WEBVTT

00:01.613 --> 00:06.535
[SPEAKER_00]: A single gunshot booms across a dark windy golf course just before dawn.

00:07.875 --> 00:13.317
[SPEAKER_00]: First responders rush to a bleeding victim, only to discover the weapon has vanished.

00:14.598 --> 00:25.302
[SPEAKER_00]: Searching the damp grass reveals no footprints or attacker, just twisted string, scattered rubber bands, and chilling cash receipts for industrial helium.

00:26.807 --> 00:29.332
[SPEAKER_00]: This is Forensic Tales, episode 356.

00:29.532 --> 00:32.918
[SPEAKER_00]: The mysterious death of Alan Abrahamson.

01:01.178 --> 01:02.539
[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to Forensic Tales.

01:02.919 --> 01:04.560
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm your host, Courtney Fretwell.

01:05.100 --> 01:12.104
[SPEAKER_00]: If you enjoy deep dives into real cases and the science behind them, make sure you're subscribed so you never miss an episode.

01:12.664 --> 01:23.370
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you want even more content, including monthly full length bonus episodes in early ad free access to over 350 episodes, you can join our community over on Patreon.

01:23.870 --> 01:27.412
[SPEAKER_00]: To learn more, visit patreon.com slash Forensic Tales.

01:29.613 --> 01:36.182
[SPEAKER_00]: We discuss many sensitive topics on this show, and this episode includes discussion of suicide and self-harm.

01:37.023 --> 01:38.686
[SPEAKER_00]: Please take care while listening.

01:39.747 --> 01:44.614
[SPEAKER_00]: I'll share support resources at the end of the episode and include them in the episode notes.

01:47.135 --> 01:55.118
[SPEAKER_00]: On the morning of January 25, 2018, residents of a fancy Florida-gated community woke up to some very shocking news.

01:56.298 --> 02:04.821
[SPEAKER_00]: A 71-year-old businessman, husband and father, named Alan Abrahamson, had been found dead in a field not far from his house.

02:06.738 --> 02:14.386
[SPEAKER_00]: When the news first came across the desks of the Palm Beach Gardens Police Department's detectives, they thought they knew what had happened.

02:15.327 --> 02:18.630
[SPEAKER_00]: But the more they looked into Allen's death, the less it made sense.

02:20.612 --> 02:29.161
[SPEAKER_00]: Before his name made headlines in one of Florida's most unusual death investigations, Allen Abrahamson was a West Hartford Connecticut native.

02:30.625 --> 02:41.712
[SPEAKER_00]: After graduating from Kingswood High School, he eventually earned his master's from Syracuse University and became the owner of CNS, a building supply company in Windsor, Connecticut.

02:43.293 --> 02:47.235
[SPEAKER_00]: Allen had two children from his first marriage, Rachel and Daniel.

02:48.355 --> 02:55.860
[SPEAKER_00]: He later married Linda Gampel Abrahamson and became a stepfather to her three children, Stephanie Dana and Ben.

02:57.377 --> 03:00.798
[SPEAKER_00]: People who knew Alan described him as the life of the party.

03:01.798 --> 03:06.779
[SPEAKER_00]: He could sometimes be a little loud and obnoxious, but he loved to laugh and have a good time.

03:07.619 --> 03:10.440
[SPEAKER_00]: He was also an avid golfer who loved to travel.

03:11.580 --> 03:19.662
[SPEAKER_00]: But on a January morning in 2018, Alan became the center of a mystery that only grew stranger with every new clue.

03:21.629 --> 03:26.591
[SPEAKER_00]: Bell and Iel's Country Club isn't the first place to come to mind when talking about bizarre deaths.

03:27.391 --> 03:37.416
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a highly prestigious 24-hour, guard-gated, private residential club community situated on 1300 acres in the heart of Palm Beach Gardens, Florida.

03:38.496 --> 03:41.357
[SPEAKER_00]: It's also home to tennis superstar Venus Williams.

03:42.158 --> 03:46.739
[SPEAKER_00]: But that morning, Allen lay dead in an empty field near the community's

03:52.443 --> 03:57.847
[SPEAKER_00]: Just before seven that morning, a man arrived at the field in his golf cart to walk his dogs.

03:58.467 --> 04:05.632
[SPEAKER_00]: He'd already taken them out earlier around 530 to 545 and hadn't seen anything suspicious before heading home.

04:06.532 --> 04:12.996
[SPEAKER_00]: But when he returned, his dogs immediately jumped out of the cart and drew his attention to someone lying in the grass.

04:13.837 --> 04:15.418
[SPEAKER_00]: The man then flagged down a woman

04:20.621 --> 04:28.086
[SPEAKER_00]: When first responders arrived, Allen's body was still warm to the touch, suggesting he hadn't been dead for long.

04:29.407 --> 04:34.251
[SPEAKER_00]: He lay face up, his legs stretched out and his arms resting at his sides.

04:35.411 --> 04:41.596
[SPEAKER_00]: He was wearing light-colored shorts and a blue sweatshirt, a typical outfit for his daily pre-don walks.

04:43.111 --> 04:50.435
[SPEAKER_00]: Alan had recently started walking to lose a few pounds he'd gained on a cruise, then headed to Starbucks to meet a friend for coffee.

04:51.556 --> 04:53.817
[SPEAKER_00]: But that morning, he was a no-show.

04:55.699 --> 05:04.804
[SPEAKER_00]: The gunshot wound was right near Alan's heart, with unburned gunpowder particles on his sweatshirt, suggesting he'd been shot at very close range.

05:12.863 --> 05:18.126
[SPEAKER_00]: There was also an unexplained, small blood trail on his sweatshirt near the gunshot wound.

05:19.147 --> 05:20.508
[SPEAKER_00]: But here's the strange part.

05:21.609 --> 05:25.151
[SPEAKER_00]: No gun or shell casing was ever found at the scene.

05:26.732 --> 05:31.375
[SPEAKER_00]: When they turned his body over, expecting to find it, it wasn't there.

05:32.135 --> 05:36.438
[SPEAKER_00]: And even after searching every square inch of that field, it never turned up.

05:37.419 --> 05:40.781
[SPEAKER_00]: So if Alan had shot himself, where was the gun?

05:43.058 --> 05:47.220
[SPEAKER_00]: With no gun at the scene, the next logical theory became a homicide.

05:47.981 --> 05:54.564
[SPEAKER_00]: Someone must have approached Alan while on his morning walk, lured him to that quiet field, and shot him.

05:55.404 --> 05:57.686
[SPEAKER_00]: But even that theory didn't make much sense.

05:59.086 --> 06:04.589
[SPEAKER_00]: Alan's wallet was found in his back pocket, and the scene was filled with puzzling details.

06:05.470 --> 06:07.651
[SPEAKER_00]: Police found his cell phone and earbuds,

06:13.039 --> 06:14.383
[SPEAKER_00]: then there was Alan himself.

06:15.707 --> 06:20.561
[SPEAKER_00]: Who would want to kill someone described by so many as the life of the party?

06:22.643 --> 06:29.568
[SPEAKER_00]: Allen's autopsy was performed the next day where the medical examiner found a single gunshot wound to his chest.

06:30.709 --> 06:32.890
[SPEAKER_00]: The bullet had expanded into six points.

06:33.451 --> 06:43.018
[SPEAKER_00]: Severely damaging his heart, passing through both lungs, and breaking a rib before lodging beneath the skin of his back, and there wasn't an exit wound.

06:44.872 --> 06:49.917
[SPEAKER_00]: The first person who needed to know about Allen's death had to be his wife, Linda.

06:50.838 --> 07:01.169
[SPEAKER_00]: But when detectives knocked on the couple's $900,000, 5000 square foot home just minutes away from where his body had been found, no one answered the door.

07:02.130 --> 07:07.315
[SPEAKER_00]: Linda was thousands of miles away in Boston, visiting her daughter who had just had a baby.

07:09.050 --> 07:13.538
[SPEAKER_00]: When she found out what happened to her husband, she was completely devastated.

07:13.958 --> 07:16.643
[SPEAKER_00]: Telling detectives, he was the love of her life.

07:18.695 --> 07:29.781
[SPEAKER_00]: According to her, Allen had also been on the trip in Boston, but grew bored of staying in a hotel and decided to return home to West Palm Beach on January 21st.

07:30.461 --> 07:36.384
[SPEAKER_00]: But he was supposed to fly back to Boston to finish out the visit about a week later on the 28th.

07:36.944 --> 07:41.366
[SPEAKER_00]: But just three days before he was supposed to board a plane to reunite with his wife,

07:48.912 --> 07:57.596
[SPEAKER_00]: Linda told detectives that Allen usually carried between $300 and $500 in cash, held together with a binder clip in his pants pocket.

07:58.556 --> 08:01.377
[SPEAKER_00]: But the clip found near his body was empty.

08:02.478 --> 08:04.459
[SPEAKER_00]: They also couldn't account for a watch.

08:05.499 --> 08:14.667
[SPEAKER_00]: Linda had recently given Alan a large blue watch worth about $350, which she'd bought at a charity flea market the previous December.

08:15.388 --> 08:21.353
[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't wear it every day, but when she searched their house, she could only find its empty case.

08:23.385 --> 08:31.333
[SPEAKER_00]: with the cash apparently missing and the watch nowhere to be found, detectives wondered if Alan had been killed in a robbery gone wrong.

08:32.014 --> 08:35.718
[SPEAKER_00]: But Linda couldn't explain the scissors found near his body.

08:36.499 --> 08:39.662
[SPEAKER_00]: As far as she knew, Alan never carried scissors.

08:42.127 --> 08:45.348
[SPEAKER_00]: There were also two other obvious problems with this theory.

08:46.068 --> 08:51.110
[SPEAKER_00]: Number one, Alan didn't show any defensive wounds or signs of a struggle.

08:51.690 --> 08:56.252
[SPEAKER_00]: And according to his daughter Rachel, he wasn't someone she'd expect to back down.

08:56.952 --> 08:58.753
[SPEAKER_00]: If someone had tried to rob him,

08:59.293 --> 09:05.519
[SPEAKER_00]: She believed he might have fought back, and number two, this happened in a very safe neighborhood.

09:06.340 --> 09:12.746
[SPEAKER_00]: Not the kind of place you'd expect a 71-year-old man who was out for a morning walk to be robbed and killed.

09:13.426 --> 09:18.891
[SPEAKER_00]: Yet detectives hadn't found anyone who'd seen an attack or heard a confrontation.

09:20.153 --> 09:24.657
[SPEAKER_00]: If someone had approached Alan, there was no witness who could tell them what happened.

09:26.568 --> 09:33.911
[SPEAKER_00]: With Linda and Boston when Alan died, detectives turned their attention to the people he'd seen in the days leading up to his death.

09:34.672 --> 09:37.833
[SPEAKER_00]: And one of them was his friend Victor Greenstein.

09:39.334 --> 09:42.255
[SPEAKER_00]: The two had been friends since Alan moved to Belliniles.

09:43.036 --> 09:47.358
[SPEAKER_00]: But earlier that week, they'd started meeting for coffee at a nearby Starbucks.

09:48.613 --> 09:55.824
[SPEAKER_00]: That Thursday was supposed to be their third coffee meet-up, sometime between 630 and 645 in the morning.

09:56.545 --> 10:00.652
[SPEAKER_00]: So detectives wanted to hear from the friend, Alan had planned to see that day.

10:02.298 --> 10:06.721
[SPEAKER_00]: Victor described Allen as a fun guy people naturally gravitated toward.

10:07.701 --> 10:12.604
[SPEAKER_00]: He also said Allen and Linda had a great relationship, describing them as soulmates.

10:13.425 --> 10:18.968
[SPEAKER_00]: But when detectives questioned him about Allen's death, he wasn't able to provide anything useful.

10:20.109 --> 10:26.053
[SPEAKER_00]: He said he wasn't too concerned when Allen missed their coffee date, and just assumed maybe he overslept.

10:26.813 --> 10:31.237
[SPEAKER_00]: and nothing detectives uncovered pointed to Victor being involved in Allen's death.

10:32.338 --> 10:36.081
[SPEAKER_00]: He was simply a friend who'd been expecting him for coffee that morning.

10:37.983 --> 10:47.271
[SPEAKER_00]: Another person detectives spoke to was Allen's biological daughter Rachel, and what she said opened the door to dozens of new possibilities.

10:49.093 --> 10:54.736
[SPEAKER_00]: Rachel said that she and her dad had been estranged since her parents divorced several years earlier.

10:55.557 --> 10:59.659
[SPEAKER_00]: And when describing her father, she said that he was no boy scout.

11:01.340 --> 11:10.625
[SPEAKER_00]: She also wondered if his love of blackjack meant he might have owed someone money, or if someone had tried to rob him, could he have fought back?

11:12.326 --> 11:16.489
[SPEAKER_00]: She described her dad as cocky and said that would have been something he'd do.

11:17.923 --> 11:23.905
[SPEAKER_00]: But these were possibilities Rachel was trying to make sense of, rather than evidence of what had happened.

11:26.226 --> 11:29.748
[SPEAKER_00]: Allen's biological son Daniel said a lot of the same things.

11:30.428 --> 11:36.610
[SPEAKER_00]: He said that he and his father were also estranged, and the last time he saw him was about three years earlier.

11:37.471 --> 11:43.373
[SPEAKER_00]: He claimed to have no idea who could have shot his dad and was living in Texas at the time of the shooting.

11:45.283 --> 11:51.671
[SPEAKER_00]: In the end, nothing investigators uncovered linked either of Allen's children to his death.

11:52.492 --> 11:58.019
[SPEAKER_00]: Whatever distance had grown between them and their father, they were now facing his sudden loss.

11:58.940 --> 12:02.705
[SPEAKER_00]: And trying to understand what had happened just like everyone else.

12:05.105 --> 12:09.347
[SPEAKER_00]: That's when the police decided to look beyond Allen's family and close friends.

12:09.987 --> 12:20.211
[SPEAKER_00]: They started by reviewing surveillance footage from nearby businesses, checking reports of recent robberies, and stopping drivers and pedestrians in the early morning hours.

12:20.771 --> 12:22.832
[SPEAKER_00]: Hoping someone had seen something.

12:23.992 --> 12:32.319
[SPEAKER_00]: A crime stopper's reward was also offered, and Allen's friends pulled money to increase it, but no credible tips came in.

12:33.860 --> 12:43.167
[SPEAKER_00]: With detectives still investigating Allen's death as a possible homicide, they began looking more closely at his life in the days and weeks before he died.

12:44.528 --> 12:50.793
[SPEAKER_00]: His cell phone offered a place to start, and what they found led them to some unusual purchases

12:54.494 --> 12:59.855
[SPEAKER_00]: As they went through his phone, they used his Google location history to retrace his movements.

13:00.675 --> 13:04.636
[SPEAKER_00]: And that led them to a gas supplier in West Palm Beach called Air Gas.

13:05.737 --> 13:14.379
[SPEAKER_00]: There they found a receipt showing that Allen had bought a 40 cubic foot tank of helium on January 23rd, just two days before his death.

13:15.319 --> 13:18.199
[SPEAKER_00]: He'd paid nearly $190 in cash.

13:19.340 --> 13:20.780
[SPEAKER_00]: But why did he need helium?

13:22.602 --> 13:25.744
[SPEAKER_00]: an email in his Gmail account offered another clue.

13:26.584 --> 13:34.768
[SPEAKER_00]: On Christmas Day, he'd ordered a weather balloon from a company called High Altitude Science, which arrived at his house three days later.

13:35.849 --> 13:38.190
[SPEAKER_00]: But that wasn't his first purchase from the company.

13:39.774 --> 13:47.558
[SPEAKER_00]: When detectives contacted the owner, they learned Allen had also bought a smaller weather balloon and an inflater back in October.

13:48.719 --> 13:51.160
[SPEAKER_00]: He'd also been emailing the company with questions.

13:51.940 --> 14:00.024
[SPEAKER_00]: He wanted to know how much helium the balloons could hold, how much weight they could lift, and how high they could travel before bursting.

14:00.945 --> 14:03.966
[SPEAKER_00]: But there was one particular question that stood out to the owner.

14:05.307 --> 14:12.336
[SPEAKER_00]: Alan had asked whether an inflated balloon would lose much helium if he waited 12 to 14 hours before launching it.

14:13.918 --> 14:19.686
[SPEAKER_00]: The owner thought the question was odd because people normally inflate weather balloons right before launch.

14:21.745 --> 14:29.715
[SPEAKER_00]: Detectives asked Allen's family and friends, whether any of this made sense, was he interested in whether research or aerial photography?

14:30.396 --> 14:33.519
[SPEAKER_00]: Did anyone know of a hobby that would explain these purchases?

14:34.561 --> 14:35.402
[SPEAKER_00]: But nobody did.

14:36.283 --> 14:40.468
[SPEAKER_00]: Then investigators followed another tip recorded in his location history.

14:41.529 --> 14:52.447
[SPEAKER_00]: At a second supplier called Nexair, they discovered Allen had bought another helium tank on January 24th, the day before he died, and once again, he'd paid in cash.

14:54.469 --> 15:03.857
[SPEAKER_00]: So now they had two weather balloon purchases, two 40 cubic foot helium tanks, and a series of detailed questions to the balloon supplier.

15:05.298 --> 15:08.841
[SPEAKER_00]: Somehow, these purchases fit into Allen's final days.

15:09.462 --> 15:11.584
[SPEAKER_00]: Detectives just didn't yet know how.

15:13.608 --> 15:16.849
[SPEAKER_00]: Next, they looked at Allen's movements the night before he died.

15:18.129 --> 15:29.353
[SPEAKER_00]: According to his cell phone's location data, his vehicle had stopped for about 55 minutes at a business complex, just east of the field, where his body would be found the next morning.

15:30.548 --> 15:32.450
[SPEAKER_00]: What was he doing there for nearly an hour?

15:33.131 --> 15:35.093
[SPEAKER_00]: And did it have anything to do with his death?

15:36.114 --> 15:40.159
[SPEAKER_00]: And the timeline from the next morning raised another weird question.

15:41.160 --> 15:48.108
[SPEAKER_00]: Surveillance footage showed Alan walking out of the Belleniles gate at 553 carrying something in his left hand.

15:48.849 --> 15:51.352
[SPEAKER_00]: But it was too dark to tell what exactly it was.

15:53.383 --> 16:01.366
[SPEAKER_00]: About 37 minutes later, the camera's microphone picked up a single gun shot, but the shooting itself happened out of you.

16:03.106 --> 16:13.190
[SPEAKER_00]: When a detective walked from the gate to the spot where Alan's body was found, the trip took just over four minutes, so what had he been doing for the remaining half hour?

16:14.711 --> 16:19.612
[SPEAKER_00]: The answer wasn't on the surveillance footage, but a deeper look into Alan's Google account

16:23.133 --> 16:29.836
[SPEAKER_00]: On February 28th, crime analyst Colleen Machado examined his phone and found Google's myactivity feature.

16:30.936 --> 16:36.779
[SPEAKER_00]: It contained a history of searches and websites visited that had an appeared in the initial phone download.

16:37.920 --> 16:42.382
[SPEAKER_00]: That information was stored in his Google account rather than on the device itself.

16:43.902 --> 16:46.604
[SPEAKER_00]: She first came across a voice search about helium.

16:47.344 --> 16:53.468
[SPEAKER_00]: From there, she began looking for related terms, including balloons, guns, and suicide.

16:54.109 --> 17:00.573
[SPEAKER_00]: And over the next several days, she uncovered a search history, stretching all the way back to 2009.

17:01.853 --> 17:07.457
[SPEAKER_00]: Nearly nine years before Alan's death, he'd been searching for information about taking his own life.

17:09.362 --> 17:11.103
[SPEAKER_00]: the searches continued over the years.

17:11.823 --> 17:16.326
[SPEAKER_00]: There were questions about firearms, poisoning, and other suicide methods.

17:17.106 --> 17:22.930
[SPEAKER_00]: And in April of 2012, he'd also searched for information about life insurance and suicide.

17:24.491 --> 17:30.134
[SPEAKER_00]: By 2016, some of his searches focused on whether a suicide could go undetected.

17:31.315 --> 17:35.477
[SPEAKER_00]: Then later that year, questions about helium balloons began appearing too.

17:36.972 --> 17:48.425
[SPEAKER_00]: then, in February of 2017, almost a year before his death, Alan searched for information about fatal gunshot wounds and how investigators examined suicides.

17:49.766 --> 17:54.532
[SPEAKER_00]: One question was, can you have a gunshot suicide with no weapon present?

17:56.092 --> 18:00.095
[SPEAKER_00]: That was the very situation detectives were now trying to understand.

18:01.416 --> 18:04.919
[SPEAKER_00]: Alan had been found with a gunshot wound, but no gun.

18:05.559 --> 18:09.402
[SPEAKER_00]: And months before his death, he'd been researching whether that was possible.

18:11.434 --> 18:14.234
[SPEAKER_00]: more questions about life insurance surface too.

18:15.215 --> 18:21.636
[SPEAKER_00]: He wanted to know whether a policy would pay after a suicide and whether an insurance company could deny the claim.

18:22.456 --> 18:26.537
[SPEAKER_00]: And some of this evidence went well beyond just words on a screen.

18:27.937 --> 18:33.718
[SPEAKER_00]: Allen had used voice searches and recordings of those searches were still available in his Google account.

18:34.418 --> 18:37.859
[SPEAKER_00]: This meant detectives working the case could actually hear him

18:41.508 --> 18:47.011
[SPEAKER_00]: In the days just before his death, his searches became more closely connected to his movements.

18:48.292 --> 18:55.456
[SPEAKER_00]: He looked up local helium suppliers, sunrise and sunset times, and traffic information for Palm Beach County.

18:56.296 --> 19:05.641
[SPEAKER_00]: He also had made voice command searches on the phone, asking, do life insurance policies pay for suicide, the lifting capacity of a three-foot balloon,

19:10.895 --> 19:15.802
[SPEAKER_00]: His final recorded search on January 24th was for Don and Dusk Times.

19:17.698 --> 19:25.040
[SPEAKER_00]: Armed with the Google searches for suicide that spanned back a decade, the purchases for helium and a weather balloon.

19:25.880 --> 19:28.821
[SPEAKER_00]: The mysterious visit to the field the night before.

19:29.621 --> 19:43.765
[SPEAKER_00]: The police developed a wild theory that maybe Allen had committed suicide by tying a string to the weather balloon and attaching the gun to the string, so that when he shot himself, the weapon would then be carried up into the air with the balloon.

19:44.525 --> 19:53.647
[SPEAKER_00]: That would also explain the string and rubber bands found at the scene, along with the mysterious small blood trail on Allen's sweatshirt near the gunshot wound.

19:54.447 --> 20:00.088
[SPEAKER_00]: Investigators believed the string and rubber bands were part of the setup connecting the gun to the balloon.

20:00.828 --> 20:09.610
[SPEAKER_00]: And as the balloon lifted the gun away, the string may have dragged through the blood on Allen's sweatshirt, leaving that thin streak behind.

20:11.533 --> 20:15.214
[SPEAKER_00]: Authorities also found a connection between the field and Allen's home.

20:16.115 --> 20:21.476
[SPEAKER_00]: When your mental health is suffering, therapy can help, but sometimes it's not the whole answer.

20:22.457 --> 20:30.840
[SPEAKER_00]: Talk eye-a-tree gives you access to real psychiatric care with licensed clinicians who can diagnose and prescribe medication if it's right for you.

20:31.760 --> 20:34.241
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a simple way to get effective treatment right from home.

20:35.671 --> 20:38.912
[SPEAKER_00]: Unlike therapy-only platforms, this is psychiatry.

20:39.732 --> 20:46.494
[SPEAKER_00]: You're seeing a medical provider who can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication when it's appropriate.

20:47.374 --> 20:59.317
[SPEAKER_00]: You can meet with a licensed psychiatrist who takes the time to understand what's going on, builds a personalized treatment plan, and supports you over time with consistent, evidence-based care.

21:03.478 --> 21:09.045
[SPEAKER_00]: to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes.

21:09.646 --> 21:16.194
[SPEAKER_00]: That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y dot com slash tails to get matched in minutes.

21:17.035 --> 21:19.358
[SPEAKER_00]: Talkiatree dot com slash tails.

21:20.772 --> 21:29.277
[SPEAKER_00]: During another search on February 5th, they discovered not-ed white string and colored rubber bands about 40 yards from where his body had been found.

21:30.097 --> 21:33.199
[SPEAKER_00]: Later that day, detectives searched his home office.

21:33.939 --> 21:41.843
[SPEAKER_00]: Inside his desk drawers, they found a role of white string and a bag of colored rubber bands consistent with the ones recovered in the field.

21:43.944 --> 21:49.027
[SPEAKER_00]: As crazy as this theory is, Allen Abrahamson wouldn't be the first person to attempt this.

21:51.406 --> 22:03.713
[SPEAKER_00]: On March 15, 2008, 55-year-old Thomas Hickman, a regional manager for Red Lobster who lived in Texas, was found dead along a highway southeast of Santa Rosa.

22:04.714 --> 22:09.517
[SPEAKER_00]: His mouth was covered with duct tape, and the police initially suspected someone had killed him.

22:10.479 --> 22:14.401
[SPEAKER_00]: But only about 30 feet from his body, they found an unusual clue.

22:15.141 --> 22:19.504
[SPEAKER_00]: Six or seven white balloons tangled in a cactus with a revolver attached.

22:20.604 --> 22:27.248
[SPEAKER_00]: So the police wondered if the balloons were supposed to carry the gun away, leaving behind what looked like a murder scene.

22:28.208 --> 22:29.989
[SPEAKER_00]: Instead, they'd become caught nearby.

22:31.397 --> 22:33.681
[SPEAKER_00]: Other evidence also pointed back to Hickman.

22:34.262 --> 22:42.895
[SPEAKER_00]: The gun had been altered in what investigators believed was an attempt to reduce its weight, and matching metal shavings were found in his garage in Texas.

22:44.310 --> 22:53.795
[SPEAKER_00]: There was one spent cartridge case in the revolver's cylinder and no signs of a struggle, and despite the tape over his mouth, Hickman hadn't been otherwise restrained.

22:55.316 --> 23:02.540
[SPEAKER_00]: His death was ultimately ruled a suicide, and police concluded that the scene had been deliberately arranged to look like a homicide.

23:03.680 --> 23:05.260
[SPEAKER_00]: Then there was the television connection.

23:06.461 --> 23:13.902
[SPEAKER_00]: People kept telling the lead detective that an old episode of CSI crime scene investigation featured a similar scenario.

23:14.562 --> 23:16.663
[SPEAKER_00]: So he rented the episode and took notes.

23:17.663 --> 23:27.305
[SPEAKER_00]: The episode, which aired in October of 2003, included a storyline involving helium balloons attached to a gun to carry it away after a suicide.

23:28.845 --> 23:36.090
[SPEAKER_00]: Police were careful to say they couldn't prove Hickman had watched it, but the similarities gave them another example to consider.

23:36.810 --> 23:44.515
[SPEAKER_00]: And nearly 10 years later, Allen's investigators would encounter both the New Mexico case and that same fictional storyline.

23:46.356 --> 23:51.039
[SPEAKER_00]: To prove that's what Allen did, the police needed to find either the balloon or the gun.

23:51.880 --> 23:54.421
[SPEAKER_00]: And here's where this story gets even more bizarre.

23:59.174 --> 24:02.475
[SPEAKER_00]: Detectives tried several ways to track down the missing balloon.

24:03.035 --> 24:08.197
[SPEAKER_00]: They first contacted the airport's air traffic control tower, but nothing had appeared on radar.

24:08.917 --> 24:13.319
[SPEAKER_00]: Then they spoke with a television news helicopter that had been flying nearby that morning.

24:13.959 --> 24:16.180
[SPEAKER_00]: But its reporter hadn't seen anything either.

24:17.180 --> 24:24.488
[SPEAKER_00]: They also search the field with a drone, cut back thick vegetation, and brought in divers to search nearby water.

24:25.209 --> 24:32.137
[SPEAKER_00]: They even alerted other law enforcement agencies to ask whether anyone had recovered a weather balloon or pieces of one.

24:33.495 --> 24:40.217
[SPEAKER_00]: When all of that turned up empty, they consulted the balloon supplier and used a computer model to estimate its possible route.

24:41.197 --> 24:47.399
[SPEAKER_00]: But to make things even more complicated, it had been a windy morning with gusts reaching 32 miles per hour.

24:48.859 --> 24:54.961
[SPEAKER_00]: The model suggested the balloon could have traveled out over the Atlantic and burst somewhere north of the Bahamas.

24:56.081 --> 25:00.382
[SPEAKER_00]: So although the experiment offered a possible explanation for where the gun had gone,

25:00.940 --> 25:02.120
[SPEAKER_00]: It's never been recovered.

25:03.261 --> 25:07.842
[SPEAKER_00]: If Allen never wanted anyone to find the gun that killed him, he was successful.

25:10.722 --> 25:24.286
[SPEAKER_00]: When the Palm Beach Gardens detectives approached Allen's family about their theory, they were genuinely shocked, not just because of the crazy way he might have carried this out, but because the Allen they knew wasn't suicidal.

25:29.267 --> 25:33.290
[SPEAKER_00]: And by all outward appearances, he seemed like a totally happy guy.

25:34.170 --> 25:43.596
[SPEAKER_00]: So for this suicide theory to become plausible, Alan Abrahamson had to be someone who was suffering in silence, and that dates back over a decade.

25:44.396 --> 25:51.421
[SPEAKER_00]: The police found digital evidence on his cell phone and computers suggesting he had been thinking about suicide for a long time.

25:52.101 --> 25:54.503
[SPEAKER_00]: This wasn't something he thought about for a few months.

25:55.283 --> 25:59.385
[SPEAKER_00]: These thoughts lasted years, but Alan allegedly never told anyone.

26:00.566 --> 26:05.649
[SPEAKER_00]: To the outside world, he was this happy, loud guy, married to the love of his life.

26:06.510 --> 26:10.072
[SPEAKER_00]: But investigators were starting to realize it was all a show.

26:12.113 --> 26:22.339
[SPEAKER_00]: Even without either the gun or the balloon, the police presented their findings to the state attorney's office on March 5, 2018, which accepted the case as a suicide.

26:23.638 --> 26:32.248
[SPEAKER_00]: The next day, they met with the medical examiner who agreed that the official manner of death would be changed once her final report was complete.

26:33.910 --> 26:41.298
[SPEAKER_00]: Although the forensic evidence initially suggested Allen had been murdered, that same evidence now proved suicide.

26:43.395 --> 26:49.542
[SPEAKER_00]: When Alan died, he had several life insurance policies naming his wife Linda as the beneficiary.

26:50.183 --> 27:00.134
[SPEAKER_00]: Many policies have a suicide exclusion, meaning they won't pay the full death benefit if someone takes their own life within a certain period after buying the coverage.

27:00.932 --> 27:08.240
[SPEAKER_00]: The idea is to discourage people from purchasing a policy with plans to end their life and leave the money to their family.

27:08.920 --> 27:18.070
[SPEAKER_00]: But according to the television show, accident, suicide, or murder, Alan had held his policies for years, and those exclusion periods had already passed.

27:18.770 --> 27:23.611
[SPEAKER_00]: So the insurers paid the claims, and Linda received an undisclosed amount.

27:24.352 --> 27:29.113
[SPEAKER_00]: And to this day, it's unclear whether that was part of Allen's plan all along.

27:29.873 --> 27:37.795
[SPEAKER_00]: He might have known those exclusion periods had already passed, so he waited to make sure his wife was financially cared for after his suicide.

27:40.031 --> 27:44.296
[SPEAKER_00]: The forensic investigation answered many of the questions surrounding Allen's death.

27:44.857 --> 27:48.841
[SPEAKER_00]: His location history helped detectives retrace his movements.

27:49.542 --> 27:52.786
[SPEAKER_00]: E-mails and receipts revealed the unusual purchases.

27:53.467 --> 27:59.233
[SPEAKER_00]: And a thin streak of blood on his sweatshirt offered a possible explanation for how the gun had disappeared.

28:00.154 --> 28:02.095
[SPEAKER_00]: No single clue told the whole story.

28:02.735 --> 28:14.720
[SPEAKER_00]: But together with his search history, including questions recorded in his own voice, the evidence led investigators to conclude that Alan had taken his own life and arranged for it to look like a murder.

28:16.080 --> 28:19.522
[SPEAKER_00]: What the forensic evidence couldn't fully explain was why.

28:20.482 --> 28:27.725
[SPEAKER_00]: It revealed things he had researched, but it couldn't tell us everything he was feeling or what finally led him to act that morning.

28:29.910 --> 28:33.371
[SPEAKER_00]: For his daughter Rachel, learning the conclusion was devastating.

28:34.191 --> 28:41.012
[SPEAKER_00]: In an essay for today, she recalled getting a call from a detective roughly six weeks after her father died.

28:41.632 --> 28:44.433
[SPEAKER_00]: She thought he was calling to tell her they'd found the killer.

28:45.073 --> 28:48.113
[SPEAKER_00]: Instead, he told her the wound was self-inflicted.

28:49.013 --> 28:55.194
[SPEAKER_00]: Then months later, the story became national news, and her family's private grief became

28:58.735 --> 29:07.261
[SPEAKER_00]: Rachel described receiving cruel messages accusing her father of wasting police resources and demanding that she repay the state.

29:08.102 --> 29:13.206
[SPEAKER_00]: She also wrote about watching news coverage because it included recordings of her dad's voice.

29:14.046 --> 29:17.989
[SPEAKER_00]: But those recordings weren't of a conversation or a happy memory.

29:18.530 --> 29:21.452
[SPEAKER_00]: They were of him searching for ways to end his life.

29:22.938 --> 29:26.039
[SPEAKER_00]: for Florida detectives that audio was evidence.

29:27.079 --> 29:33.261
[SPEAKER_00]: For Rachel, it was her father's voice, and hearing it brought a kind of pain the headlines couldn't capture.

29:34.861 --> 29:39.882
[SPEAKER_00]: Her essay asks us to remember that people are more than the circumstances of their deaths.

29:40.783 --> 29:49.945
[SPEAKER_00]: Allen had a life before this investigation, a family, friendships, work, travels, and ordinary moments that never made the news.

29:51.946 --> 30:01.533
[SPEAKER_00]: Forensic Evidence helped explain what happened that January morning, but remembering Allen means making room for the 71 years that came before it, too.

30:03.395 --> 30:10.360
[SPEAKER_00]: If you or someone you know is in crisis, call 9-8-8 to reach the suicide and crisis lifeline.

30:11.081 --> 30:15.024
[SPEAKER_00]: You can also call the network previously known as the National Suicide Prevention

30:20.848 --> 30:25.070
[SPEAKER_00]: To share your thoughts on this week's story, follow forensic tales on social media.

30:25.630 --> 30:32.434
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you'd like to support this independent, one-woman podcast, you can join us on Patreon for as little as $3 a month.

30:33.014 --> 30:38.997
[SPEAKER_00]: Patreon members receive new episodes early and add free, along with monthly, full-length bonus episodes.

30:39.698 --> 30:44.040
[SPEAKER_00]: Your support directly helps fund the show's research, production, and editing.

30:49.935 --> 30:52.637
[SPEAKER_00]: forensic tales is a Rockefeller audio production.

30:53.198 --> 30:56.100
[SPEAKER_00]: The show is written and produced by me, Courtney Fretwell.

30:56.981 --> 31:04.668
[SPEAKER_00]: If you'd like to support the show and help fund research, production and editing, you can do so with a small monthly contribution on Patreon.

31:05.288 --> 31:10.630
[SPEAKER_00]: Patreon supporters get early access to ad-free episodes and exclusive bonus content.

31:11.251 --> 31:15.132
[SPEAKER_00]: You can learn more at patreon.com slash forensic tales.

31:16.213 --> 31:20.634
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much to this week's newest supporter on Patreon, Misty J.

31:21.595 --> 31:26.517
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you enjoy the show, leaving a positive rating or review really helps others discover it.

31:28.248 --> 31:33.034
[SPEAKER_00]: For a full list of sources used in this episode, visit forensictails.com.

31:34.215 --> 31:36.458
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening, and I'll see you next week.

31:37.359 --> 31:40.823
[SPEAKER_00]: Until then, remember, not all stories have happy endings.

