --> 14:01.141
[SPEAKER_01]: The sub is privateed and basically to function now, but I have my ways, and I managed to get through.

14:02.181 --> 14:12.584
[SPEAKER_01]: And what I could see from the posts last year, was a lot of criticism about the way Michaela handled the animals, very like my new tracking of all of her behaviors.

14:12.984 --> 14:15.605
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, oh, she bottle fed this fox when it was too young,

14:16.445 --> 14:19.848
[SPEAKER_01]: She was breeding foxes and purchasing from breeders, which was unethical.

14:20.328 --> 14:22.170
[SPEAKER_01]: Certain animals were dying in her care.

14:22.190 --> 14:24.772
[SPEAKER_01]: She's bragging about how expensive her husband's car was.

14:24.792 --> 14:25.553
[SPEAKER_01]: That was one of the posts.

14:25.733 --> 14:28.896
[SPEAKER_01]: They were like, how dare she talk about how much her husband's car cost?

14:29.396 --> 14:31.798
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, those foxes can't even afford cars.

14:34.901 --> 14:40.746
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the wildest claim was that since Michaela posed with some foxes in her only fans.

14:41.408 --> 14:43.349
[SPEAKER_01]: Chew was engaging in like bestiality.

14:43.389 --> 14:44.409
[SPEAKER_01]: That's how people framed it.

14:45.249 --> 14:49.891
[SPEAKER_01]: Again, most of this, this is like when people see tits in public and they're like, we can't consent to that.

14:49.911 --> 14:51.091
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm like, get a fucking grip.

14:51.452 --> 14:52.472
[SPEAKER_01]: Get a fucking grip.

14:52.492 --> 14:55.993
[SPEAKER_02]: So like, which, like, where, where were the foxes situate?

14:56.013 --> 14:58.314
[SPEAKER_01]: They're like the foxes can't consent to being like,

14:58.754 --> 15:00.797
[SPEAKER_01]: It's actually like, I'm like, you, please.

15:00.817 --> 15:02.940
[SPEAKER_01]: Uh, I don't know.

15:03.081 --> 15:12.895
[SPEAKER_01]: Anyways, people took her posing with the foxes, like they said that that was bad in its own right, but then people took it to another extreme and we're kind of alleging that she was engaging in bestiality with them, like actual bestiality.

15:13.836 --> 15:20.261
[SPEAKER_01]: Again, most of this was unverified, but it's safe to say that the reddit was very fixated on Michaela's every action.

15:21.482 --> 15:33.210
[SPEAKER_01]: Michaela was aware of this community, let's say, of haters, and in the weeks leading up to her death, she had also made a deal with the local fur farm to purchase a number of foxes in order to save them.

15:33.670 --> 15:39.375
[SPEAKER_01]: And it seems like she was struggling with the workload she had taken on from this, like it was a lot of foxes she had purchased.

15:40.075 --> 15:54.448
[SPEAKER_01]: She was also receiving criticism online that she had done something unethical by giving money to these fur farms in the first place that you shouldn't be engaging with them and this kind of like monetary transaction even though what it results in is like foxes being, you know, removed from the fur farm.

15:54.949 --> 15:55.529
[SPEAKER_01]: When she died,

15:56.410 --> 16:02.177
[SPEAKER_01]: Her husband, Ethan, announced it in a post on the save of Fox Instagram, it's extremely devastating post, it's still up there.

16:02.678 --> 16:08.124
[SPEAKER_01]: People have speculated that the hate campaign was Astro-Turfed by the fur farms, but that's just conjecture.

16:08.745 --> 16:12.990
[SPEAKER_01]: And unfortunately, it's not out of character for a subreddit to get out of hands like that.

16:13.491 --> 16:13.931
[SPEAKER_01]: What?

16:14.788 --> 16:26.573
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, crazy, her fans established a change.org petition which stated that Michaela's death was quote, do in large part to horrendous cyberbullying by the subreddit, save a fox, snark, and many other wildlife subs.

16:26.953 --> 16:31.254
[SPEAKER_01]: And that quote, we need to tell Reddit and any other social media platform that this is not okay.

16:31.634 --> 16:35.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Sign this petition so we can tell the world that bullying is wrong, even in cyberspace.

16:36.853 --> 16:51.357
[SPEAKER_01]: Reddit responded by saying that they condemn and prohibit harassment and hate and that snark pages were regularly banned on the site They even pointed out that save a fox sub was not active before going private and had very few posts, although it seems like the sub was actually just scrubbed when Michaela died.

16:51.377 --> 16:54.938
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it was actually very active So kind of random for them to be saying that

16:56.218 --> 17:08.469
[SPEAKER_01]: I was curious about what Snark read it in general, thought about the situation, so I went onto other Snark readits, and I found a post on R slash LA influencer Snark from a person who said, quote, this is what harmless gossip does to people.

17:08.649 --> 17:15.976
[SPEAKER_01]: I get disliking someone or feeling like they're presenting a fake view, but dedicating hours of your life to reading and commenting mean things about them is so fucking weird.

17:16.276 --> 17:19.559
[SPEAKER_01]: The fact that no one on these subs finds that wrong is very disturbing to me.

17:20.480 --> 17:34.124
[SPEAKER_01]: many people in that specific thread talked about how what happened to Michaela was wrong but like few commented on the criticism of the snark in general that this person was making because again they're in a subreddit that is a snark subreddit.

17:34.364 --> 17:36.424
[SPEAKER_01]: The person who made that post actually deleted their account.

17:36.484 --> 17:38.865
[SPEAKER_01]: I think probably around when this happened probably because they realized that

17:39.285 --> 17:42.667
[SPEAKER_01]: that it was like bad to be a member of one of these Snarks.

17:43.748 --> 17:48.371
[SPEAKER_01]: One person in the thread differentiated themselves by saying, I snark on materialism.

17:48.531 --> 17:49.252
[SPEAKER_01]: That's my thing.

17:49.552 --> 17:50.492
[SPEAKER_01]: That and racism.

17:50.793 --> 17:52.834
[SPEAKER_01]: But there are some people who take things too far.

17:54.855 --> 17:56.256
[SPEAKER_01]: What do you use Reddit for, Hannah?

17:56.976 --> 17:59.157
[SPEAKER_02]: Researching this show mostly.

18:00.418 --> 18:10.563
[SPEAKER_02]: When I want to know what people think about certain reality TV situations, I'm really, I'm watching Vanderpump Rules all the way through.

18:11.443 --> 18:15.084
[SPEAKER_02]: Look, Emma, see, I'm probably going to sound like a hippocryte.

18:16.144 --> 18:31.188
[SPEAKER_02]: We neither of us are fans of Ariana Maddox, so watching the show back and I'm like, I don't like the way she's behaving right now, so I just wanted to know what people on their thought of her considering the fact that she's so beloved now.

18:31.569 --> 18:32.749
[SPEAKER_02]: I was like, how did that happen?

18:32.829 --> 18:36.290
[SPEAKER_02]: And back then, they're so little within the show to kind of like criticize Ariana.

18:36.790 --> 18:37.250
[SPEAKER_02]: in general.

18:37.590 --> 18:45.393
[SPEAKER_02]: She's kind of vilified, not vilified fully, but like she's antagonized for a few seasons and then apparently she has like a switch-up.

18:45.673 --> 18:54.576
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it wouldn't, she becomes less enamored with Tom Santival probably, but like right now she's like, I'm a guy's girl and like, whatever.

18:54.596 --> 18:55.336
[SPEAKER_02]: She's so punching.

18:55.676 --> 18:55.876
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

18:56.516 --> 18:58.718
[SPEAKER_02]: but see it look like a main gauging and snark.

18:59.578 --> 18:59.918
[SPEAKER_02]: What else?

19:00.018 --> 19:01.619
[SPEAKER_02]: Sometimes beauty things.

19:01.799 --> 19:05.842
[SPEAKER_02]: When I'm like, I want to know the best old brand alternative for this.

19:06.162 --> 19:09.284
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like crowdsourcing information more than anything.

19:09.824 --> 19:10.184
[SPEAKER_02]: Totally.

19:10.484 --> 19:11.085
[SPEAKER_01]: I do the same thing.

19:11.105 --> 19:16.748
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I typically, I have also done the reality TV show, like looking up my own opinion to see who agrees with me.

19:17.228 --> 19:21.189
[SPEAKER_02]: My god, watching the violin with my year, the whole time she's just, like, scrolling.

19:21.489 --> 19:27.550
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I'll just look up like the episode number and it'll be like the episode recap or like the episode life shot.

19:28.130 --> 19:28.830
[SPEAKER_01]: It's bad, of course.

19:28.850 --> 19:38.492
[SPEAKER_01]: Like reality TV has its own kind of fantasy league thing where it's like, you, you're like, you're lying yourself with one character or lying against the other character.

19:38.712 --> 19:41.433
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think like the frustrating part of watching them is that so many, like,

19:42.013 --> 19:45.716
[SPEAKER_01]: really unkind people get away with a lot of unkind things on the shows.

19:46.096 --> 20:01.768
[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, you feel like the only catharsis is for you to kind of have other people agree that what they're doing is wrong, like kind of verify it, but it is, of course, engaging in snark, especially because those, like the real housewives subreddit, like those people are going into there doing some investigative work, which we'll talk about.

20:01.928 --> 20:04.830
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, those are some malicious people for sure.

20:05.070 --> 20:05.631
[SPEAKER_02]: Of course.

20:05.831 --> 20:14.378
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that there is like a, you know, whatever democratic if you want to say edge to reddit, like, I typically use it to alleviate or like, sue with my health anxiety.

20:14.738 --> 20:18.581
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, if I'm having a symptom of something, I'll look at the symptom and then I'll put like reddit at the end of the search.

20:18.761 --> 20:24.145
[SPEAKER_01]: So that like webcam D isn't coming up and telling me that I'm like, gonna die in a day.

20:24.165 --> 20:27.007
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just more like other people going through the same thing.

20:27.708 --> 20:30.210
[SPEAKER_01]: Really, I'm putting in hours on the IBS subreddit.

20:32.051 --> 20:34.373
[SPEAKER_01]: It's really my friend at this point.

20:34.773 --> 20:50.183
[SPEAKER_01]: I also use it for PMDD, like I just feel like when it comes to women's reproductive health doctors are Honestly straight up only helpful to the extent that they'll tell you to go on birth control or like pop an antidepressant and be on your merry way Like they're so uninterested in like getting to the root cause of

20:51.044 --> 20:54.066
[SPEAKER_01]: what you're going through at all, like, from my experience.

20:54.486 --> 21:03.970
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I recently went to an OBGYN and it was a $200 consultation because I live in the States and I told her that I, yeah, I suffered from PMDD.

21:04.050 --> 21:07.312
[SPEAKER_01]: And like, two seconds, like, I had been speaking this woman for all of two minutes.

21:07.352 --> 21:08.733
[SPEAKER_01]: She was like, you should go on birth control.

21:09.333 --> 21:11.276
[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, honey, I'm 30 years old.

21:11.757 --> 21:13.779
[SPEAKER_01]: I have exhausted my options with that.

21:13.839 --> 21:15.362
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you don't think I've ever fucking heard of that.

21:15.522 --> 21:17.405
[SPEAKER_01]: And then she was like, or have you tried SSRIs?

21:17.485 --> 21:21.210
[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, you haven't even tried to understand like, why I have this in the first place.

21:21.230 --> 21:23.814
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, anyways, it just makes you kind of... Crazy.

21:24.855 --> 21:29.079
[SPEAKER_01]: So Reddit is kind of a good community for people struggling with like under research health issues.

21:29.099 --> 21:37.287
[SPEAKER_01]: I would say I'm I'm kind of moving like Miranda July's character in all fours, yeah, when she's she's in that Reddit to talk about I think she has like a miscarriage in the moon.

21:37.307 --> 21:38.929
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh anyways, haven't read it yet.

21:39.049 --> 21:42.853
[SPEAKER_01]: She's a really traumatic birth in the book and she like isn't the subreddit all the time.

21:43.499 --> 21:44.600
[SPEAKER_01]: kind of like commiserating.

21:45.061 --> 21:51.649
[SPEAKER_01]: Otherwise, I'm not really on there other than to do research for the podcast, but that makes it sound like a one there a lot, which I am, so I'll own it.

21:51.889 --> 21:54.653
[SPEAKER_01]: Well here, you know, I don't post research a lot.

21:55.313 --> 21:56.014
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, no.

21:56.435 --> 22:01.982
[SPEAKER_02]: I've never posted it in it in the only time I've ever commented in it is when I was in a sewing one.

22:02.402 --> 22:04.883
[SPEAKER_02]: And this girl had this gunny socks dress.

22:04.943 --> 22:12.547
[SPEAKER_02]: I have the same dress and those dresses are, I got mine for like 40 bucks, but like that just retails for like $500.

22:12.987 --> 22:15.208
[SPEAKER_02]: And she was like, I found this my mom's closet.

22:15.648 --> 22:18.489
[SPEAKER_02]: Should I like alter it in this sewing for them?

22:18.869 --> 22:22.651
[SPEAKER_02]: I wanna like upcycally and I was like, I simply can't let that happen.

22:22.671 --> 22:24.312
[SPEAKER_02]: So I was like, do not do that, that is.

22:24.745 --> 22:27.105
[SPEAKER_02]: a collector's item and it's like $500.

22:27.305 --> 22:27.786
[SPEAKER_02]: Good for you.

22:28.166 --> 22:30.686
[SPEAKER_02]: I just, I couldn't stand by and be a bystander.

22:30.906 --> 22:33.167
[SPEAKER_02]: I couldn't stand by and be a bystander.

22:33.287 --> 22:35.667
[SPEAKER_02]: She's gonna found a charity called Save Address.

22:35.987 --> 22:37.067
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, anyways.

22:37.307 --> 22:39.208
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, that's the one time I've ever posted in there.

22:39.688 --> 22:40.668
[SPEAKER_01]: We love to hear it, honey.

22:40.888 --> 22:42.268
[SPEAKER_01]: Your community member, for sure.

22:43.569 --> 22:45.269
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you ever go on snark pages?

22:45.569 --> 22:51.230
[SPEAKER_01]: And can you explain what they are for our listeners who don't know they're like, what the fuck do you mean by snark?

22:51.542 --> 22:55.023
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, so I have four research purposes.

22:55.584 --> 23:07.148
[SPEAKER_02]: So when we did our episode on Caroline Callaway, I referenced the Caroline Callaway's Snark page, and then they went and posted the episode in there, and they snarked us.

23:07.708 --> 23:09.689
[SPEAKER_02]: So we've actually been victims of snark.

23:10.129 --> 23:14.311
[SPEAKER_02]: But as snark page is basically just, it's a Reddit page where people talk.

23:14.687 --> 23:18.408
[SPEAKER_02]: match it about whatever the category is.

23:18.508 --> 23:20.949
[SPEAKER_02]: So sometimes it's dedicated to a singular person.

23:21.269 --> 23:26.011
[SPEAKER_02]: There's podcast, Nark, and pretty sure people have also talked mad shit about us in there.

23:26.491 --> 23:29.992
[SPEAKER_02]: The worst thing you can do is name search on Reddit.

23:30.052 --> 23:30.312
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

23:30.752 --> 23:35.813
[SPEAKER_02]: I have actually done that as well, and I vowed not to do it again, and it's been years.

23:36.333 --> 23:45.975
[SPEAKER_02]: But there's that, there's like general ones like influence or snarke, or beauty bloggers snarke, or when I was doing that, but so I don't like grow the find.

23:46.355 --> 23:50.516
[SPEAKER_02]: It was like a fundamentalist snarke, like that kind of thing.

23:50.896 --> 23:58.337
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's, yeah, yeah, it can be really specific or it can be a bit broader, but it's like a place for people to just talk shit, essentially.

23:58.697 --> 24:02.080
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah, a safe space, if you will, to just be willing, I mean.

24:02.360 --> 24:07.504
[SPEAKER_02]: But there was people do follow whatever the subjects are, like, really intensely.

24:07.544 --> 24:14.228
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's like anything they do is being put on there to be, like, basically, like, nitpicks apart by the people in the video.

24:14.248 --> 24:15.970
[SPEAKER_01]: You could almost call it, like, influencer watch.

24:16.470 --> 24:17.191
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, it's like a watch.

24:17.231 --> 24:17.771
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, yeah.

24:18.131 --> 24:20.933
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, which, which we're going to get into, how it functions that way.

24:21.214 --> 24:22.054
[SPEAKER_02]: Um, so, okay.

24:22.755 --> 24:22.915
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

24:22.935 --> 24:23.835
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's exactly it.

24:23.936 --> 24:25.837
[SPEAKER_01]: And Caroline Calloway's, we're so ready.

24:25.857 --> 24:27.038
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll come up in this episode.

24:27.693 --> 24:28.974
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, fuck those guys.

24:29.634 --> 24:30.455
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, be careful, girl.

24:30.555 --> 24:32.256
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm actually scared of this episode.

24:32.296 --> 24:36.540
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I'm a little scared to even talk about Snark Reddits because it feels like such a cancer.

24:36.620 --> 24:38.081
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, it feels like the second you talk about.

24:38.101 --> 24:40.723
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, you're on there, terrifying concept.

24:41.663 --> 24:46.427
[SPEAKER_01]: So the word Snark in the context of Reddit, it's understood to mean like gossip or a surrogate commentary.

24:46.447 --> 24:54.253
[SPEAKER_01]: A Snark subreddit is a type of Reddit group that essentially functions the space like Hannah was saying for people to vent usually about public figures.

24:54.733 --> 24:56.154
[SPEAKER_01]: and anti-fandom of sorts.

24:56.695 --> 25:01.839
[SPEAKER_01]: Some of the biggest ones are NYC influencer snark, LA influencer snark, and blog snark.

25:02.259 --> 25:04.561
[SPEAKER_01]: Like Hannah was saying, these are kind of the broader categories.

25:05.048 --> 25:10.129
[SPEAKER_01]: They're also countless dedicated solely to one specific influencer, so, for example, Caroline Callaway.

25:10.769 --> 25:13.790
[SPEAKER_01]: Sobredda is called Small Bean Snark, or the eye forgot that.

25:14.070 --> 25:15.931
[SPEAKER_01]: They're like roasting her for being tweet, I guess.

25:16.691 --> 25:21.712
[SPEAKER_01]: And these stark pages are focused on talking about the things that influencers do that annoy people.

25:21.992 --> 25:33.395
[SPEAKER_01]: So like being dishonest about products, they're selling, being out of touch, scamming, and what Snarkers perceive to be unethical behaviors, which we'll find out is a very loose,

25:35.255 --> 25:44.763
[SPEAKER_01]: The whole idea that we're being subjected to this influencer economy where influencers have all the power and can be poorly behaved without any real accountability is kind of like the crux of this.

25:45.364 --> 25:51.229
[SPEAKER_01]: I'd say that a lot of the sources I was reading when researching this episode were actually positive about the function of Snark Reddits.

25:51.969 --> 25:58.775
[SPEAKER_01]: Their kind of position is doing the work of interrogating and investigating the daily habits of influencers that mainstream journalists aren't willing to do.

25:59.516 --> 26:00.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Probably for good reason.

26:01.257 --> 26:10.540
[SPEAKER_01]: They can often take action like full-on going into financial records and sometimes even like calling child services on mommy bloggers, for example, that they suspect to be abusing their children.

26:11.280 --> 26:14.041
[SPEAKER_01]: Mommy bloggers are like a particular subject of scorn on these subs.

26:14.541 --> 26:24.564
[SPEAKER_01]: I'd say they're positioned as a sort of like checks and balances system against the governing bodies of influencers, like they are the Senate and Congress to the influencers president, if you will.

26:25.124 --> 26:29.585
[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of them function kind of like online communities, like people make

26:31.015 --> 26:32.535
[SPEAKER_01]: People make internet on these subs.

26:33.256 --> 26:34.056
[SPEAKER_01]: People make internet.

26:35.236 --> 26:37.356
[SPEAKER_02]: I hate when people make internet on themselves.

26:37.577 --> 26:39.857
[SPEAKER_02]: Honestly, internet on these subs.

26:40.497 --> 26:42.278
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll be like, yeah, people are here.

26:42.338 --> 26:47.759
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like it's like if you got AI to describe our show, feel like people make internet on themselves.

26:48.199 --> 26:49.619
[SPEAKER_01]: Two girls make internet on themselves.

26:50.780 --> 26:52.200
[SPEAKER_01]: No idea what I'm trying to say there.

26:52.720 --> 26:56.601
[SPEAKER_01]: They share advice with each other, or they'll recommend recipes or books, whatever.

27:02.522 --> 27:04.703
[SPEAKER_02]: But it's not, it's the internet and not the friend we made along the way.

27:04.723 --> 27:05.583
[SPEAKER_02]: They're internet friends.

27:05.683 --> 27:06.603
[SPEAKER_02]: They make internet friends?

27:06.663 --> 27:09.203
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's what I was trying to say.

27:09.784 --> 27:10.384
[SPEAKER_01]: Mm-hmm.

27:11.804 --> 27:20.225
[SPEAKER_01]: Or even, yeah, so they're resharing recipes or books and making friends, or even alternative influencers to follow who they find more appropriate, like they'll recommend those.

27:21.006 --> 27:28.807
[SPEAKER_01]: One person I was reading on a thread about Snark said that the Stark subs, which specifically call it religious abuse, saved this one poster's life.

27:29.527 --> 27:32.748
[SPEAKER_01]: probably similar to what you were talking about with R slash fundamentalist snark.

27:33.508 --> 27:44.330
[SPEAKER_01]: They said, I feel the work they do keeps things in check and calls out hiding child sex abuse among hundreds of other things happening that goes unchecked because religion says it's okay to abuse and just forgive and smile a bit.

27:44.731 --> 27:46.691
[SPEAKER_01]: Everyone in those subs are like tiny heroes to me.

27:47.031 --> 27:49.992
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel safer knowing they're there and they see it and call it out.

27:50.212 --> 27:54.593
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like you could say that that type of sub is a sub with like a very specific goal in mind.

27:54.913 --> 27:57.073
[SPEAKER_01]: The other ones dedicated to just general

28:00.275 --> 28:02.117
[SPEAKER_01]: Goal oriented, shall I say.

28:03.037 --> 28:12.146
[SPEAKER_01]: Different snargers have been interviewed by outlets who were covering snark reddit and typically they'll like defend themselves by saying that influencers are putting their entire lives out there.

28:12.206 --> 28:16.190
[SPEAKER_01]: So like an influencer would be naive to expect they wouldn't get any pushback.

28:16.830 --> 28:19.373
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, that's always the justification for this type of thing.

28:20.011 --> 28:21.872
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, they're like, well, you're putting like, you're out there.

28:21.932 --> 28:24.033
[SPEAKER_01]: So like, we have the right to be mad at you.

28:24.073 --> 28:27.214
[SPEAKER_02]: And especially because they're like, well, you're profiting off of like your life.

28:27.394 --> 28:33.456
[SPEAKER_02]: So then your life becomes content and your life is like up for criticism, at any capacity.

28:33.837 --> 28:36.878
[SPEAKER_02]: Your life is the commodity and we want our money back, but, you know?

28:37.058 --> 28:46.001
[SPEAKER_02]: And like with the content creator, it's like there aren't obviously like set boundaries of like when you are on or off the clock because you can monetize any aspect of your life.

28:46.442 --> 28:46.702
[SPEAKER_02]: So,

28:47.442 --> 28:57.066
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I mean, like I understand that that perspective to an extent, I'm just like, maybe you guys should get a life so true and I agree.

28:57.526 --> 29:08.951
[SPEAKER_01]: There was one Snarker interviewed who said that sometimes she second guesses her membership to these subs, but then she was like, If there was a piece with trusted sources about various influencers, knowledge is closing their financial interests, then that would be really interesting to me.

29:09.591 --> 29:11.812
[SPEAKER_01]: But there isn't one, so I go back to Reddit.

29:12.512 --> 29:13.773
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm just like, what do you think of that?

29:13.813 --> 29:19.615
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, do you think participating in a sub is a cathartic or productive way to critically engage with the influencer economy?

29:19.675 --> 29:21.415
[SPEAKER_01]: The way that these people are painting it?

29:21.435 --> 29:23.556
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, can you see where they're coming from, I guess?

29:24.497 --> 29:28.978
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's putting a lot of power into the hands of like these influencers.

29:29.259 --> 29:40.743
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, it's treating them like they're people akin to real public or like political figures or something where I understand that

29:41.183 --> 29:43.204
[SPEAKER_02]: It's important to have people keep tabs on them.

29:43.224 --> 29:58.094
[SPEAKER_02]: Like the reason that journalists aren't following their lives that litigously is Because it's not actually that relevant to us, especially if we're talking about like influencers that you know if you pulled most of the country most people wouldn't even know who they are.

29:58.494 --> 30:03.177
[SPEAKER_02]: Like if you're not giving them your money, I don't really understand

30:04.197 --> 30:08.358
[SPEAKER_02]: why people feel there's like a moral kind of obligation.

30:08.378 --> 30:09.398
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

30:09.878 --> 30:21.961
[SPEAKER_02]: Look, with the Caroline Calloway, it was like, I get this idea that she was genuinely scamming people and maybe I understand why people were at least a little like we should draw attention to that.

30:22.241 --> 30:26.402
[SPEAKER_02]: Do I think that they needed to integrate every single thing that she ever did ever?

30:27.042 --> 30:31.487
[SPEAKER_02]: No, I thought that's crazy, but I think there's like a line to be drawn.

30:31.607 --> 30:35.751
[SPEAKER_02]: I was like, well, I kept getting videos from this woman who has all these cats.

30:35.771 --> 30:44.080
[SPEAKER_02]: She's got like eight cats, but then she's also like, I'm an independent fosterer, but then she keeps like keeping some of the cats and she really just has too many cats.

30:44.660 --> 30:49.265
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think she used to be like fostering and hoarding and sometimes it's be pretty.

30:49.425 --> 31:16.490
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, yeah, and I was all the people on Instagram were like generally supportive of it, but I was like some of this stuff she's doing is so weird to me And also like she's to be like a beauty blogger and she like has like kid and she like keeps the cats and like this one room anyways Weirded me out, so then I did look her up on Reddit because I was just like someone must know the full story of this and then I did participate I suppose by reading the snark because I was like, this is weird to me.

31:16.510 --> 31:16.590
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah

31:17.630 --> 31:20.953
[SPEAKER_02]: But I wouldn't go anywhere further than that.

31:21.013 --> 31:23.456
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know where that leaves me as far as like culpability.

31:23.636 --> 31:26.619
[SPEAKER_01]: But no, I mean, I think you're not fully posting in it.

31:26.739 --> 31:29.381
[SPEAKER_01]: You're not like materially contributing to the snark.

31:29.421 --> 31:32.805
[SPEAKER_01]: I think in any real way viewing the snark doesn't really do much.

31:33.245 --> 31:36.469
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, yeah, I think there's a lot to criticize about the way that influencers move.

31:36.710 --> 31:43.418
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, I work with sponsors on my YouTube channel and like we work with sponsors on the podcast, but I'd like to think that's not like our main function.

31:43.939 --> 31:52.009
[SPEAKER_01]: Many of these influencers know that is what they do, like they sell shit to people for living and it's depressing and it can very easily be disingenuous.

31:52.449 --> 31:55.650
[SPEAKER_01]: But I guess for me, yeah, I have trouble seeing why this is like a necessity.

31:55.830 --> 31:58.871
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, to this woman, I'm like, could you not just like un-follow these people?

31:59.331 --> 32:02.992
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you're so put off by these people that you have to go join to subreddit.

32:03.012 --> 32:05.993
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's like, okay, but you could also just like literally un-follow them.

32:06.634 --> 32:09.755
[SPEAKER_01]: You don't need to buy shit that an influencer is selling you, you could discover stuff on your own.

32:09.915 --> 32:12.816
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I don't under, like, you know, it's not a vital necessity of life.

32:12.976 --> 32:16.957
[SPEAKER_02]: That's the thing is like, I think it is just like acting like influencer has power over you.

32:17.517 --> 32:23.725
[SPEAKER_02]: I've, you know, relatively online, and I've never bought anything, and influencer has tried to sell to me.

32:23.765 --> 32:25.467
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't follow any influencers.

32:25.587 --> 32:29.933
[SPEAKER_02]: You don't have to do it, and you can still be a functioning human being.

32:29.993 --> 32:33.177
[SPEAKER_02]: And then you won't hate some random blonde girl or whatever.

32:33.989 --> 32:40.253
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there is a bit of like a help me help you saying like yeah, they don't need to be broadcasting their lives But also like you don't need to be listening to them.

32:40.614 --> 32:41.214
[SPEAKER_01]: That's a choice.

32:41.554 --> 32:57.445
[SPEAKER_01]: You were making a choice But basically many of the sources I was reading were saying that snark pages have like a pro social function They're checks and balances against a largely unchecked and it's just industry They promote critical thinking and they foster community and the way that this was being framed really mean me think

32:58.386 --> 33:04.552
[SPEAKER_01]: of this recent spin on gossip that's been really like circulating around the internet as being like a feminist act.

33:05.112 --> 33:06.233
[SPEAKER_01]: Have you heard this theory Hannah?

33:06.273 --> 33:08.295
[SPEAKER_01]: This whole gossip is for women thing.

33:08.724 --> 33:13.647
[SPEAKER_02]: Um, yeah, it's this idea that gossip is like a way that women have like always socialized.

33:13.747 --> 33:27.634
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like ingrained into the interpersonal relationships between women and that gossip can also end up being a useful way of like conveying information to each other that discreetly.

33:28.034 --> 33:33.737
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, essentially, which as a gossip, oh, you're barely a gossip.

33:34.237 --> 33:35.338
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm a gossip.

33:35.718 --> 33:37.039
[SPEAKER_02]: I have a gossip with tact.

33:38.603 --> 33:42.526
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you're just like you're rarely like the conveyor of the girls I feel like you'll listen to it.

33:42.546 --> 33:46.409
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like sometimes it's because you forget the information that we all That is true.

33:46.469 --> 33:59.958
[SPEAKER_02]: I once ran into two people I know who would like start a dating, but they hadn't like really told people yet And I ran into them on a date and then One of them brought it up to someone else who knew they were like, oh, I ran into Hannah and they're like, oh, I didn't know that.

34:00.018 --> 34:00.759
[SPEAKER_02]: She didn't say anything

34:01.199 --> 34:05.181
[SPEAKER_02]: and they were so touched and then the other person was like, no, she definitely just forgot.

34:05.201 --> 34:14.967
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you should, you're like, you know, you just, it's more that you can't retain the information, long enough to like, bring it like, I'm always met like Hannah and I will talk and like, do you have anything for me?

34:15.347 --> 34:22.952
[SPEAKER_01]: And she's like, no, meanwhile, like all her gossip, at all, store it in the little storage container in my brain because I'm like, I have to tell Hannah this, she'll love it.

34:23.672 --> 34:26.994
[SPEAKER_01]: Even this morning, we talked in our 20-minute catch-up and I was like, Hannah, I have gossip.

34:27.258 --> 34:30.159
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't have anyone to tell you gossip about here, like, you don't know.

34:30.179 --> 34:33.379
[SPEAKER_01]: I want to know, you know why I just like to hear about it, even if it has nothing to do with me.

34:33.399 --> 34:34.280
[SPEAKER_01]: I know you're like my mom.

34:34.300 --> 34:34.760
[SPEAKER_01]: You know those.

34:35.080 --> 34:35.940
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't care about gossip.

34:36.300 --> 34:39.001
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't care about gossip if I don't know who the people are.

34:39.721 --> 34:40.101
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.

34:40.121 --> 34:41.301
[SPEAKER_01]: So this is what I was a year-not-a-girl.

34:41.321 --> 34:42.462
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think you could be so popular.

34:42.482 --> 34:43.042
[SPEAKER_01]: That is popular.

34:43.262 --> 34:46.863
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's so much more malicious to gossip about people you know.

34:46.883 --> 34:47.983
[SPEAKER_02]: I think I'm worse.

34:50.303 --> 34:51.264
[SPEAKER_02]: I just think Hannah's nice.

34:52.044 --> 34:52.864
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm not.

34:57.443 --> 35:02.126
[SPEAKER_01]: Or she's just ADHD, she's like the, is she skinny or is the outfit good?

35:03.287 --> 35:04.768
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's a bit of both.

35:05.128 --> 35:07.009
[SPEAKER_01]: If she's nice, she just forgot to be me, do you?

35:08.070 --> 35:09.971
[SPEAKER_02]: Is the dress black or is it blue?

35:11.372 --> 35:15.615
[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly, black and gold, white and white and black and blue, white and gold.

35:17.215 --> 35:23.520
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so yes Hannah, that is exactly what the theory, this kind of like reclaiming of gossip has been.

35:23.880 --> 35:25.762
[SPEAKER_02]: It's back to my research, let's make this clear.

35:25.782 --> 35:32.707
[SPEAKER_01]: So there have been a number of sociological and anthropological studies over the years, which have found that gossip has a positive function for human social groups.

35:33.247 --> 35:41.634
[SPEAKER_01]: There was this book by psychologist named Robin Dunbar back in 1996, which talks about how gossip is a bonding mechanism for social groups, almost like the way that primates

35:43.135 --> 36:02.218
[SPEAKER_01]: There's also this social psychologist named Francis Team Akandru who explains that gossip is a really powerful way for people to compare themselves socially to other people and that this is good at fostering healthy competition within groups in hunter gatherer societies for instance it was important for groups traveling together to obtain certain adaptive social traits like.

36:02.678 --> 36:22.995
[SPEAKER_01]: discerning a reproductably viable mate, managing friendships, and alliances, and keeping up good relations with families, and this necessitated an ability to predict and influence the behavior of other people, like a sort of social intelligence, which McHandrie says was often gained from obtaining information about the private dealings of other people within the group.

36:23.816 --> 36:34.026
[SPEAKER_01]: He says, quote, in short, people who were fascinated with the lives of others were simply more successful than those who were not, and it is the genes of those individuals that have come down to us through the ages.

36:34.226 --> 36:37.729
[SPEAKER_01]: I love being like my primate ancestors were such little fucking...

36:38.812 --> 36:51.315
[SPEAKER_01]: untrustworthy bitches, it kind of comes back to let little finger thing we talked about in the Perez Hilton, bonus episode, which you guys should go check out on Patreon, where does this idea like information is power I guess?

36:51.675 --> 37:02.138
[SPEAKER_01]: McGandre says that gossip can be a way of learning the unwritten rules of a group and a culture, a way to socialize newcomers into the group, and a deterrent to deviant behavior.

37:02.880 --> 37:07.187
[SPEAKER_01]: He calls it a low-cost form of punishment, almost like a regulating tool.

37:07.808 --> 37:15.420
[SPEAKER_01]: Can you guess how gossip became sort of like perceived as a negative trait as time went on and like a trait associated exclusively with women?

37:15.964 --> 37:41.190
[SPEAKER_02]: I guess because when I think about gossip, I think about women sitting in the parallel room who have nothing but idle time on their hands who are doing their little needle points and then spreading information that they may be heard through their husbands and whatever that they ought to not be like relaying and basically the idle mind is the devil's playground.

37:46.111 --> 37:48.192
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, literally exactly.

37:48.352 --> 37:50.774
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the idleness is a really key point here.

37:51.174 --> 37:54.936
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like while men work women sit around and jibber jabber basically.

37:54.956 --> 37:57.658
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so almost like a useless thing.

37:57.678 --> 38:05.643
[SPEAKER_01]: Like it started to be perceived as a useless thing once like women started adopting it because men didn't have time to do it because they were like working and not out.

38:06.283 --> 38:09.845
[SPEAKER_01]: I guess it's not that different than like they are hunting the ladies are gathering.

38:09.925 --> 38:12.947
[SPEAKER_01]: But like now it's like the ladies are gathering you're sitting in the parlor because they're forced to.

38:13.463 --> 38:28.017
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and then I think if you honestly just think about like any Oscar wild play like that's just like people sitting in different rooms Gossiping about the other people in the play like and it's mostly women and then like a bunch of Dandy is and like you know non-working men so

38:28.998 --> 38:46.879
[SPEAKER_01]: Listless upper class is exactly the case in the girls basically the girls in the guys So the term gossip comes from the old English phrase god-sib which means god-parent This originally meant people who were like not relative to the birth parents but close enough to be named a substitute parent should anything go wrong kind of like today

38:47.439 --> 38:52.521
[SPEAKER_01]: But historically, God's parents were almost always women, and they'd often be around when the baby was born.

38:53.161 --> 39:00.543
[SPEAKER_01]: Usually, in medieval Europe, the birthing room was restricted to women only, and this is where a lot of conversation would be going on during the long hours of labor.

39:01.143 --> 39:04.864
[SPEAKER_01]: So God said, became a bit synonymous with a woman chatting.

39:05.625 --> 39:08.706
[SPEAKER_01]: By the 1500s, the words started to take on a negative connotation.

39:08.906 --> 39:12.147
[SPEAKER_01]: One of its first known uses in literature is in a mid-summer

39:13.487 --> 39:24.236
[SPEAKER_01]: And the Oxford Dictionary defines God's sib as a woman of light and trifling character who delights in idle talk, good job Hannah, and was a tattler.

39:24.656 --> 39:33.583
[SPEAKER_01]: It's been suggested that the word became derogatory because of the idea that a group of women coming together and chatting, kind of meant bad news for men, like that's bad news bears we got to separate these ladies.

39:34.163 --> 39:38.747
[SPEAKER_01]: In the 1500s, there was a device developed to punish women who were perceived as gossips.

39:38.968 --> 39:51.619
[SPEAKER_01]: It was called a scold bride, and it was this iron cage like mask that you would wear on your head and it has like a flat, sometimes spiked piece of iron that would go into your mouth, so you could- Oh my god.

39:51.639 --> 39:56.464
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think it was employed that- I need to get one of those.

39:56.484 --> 39:59.166
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, she could put me in one of those, baby.

39:59.905 --> 40:04.166
[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes it would have a bell on the top of it, like, you've like, Asian styles, or like, a dud's cap?

40:04.807 --> 40:05.727
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, my God.

40:05.747 --> 40:08.748
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like... Oh, man.

40:08.968 --> 40:16.090
[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, over the years, especially recently, people have come to reclaim gossip as a socially positive force, especially shared by women.

40:16.631 --> 40:20.652
[SPEAKER_01]: There's this great quote from a literary scholar named Patricia Myers-Bax, that I wanted to read.

40:21.432 --> 40:24.976
[SPEAKER_01]: Perhaps gossip shouldn't be considered a mode of discourse at all.

40:25.356 --> 40:28.499
[SPEAKER_01]: People discourse to one another, they gossip with.

40:29.140 --> 40:32.643
[SPEAKER_01]: One discourse is from a height, gossips around the kitchen table.

40:33.404 --> 40:35.906
[SPEAKER_01]: Why value platforms to the exclusion of rocking chairs?

40:36.226 --> 40:45.035
[SPEAKER_01]: We need not reject discourse and it's concern with large truth, but we might acknowledge also, as the philosophers do not, the revelatory power of the small, shared truth.

40:45.595 --> 40:52.401
[SPEAKER_01]: She says there are two kinds of gossip, one that has to do with using private information for public ends, like advancing oneself.

40:53.002 --> 41:00.848
[SPEAKER_01]: This one she says is an expression of envy and aggression towards other people, but she does say that it still serves the purpose of social solidarity and information gathering.

41:01.289 --> 41:03.791
[SPEAKER_01]: The other one is what she calls the healing kind.

41:04.311 --> 41:07.274
[SPEAKER_01]: This takes place in private between smaller groups, and

41:07.474 --> 41:13.235
[SPEAKER_01]: and is more about discovery like who's sleeping with who and this is the one that happens mostly among women.

41:13.775 --> 41:29.079
[SPEAKER_01]: She also sites this Romanian guy she spoke with who said that men in Romanian gossip a lot and said the guy said apparently that American men are too competitive with each other to ever indulge in that kind of thing which I do think had a place into this growing theory I have that ethnic old men have it all figured out like

41:29.359 --> 41:31.921
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad was saying that, yeah, through your dad's, right?

41:31.941 --> 41:43.691
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I just like, I look at them and like, you're sitting on tubes, you're sitting at the patio, you're playing chess in the park together, and probably gossiping, whereas like, walls be men are completely siloed from each other and depressed and lonely and like killing themselves.

41:44.091 --> 41:48.315
[SPEAKER_02]: I am genuinely like, what do you guys talk about then?

41:48.815 --> 41:57.022
[SPEAKER_02]: Especially if you are like in a group or you don't know each other that well, if you're not talking about other people, what do you talk about?

41:57.652 --> 42:00.514
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like the ethnic grandples are definitely chatting shit, you know.

42:00.534 --> 42:06.977
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh my god, my granny, she was such a gossip apparently like she was just in everyone's business.

42:07.057 --> 42:23.866
[SPEAKER_02]: She was joining all these clubs just because she like she was a president of like the golf team that she didn't play golf but she just like wanted to like get in on the tea like she wanted to know what was going on with everybody in town and people would just pop, you know, island people just pop by her house and then you make them have a cup of tea and you sit at the table, what do you do?

42:24.106 --> 42:25.047
[SPEAKER_02]: You're talk about people.

42:25.465 --> 42:26.387
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's like a small tent.

42:26.407 --> 42:27.228
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like a village thing.

42:27.569 --> 42:29.172
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and that's kind of key here.

42:29.192 --> 42:33.179
[SPEAKER_01]: So, I don't know, how do you feel of a gossip, Hannah?

42:33.239 --> 42:35.342
[SPEAKER_01]: Like yourself, how do you feel when you gossip?

42:35.382 --> 42:38.528
[SPEAKER_01]: And like, do you agree with this idea that it's like largely positive?

42:38.908 --> 42:49.653
[SPEAKER_02]: This is what I mean, I'm attacked for gossip because I do find it can be cathartic to gossip, but I think you learn who you can or cannot gossip to and you learn how to gossip.

42:50.053 --> 42:59.377
[SPEAKER_02]: I think those are important because I think that everyone gossips to some extent, and everyone can gossip, but not everybody can be gossip to.

43:00.137 --> 43:28.690
[SPEAKER_02]: So I have definitely been the subject of gossip in my life for a number of reasons, and like I think when I was younger that What the type of thing kind of drove me crazy, but like nowadays and like I don't really when you can kind of anticipate that if someone is somewhere on else I would probably be talking about it That it's just like I think gossip is just a thing we have to do and like sometimes it doesn't actually mean anything like you're just talking about people

43:29.370 --> 43:31.612
[SPEAKER_02]: So I don't know I agree like I don't know.

43:31.712 --> 43:47.127
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm definitely a gossip myself, and I don't know when I come across someone who's like I don't partake in that I almost like immediately write them off because I'm like, okay, you're boring I don't know and I don't think they're being honest with themselves But I do have trouble with the idea that it's like necessarily positive or like a virtue

43:48.061 --> 43:54.227
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that it can be a- it can be- I think it's like neutral and then like sometimes veering into negative to be honest.

43:54.288 --> 44:01.815
[SPEAKER_01]: I think I view it personally for myself as a negative aspect of myself that like I'm okay with owning up to but I don't necessarily think it's like a nice thing I do.

44:02.036 --> 44:04.358
[SPEAKER_02]: There's nothing virtuous about gossiping.

44:04.458 --> 44:11.065
[SPEAKER_01]: Like no and I do think that this reclamation like sometimes when we reclaim things I feel like we need to so hard swing in the other direction to be like no this is good.

44:11.305 --> 44:13.926
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm like, no, I think it can be bad and just own up to that.

44:14.326 --> 44:19.809
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a necessary function of social life, but I don't think a necessarily needs to be like a good, like, perceived as a good thing.

44:19.829 --> 44:21.730
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, it's just kind of a tree.

44:21.790 --> 44:23.190
[SPEAKER_01]: Others the way you want to be treated thing.

44:23.230 --> 44:26.472
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I heard from someone recently that I was being talked about at a party.

44:26.512 --> 44:29.353
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was like, ah, I don't really know if I like this feeling.

44:29.833 --> 44:31.094
[SPEAKER_01]: And this knowledge, you know what I mean?

44:31.834 --> 44:34.475
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's like, I don't know, like, we could lead with that.

44:34.495 --> 44:35.916
[SPEAKER_01]: But it doesn't mean we have to stop gossiping.

44:35.936 --> 44:38.197
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's just a necessary aspect of social life.

44:38.517 --> 44:44.963
[SPEAKER_02]: Never tell somebody that they're being gossiped about, unless it's like a really specific situation where they really ought to know.

44:45.464 --> 44:50.128
[SPEAKER_02]: Otherwise, don't tell people these things, is I think the number one rule of gossip.

44:50.328 --> 44:55.313
[SPEAKER_01]: This one was kind of fine because it actually was a more positive story, but I was like, whoa, it's just really uncanny.

44:55.373 --> 44:58.016
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like senior side profile, you know, like I shouldn't know about that.

44:58.476 --> 45:00.498
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm an orb floating through space.

45:01.933 --> 45:11.278
[SPEAKER_01]: So when we look at Snark Reddit, would we qualify it as like healing gossip in the way that the Snarkers are trying to qualify it as undermires, SPACs, I don't even know.

45:12.099 --> 45:16.721
[SPEAKER_02]: No, what it is, what it is is akin to fandom, it's just like the opposite of that.

45:16.821 --> 45:24.826
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's already like, I understand that people are getting this benefit from it because like there's a social element to it, people are developing relationships.

45:25.346 --> 45:40.421
[SPEAKER_02]: It's an interest of theirs and people are finding like online community and whatever like it's fulfilling something that like I think people fulfill from fandom but like also the thing that fandom is that there is a line where it becomes unhealthy.

45:40.901 --> 45:43.943
[SPEAKER_02]: and parasocial, even if it's something positive.

45:44.043 --> 45:50.328
[SPEAKER_02]: So when you spend that and whatever you flip it and it's about something negative and inherently, then no.

45:50.889 --> 45:53.550
[SPEAKER_01]: Like finding community and anti-fandom is really strange.

45:53.991 --> 45:56.693
[SPEAKER_01]: It isn't inherently negative by definition.

45:57.285 --> 46:07.350
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly and it's I mean one like it's called being a group of haters and like that's not really Company, I want to find myself in Thank you very much.

46:07.490 --> 46:09.451
[SPEAKER_01]: I like I like having shared Hater.

46:09.491 --> 46:10.472
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel even with dating.

46:10.492 --> 46:20.417
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm like I need to have someone who can like hate on the same things with me Sure, like I like you have to be you have to engage in a little bit of haters, but I agree But this is people who's hobby is hating exactly

46:20.797 --> 46:26.002
[SPEAKER_02]: It's not just like a casual sort of chitchatting about, you know, a new story.

46:26.183 --> 46:34.071
[SPEAKER_02]: It is people following everything that these people do and like looking for more little pieces that they can like throw in the flames.

46:34.691 --> 46:35.192
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, yeah.

46:35.352 --> 46:41.758
[SPEAKER_01]: So I peruse the various like big star credits and mostly what I was coming across just felt extremely mean spirited.

46:42.619 --> 46:57.566
[SPEAKER_01]: For example, there was this one post on the NYC snark that was a picture of this single mom influence her named Brittany Lee Ball, where someone reposted a picture of her like hard launching her new boyfriend, and all of the comments were like, he's made out of clay, these are direct quotes, help why do they look conjoined here?

46:57.846 --> 47:06.330
[SPEAKER_01]: His face is literally melting, he must look worse in color photos, and she went for military wife to cause playing as a waspy and NYC's socialite to now being obsessed with London.

47:07.150 --> 47:09.371
[SPEAKER_01]: These people using the word cause play makes me just want to.

47:11.184 --> 47:32.583
[SPEAKER_01]: there was one post talking about how Georgia from too hot to handle got a bad boob job and like basically everyone doing semi-autics on the picture of her tits like they were like really trying to figure out if it happened one was this person reposting an in-spopose from TikTok that had been captioned a niche girl's idol and it features both like pictures of Lila Moss and this influencer Lily Chi on this slide I don't know if you've heard of her maybe

47:33.243 --> 47:40.786
[SPEAKER_01]: Lily Qi, I feel like it's a subject of a particular scorn because it's speculated that she works as an escort for high-profile men, and that's how her career took off.

47:41.266 --> 47:48.149
[SPEAKER_01]: And all the comments here are like, if I were my lilamoss, I would sue because no way they put my real NEPO ass in the same box as Lily Qi's.

47:48.650 --> 47:51.251
[SPEAKER_01]: And supermodels daughter getting compared to an escort.

47:51.591 --> 47:52.271
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, the Lord!

47:52.831 --> 47:59.074
[SPEAKER_01]: We're just so funny because unlike as if one of those is more virtuous and the other, like one person's a NEPO baby being inherently more virtuous than a girl who

47:59.374 --> 48:04.778
[SPEAKER_01]: Like I thought we were pro sex work, but when it comes to Lily Chee, it's like, it's the misogyny, it's like crazy with her.

48:04.838 --> 48:05.118
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

48:05.378 --> 48:08.720
[SPEAKER_02]: No, we're not actually, or not actually.

48:08.980 --> 48:12.142
[SPEAKER_01]: I was just like, when it's like a pretty girl, my god, I feel like people cannot handle that.

48:12.202 --> 48:17.326
[SPEAKER_01]: Like it's just like, when it comes to the subs that are dedicated to specific people, shit is even more insane.

48:17.766 --> 48:25.851
[SPEAKER_01]: So I spoke about this in our bonus episode about her from a few years ago, but there was a YouTuber named Ashley, also known as Best Dressed, who I covered in a video,

48:27.652 --> 48:41.378
[SPEAKER_01]: abuse because basically she was like cute girl making lifestyle content videos that were pretty innocuous if not a bit like overly confessional maybe and she generated this really bizarre or extremely obsessive young female audience who really started to turn on her over the years.

48:41.618 --> 48:48.081
[SPEAKER_01]: They got so bad that she ended up leaving YouTube for good and to this day she still has these people expanding to her comment sections asking her to come back.

48:48.541 --> 48:56.305
[SPEAKER_01]: It was also because this man had like stalked her and ended up on her firescape I believe probably from figuring out where she lived based on looking out the window of her apartment and her vlogs.

48:56.845 --> 49:01.387
[SPEAKER_01]: But I do think like another major reason was the sheer vitriol against her from her own fans.

49:01.907 --> 49:03.628
[SPEAKER_01]: They really are my worst nightmare audience.

49:03.728 --> 49:08.390
[SPEAKER_01]: Like the kind of people who comment on photos of you smoking being like disappointed in you Queen.

49:09.011 --> 49:31.879
[SPEAKER_01]: And it turns out a big breeding ground for this dynamic within her audience was her subreddit where people would be posting on an hourly basis about the most intimate details of this girl's life that they disapprove of, like, gossiping about the way that she handles her sisters eating disorder, how she won time-fucked her Republican, and even got to a point where they were going through her old Airbnb reviews and trying to cancel her for being like a bad Airbnb guest.

49:32.259 --> 49:33.639
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, just insane.

49:33.779 --> 49:34.580
[SPEAKER_01]: Insane shit.

49:34.760 --> 49:35.040
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

49:35.740 --> 49:42.385
[SPEAKER_01]: And when I made this video, which mind you is about several other celebrities as well, I started getting this influx of super negative comments.

49:42.585 --> 49:48.549
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it was like my closest brush to experiencing what it feels like to be cancelled because the comments were like really attacking me.

49:48.890 --> 49:52.892
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was like a barrage, like every minute a new comment being posted, that was really negative.

49:53.553 --> 49:59.998
[SPEAKER_01]: And it took me like way too long to realize that it was because my video had been posted to her subreddit, which drove all of these people over to me.

50:00.698 --> 50:03.179
[SPEAKER_01]: So since then, I've been extremely disturbed by Snarkreddit.

50:03.199 --> 50:05.860
[SPEAKER_01]: I have like a lot of trouble seeing the social benefits of it.

50:06.540 --> 50:16.463
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a tech reporter named Kat Tenbarge who's spoken about Snarkreddit, and she says that, quote, the trajectory these communities take is that they're almost always going to become more negative over time.

50:16.483 --> 50:18.084
[SPEAKER_01]: And why do you think that is?

50:18.124 --> 50:21.965
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, why do you think they so quickly veer into that territory of being like insane?

50:22.365 --> 50:26.207
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it's a bit of a slippery slope, I suppose.

50:26.447 --> 50:32.669
[SPEAKER_02]: You're like fueling your own hate or like discuss for this person.

50:33.350 --> 50:38.632
[SPEAKER_02]: So it makes sense that that would just like get worse and worse and worse as time goes on.

50:38.712 --> 50:44.194
[SPEAKER_02]: And then like, I think there's also like a little bit of yelling into the void and then being mad with the void, so yelling back.

50:44.234 --> 50:46.895
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like you're like yelling at this person and they're not responding.

50:46.935 --> 50:48.316
[SPEAKER_02]: And so like you're doubling down.

50:48.876 --> 50:49.817
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I don't know.

50:49.837 --> 51:01.673
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like when you have like an unrequited crush and then they're like continue to not match your vibe and then you'd like get more obsessive just because it's like you're literally throwing a ball against a wall It's like you're not getting anything back.

51:01.913 --> 51:03.175
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, the lack of colon response.

51:03.195 --> 51:04.176
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, sort of the lack of them.

51:04.296 --> 51:04.497
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah

51:05.418 --> 51:11.505
[SPEAKER_02]: I've never had a dream where you're trying to yell at someone and then in the dream they're not responding and so you're like keep yelling.

51:11.525 --> 51:16.592
[SPEAKER_02]: I like woken myself up actually yelling from like these dreams they're so frustrating.

51:16.612 --> 51:19.435
[SPEAKER_02]: Are you trying to get someone to tension and you're yelling?

51:20.268 --> 51:26.494
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm almost yelling at my sleep, but in general, I just know mine is like, I try and bounce basketball then I keep kicking it and then I have to pick it up and then I kick it again.

51:26.754 --> 51:28.716
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know how to throw the basketball in my dream.

51:29.156 --> 51:29.917
[SPEAKER_02]: Totally, try the brand.

51:30.798 --> 51:34.641
[SPEAKER_01]: I think a big aspect also with this here is that start credit is like, it's not the kitchen table.

51:34.781 --> 51:37.604
[SPEAKER_01]: Or like the birthing room, it's ultimately like a public space.

51:37.884 --> 51:43.209
[SPEAKER_01]: Where gossip can be read by the subjects themselves and like will exist in perpetuity on the internet.

51:43.869 --> 51:48.832
[SPEAKER_01]: I also think it's just really odd and unhealthy, just specifically form a community around the idea of gossip.

51:48.932 --> 51:53.394
[SPEAKER_01]: Like in person gossip is kind of like happenstance that occurs through other activities.

51:53.795 --> 51:56.276
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not usually the primary reason people hang out with each other.

51:56.896 --> 51:59.338
[SPEAKER_02]: And also it's like not usually

52:00.098 --> 52:09.649
[SPEAKER_02]: For cured through what is essentially stalking somebody like these people are like cyber stalking versus you know Two ladies like gossiping in the village.

52:09.690 --> 52:11.111
[SPEAKER_02]: They're not following people around.

52:11.131 --> 52:20.202
[SPEAKER_01]: They're just like hey a little birdie told me and now the birdie told you It's yeah organic and obviously girls can get out of hand in person too, but no exactly

52:20.582 --> 52:27.026
[SPEAKER_01]: And they're also creating this like dependent relationship where they like need the celebrity to kind of fuck up in order to be able to talk about it.

52:27.086 --> 52:33.149
[SPEAKER_01]: Like on Caroline Callaway's snark reddit, they do buy monthly roundups of all the post being discussed as if it's like an issue of the day thing.

52:33.609 --> 52:47.597
[SPEAKER_01]: There's also a post on a snark reddit dedicated to this food writer named Jack Monroe, which is another very active snark where a person was like, come on Jack, give us something to work with here, do a chaos, tell another outrageous lie, or divulge some personal information about a family member without their consent.

52:48.081 --> 52:48.521
[SPEAKER_01]: anything.

52:48.861 --> 52:51.042
[SPEAKER_01]: Just get back on your bullshit and give us some bullshit.

52:51.562 --> 52:57.283
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, there needs to be this feeling of like perceived negativity in order for the Snarkers to like have something to go off of.

52:57.503 --> 52:58.083
[SPEAKER_02]: How do I?

52:58.743 --> 53:04.544
[SPEAKER_01]: There's this comment I read under a YouTube video recently that is actually the reason I wanted to do an episode on this.

53:04.824 --> 53:09.405
[SPEAKER_01]: It said, I wish someone would do some sort of psychological evaluation into Reddit star pages.

53:09.745 --> 53:12.565
[SPEAKER_01]: The exhibit certain signs of mental illness, magical thinking,

53:15.506 --> 53:19.349
[SPEAKER_01]: but on a group level, and the group self monitors to make sure no one steps out of line.

53:19.710 --> 53:28.237
[SPEAKER_01]: It kind of turns into a role-play scenario where you're reading the comments made about a completely normal looking picture, and there's just full of them as random, no basis in reality, hate comments.

53:28.517 --> 53:34.202
[SPEAKER_01]: And you feel like everyone has agreed to play pretend, and actors have this very normal picture is for some reason offensive or obscene.

53:35.023 --> 53:39.227
[SPEAKER_01]: It's almost like the social, self-regulating element of gossip gone wrong.

53:39.907 --> 53:40.368
[SPEAKER_01]: What do you think?

53:41.128 --> 53:41.949
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, totally.

53:42.129 --> 53:43.930
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like the crucible or something.

53:44.010 --> 53:54.377
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like somebody's seeing something and then in order to belong in that group then you have to also be like I see it too and then it's like suddenly

53:55.177 --> 54:02.682
[SPEAKER_02]: people are picking apart things that either don't exist or fairly innocuous and like making something of them that they never needed to be.

54:03.203 --> 54:07.666
[SPEAKER_01]: Literally me and my friends like ghost hunting in elementary school or like seeing Bloody Mary in trend.

54:07.726 --> 54:08.106
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

54:08.246 --> 54:08.927
[SPEAKER_01]: Really believing it.

54:09.227 --> 54:09.727
[SPEAKER_02]: Exactly.

54:09.747 --> 54:09.967
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.

54:10.007 --> 54:12.009
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's just it's like piling up.

54:12.269 --> 54:21.736
[SPEAKER_02]: And like I remember being a kid and everyone deciding you didn't like this girl and then suddenly it was like whatever she did was actually a bad thing.

54:25.218 --> 54:28.699
[SPEAKER_02]: And you just start seeing things and you're just like, yeah, and I hate this about it.

54:28.740 --> 54:35.502
[SPEAKER_02]: And it's like things that wouldn't be necessarily like organic things you notice or be bothered by.

54:35.862 --> 54:37.743
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's straight up bullying.

54:37.763 --> 54:39.864
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I think it's just a bullying mentality.

54:40.124 --> 54:47.147
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think especially when you're taking action upon it, like your your golf, you're not only golfing, you're like actually acting upon your like total vitriol towards this person.

54:47.707 --> 54:49.868
[SPEAKER_01]: And you're doing it in like an anonymous group format.

54:50.153 --> 55:11.329
[SPEAKER_01]: There are many influencers who have denounced their own snarkredits and have called it a form of cyberbullying, which is very seldom taken seriously when it's perpetrated against adults, but a lot of snarkers who were interviewed in various articles kind of took the approach that the influencers bring it on themselves, by virtue of putting their lives at their for consumption, this one snarker said, if they want to say that they're being cyberbullied is sometimes it's a way for them to get more attention.

55:11.790 --> 55:16.273
[SPEAKER_01]: No one is trying to attack them, no one is trying to come to their home, no one is trying to beat these women up.

55:16.433 --> 55:20.974
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like they all use really dare I say gaslighty kind of thing like they're like you're insane.

55:21.234 --> 55:22.934
[SPEAKER_01]: We're not being mean to you.

55:23.435 --> 55:27.315
[SPEAKER_01]: This happened to me when I was foolishly engaging with these comments from Bestrests.

55:27.376 --> 55:34.297
[SPEAKER_01]: They kept being like you're just bullying us in this comment section because you have all the power you have a platform and it's like no you have all the power because you're anonymous.

55:34.417 --> 55:38.158
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm actually way more vulnerable because I have a face and there's like hundreds of you.

55:38.438 --> 55:41.139
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, it just feels like a child idea of human emotions.

55:41.499 --> 55:47.040
[SPEAKER_01]: And like, some of these influences are getting dogs, so I would say that like someone is trying to attack them and go to their home.

55:47.060 --> 56:07.345
[SPEAKER_02]: But then the reverse would be like, if they acknowledge it or like name the person who's done it, then it becomes, how could you subject that person to the eye or if your fans, like, people on the best resting, like, I was posting screenshots from the Snark Reddit, where they're anonymous, like, they're literal anonymous user names were on it, and they were like, I can't believe you would blow this up to your audience.

56:07.575 --> 56:09.516
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like you're posting in a public platform.

56:09.536 --> 56:13.419
[SPEAKER_02]: But that's why I think, partially where the Caroline Calloway snark read it was mad.

56:13.559 --> 56:16.761
[SPEAKER_02]: It was because we like acknowledged it in a public forum.

56:17.361 --> 56:19.203
[SPEAKER_02]: It's like, what are you, what?

56:19.703 --> 56:21.444
[SPEAKER_02]: Honey, you're talking about it.

56:21.484 --> 56:25.647
[SPEAKER_01]: I do think there is like a genuine mental illness, like group mental illness happening on those snarks.

56:25.767 --> 56:27.528
[SPEAKER_01]: Especially among these like young women, I think.

56:27.648 --> 56:29.449
[SPEAKER_01]: They're just kind of like teens in their bedrooms.

56:29.509 --> 56:30.170
[SPEAKER_01]: It's concerning.

56:30.495 --> 56:46.559
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, it's also like if we're gonna say that like people who post their lives on the internet aren't entitled to any form of privacy Then you posting gossip on the internet is also like you aren't entitled to have to do that privately Like that doesn't mean no exactly.

56:46.799 --> 56:59.903
[SPEAKER_01]: There was one post in a star credit I found which is like people talking about how whack TMZ is for tweeting about the aftermath of Presley Gerber's death and how nasty the paparazzi are in like taking pictures of Kai Gerber at his funeral It's very tragic situation

57:00.684 --> 57:03.592
[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know, do you see much difference between these things?

57:04.173 --> 57:05.937
[SPEAKER_01]: TMZ and like, snarkred it?

57:05.998 --> 57:07.963
[SPEAKER_01]: The irony of us being posted in a snarkred it.

57:08.217 --> 57:13.338
[SPEAKER_02]: I guess, you girls' TMZs going out and taking those photos or like putting people to do that.

57:13.398 --> 57:20.000
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, I understand the stark reddit is just then like the commentary, but they are stalking.

57:20.420 --> 57:23.781
[SPEAKER_02]: They are stalking in this in a different way, yeah, I think.

57:24.181 --> 57:32.243
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, it's like, yeah, expecting them to have like any kind of self-awareness, but like the hypocrisy of their own actions is like obviously a lost cause.

57:33.030 --> 57:39.576
[SPEAKER_02]: These are people who are playing moral police to complete strangers while being absolutely important.

57:39.876 --> 57:40.977
[SPEAKER_01]: What do we expect?

57:40.997 --> 57:42.759
[SPEAKER_01]: I think in some ways, it really is.

57:42.879 --> 57:43.960
[SPEAKER_01]: The social media popper-all.

57:43.980 --> 57:52.288
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like I was thinking about whether it kind of function does that, like know these people aren't following celebrities wherever they go physically, but they are like, again, tracking their every movement online.

57:52.968 --> 57:55.229
[SPEAKER_01]: And these people are posting most of their lives online.

57:55.249 --> 57:57.090
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's keeping like very close to abs.

57:57.510 --> 57:58.871
[SPEAKER_01]: They're exposing unwanted information.

57:58.911 --> 58:01.872
[SPEAKER_01]: They're profiting off of the information in the form of likes.

58:01.932 --> 58:04.173
[SPEAKER_01]: Like you are getting some sort of social cache for a minute.

58:04.933 --> 58:08.695
[SPEAKER_01]: There's also the element of influencers using smart credits to control their own narratives.

58:09.135 --> 58:11.496
[SPEAKER_01]: Kind of in the way Kim Kardashian holds the Papps on herself.

58:11.716 --> 58:18.559
[SPEAKER_01]: Like there's an influencer whose name is Elena Taber, who makes these cute lifestyle vlogs, which I actually watch.

58:18.859 --> 58:20.320
[SPEAKER_01]: And being the background for years.

58:20.980 --> 58:32.354
[SPEAKER_01]: Recently, there was a post in NYC influenza snark asking for information about Tiber and her boyfriend, who was a famous actor, and it provided a link to TikTok, which then exposed that the link was sent from Tiber's TikTok account.

58:33.415 --> 58:45.302
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and people have been like really mean about this, which honestly, it makes me really sad for her, like, the glee that she was met with from people across all of these subs, like it was it was being posted everywhere.

58:46.003 --> 58:52.687
[SPEAKER_01]: All the like shot and for it for this girl who's been like pretty inoffensive in the public eye, honestly, we're just so over the top.

58:53.107 --> 59:04.051
[SPEAKER_01]: Like I think it was just, I think it was a very human thing to do and like totally harmless, but I don't know, I just made me think about the way that like sometimes these influencers can be like benefit off the snarks if they were trying to like use it, right?

59:04.251 --> 59:06.552
[SPEAKER_01]: Because she I think she had been posting like this for years anonymously.

59:07.312 --> 59:09.253
[SPEAKER_01]: Kind of a way to generate buzz about themselves in the way.

59:09.273 --> 59:20.597
[SPEAKER_02]: Sure, the question to do is good publicity, like that makes sense, especially like if you were doing it in a way where it was like not overly negative, I totally get that.

59:21.954 --> 59:29.445
[SPEAKER_01]: Here's where I differentiate snark from like TMZ, other than like TMZ, physically stalking people that TMZ like knows it's goolish.

59:30.005 --> 59:37.977
[SPEAKER_01]: The popper Aussie know that they're a little ghouls, they're completely amoral, whereas these snarks operate with a level of like moral righteousness.

59:38.297 --> 59:50.521
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, that person's saying at the beginning that they only snarke about racism to differentiate themselves from the people getting mad at save a fox, but like, those people thought that they were morally justified, because they were protecting animals, quote, unquote, right?

59:50.541 --> 59:53.743
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like I only eat grass fed beef, like we were talking about earlier.

59:53.783 --> 59:55.523
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, okay, you're still eating beef.

59:55.643 --> 59:56.043
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

59:56.444 --> 59:57.424
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you know exactly.

59:57.824 --> 01:00:04.294
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a lot of arguing that these influencers are like larking, being working class, and they'll go through like family financial records to prove otherwise.

01:00:04.735 --> 01:00:06.197
[SPEAKER_01]: This is something they did to best rest.

01:00:06.297 --> 01:00:08.801
[SPEAKER_01]: They dox to her father, who's a professor, and who's job.

01:00:08.821 --> 01:00:11.766
[SPEAKER_01]: She like never mentioned in her videos, obviously, for his protection.

01:00:13.308 --> 01:00:21.556
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, applying social justice to the lives of people you don't know, just feels like such a weird individualistic solution to real systemic problems.

01:00:21.696 --> 01:00:28.202
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you're solving the classified because you're pointing out that this girl is in fact upper middle class instead of middle class as she claims.

01:00:28.590 --> 01:00:34.773
[SPEAKER_02]: It's also like, it's not the same as TMZ because it's like, there's people are have a passion for what they're doing as well.

01:00:35.513 --> 01:00:36.913
[SPEAKER_01]: Wait, the people who work at TMZ?

01:00:37.254 --> 01:00:56.481
[SPEAKER_02]: No, the people who are posting... Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah

01:00:58.362 --> 01:01:21.967
[SPEAKER_01]: Getting mad actually from best rest for like sleeping with a Republican is just just feels like a way to like morally A suede yourself if the guilt of gossiping about this girl that you just don't like I just haven't been able to tell throughout research in this episode of it's all because gossip has been deemed a negative trait Or because we're in this area where we just can't like own up to the idea that gossip is something we all do But that's actually not that productive when it's coming from a place of contempt

01:01:22.647 --> 01:01:36.559
[SPEAKER_01]: And I feel like the moral, the kind of like moral angle of these stars is an attempt to usher gossip into like current day situations and make it like palatable for contemporary life when what it ultimately is is just like contemptuous gossiping.

01:01:36.919 --> 01:01:37.640
[SPEAKER_02]: And perhaps

01:01:38.355 --> 01:01:51.915
[SPEAKER_02]: At the end of the day, these are people who have the human need to gossip, perhaps this is a built-in desire, since it is so part of our social lives as mammals, and they

01:01:53.377 --> 01:01:57.739
[SPEAKER_02]: actually don't have any friends to gossip to or to gossip about.

01:01:58.199 --> 01:02:07.263
[SPEAKER_02]: So they have to talk about these poor strangers on the internet because unfortunately no one they know in real life has slept with a republican because they don't know anyone.

01:02:07.963 --> 01:02:12.626
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like drawing a picture of a dog having never seen a dog before.

01:02:30.290 --> 01:02:30.820
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you.

