WEBVTT

00:17.683 --> 00:18.983
[SPEAKER_00]: We're only interested in one thing.

00:19.383 --> 00:20.504
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you tell a story about it?

00:20.624 --> 00:21.504
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you make us laugh?

00:21.564 --> 00:22.404
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you make us cry?

00:22.644 --> 00:23.885
[SPEAKER_00]: Can you make us want to break out?

00:24.045 --> 00:24.765
[SPEAKER_00]: Enjoy yourselves.

00:25.005 --> 00:27.106
[SPEAKER_00]: It's about time and a film nothing happened.

00:27.126 --> 00:28.827
[SPEAKER_00]: What a brave choice a director may.

00:28.887 --> 00:30.407
[SPEAKER_00]: What a way to pioneer this guy is.

00:30.687 --> 00:31.528
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's do nothing.

00:31.708 --> 00:34.329
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you know anything about the art of film production?

00:34.809 --> 00:36.029
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I like to think so.

00:36.389 --> 00:37.610
[SPEAKER_03]: Is this where I go to be star?

00:37.630 --> 00:40.651
[SPEAKER_01]: It's where you go to sacrifice your craft and work hard.

00:41.011 --> 00:41.391
[SPEAKER_00]: Movies.

00:41.991 --> 00:42.972
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, let's talk movies.

00:43.232 --> 00:43.572
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay?

00:43.852 --> 00:44.352
[SPEAKER_01]: Make this up.

00:45.664 --> 00:47.446
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what I'm talking about.

01:21.212 --> 01:22.292
[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to scene by scene.

01:22.352 --> 01:26.313
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a film discussion podcast where we break out a film story and technique.

01:26.794 --> 01:28.574
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Joe and my name's Justin.

01:28.854 --> 01:32.496
[SPEAKER_01]: In this episode we'll be discussing Satoshi Khan's perfect blue.

01:32.836 --> 01:38.678
[SPEAKER_01]: Our discussion will be spoiler heavy and you may find this discussion more engaging if you've seen the film before listening.

01:49.404 --> 01:54.269
[SPEAKER_02]: This is the end of the show.

02:36.914 --> 02:37.175
[SPEAKER_00]: Joe.

02:37.595 --> 02:38.256
[SPEAKER_00]: How you doing tonight?

02:38.897 --> 02:40.278
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm doing well.

02:40.759 --> 02:41.279
[SPEAKER_00]: How are you?

02:42.020 --> 02:42.621
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm alright.

02:43.322 --> 02:49.008
[SPEAKER_00]: I noticed that in preparation for this episode you were watching maybe some a documentary about anime.

02:49.388 --> 02:51.270
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, some documentaries about anime.

02:51.971 --> 02:55.374
[SPEAKER_01]: some documentaries about Otaku culture.

02:55.795 --> 03:07.586
[SPEAKER_01]: We'll discuss that, I think, throughout the podcast, because not only is it maybe relevant for someone like me who's just trying to get an understanding of a very big subject like anime.

03:08.186 --> 03:12.929
[SPEAKER_01]: But it's also actually quite relevant to the film, this particular film, perfect blue.

03:13.289 --> 03:24.536
[SPEAKER_01]: So much of the events and also the themes of the film are rooted in this Otaku culture and obsessive fans and then we'll get into that a little bit more.

03:25.356 --> 03:37.703
[SPEAKER_00]: There are times when I choose a movie that I know that I have like a fondness for or an appreciation for, I'm like, okay, I'm gonna bring it to the podcast so that we can discuss.

03:38.524 --> 03:46.148
[SPEAKER_00]: And then there's this conflicted nature of, okay, well, then I have to analyze it and how is that going to go?

03:46.648 --> 03:49.090
[SPEAKER_00]: Do I find myself appreciating the film less?

03:49.650 --> 03:54.173
[SPEAKER_00]: I also don't want to subject you to something that ultimately you hate either.

03:54.893 --> 03:58.316
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I know that's always a fear, especially if you haven't seen the film in a while.

03:58.536 --> 04:02.900
[SPEAKER_01]: What is another viewing going to do to your impression of the film?

04:03.821 --> 04:05.282
[SPEAKER_01]: Is your opinion going to change?

04:05.963 --> 04:07.904
[SPEAKER_01]: And then also what is the other person going to think of it?

04:09.206 --> 04:20.635
[SPEAKER_01]: But it also is this is a perfect movie for another thing that this podcast was for, which is like to get each other to watch things that we

04:21.316 --> 04:41.036
[SPEAKER_01]: maybe have recommended but the other person has not been motivated to actually watch and I think this falls into that category quite strongly because I don't know if I ever would have gotten around to this or I don't know when I would have gotten around to this if it hadn't been for a podcast and an episode like this and probably never respectfully like it's probably true

04:42.120 --> 04:45.201
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's not out of not being interested, I guess.

04:45.361 --> 04:47.701
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just out of everything that's out there.

04:48.401 --> 04:52.882
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just maybe a little bit lower on the list and those things tend to get ignored.

04:53.382 --> 04:53.582
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

04:54.083 --> 05:00.524
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, do you want to just be upfront and let me know whether you felt like this film still worked for you?

05:01.124 --> 05:04.545
[SPEAKER_01]: Actually, I found myself liking it even more.

05:04.565 --> 05:05.125
[SPEAKER_00]: Wow.

05:05.802 --> 05:11.144
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I was a little surprised by that because I do have such a fondness and appreciation for it.

05:11.744 --> 05:23.849
[SPEAKER_00]: One of the reasons I found myself appreciating it more is because maybe not just appreciating it for the film, but maybe some of like the timeliness of it.

05:24.269 --> 05:29.692
[SPEAKER_00]: The film was from nineteen ninety seven based off of a book from nineteen ninety one, I believe.

05:30.132 --> 05:32.773
[SPEAKER_00]: It's really fascinating to me just

05:33.633 --> 05:42.102
[SPEAKER_00]: as Toshikon captures that time, but in a way it's still just so relevant, even to this day.

05:42.122 --> 05:52.011
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that that was always there, but the more I dove in, the more research I had done, the more I found myself appreciating things.

05:53.032 --> 05:57.935
[SPEAKER_00]: This episode has been a little bit of a long time coming thing from my perspective.

05:58.515 --> 06:05.459
[SPEAKER_00]: I've encouraged, begged, pleaded for some time to try to get you to watch Perfect Blue.

06:05.840 --> 06:11.383
[SPEAKER_00]: It is a film that I had an expectation that I thought that you would appreciate.

06:11.403 --> 06:15.745
[SPEAKER_00]: I thought it was something that would maybe like pull you in a little bit more.

06:15.765 --> 06:16.706
[SPEAKER_00]: I know that

06:17.146 --> 06:21.209
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't have a extensive history with anime or anything like that.

06:21.229 --> 06:23.731
[SPEAKER_00]: I know you've seen anime films.

06:24.072 --> 06:27.835
[SPEAKER_00]: We had gone to see your name in theatrical setting.

06:28.395 --> 06:38.884
[SPEAKER_00]: But this film was one that to this day, I still put it within my top maybe five or ten films of all time.

06:39.504 --> 06:50.932
[SPEAKER_00]: I think it is a film for me that has meant a lot that I find a fantastic story with very careful and meticulous animation.

06:50.952 --> 06:59.017
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think it really did set me up for a phase that I went through where I was very into anime.

06:59.417 --> 07:19.002
[SPEAKER_01]: This episode on Perfect Blue is kind of our transition into Halloween season and our discussion of horror movies, typically try to do something categories are always hard to define but something a little bit more artistic, something that's maybe a little bit more character-driven and psychological.

07:19.542 --> 07:21.222
[SPEAKER_01]: I think this is a good pick for that, Joe.

07:21.302 --> 07:27.164
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it kind of balances the kind of psychological thriller with

07:27.811 --> 07:49.641
[SPEAKER_01]: more traditional horror tropes and traditional horror story beats and so it's kind of a good transition point into our next episode being a horror film in terms of like anime I think it's a really good place to start for people who are maybe a little bit unsure about anime because

07:50.902 --> 07:55.167
[SPEAKER_01]: Like when I'm evaluating the film, I'm not thinking this is great animation.

07:55.728 --> 07:58.831
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm typically thinking this is great filmmaking.

07:59.592 --> 08:01.093
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a good introduction.

08:01.154 --> 08:06.379
[SPEAKER_01]: It's an introduction that leaves a good impression on me kind of thing from that perspective.

08:06.419 --> 08:07.741
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a good place to start.

08:08.395 --> 08:37.003
[SPEAKER_00]: something that you said there does really resonate with me because we talk about what we recommend films and if so to who and a lot of times it's just yeah this was such a great film we think everybody should watch it this is one of those that it's sort of transcends its anime style of film or style of filmmaking from that regard I think that the film is really an interesting case study

08:37.883 --> 08:44.298
[SPEAKER_00]: There are a lot of anime films that I think are okay, that's a great anime film.

08:44.677 --> 08:47.238
[SPEAKER_00]: I have such an appreciation for Akira.

08:47.538 --> 08:55.459
[SPEAKER_00]: I think Akira is just a really great anime film, but it does feel like that anime film.

08:56.019 --> 09:04.141
[SPEAKER_00]: But with perfect blue, it just feels to me, at least, like it's more than the style of the filmmaking.

09:04.541 --> 09:14.223
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, perfect blue transcends the medium or the format of anime in a way that maybe other things don't.

09:15.188 --> 09:25.713
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so I mean briefly, I have a very, very limited experience with anime and that's partly where the documentary watching came into play for me.

09:25.733 --> 09:28.394
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just trying to get a little bit more background.

09:28.414 --> 09:36.959
[SPEAKER_01]: I had watched Akira and Ghost in the Shell maybe a decade ago, so a long time ago.

09:37.928 --> 09:42.690
[SPEAKER_01]: Joe, you lend me a DVD of Makoto Shinkai films.

09:42.830 --> 09:47.032
[SPEAKER_01]: I watched, she and her cat and voices of a distant star.

09:47.372 --> 09:48.552
[SPEAKER_01]: I forgot that I even loaned it.

09:48.692 --> 09:54.515
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so you gave me that DVD and I watched those and I think you were trying to prep me.

09:54.975 --> 09:58.980
[SPEAKER_01]: because you wanted to go see your name and then we went to go see your name in the theater.

09:59.241 --> 10:03.767
[SPEAKER_01]: But I basically just listed everything I've ever seen now.

10:03.787 --> 10:11.997
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I watched Pokemon or, you know, I was into certain things, but I never really took any of it seriously.

10:12.538 --> 10:20.244
[SPEAKER_01]: By the time I got to a point where I was evaluating film on a different level, I just never really went back to reevaluate that kind of stuff.

10:20.704 --> 10:27.509
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's pretty much my extent and then when it comes to con, this is my first experience with one of his films.

10:28.450 --> 10:37.076
[SPEAKER_01]: Director, I've heard a lot about it over a long period of time, but I've never really been motivated to watch anything.

10:37.096 --> 10:41.439
[SPEAKER_01]: So this is my first experience and overall it was a very good experience.

10:41.979 --> 10:43.080
[SPEAKER_01]: I enjoyed the film.

10:43.841 --> 10:50.005
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you want to briefly talk about your first time seeing this film or your experiences with Satoshi Khan?

10:50.335 --> 10:53.599
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I had a little bit of a different experience.

10:54.119 --> 10:59.205
[SPEAKER_00]: I initially got into anime because there was this show on like Saturday mornings.

10:59.425 --> 11:03.049
[SPEAKER_00]: It was called Escaflone or Division of Escaflone.

11:03.590 --> 11:10.498
[SPEAKER_00]: And I remember just being really drawn into the animation style, but also it really had

11:11.158 --> 11:24.460
[SPEAKER_00]: compelling characters, it had this very unique and interesting world that I don't think I was used to or I had necessarily experienced up to that point.

11:25.341 --> 11:30.982
[SPEAKER_00]: I remember just like making it a point to try to catch every episode of the twenty three episode season.

11:31.022 --> 11:33.922
[SPEAKER_00]: And if I recall correctly, and I could be wrong.

11:33.982 --> 11:38.103
[SPEAKER_00]: So if somebody remembers this and wants to correct me, please do so.

11:38.561 --> 11:49.125
[SPEAKER_00]: But I vaguely recall the last few episodes of that series never airing because the series takes quite a bit more of like a violent turn towards the end.

11:50.086 --> 11:54.308
[SPEAKER_00]: And maybe it was not the most appropriate for Saturday morning.

11:55.802 --> 12:10.882
[SPEAKER_00]: I called Saturday morning kids chose because that's what it was sort of surrounded by years later I have referenced this friend of mine who over the years I've just lost touch with but he myself and then another friend that I've lost touch with

12:11.963 --> 12:14.205
[SPEAKER_00]: They were both very big into anime.

12:14.265 --> 12:16.666
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I was just kind of starting to come around.

12:17.007 --> 12:19.568
[SPEAKER_00]: And they would recommend me things.

12:20.008 --> 12:21.570
[SPEAKER_00]: And they got me to watch a cure.

12:21.650 --> 12:23.171
[SPEAKER_00]: And again, a cure was great.

12:23.211 --> 12:26.333
[SPEAKER_00]: But I felt like something was missing for me.

12:27.153 --> 12:32.557
[SPEAKER_00]: And one random day, we were out at a physical media store.

12:32.577 --> 12:34.418
[SPEAKER_00]: We were in the anime section of that store.

12:34.838 --> 12:38.521
[SPEAKER_00]: And I randomly picked up this DVD of Perfect Blue.

12:39.141 --> 12:44.043
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was just interestingly enough drawn to like the cover art.

12:44.243 --> 13:06.092
[SPEAKER_00]: It's interesting because in one of the supplemental materials that I'm in a recommend contacts about this film initially being set for like the direct to video market and the hope would be that you know it'd be on a shelf somebody would pick it up and rent it or you know just buy it at random.

13:06.812 --> 13:08.313
[SPEAKER_00]: So he had me pegged

13:08.953 --> 13:10.496
[SPEAKER_00]: My two friends that I was with.

13:10.616 --> 13:13.340
[SPEAKER_00]: We actually just went back to one of my friends house.

13:13.400 --> 13:18.448
[SPEAKER_00]: We've we watched it and I don't remember their reactions to it.

13:18.769 --> 13:23.656
[SPEAKER_00]: I remember just sort of being blown away of this is what anime could be.

13:24.217 --> 13:27.439
[SPEAKER_00]: And when I say that, I mean, like, this is what it could be for me.

13:27.499 --> 13:49.871
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this world of anime out there that really does speak to me that draws me in, that tells interesting and compelling stories that maybe aren't rooted necessarily in the futuristic sci-fi world or something that's like monster or, you know, mac base.

13:50.272 --> 13:51.792
[SPEAKER_00]: I am not discrediting any of that.

13:52.113 --> 13:54.553
[SPEAKER_00]: Again, I started with Escaflona.

13:54.573 --> 13:56.814
[SPEAKER_00]: I love Avon Galian.

13:57.154 --> 14:10.698
[SPEAKER_00]: I have an appreciation for those two, but perfect blue just it really opened up my eyes to what anime can be from a filmmaking, from a storytelling perspective.

14:11.338 --> 14:16.625
[SPEAKER_00]: And even though this was years ago, it was still something that resonated with me.

14:16.825 --> 14:20.410
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's a film that I revisit every couple of years.

14:20.430 --> 14:27.700
[SPEAKER_00]: And every time I find more in it and more that speaks to me more than I'm drawn to.

14:28.701 --> 14:30.682
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it brings back a lot of memories.

14:31.163 --> 14:37.046
[SPEAKER_00]: It takes me back to a different time in my life where I was discovering new things.

14:37.386 --> 14:49.234
[SPEAKER_00]: I was finding things that I didn't necessarily initially have an appreciation for, but this one just opened up my perspective into like a whole new direction.

14:49.574 --> 14:50.915
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.

14:51.215 --> 14:59.267
[SPEAKER_01]: Did you dive into Satoshi Khan's films at some point after that, or what is your experience with him as a director?

14:59.727 --> 15:01.830
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, actually, I didn't.

15:02.511 --> 15:05.776
[SPEAKER_00]: And it wasn't until last year.

15:06.477 --> 15:10.898
[SPEAKER_00]: that I started to poke about his filmography a little bit more.

15:11.038 --> 15:21.521
[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't know that we can necessarily talk about him without referencing some of the inspiration that he's had on modern films and filmmakers.

15:22.061 --> 15:25.322
[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's pretty well documented that.

15:25.742 --> 15:35.165
[SPEAKER_00]: Within Perfect Blue, there's things that Darren Aeronovsky had paid homage to kind of put that maybe an air quotes a little bit.

15:35.805 --> 15:43.750
[SPEAKER_00]: going beyond that, you know, paprika was an influence or an inspiration for Christopher Nolan's inception.

15:44.270 --> 15:53.475
[SPEAKER_00]: Going back to your initial question though, I hadn't seen his three features up until recently or within the last year.

15:53.496 --> 15:59.419
[SPEAKER_00]: I did see paranoia agent though, going back to my younger days, I guess.

15:59.919 --> 16:02.541
[SPEAKER_00]: paranoia agent would release a DVD every

16:04.602 --> 16:11.610
[SPEAKER_00]: few months because it was like a four disc set and you'd only get a couple episodes on each disc.

16:12.250 --> 16:23.943
[SPEAKER_00]: So I remember being so drawn to that one because again, interesting unique storytelling and I remember that I would the day of the new disc release.

16:24.423 --> 16:25.885
[SPEAKER_00]: I would make it a point to go on purchases.

16:26.125 --> 16:29.587
[SPEAKER_00]: And I still have that box at somewhere around here.

16:29.607 --> 16:35.129
[SPEAKER_01]: You wanna attempt a synopsis before we get started discussing the film.

16:35.590 --> 16:47.796
[SPEAKER_00]: Perfect Blue tells the story of Mima who, as the film starts, is a Japanese pop idol who were introduced to her during her last show.

16:48.296 --> 16:52.358
[SPEAKER_00]: As the film lays its groundwork, it's established that

16:52.998 --> 16:59.320
[SPEAKER_00]: Mima is leaving her pop idol group, Chan, to pursue acting.

16:59.940 --> 17:13.643
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this conflicted nature to it where her representatives, like her managers, are kind of fighting between each other about, no, she's a pop idol.

17:13.723 --> 17:15.003
[SPEAKER_00]: She should be a pop idol.

17:15.063 --> 17:22.065
[SPEAKER_00]: She should stay with Chan while the other representative is saying, no, she's, she needs to be an actress.

17:23.165 --> 17:39.624
[SPEAKER_00]: And as the film progresses, there's this more sinister kind of undertone that happens where even though Mima agrees to be this actress, the roles that she finds herself in are very small, but then

17:40.765 --> 17:48.327
[SPEAKER_00]: sexual in nature where she's in this like copper detective show where her character is raped.

17:48.787 --> 18:03.430
[SPEAKER_00]: It becomes this thing where Mima herself sort of becomes fractured between who she was, who she truly is and almost this question of is there a real Mima anymore?

18:03.450 --> 18:09.972
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this dissociative disorder that's sort of happening within Mima as the film progresses

18:10.812 --> 18:27.825
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this stalker character who is in his way protecting Mima because he sees Mima from Chan as this pure character this pure individual and as she

18:28.525 --> 18:30.807
[SPEAKER_00]: goes on the path of acting and modeling.

18:30.827 --> 18:33.169
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, she's more exposed.

18:33.229 --> 18:39.254
[SPEAKER_00]: There's the before mentioned rape scene, but then she's also appearing like nude.

18:39.835 --> 18:43.518
[SPEAKER_00]: It's later revealed that this stalker character is

18:44.759 --> 18:47.260
[SPEAKER_00]: being manipulated in a way as well.

18:48.101 --> 19:02.187
[SPEAKER_00]: Mima discovers this website called Mima's room that is this very like stalker-ish website that seems like it knows Mima as well as Mima does.

19:02.847 --> 19:14.036
[SPEAKER_00]: That plays into like Mima's dissociativeness where she's beginning to question her own reality if she wrote something on Mima's room.

19:14.516 --> 19:20.240
[SPEAKER_00]: It's eventually revealed that it was Mima's representative who

19:21.421 --> 19:26.163
[SPEAKER_00]: was encouraging her to say with Cham a character named Rumi.

19:26.923 --> 19:38.688
[SPEAKER_00]: Rumi is sort of this representation of what Mima used to be with Cham and just trying to pull her back to that lifestyle.

19:38.708 --> 19:42.710
[SPEAKER_00]: I know that there's more to kind of unpack with this one.

19:43.230 --> 19:45.991
[SPEAKER_00]: Things that we'll talk about as the episode progresses.

19:46.011 --> 19:48.532
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know how relevant this really is.

19:49.192 --> 19:54.517
[SPEAKER_01]: The stalker character has this desire to possess Mima.

19:55.297 --> 20:06.046
[SPEAKER_01]: He has this image of her that is this image of purity and this sort of new career is basically going against the way he views her.

20:06.987 --> 20:12.291
[SPEAKER_01]: And so his way of protecting her is to kind of like kill these people who are corrupting her.

20:12.492 --> 20:13.713
[SPEAKER_01]: He kills the writer.

20:14.253 --> 20:15.834
[SPEAKER_01]: Now a lot of this is up for debate.

20:15.874 --> 20:17.055
[SPEAKER_01]: I think we'll get into this.

20:17.175 --> 20:20.138
[SPEAKER_01]: But let's just take it at face value, I guess.

20:20.938 --> 20:23.380
[SPEAKER_01]: He kills the writer who writes the rapes in.

20:23.981 --> 20:28.324
[SPEAKER_01]: He kills the photographer who photographs her nude.

20:29.025 --> 20:35.090
[SPEAKER_01]: And later comes after Mima and sort of like doesn't view her as the real Mima.

20:35.290 --> 20:35.930
[SPEAKER_01]: She's the

20:36.711 --> 20:41.058
[SPEAKER_01]: dirty, corrupt version of Mima that also needs to be destroyed.

20:41.578 --> 20:47.367
[SPEAKER_01]: And then in the end, it's revealed that her manager Rumi is the one attacking her at the end.

20:48.168 --> 20:52.395
[SPEAKER_01]: That is a situation in which I think she has this image of who

20:53.156 --> 21:06.929
[SPEAKER_01]: Mima is this image of who she was she believes that she's now the real Mima the pure Mima the the pop idol Mima and so she's also trying to kill the real Mima

21:07.770 --> 21:15.075
[SPEAKER_01]: because she's the, again, the corrupted one, the dirty one, the, the one who is not the true identity.

21:15.675 --> 21:29.023
[SPEAKER_01]: So a lot of this is about the way we see ourselves, but also the way we see celebrities, the way women are specifically viewed and judged and scrutinized.

21:29.363 --> 21:36.928
[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, this gets into the idol Otaku's, which sort of idolize and make these pop stars their whole identity.

21:37.410 --> 21:39.551
[SPEAKER_00]: Everything that you added absolutely great additions.

21:39.891 --> 21:48.874
[SPEAKER_00]: The other thing that really stands out to me too with this is so much of it is like this like dark side of the celebrity.

21:49.334 --> 21:56.057
[SPEAKER_00]: We see Mima, maybe not making like the decisions for herself, the control that she

21:57.277 --> 22:15.516
[SPEAKER_00]: has and does give up but then also as she starts to see what her life is and what her life becomes she's wrestling with this and the element of like personality is another item we'll talk about here in greater detail but

22:16.296 --> 22:21.458
[SPEAKER_00]: this inability to recognize oneself, partially because of the celebrity.

22:21.838 --> 22:25.359
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you want to talk more about the Otaku culture?

22:25.759 --> 22:35.122
[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's probably worth discussing the Japanese idol culture, what that all entails, and maybe a little bit of how it's represented here.

22:35.722 --> 22:35.982
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.

22:36.402 --> 22:45.684
[SPEAKER_01]: The idea of an Otaku is just somebody who likes something so much sort of becomes an expert on something.

22:45.905 --> 22:54.627
[SPEAKER_01]: They like something so much that they basically shape their whole identity around it and engage in nothing else but that.

22:55.087 --> 22:58.087
[SPEAKER_01]: There can be an Otaku for almost anything.

22:58.468 --> 23:00.088
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a documentary that I do want to

23:00.428 --> 23:26.162
[SPEAKER_01]: mentioned later but within that documentary there's obviously manga otaku, there's obviously anime otaku in idol otaku which is maybe most relevant to this particular film but there were also things in that documentary like model building they get into role playing in like bondage and like military otaku which are basically they just

23:26.682 --> 23:30.503
[SPEAKER_01]: dress up and they put on these sort of simulated battles.

23:31.024 --> 23:33.684
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it can be anything, anything someone loves.

23:34.185 --> 23:39.827
[SPEAKER_01]: And a lot of these documentaries, I mean, the good ones at least, the ones that are, I think, informative are a little dated.

23:40.307 --> 23:46.269
[SPEAKER_01]: But they definitely show a lack of respect for Otaku.

23:46.669 --> 23:54.392
[SPEAKER_01]: They are viewed as sort of childish and people who never really grew up and grew out of childish passions.

23:55.392 --> 23:56.272
[SPEAKER_01]: or interests.

23:57.032 --> 24:04.174
[SPEAKER_01]: And they interview women about Otaku and their view is disgusting and dangerous and untrustworthy.

24:04.954 --> 24:09.335
[SPEAKER_01]: In my mind, made me think of insult culture today.

24:09.815 --> 24:10.976
[SPEAKER_01]: Don't have a lot of friends.

24:11.056 --> 24:15.717
[SPEAKER_01]: They use these material objects or these

24:16.437 --> 24:27.271
[SPEAKER_01]: passions to kind of fill this loneliness and they can sometimes go a little bit too far with this fandom, which again relates directly to perfect blue.

24:27.892 --> 24:30.535
[SPEAKER_01]: I think perfect blue is critical of

24:31.636 --> 24:36.081
[SPEAKER_01]: Otaku culture and like specifically idol Otaku.

24:36.281 --> 24:41.467
[SPEAKER_01]: It comes down to Otaku's don't view these idols as people.

24:42.068 --> 24:51.859
[SPEAKER_01]: They view them as possessions who belong to them and that if they in any way change or evolve they view that very negatively and

24:53.200 --> 25:00.704
[SPEAKER_01]: In the film, the way that's portrayed is through becoming very violent, which obviously does not represent everyone.

25:00.724 --> 25:06.787
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a very critical way of portraying this popular concept in Japan.

25:07.127 --> 25:10.429
[SPEAKER_01]: This isn't completely foreign to Westerners either, though.

25:10.449 --> 25:17.273
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, we've had a lot of examples of people taking celebrity fandom too far and trying to kill

25:17.973 --> 25:35.451
[SPEAKER_01]: either their celebrity crush or kill for their celebrity crush or you know just stalking that happens here too and and be obviously have a strong celebrity culture in America tabloids follow their every move and the internet only enhances that and

25:36.212 --> 25:48.177
[SPEAKER_01]: Con is making a comment on Idol Otaku's who idolize these people as objects for their entertainment and ignore the fact that they're people.

25:48.577 --> 26:01.823
[SPEAKER_00]: The big one that you can clearly identify is the stalker, but I find the film very like smart from the perspective that that's not the only Otaku that we get because it would be one thing if

26:02.283 --> 26:28.329
[SPEAKER_00]: kind of only focused on that but occasionally we cut to these other guys who are demonstrating normal fandom or maybe even like slightly elevated fandom talking about you know the rumors or the the things that maybe interest them there's the festival where items are like being sold and people are bartering where there are those like probably elements but

26:28.909 --> 26:32.392
[SPEAKER_00]: They don't manifest the way they do with Mamania.

26:32.913 --> 26:33.353
[SPEAKER_00]: I agree.

26:33.373 --> 26:42.542
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, like the film is critical of Otaku culture, but I do think it's worth noting that there is representation of like different layers to it as well.

26:42.562 --> 26:44.104
[SPEAKER_01]: I would make the argument that

26:45.084 --> 26:58.116
[SPEAKER_01]: The film is critical of that group of guys as well, but you have to acknowledge that the way they approach it, the way it manifests in them is, it's not dangerous to other people.

26:58.837 --> 27:05.824
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that feels the most like the way we treat celebrities in America or in Hollywood.

27:06.344 --> 27:17.112
[SPEAKER_01]: because so much of it is like engaging in gossip and then being kind of really judgmental and unfair and there is almost this entitlement.

27:17.512 --> 27:23.636
[SPEAKER_01]: The film opens on this sequence where it's meme as last performance with sham.

27:23.996 --> 27:29.040
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, we start on this like power rangers, ask performance and then the camera kind of

27:29.660 --> 27:51.057
[SPEAKER_01]: leads outside the venue and it's all these people waiting and a camera kind of floats from one group to the next group and we get all this basically exposition setting up who Mima is as a character and all these people gossiping about like I heard that she's gonna leave sham and again I think it's ignoring the fact that

27:51.697 --> 28:16.262
[SPEAKER_01]: she's more than just her public persona and that's the way I think we view celebrities in general is like we act like we know them because of this public persona but there's so much more below that that we don't have the slightest clue of and yet we feel like we can speak about them in their lives even though we have just a fraction of this story so

28:17.230 --> 28:19.231
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, I don't think that's inherently dangerous.

28:19.871 --> 28:26.715
[SPEAKER_01]: I do think it's maybe irresponsible or immature in some way, but it's not dangerous.

28:27.776 --> 28:33.099
[SPEAKER_00]: Something that always stood out to me with this film, especially when I first watched it.

28:33.919 --> 28:58.813
[SPEAKER_00]: I was fascinated by the Japanese idol culture, and you highlighted we have a little bit of it here, but I don't think it's to the extent that what the idol culture in like the sixties, seventies, eighties into the nineties was like in Japan, but these Japanese pop idols were selected very young at a very young age.

28:59.842 --> 29:15.737
[SPEAKER_00]: their whole image, their whole personality, persona is this thing that is manufactured for them, and they need to present themselves this way, but they are being presented to the public this way.

29:16.618 --> 29:22.803
[SPEAKER_00]: and with Japanese idol culture, it is this notion of idolized youth.

29:23.143 --> 29:34.232
[SPEAKER_00]: It's this air quotes, perfect woman of the perfect age that is innocent and pure and that is what they are.

29:34.933 --> 29:39.736
[SPEAKER_00]: It's reflective of this fantasy, this infatuation, this lust.

29:40.697 --> 29:42.078
[SPEAKER_00]: Even that side of it to me is

29:43.139 --> 30:01.683
[SPEAKER_00]: the work, the effort that goes into creating these personas is irresponsible and manipulative because these idols are basically presented as they can't do certain things, they can't date, they can't do certain things in public.

30:02.003 --> 30:09.905
[SPEAKER_00]: It's all just like so controlled, not excusing behaviors of the Otaku or the stalker culture.

30:10.765 --> 30:22.008
[SPEAKER_00]: But when like this is being presented to people, as here is your ideal, whatever, you know, in this case, a pop idol, here's your ideal woman.

30:22.668 --> 30:29.470
[SPEAKER_00]: The level of fandom can only grow and spread and hit unhealthy points.

30:30.130 --> 30:35.792
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm not defending any side of this, but I do think that it's two sides of the same coin almost here.

30:36.212 --> 30:47.015
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and I think this pressure or the acceptance, I guess, of young males idolizing to the point of like, they need to protect these women.

30:47.395 --> 31:01.119
[SPEAKER_01]: So like, this is inherently a very sexist belief too, but like, so much of this for the men is like, these women are so perfect, so pure, almost like goddesses that they need someone else.

31:01.359 --> 31:03.640
[SPEAKER_01]: They need the men there to protect them.

31:04.260 --> 31:09.324
[SPEAKER_01]: That obviously creates a very dangerous culture, which obviously we see in perfect blue.

31:09.825 --> 31:26.159
[SPEAKER_01]: One of the things I found fascinating is watching some of these documentaries, some of them interview, self-identifying Otaku, Idol Otaku, and some of them talk about how some of them do have sexual fantasies about these women.

31:26.699 --> 31:39.823
[SPEAKER_01]: but then other Otaku's do not because they are basically like goddesses and they are so pure that they can't even allow themselves to be that disrespectful towards them.

31:40.123 --> 31:45.425
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, obviously it's a little bit different for everyone, but it's this weird thing where... It's a level of hypocrisy.

31:45.845 --> 31:46.125
[SPEAKER_00]: Isn't it?

31:46.185 --> 31:46.466
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.

31:46.766 --> 31:47.046
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

31:47.347 --> 32:07.085
[SPEAKER_00]: If the image is supposed to be pure and perfect, but then they are sexualized, which I think that they often are, and we even see like the way that a sham is introduced, these are supposed to be like pure, pristine, perfect women.

32:08.026 --> 32:12.267
[SPEAKER_00]: but they're also very sexualized in their presentation.

32:12.547 --> 32:27.971
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, another kind of parallel in the film is like this guy expects his idol to be pure and perfect, but he himself is willing to sexually assault her.

32:28.571 --> 32:37.773
[SPEAKER_01]: It's an interesting thing that you expect something from someone else, but you yourself can kind of have different rules or different expectations for yourself.

32:38.273 --> 32:46.279
[SPEAKER_00]: Unless that's the point though, that's why we idolize these people because they are so perfect and I am not.

32:46.919 --> 32:47.540
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, maybe.

32:47.980 --> 32:57.487
[SPEAKER_00]: So Perfect Blue is very loosely based off of a book that does deal with a Japanese pop idol who has a stalker and

32:58.087 --> 33:24.925
[SPEAKER_00]: The idea was that this was originally going to be a live action film, but then due to like budget limitations, things of that nature, the direction of it changed into an OVA, otherwise known as original video animation, which is essentially like a direct to video directed DVD anime film, due to a number of circumstances the film actually got eighth theatrical release and I'll kind of talk about this because

33:25.705 --> 33:51.062
[SPEAKER_00]: context about decisions made when it's an OVA versus knowing oh it's going to go theatrical the root of the story is is there this is what it's about but context it in a far more interesting direction I think I will admit I actually started reading the book I found the film just far more fascinating compelling I might pick it back up and complete it but I don't know for certain

33:51.442 --> 34:10.298
[SPEAKER_00]: With that said, the thing that's sort of interesting about this film, the film version of Perfect Blue is we just spent all this time talking about Otaku culture, Japanese pop idols and this film is dated all the way back in ninety seven, the book came out in nineteen ninety one.

34:10.818 --> 34:13.801
[SPEAKER_00]: And we're still seeing these behaviors.

34:13.882 --> 34:20.408
[SPEAKER_00]: We're still seeing these situations manifest strictly focusing on the film.

34:20.789 --> 34:30.980
[SPEAKER_00]: It talks and explores like internet culture and internet fandom like this cat-fishing element that also feels just so like timeless.

34:31.580 --> 34:32.160
[SPEAKER_00]: in a way.

34:32.320 --> 34:33.521
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, in a head of its time.

34:33.961 --> 34:35.161
[SPEAKER_00]: Definitely ahead of its time.

34:35.382 --> 34:36.102
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely.

34:36.182 --> 34:38.163
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I'm just new.

34:38.183 --> 34:39.543
[SPEAKER_00]: He saw the future.

34:39.823 --> 34:48.727
[SPEAKER_00]: That's just like one of the things that makes to me this movie just like so perfect is there was this like understanding of things that were happening.

34:49.927 --> 34:53.689
[SPEAKER_00]: and how they could manifest and actually how they have.

34:53.709 --> 34:55.730
[SPEAKER_01]: Joe, I have a question for you.

34:55.750 --> 35:01.573
[SPEAKER_01]: I heard somewhere that the live action film was actually closer to the book.

35:02.053 --> 35:03.134
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you know if that's true?

35:03.354 --> 35:12.218
[SPEAKER_01]: Because I was surprised by how like underbaked that whole story seemed in that version of the film.

35:12.618 --> 35:15.560
[SPEAKER_00]: So I did purchase a bootleg copy of

35:16.320 --> 35:21.127
[SPEAKER_00]: the live action perfect blue when I found out that it was a thing.

35:21.567 --> 35:30.500
[SPEAKER_00]: I watched it once and I very vaguely recall the film, but what I do remember of it versus what I was reading in the book.

35:30.881 --> 35:31.742
[SPEAKER_00]: It did feel

35:32.763 --> 35:35.264
[SPEAKER_00]: At least in my mind, like a true word adaptation.

35:35.324 --> 35:38.166
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, I could be wrong because again, it's been a minute.

35:38.646 --> 35:40.267
[SPEAKER_00]: I also had heard that.

35:40.747 --> 35:48.351
[SPEAKER_01]: This is maybe a bold statement if that's true that the live action is closer to the original book.

35:48.792 --> 35:54.555
[SPEAKER_01]: I actually think it's unfair to say that Satoshi Khan's perfect blue is even based on the book.

35:55.395 --> 35:58.337
[SPEAKER_01]: in the sense that like it doesn't feel like the same story to me.

35:58.778 --> 36:06.804
[SPEAKER_01]: He adds so much richness just in the themes he's trying to tackle just in like how well thought out.

36:07.204 --> 36:09.986
[SPEAKER_01]: The story is just in having a perspective.

36:10.807 --> 36:14.750
[SPEAKER_01]: I watched the live action remake and I was like, what does this film even about?

36:15.230 --> 36:21.235
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know, maybe that's partly on me being maybe unfamiliar with things culturally.

36:21.575 --> 36:23.657
[SPEAKER_01]: There could be things that I'm just not picking up on.

36:24.670 --> 36:38.120
[SPEAKER_01]: It felt like it was a metaphor for something that just didn't click with me and I ended up thinking like what is this even about versus Satoshi Khan's is like what is this film not about in a way?

36:38.140 --> 36:44.585
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know how much you dove into interviews or the history with this film.

36:45.365 --> 36:59.633
[SPEAKER_00]: It has been and is widely acknowledged that the only similarity really between this and the book is the fact that it's about a pop idol who has a stalker.

36:59.934 --> 37:02.775
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's where the similarities essentially end.

37:03.676 --> 37:12.941
[SPEAKER_00]: Contacts about how the studio had the rights to it and just gave him the freedom to take it in the direction that he wanted to.

37:14.282 --> 37:26.572
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely accurate that this anime, the only things that it shares with its original source material are the title and that there's a pop idol that's being stocked.

37:27.133 --> 37:31.156
[SPEAKER_00]: But what I'm hearing is the live action version didn't work for you at all.

37:31.536 --> 37:32.017
[SPEAKER_00]: It did not.

37:32.337 --> 37:36.761
[SPEAKER_00]: I thought about revisiting it, but I just, I did run out of time for that one.

37:37.085 --> 37:41.089
[SPEAKER_01]: There's things like I want to ask you about night debate if they're even important.

37:41.569 --> 37:43.231
[SPEAKER_01]: The film is experiential.

37:43.491 --> 37:44.633
[SPEAKER_01]: It's about the experience.

37:45.353 --> 37:50.498
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's about putting you in the perspective in the mind of someone who is losing their mind.

37:50.879 --> 37:56.564
[SPEAKER_01]: It's putting you in the perspective of someone who's questioning what's real, what's not real.

37:57.345 --> 38:02.428
[SPEAKER_01]: So you as the viewer also are questioning what's real and what's not real.

38:02.728 --> 38:04.549
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's really the point, I think.

38:05.149 --> 38:08.851
[SPEAKER_01]: So the answers to these questions are not the point.

38:09.532 --> 38:10.472
[SPEAKER_01]: It really doesn't matter.

38:10.552 --> 38:14.695
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's about disorienting you, making you question reality.

38:14.995 --> 38:17.616
[SPEAKER_01]: But I also think you can have different opinions on these questions.

38:17.936 --> 38:22.259
[SPEAKER_01]: There's an interpretation there that, you know, we could disagree on this potentially.

38:22.550 --> 38:40.158
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, one of my favorite things that I watched in preparation for this podcast and it's it's on the blue ray and I know you're not a fan of steel books, but it's on the steel book blue ray and it's the perfect blue lecture series with Satoshi Khan

38:40.638 --> 38:41.479
[SPEAKER_00]: It's fantastic.

38:41.999 --> 39:00.214
[SPEAKER_00]: We often talk about how we could listen to Lynch talk about felt like con breaking down this film and he starts the first lecture with I'm going to paraphrase a little bit here, but this is my personal interpretation and that specifically how the film should be interpreted.

39:00.730 --> 39:17.888
[SPEAKER_00]: for a director to say that and to know and acknowledge that even he is interpreting the film one way and he explains his intent, he explains some of

39:18.248 --> 39:25.351
[SPEAKER_00]: His meaning behind things, he's not saying this is absolutely the lens that this should be viewed from.

39:25.851 --> 39:27.252
[SPEAKER_00]: This might seem obvious.

39:27.332 --> 39:30.473
[SPEAKER_00]: This might just seem, well, yeah, any good director should be doing this.

39:31.134 --> 39:32.734
[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't always happen either.

39:33.055 --> 39:34.855
[SPEAKER_00]: There is a lot of handholding in films.

39:34.895 --> 39:38.737
[SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot of texts with no subtext.

39:39.237 --> 39:40.378
[SPEAKER_00]: What you touched on here,

39:41.438 --> 40:00.763
[SPEAKER_00]: is I think maybe a good warning for our listeners now that we're actually like getting into the story, the happenings, the events and some of the the thematic elements of perfect blue is these are going to be our interpretations, but that doesn't make them right.

40:00.983 --> 40:03.623
[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't make them the only way to interpret.

40:03.883 --> 40:08.124
[SPEAKER_00]: If somebody else has a different interpretation, I think it's great and I'd love to hear it.

40:08.624 --> 40:10.605
[SPEAKER_00]: So Justin, you had questions.

40:11.205 --> 40:22.112
[SPEAKER_01]: Essentially, we're put into Mima's mind, the mind of someone who is beginning to unravel, and she herself is questioning what is real and what's not.

40:22.733 --> 40:30.518
[SPEAKER_01]: And if the film is being told through her eyes, from her perspective, and some things are not real,

40:31.298 --> 40:52.417
[SPEAKER_01]: we essentially have an unreliable narrator and you know if some things are not real we kind of can question if anything's real or if some things are real to what extent and so I think this begs some questions the film opens at this concert and you know there's these group of guys who are

40:53.058 --> 41:08.630
[SPEAKER_01]: just kind of being loud and disrespectful and causing trouble and they're throwing things at the performers and there's this security guard who basically confronts them and they get into a fight and this security guard is

41:09.511 --> 41:17.258
[SPEAKER_01]: Mamania, the person who we then see stalking her in appearing at various points in her life and eventually attacks her.

41:17.859 --> 41:28.909
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think it's possible that everything after this first scene and which she is seen confronting this group of guys could possibly be in

41:29.770 --> 41:30.350
[SPEAKER_01]: her mind.

41:30.770 --> 41:36.312
[SPEAKER_01]: Mima witnesses him being violent, getting into this fight.

41:36.872 --> 41:41.173
[SPEAKER_01]: He certainly has a look to him that is memorable.

41:41.573 --> 41:44.854
[SPEAKER_01]: He has a unique memorable appearance.

41:44.994 --> 41:48.775
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it possible that this person just imprinted on her mind?

41:49.175 --> 41:55.357
[SPEAKER_01]: And she's already, I think, starting to lose her grip on reality at this point.

41:55.417 --> 41:59.098
[SPEAKER_01]: It only heightens as things unfold in the story, but

41:59.998 --> 42:04.141
[SPEAKER_01]: She is already uncomfortable with what is happening in her life.

42:04.582 --> 42:09.105
[SPEAKER_01]: She is already changing and making sacrifices to please other people.

42:09.445 --> 42:15.669
[SPEAKER_01]: These are not decisions she wants to make and it is already creating a identity crisis for her.

42:16.270 --> 42:23.234
[SPEAKER_01]: So is it possible that this person that we see is just a figment of her imagination and is

42:24.115 --> 42:30.862
[SPEAKER_01]: the visual representation of him is being taken from someone she saw at this concert.

42:31.062 --> 42:32.303
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you think that's a possibility?

42:32.503 --> 42:33.464
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, absolutely.

42:33.504 --> 42:33.705
[SPEAKER_00]: I do.

42:33.965 --> 42:36.067
[SPEAKER_00]: The film does put us in her mind.

42:36.147 --> 42:39.651
[SPEAKER_00]: So we are constantly questioning this reality.

42:39.751 --> 42:43.735
[SPEAKER_00]: So I don't know that I fully buy into the

42:44.135 --> 42:56.544
[SPEAKER_00]: that there's like other elements that I'm like, I'm not sure that I can like rationalize her to justify it, but I do think that there's an element of Mamania like representing something.

42:57.045 --> 43:01.348
[SPEAKER_00]: There is the attempted rape scene later.

43:01.768 --> 43:09.854
[SPEAKER_00]: That's like the big one that stands out to me where I'm like, it is an actual individual versus a manifestation in her psyche.

43:10.374 --> 43:13.197
[SPEAKER_01]: I would say if it wasn't almost a mirror,

43:14.017 --> 43:16.298
[SPEAKER_01]: of the sequence that happens in the TV show.

43:16.318 --> 43:37.067
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I would say maybe that's evidence that it's really happening, but the location, the positioning, I guess the blocking, let's say, some of his behaviors mirror the way that the assault scene is depicted in the fictional TV show and then also

43:37.947 --> 43:50.955
[SPEAKER_01]: going off of this theory that I have potentially that the person committing the act is also coming from someone she crossed paths with or witnessed earlier in the film.

43:51.435 --> 43:54.917
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like both things are being influenced by something else in her life.

43:55.418 --> 43:57.979
[SPEAKER_01]: It's being influenced by her experiences on the show.

43:58.039 --> 44:06.284
[SPEAKER_01]: It's being influenced by this man that she saw in this very confrontational violent moment at the concert.

44:06.364 --> 44:06.604
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's

44:07.966 --> 44:12.690
[SPEAKER_01]: What are the chances or why does it happen the way it happens in the show?

44:12.710 --> 44:32.424
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I agree with that I see that and that's a common theme too is like this blurring of what is the TV show and what is her actual life and they're being crossover and repeating things and mirroring and it's like brilliantly executed, but it just gets so disorienting.

44:32.884 --> 44:53.254
[SPEAKER_00]: I must have reflecting on what you just said to where Mamania is first introduced as almost this protective character as security, but then as her psyche breaks and she disassociates more and more from reality this protective figure.

44:53.734 --> 45:04.503
[SPEAKER_00]: and even like Rumi, like we'll talk about Rumi here at a moment, but the fact that these would be protective characters become these antagonists.

45:05.144 --> 45:09.127
[SPEAKER_00]: It's just brilliant filmmaking, really like brilliant filmmaking, brilliant storytelling.

45:09.668 --> 45:12.250
[SPEAKER_00]: We've talked about these a little bit.

45:12.931 --> 45:17.855
[SPEAKER_00]: It's this element of this false ownership of Mima.

45:18.275 --> 45:43.462
[SPEAKER_00]: where he is so infatuated, the character that she portrays as a member of Cham is so critical and vital to him that he feels that he owns that, he has this connection and in a way he has to defend that idea of her versus accepting the reality.

45:44.142 --> 45:53.630
[SPEAKER_00]: That does also support the question or the belief that, you know, it's not a true character, but that's Mimi's own personal manifestation.

45:54.050 --> 46:09.243
[SPEAKER_01]: This is what's interesting is like if she feels like she needs someone to protect her and she basically invents this fictional person who is her protector, who goes after these people who've manipulated her or

46:09.963 --> 46:16.706
[SPEAKER_01]: exploited her, specifically the screenwriter and the photographer, but then also maybe her management.

46:17.207 --> 46:26.972
[SPEAKER_01]: It could be her committing those crimes, the way she justifies it sort of compartmentalizes it, is by assigning those actions, those horrible actions to this

46:27.732 --> 46:28.472
[SPEAKER_01]: other person.

46:28.773 --> 46:37.776
[SPEAKER_01]: So then the question is sort of like, is she, she's obviously not aware that this person isn't real, but it's like, is she an active participant in it?

46:38.277 --> 46:40.738
[SPEAKER_01]: Or is it something sort of out of her control?

46:41.178 --> 46:43.059
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it something that's terrorizing her?

46:43.379 --> 46:46.900
[SPEAKER_01]: Or is it something that is awakened in her to protect her?

46:47.261 --> 46:49.321
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that question arises then too.

46:49.782 --> 46:54.684
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a scene in the TV show, the fictional TV show in which the two characters are talking.

46:54.844 --> 46:56.705
[SPEAKER_01]: They're the lead detectives or something.

46:57.685 --> 47:01.649
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the guy says the murder is an illusion she's created.

47:02.109 --> 47:02.710
[SPEAKER_01]: Question mark.

47:03.110 --> 47:09.556
[SPEAKER_01]: The woman responds yes and something and then adds on that she fears an imaginary security guard.

47:09.977 --> 47:16.703
[SPEAKER_01]: So they're referencing the fact that like the character in the TV show is fearing an imaginary security guard.

47:17.184 --> 47:20.567
[SPEAKER_01]: It's interesting that Mamania is a security guard.

47:21.167 --> 47:23.149
[SPEAKER_01]: is he also imaginary.

47:23.449 --> 47:44.249
[SPEAKER_01]: There's parallels between the TV show in her real life and he makes you question, are these all just inventions of her mind that are being inspired by outside things, particularly things she's reading in a script or things she's filming on set and that's influencing her quote unquote real life.

47:44.509 --> 47:45.710
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's a possibility.

47:45.790 --> 47:46.511
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know though.

47:47.011 --> 48:11.184
[SPEAKER_00]: We have the scene where we're following Mamania and Mamania is in this like dark room and the only thing that we see really is like the flickering of a computer screen and he's having this interaction with the person representing themselves as Mima from Mima's room.

48:11.604 --> 48:15.786
[SPEAKER_00]: And it is very much played like it's Rumi.

48:16.367 --> 48:28.534
[SPEAKER_00]: So I mentioned earlier that Rumi is revealed to be one of the characters, if not the main orchestrator in everything that's happening as a way of protecting Mima.

48:29.094 --> 48:39.620
[SPEAKER_00]: That feels like the film telling us that these are physical manifestations more than psychological, but I can still see it.

48:39.820 --> 48:42.202
[SPEAKER_01]: My first watch, I watched the film twice.

48:42.222 --> 48:44.964
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the film needs more than two watches.

48:45.224 --> 48:50.367
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think my interpretations are fully formed because I think it requires more than two watches.

48:50.928 --> 48:56.511
[SPEAKER_01]: But my first watch, I was like, wait a minute, now we're switching perspectives to the stalker character.

48:57.312 --> 48:58.152
[SPEAKER_01]: So it feels like

48:59.081 --> 49:10.931
[SPEAKER_01]: where now in the stalker's perspective, Mamani is perspective in which he's talking to this perfect dealic version of Mima that he's created.

49:10.951 --> 49:18.317
[SPEAKER_01]: Then on second view, I questioned, are we really switching perspectives or is this all just part of

49:19.037 --> 49:21.618
[SPEAKER_01]: meme is unraveling and this is all in her mind.

49:21.778 --> 49:30.719
[SPEAKER_01]: She's invented this character and she's imagining that this is what this character who's terrorizing her is doing right now.

49:31.540 --> 49:33.320
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I thought that was maybe a possibility.

49:33.480 --> 49:34.000
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

49:34.920 --> 49:43.322
[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean also Rumi who is at the end of the film revealed to be potentially be the perpetrator of all this.

49:44.306 --> 49:50.189
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it really her and she's talking to this fictional version of Mamania?

49:50.609 --> 49:51.610
[SPEAKER_01]: Is that a possibility?

49:51.690 --> 50:01.215
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, if we are talking about a real character in that scene, because it's revealed that Rumi is like this perfect in her mind, she's this perfect Mima.

50:01.455 --> 50:09.620
[SPEAKER_01]: But so is it possible that that visualization of the perfect idol version of Mima is actually a Rumi in that scene?

50:10.040 --> 50:14.203
[SPEAKER_01]: This isn't necessarily how I view it, but is that a possibility to look at it that way, too?

50:15.244 --> 50:28.634
[SPEAKER_01]: It's interesting when we have at least three characters who have these, for lack of a better expression, multiple personalities in one film, and we're wondering which ones are real and which ones are not.

50:29.025 --> 50:42.919
[SPEAKER_00]: Since we're on the topic of the Rumi reveal, as you mentioned, the film reveals that Rumi is the one that's orchestrated this or at least in Mema's mind.

50:43.820 --> 50:45.362
[SPEAKER_00]: She used the one that is orchestrated this.

50:45.942 --> 50:46.843
[SPEAKER_00]: Just for a moment.

50:47.644 --> 50:53.888
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's say that it is like a physical like character and not a manifestation in mimisman.

50:54.188 --> 50:58.710
[SPEAKER_00]: For the sake of this conversation, how do you feel about that reveal?

50:59.210 --> 51:03.373
[SPEAKER_01]: If that is what's happening, I like it because I do think it goes back to this.

51:04.013 --> 51:07.538
[SPEAKER_01]: Exploration of the way particularly women are treated.

51:07.898 --> 51:18.232
[SPEAKER_01]: We talked about Otaku culture and maybe the way that this group, which is largely men, kind of viewed these women and talk about these women.

51:18.813 --> 51:21.536
[SPEAKER_01]: But here's a situation in which women

51:22.157 --> 51:27.760
[SPEAKER_01]: are also guilty in a way where Rumi is whether it be jealousy.

51:27.780 --> 51:29.721
[SPEAKER_01]: I want this person's life.

51:29.781 --> 51:31.102
[SPEAKER_01]: I want to be this person.

51:31.522 --> 51:45.570
[SPEAKER_01]: She's willing to also kind of like cut down this other woman, destroy this other woman's life or even kill this other woman to achieve some level of fame to get back to where she wants was in her career.

51:46.170 --> 51:48.352
[SPEAKER_01]: Women are constantly being

51:49.292 --> 51:52.434
[SPEAKER_01]: used and exploited by her management for money.

51:52.994 --> 52:00.038
[SPEAKER_01]: The male manager wants her to become an actress because there's more money in it for her and therefore money for them.

52:00.058 --> 52:07.323
[SPEAKER_01]: This isn't what's necessarily best for her but this is what's best for me so there's like this exploitation happening.

52:08.343 --> 52:11.325
[SPEAKER_01]: And then it's not just happening from men.

52:11.345 --> 52:14.346
[SPEAKER_01]: The women are also guilty of doing it as well.

52:14.406 --> 52:20.209
[SPEAKER_01]: And like she has her own ulterior motives for wanting to keep her as a pop idol.

52:20.749 --> 52:22.330
[SPEAKER_01]: It isn't just like the man.

52:22.410 --> 52:27.873
[SPEAKER_01]: It isn't necessarily for Mima's best interest or from Mima's happiness or whatever.

52:27.913 --> 52:32.335
[SPEAKER_01]: It's because she has her own secret desires, her own ulterior motive.

52:33.047 --> 52:38.640
[SPEAKER_01]: And it kind of reminds me of like a parent like living their dreams out through their child or something.

52:39.580 --> 52:46.502
[SPEAKER_01]: you're gonna do this because it's the life I always wanted and I failed to accomplish it or failed to achieve it.

52:47.622 --> 52:57.464
[SPEAKER_01]: And maybe there's so much more too, but like I liked it because I felt like it's enhancing the themes, it's adding to the richness and the complexity of the themes.

52:57.905 --> 53:02.846
[SPEAKER_00]: You very briefly like touched on the thing that maybe captivated me the most about it is

53:04.186 --> 53:09.931
[SPEAKER_00]: Rumi is discussed as this retired pop idol herself.

53:10.851 --> 53:26.063
[SPEAKER_00]: And as she continues to try to pull Mima back towards Cham or towards the pop idol life, there's this representation of trying to maintain that level of celebrity and

53:28.105 --> 53:38.114
[SPEAKER_00]: While we don't necessarily see it until closer to the end here, there's that element of like jealousy or trying to like maintain the status quo.

53:38.435 --> 53:45.741
[SPEAKER_00]: And then when we have the reveal of Rumi wearing the like red champ or pop idol.

53:46.502 --> 53:46.982
[SPEAKER_00]: dress.

53:47.582 --> 53:57.225
[SPEAKER_00]: It screamed to me like that faded star or that lost celebrity that has been unable to move on.

53:57.805 --> 54:06.648
[SPEAKER_00]: She does and has because she's had to, but she still has that like yearning for the things that she's witnessing me might give up.

54:07.148 --> 54:14.790
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's what's interesting too though, is like the first view you have this impression of who Rumi is and what her motivations are.

54:15.350 --> 54:21.432
[SPEAKER_01]: And the second view or repeat viewings, it completely changes what her motivations are.

54:22.452 --> 54:25.153
[SPEAKER_01]: But it also completely makes sense.

54:25.353 --> 54:26.173
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think there's any

54:26.873 --> 54:33.055
[SPEAKER_01]: It's hard to say because it's all about messing with you really, but I don't think the film cheats in any way.

54:33.495 --> 54:35.155
[SPEAKER_01]: Like I feel like it makes sense.

54:36.015 --> 54:40.756
[SPEAKER_01]: There's like little clues and things that you kind of pick up on the second viewing.

54:41.217 --> 54:42.357
[SPEAKER_01]: For me, that works.

54:42.697 --> 54:45.918
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't say I necessarily saw that coming.

54:46.238 --> 54:47.838
[SPEAKER_01]: It definitely worked for me.

54:48.378 --> 54:54.560
[SPEAKER_01]: Then you question like so if she's the real perpetrator or she's the real

54:55.460 --> 55:03.725
[SPEAKER_01]: mastermind and let's say that Mamania isn't real is a fictional creation of someone's mind.

55:04.426 --> 55:08.448
[SPEAKER_01]: Is she the one killing all these people who die in the film?

55:08.468 --> 55:12.010
[SPEAKER_01]: And this was my other question, who's killing these people?

55:12.831 --> 55:14.352
[SPEAKER_01]: Are these people even being killed?

55:14.652 --> 55:16.093
[SPEAKER_01]: Again, you have to question everything.

55:16.373 --> 55:23.738
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I've watched this several more times than you and even now I'm finding like interesting challenges to like

55:24.438 --> 55:38.487
[SPEAKER_00]: the way that I've watched it because I've frequently interpreted either both Rumi and Mamania are real or both of them are manifestations of Mima.

55:38.787 --> 55:49.474
[SPEAKER_00]: But I've never necessarily questioned is one real Rumi and Mamania just a manifestation.

55:49.794 --> 55:50.636
[SPEAKER_00]: That's interesting.

55:50.936 --> 55:51.817
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.

55:52.198 --> 55:58.608
[SPEAKER_01]: When you question if Rumi is real, do you mean Rumi as a character is real at all?

55:58.948 --> 56:01.873
[SPEAKER_01]: Or just that Rumi is, she's revealed.

56:01.913 --> 56:03.034
[SPEAKER_00]: The way that she's revealed.

56:03.054 --> 56:03.115
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.

56:04.311 --> 56:09.098
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, I believe that Rumi is a real character.

56:09.598 --> 56:15.827
[SPEAKER_00]: Certain characters are real, but the form that maybe they take later.

56:16.288 --> 56:19.212
[SPEAKER_01]: That's another element I find pretty interesting as well is

56:20.353 --> 56:42.928
[SPEAKER_01]: not being able to trust let's say the Rumi reveal actually happened like that is what Rumi was doing Rumi did attack her not being able to trust the people who are supposed to be looking out for you who are supposed to be taking care of you or let's say Rumi attacking Mima is

56:43.868 --> 56:52.273
[SPEAKER_01]: in meme as mind, then from that perspective it's questioning whether you can trust the people who are supposed to look out for you and protect you.

56:52.974 --> 57:12.186
[SPEAKER_01]: I find that an interesting element as well and I think that ties back to celebrity and how often I think celebrities have to question who they can trust, who is really there for them and protecting them and not just in it for themselves.

57:13.306 --> 57:36.226
[SPEAKER_01]: It's, you know, obviously not uncommon for agents and in management to manipulate careers for their own benefit, not for the stars benefit or, you know, managers just straight up stealing money from celebrities and it's an interesting part of the film's exploration of celebrity as well.

57:36.506 --> 57:38.588
[SPEAKER_01]: But also, I mean, I think it's just interesting.

57:39.128 --> 57:44.132
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, realizing you can't trust the people closest to you, the people who are supposed to be looking after you.

57:44.152 --> 57:52.218
[SPEAKER_01]: And that makes total sense within the context of the film where she is being kind of pushed in a direction that she doesn't want to go.

57:52.238 --> 57:58.784
[SPEAKER_01]: And she's saying, oh, I'm okay doing this, but deep down she really is not okay doing this.

57:59.084 --> 58:04.028
[SPEAKER_01]: And she's agreeing to do things just to make other people happy.

58:04.908 --> 58:15.857
[SPEAKER_01]: And after a while, resentment, anger would build up in that would manifest itself in like, I'm being attacked by my management or something.

58:16.017 --> 58:19.780
[SPEAKER_01]: Whether the attack is real or not, maybe is offered a bait.

58:19.840 --> 58:28.027
[SPEAKER_01]: But it takes that form because she feels like they're not really out there to protect her or look after her.

58:28.047 --> 58:30.129
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's an interesting element as well.

58:30.898 --> 58:52.388
[SPEAKER_00]: the idle way, the idle method that happens here is if this is the life that you know and you are trained to follow this managerial group or your people, you believe that they have your interests in mind because that's what you've been

58:53.068 --> 59:16.410
[SPEAKER_00]: sold or conditioned to believe and you want to make them happy so even though it's clear that me my isn't interested in this or maybe has like an apprehensive nature she's not speaking up on it she goes with it there is that scene where her managers are basically like going back and forth about what's best for her

59:17.190 --> 59:21.872
[SPEAKER_00]: and Mima is looking down and she says, no, I'm an actress now.

59:22.493 --> 59:28.455
[SPEAKER_00]: Even though her tone gives this impression, the body language says otherwise.

59:29.215 --> 59:38.419
[SPEAKER_00]: I know we often talk about live action films, but there is something to be said about characters in an animated film.

59:39.780 --> 59:46.404
[SPEAKER_00]: depicting mood, or tone, or emotion through body language as well.

59:47.264 --> 59:50.926
[SPEAKER_00]: This film, for the most part, does it in a pretty subtle way.

59:51.646 --> 01:00:07.515
[SPEAKER_00]: One last thing that I want to touch on with this, too, though, is the foreshadowing and just like the foundation of that argument of Rumi versus Mr. Toto-Koro pulling Mima in these two separate directions and

01:00:08.515 --> 01:00:18.963
[SPEAKER_00]: how as the film evolves and as the film continues, it is so much about her psyche and her mental state just being pulled in all of these different directions.

01:00:19.464 --> 01:00:32.294
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's like the great subtext of the film because you think it's just this conversation, but the film is laying the foundation for what's going to happen or what truly matters.

01:00:34.044 --> 01:00:49.947
[SPEAKER_00]: Something regarding those killings, and regardless of who is the killer, who's responsible for it, I really appreciate it the element of how the level of violence sort of escalates.

01:00:50.327 --> 01:00:52.928
[SPEAKER_00]: Just to be very clear, I'm omitting the rapes scene.

01:00:53.248 --> 01:01:02.530
[SPEAKER_00]: That is absolutely violence, but the violence against these characters that sort of negatively influence or

01:01:03.210 --> 01:01:04.891
[SPEAKER_00]: take away from Mima's purity.

01:01:05.452 --> 01:01:15.038
[SPEAKER_00]: It starts with this letter bomb, and Mr. Chota Coro survives that, and it is presented as this warning.

01:01:15.558 --> 01:01:19.040
[SPEAKER_00]: Have the screenwriter as the next victim I believe?

01:01:19.761 --> 01:01:26.065
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't actually see the violence or what's done to him, but rather the outcome.

01:01:27.025 --> 01:01:31.609
[SPEAKER_00]: as his body is left in an elevator with the size removed.

01:01:32.010 --> 01:01:33.411
[SPEAKER_00]: There's blood everywhere.

01:01:33.831 --> 01:01:35.193
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't actually see the attack.

01:01:35.273 --> 01:01:37.775
[SPEAKER_00]: We see the outcome or the results of the attack.

01:01:38.396 --> 01:01:47.384
[SPEAKER_00]: And then we have the photographer who is stabbed and we get more of a depiction of violence.

01:01:48.044 --> 01:01:52.028
[SPEAKER_00]: We basically see that entire scene unfold of the attack.

01:01:53.066 --> 01:02:01.508
[SPEAKER_00]: One, from a filmmaking perspective, you're escalating these attacks and what the audience sees showing more.

01:02:01.988 --> 01:02:14.252
[SPEAKER_00]: But also, the level of violence is struck suppose against how much or to the degree that Mima feels violated by these characters.

01:02:14.612 --> 01:02:17.052
[SPEAKER_00]: The screenwriter wrote the scene.

01:02:17.512 --> 01:02:19.453
[SPEAKER_00]: We see kind of the horrific outcome.

01:02:20.145 --> 01:02:26.808
[SPEAKER_00]: But it's clear that the photographer did more from a certain perception or perspective.

01:02:27.728 --> 01:02:32.890
[SPEAKER_00]: And that resulted in more significant violence displayed or depicted against him.

01:02:33.190 --> 01:02:34.691
[SPEAKER_00]: It creates this like parallel.

01:02:34.991 --> 01:02:43.614
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think that that's just like really thoughtful when making decisions, when putting that story together, that I don't know that we always think about.

01:02:44.482 --> 01:02:45.943
[SPEAKER_00]: Do we ever come to the conclusion?

01:02:45.963 --> 01:02:51.086
[SPEAKER_00]: Is Mamania real and was it really actually all Rumi?

01:02:51.607 --> 01:02:59.552
[SPEAKER_01]: Was it not Rumi and was it Mima or was it all just in Mima's mind and nobody was killed?

01:02:59.972 --> 01:03:13.705
[SPEAKER_01]: I just think you can read it different ways because as soon as you have to start questioning one thing you can start questioning everything and I don't know if I necessarily have a definitive answer.

01:03:13.725 --> 01:03:21.313
[SPEAKER_01]: I just think if someone told me that they had one of those four perspectives

01:03:22.153 --> 01:03:23.774
[SPEAKER_01]: I would be like, oh, yeah, I can see that.

01:03:23.954 --> 01:03:26.096
[SPEAKER_01]: I understand why you view it that way.

01:03:26.636 --> 01:03:38.323
[SPEAKER_01]: The fact that we don't necessarily have an answer makes the film interesting, but it also, I think, heightens or it supports the themes and this idea of

01:03:38.923 --> 01:03:43.226
[SPEAKER_01]: blurring of reality and fantasy kind of thing that that's going on in the film.

01:03:43.286 --> 01:03:55.636
[SPEAKER_01]: So not only is it open to interpretation, but the fact that there are possible interpretations in itself supports what the movie is trying to accomplish.

01:03:56.036 --> 01:04:03.362
[SPEAKER_00]: We've been talking about the element of celebrity and I know we talked about celebrity in general and

01:04:04.204 --> 01:04:25.162
[SPEAKER_00]: you talked about the Otaku culture we've talked about the Japanese like pop idol element and Mima is a celebrity and what's depicted here of her trying to appease others being pulled in these various directions but I guess I'm curious to hear your take on like how how

01:04:25.882 --> 01:04:34.790
[SPEAKER_00]: This film depicts being a celebrity, not like an a-list celebrity, but, you know, this middling kind of celebrity.

01:04:35.211 --> 01:04:46.120
[SPEAKER_01]: It shows only part of it, but I think what it shows is a good representation, I think, not that I know what it's like to be a celebrity.

01:04:46.180 --> 01:04:46.461
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.

01:04:48.022 --> 01:05:02.729
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I think it focuses mostly on the way people view her, the opening scene as people wait for the performance of champ to start and all these people are talking about rumors of her leaving the group, her prospects is an actress.

01:05:03.270 --> 01:05:13.435
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, like whether she is a good actress, whether she has a career in that, there's people talking about her in the manga shops and

01:05:14.175 --> 01:05:23.658
[SPEAKER_01]: talking about how they watched the latest episode and she's barely in it and that kind of like gossip that's just sort of inherent to being a celebrity.

01:05:24.338 --> 01:05:28.059
[SPEAKER_01]: Certainly shows like sort of the obsessive fan part of it as well.

01:05:28.720 --> 01:05:38.903
[SPEAKER_01]: The only other thing that I think it depicts and actually this is one of my favorite parts of the film is the loneliness of being a celebrity.

01:05:39.931 --> 01:06:04.167
[SPEAKER_01]: It's very strongly contrasted where she's leaving the performance and all these people are cheering for her and she's being handed like fan mail and she's getting into a car and people are shouting her name and then she gets home and she lives in the small apartment and it's very quiet.

01:06:08.375 --> 01:06:16.201
[SPEAKER_01]: And she kind of relies on her fish, which is like the most isolated pet to have.

01:06:16.681 --> 01:06:18.402
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not like you can even touch the fish.

01:06:18.622 --> 01:06:20.143
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not like a dog or a cat.

01:06:20.784 --> 01:06:22.205
[SPEAKER_01]: There's not that connection.

01:06:22.945 --> 01:06:26.728
[SPEAKER_01]: And then she relies on like the occasional phone call from her mother from home.

01:06:27.308 --> 01:06:32.694
[SPEAKER_01]: But the phone calls are always very short, just like a lack of connection between them.

01:06:32.774 --> 01:06:36.277
[SPEAKER_01]: They always seem like they're struggling to communicate.

01:06:36.658 --> 01:06:40.782
[SPEAKER_01]: Like there's a moment where her conversation with her mother is interrupted by another call.

01:06:41.142 --> 01:06:43.225
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like her only friend is Rumi.

01:06:43.645 --> 01:06:46.888
[SPEAKER_01]: She's the only person who like visits her at her apartment.

01:06:47.569 --> 01:06:58.818
[SPEAKER_01]: And then that goes back to this conversation about like the idea of can celebrities have friends, and especially can celebrities have friends if that friend works for them.

01:06:59.358 --> 01:07:07.405
[SPEAKER_01]: Because that person is relying on you to be successful in order for them to also make money.

01:07:08.025 --> 01:07:11.968
[SPEAKER_01]: So they're probably not putting the friendship first.

01:07:12.008 --> 01:07:15.511
[SPEAKER_01]: They're probably putting the business and the money first.

01:07:16.752 --> 01:07:23.738
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a lot of solitude and the filmmaking really kind of heightens the silence I think of those moments at home.

01:07:24.198 --> 01:07:26.620
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the part I think that spoke to me the most.

01:07:27.501 --> 01:07:44.315
[SPEAKER_00]: Another way that this film sort of just like pulls all of these different elements together from my perspective, one of the most perfect ways possible is we see like the tiring nature of that celebrity and how that

01:07:44.975 --> 01:08:05.758
[SPEAKER_00]: feeds into this disconnect and her mental state and how she's spiraling, even her questioning like, did I write this post on Mima's room where it's easy to kind of convey that there's just so much to her celebrity life, you know, spending all day

01:08:06.799 --> 01:08:13.024
[SPEAKER_00]: on a set or working in that heightened environment in the regards to the scenes that they're shooting.

01:08:13.605 --> 01:08:20.451
[SPEAKER_00]: It's one of those things feeding into the mental state, the spiral that she's having.

01:08:20.971 --> 01:08:33.401
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, this is communicating other things as well, but also just how the repetition and also how she's like in one place, she thinks she's somewhere and then we cut

01:08:34.222 --> 01:08:50.432
[SPEAKER_01]: and reveal that she's like on set filming a scene this like again can mean other things but almost like this impression that she doesn't remember how she got there she doesn't just like time as a whole is yeah that passing naturally for her

01:08:51.054 --> 01:08:57.779
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and it can be like a very draining exhausting existence physically mentally and emotionally.

01:08:58.019 --> 01:09:02.383
[SPEAKER_01]: I think you get that sense just from the way the film is structured as well.

01:09:02.643 --> 01:09:05.185
[SPEAKER_01]: I do feel like this is a very lonely film.

01:09:05.685 --> 01:09:09.909
[SPEAKER_01]: The other element that kind of signals loneliness is even when she's on set.

01:09:10.369 --> 01:09:15.853
[SPEAKER_01]: I think of her first day of shooting and they call her they're ready to shoot her scenes.

01:09:16.334 --> 01:09:19.056
[SPEAKER_01]: She has like one line of dialogue and as they're kind of

01:09:19.516 --> 01:09:41.993
[SPEAKER_01]: prepping the shot she's sitting there and we get like a series of cutaways in her perspective, you know what she's looking at and we get these shots of like the studio lights shining down on her and then we get a shot of the other actors and like the director talking and laughing and you know she's there sitting alone

01:09:42.593 --> 01:09:59.146
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, even in this world where she's surrounded by theoretically people who should kind of understand the life and maybe be a little bit more welcoming and sympathetic to it because maybe they've been there themselves in the past.

01:09:59.806 --> 01:10:01.967
[SPEAKER_01]: They don't offer that hand.

01:10:02.087 --> 01:10:08.348
[SPEAKER_01]: They form these sort of clicks, I guess, and they're off somewhere else, and they kind of leave her alone.

01:10:08.488 --> 01:10:10.709
[SPEAKER_01]: And so she's lonely at home.

01:10:11.329 --> 01:10:12.729
[SPEAKER_01]: She's lonely on set.

01:10:13.450 --> 01:10:22.412
[SPEAKER_01]: She's lonely in meetings with her managers because they're bickering back and forth, and she's kind of in the middle.

01:10:23.532 --> 01:10:29.934
[SPEAKER_01]: you know, no one's really putting her wishes or concerns first or even really considering them at all.

01:10:30.514 --> 01:10:31.854
[SPEAKER_01]: But that's just her perspective.

01:10:31.894 --> 01:10:42.576
[SPEAKER_01]: If we want to look at Mamania, let's say he's a real character, what leads him to his obsession with Mima is probably loneliness.

01:10:42.957 --> 01:10:51.519
[SPEAKER_01]: He has no friends, no girlfriend, and he's filling this void, this loneliness with this pop idol.

01:10:53.719 --> 01:11:08.320
[SPEAKER_01]: sort of feeling like she betrays him after she changes and that's what leads to him kind of lashing out so like I think loneliness is certainly part of that character as well and definitely leads to

01:11:09.101 --> 01:11:11.722
[SPEAKER_01]: his behaviors and his actions.

01:11:11.802 --> 01:11:16.124
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think you could probably say the same thing about Rumi as well.

01:11:16.144 --> 01:11:22.186
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, we don't get a lot of her outside of her interactions with Mima, obviously.

01:11:22.686 --> 01:11:30.709
[SPEAKER_01]: But if you think the celebrity life is lonely, I guess imagine what it's like to then not even be a celebrity.

01:11:31.329 --> 01:11:33.110
[SPEAKER_01]: And you don't even have the fans.

01:11:34.230 --> 01:11:36.692
[SPEAKER_01]: idolizing you and talking about you.

01:11:36.712 --> 01:11:39.975
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like even more lonely in a way.

01:11:40.476 --> 01:11:49.363
[SPEAKER_00]: There's something else that when it comes to this theme of loneliness that I also through several viewings you sort of pick up on.

01:11:50.104 --> 01:11:55.546
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's really the lack of like human contact that Mima has.

01:11:56.206 --> 01:12:04.990
[SPEAKER_00]: When she's like struggling to make the announcement on stage with Cham, there's human contact there with a member of Cham.

01:12:05.610 --> 01:12:22.221
[SPEAKER_00]: but then we don't see outside of that any like physical touch except for during these scenes within like the cop show that she's shooting otherwise it's almost completely devoid of

01:12:23.141 --> 01:12:24.561
[SPEAKER_00]: human contact with Mima.

01:12:25.261 --> 01:12:44.065
[SPEAKER_00]: So not only is it like this theme that's like being put out there and how lonely it is through her coming home alone to this small cramped apartment, the fact that it's, it's just the fish, but even in like her day to day, her interactions, there's just a lack of that touch.

01:12:44.645 --> 01:12:49.526
[SPEAKER_00]: Just those little things like that do reinforce that loneliness.

01:12:49.987 --> 01:12:50.727
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I agree.

01:12:50.747 --> 01:12:59.790
[SPEAKER_01]: And like something else, too, is if people have been listening to the podcast, this has come up before, I'm very critical of characters talking to themselves.

01:13:00.711 --> 01:13:04.592
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's one of those things where I'll acknowledge people do it in real life.

01:13:04.892 --> 01:13:06.553
[SPEAKER_01]: All right, sometimes do it in my life as well.

01:13:07.113 --> 01:13:17.597
[SPEAKER_01]: But there's certain things when translated to film that they feel artificial or they feel like they're a tool used by a screenwriter or a filmmaker.

01:13:18.637 --> 01:13:21.898
[SPEAKER_01]: characters talking to themselves typically feels that way to me.

01:13:22.658 --> 01:13:36.302
[SPEAKER_01]: But here's an example where I think her coming home to this empty quiet lonely apartment and her talking to herself does actually support this theme of loneliness and reveal a lot about who the character is.

01:13:36.602 --> 01:13:45.025
[SPEAKER_01]: She comes home, she's looking in her fridge and she's like, oh, the cheese has gone bad already and she's, you know, saying just these mundane things to herself.

01:13:46.085 --> 01:13:48.406
[SPEAKER_01]: And I would normally be kind of critical of that.

01:13:48.466 --> 01:13:51.807
[SPEAKER_01]: I think sometimes it's even used to like just feel silence in a film.

01:13:52.307 --> 01:14:08.873
[SPEAKER_01]: But here I think it is revealing a lot about the character and it's like showing her filling that void that she feels that is produced by this loneliness by just kind of talking to herself, her filling the silence in her life.

01:14:09.494 --> 01:14:10.554
[SPEAKER_01]: Something simple like that.

01:14:10.614 --> 01:14:12.835
[SPEAKER_01]: I think really supports this as well.

01:14:13.235 --> 01:14:31.373
[SPEAKER_00]: there's a number of items on the just and hates this in film bingo card that is kind of strewn about perfect blue changing of perspectives and character talking to themselves and i'm i'm acutely aware of this when i was watching it for the podcast because i'm like

01:14:32.313 --> 01:14:35.676
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, you know, we've been doing this podcast for a bit.

01:14:36.356 --> 01:14:42.801
[SPEAKER_00]: Even before that, I had a sense of the things that Justin likes or doesn't like.

01:14:43.121 --> 01:14:51.406
[SPEAKER_01]: So this is a good example of like I can be very critical of this, but every technique has its purpose.

01:14:51.707 --> 01:14:53.608
[SPEAKER_01]: Every technique has its place.

01:14:53.988 --> 01:14:57.871
[SPEAKER_01]: Every technique can be used effectively if there's

01:14:58.351 --> 01:15:04.517
[SPEAKER_01]: I think a purpose behind it, if there's intention behind it, this illustrates that, I think it works in this film.

01:15:05.057 --> 01:15:08.340
[SPEAKER_01]: I think you just have to question why are we doing it?

01:15:08.981 --> 01:15:14.425
[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe sometimes I'm a little over critical, but I just, when I'm watching most films that are guilty of this,

01:15:15.556 --> 01:15:22.920
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't see a reason behind it other than exposition or filling silence or something like that.

01:15:23.701 --> 01:15:25.102
[SPEAKER_00]: This rap scene that occurs.

01:15:25.542 --> 01:15:40.931
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a scene being shot for this television show that Mima had basically one scene and total curls like advocating for Mima to have more scenes to do more in this show and

01:15:42.673 --> 01:15:55.312
[SPEAKER_00]: It results in her character becoming like a bigger part and they shoot this rap scene at this club where she's a stripper and the crowd assaults her.

01:15:56.266 --> 01:16:06.754
[SPEAKER_00]: It's something that came up during the perfect blue lecture series in that Satoshi kind of says that he may have gone too far with it.

01:16:07.175 --> 01:16:09.557
[SPEAKER_00]: First off, I'm going to pose the question to you.

01:16:09.837 --> 01:16:13.940
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you feel like that is accurate or the case?

01:16:13.960 --> 01:16:16.322
[SPEAKER_01]: This is tough.

01:16:16.822 --> 01:16:19.604
[SPEAKER_01]: It's possible that he went a little too far.

01:16:20.625 --> 01:16:31.769
[SPEAKER_01]: But I do think it is important to make the scene as impactful as traumatizing as possible for the character, for the audience.

01:16:31.869 --> 01:16:36.571
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think what is striking about the scene is how effective it actually is.

01:16:37.292 --> 01:16:40.773
[SPEAKER_01]: At least for me, I was like, okay, this is pretty rough.

01:16:41.393 --> 01:16:44.234
[SPEAKER_01]: And yet I know I'm watching lines on a screen.

01:16:44.554 --> 01:16:45.615
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not a real person.

01:16:47.020 --> 01:17:13.998
[SPEAKER_01]: like there's always that disconnect where it's like okay this isn't real but you have to think about like if it's a live action film you go okay well it's not real but you know an actor was still subjected to this experience of filming it and it's obviously not pleasurable thing to film I mean even consensual sex scenes can be very uncomfortable to film this could be very traumatizing maybe this brings up

01:17:14.578 --> 01:17:21.580
[SPEAKER_01]: very traumatic experiences or thoughts, you know, even within that actor actress.

01:17:21.880 --> 01:17:26.482
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a voice actor, obviously, but it's not even a real person, you know, it's a drawing.

01:17:26.902 --> 01:17:35.605
[SPEAKER_01]: And yet it still is very effective at making me feel like, okay, this is, this is rough, and this is horrible, and I'm uncomfortable, which I think is

01:17:36.285 --> 01:17:37.825
[SPEAKER_01]: kind of miraculous really.

01:17:38.366 --> 01:17:58.610
[SPEAKER_00]: It's an effective scene because you can empathize with Mima in this moment because you are uncomfortable watching it and you can understand like it's got to be that much more uncomfortable doing it even though like you said it's not a human that this is happening to you.

01:17:59.150 --> 01:18:01.530
[SPEAKER_01]: There's certainly things I like about the scene.

01:18:02.171 --> 01:18:03.351
[SPEAKER_01]: It's interesting because

01:18:04.051 --> 01:18:10.434
[SPEAKER_01]: There's the moment where the actor, the male actor in the scene, is apologizing.

01:18:10.654 --> 01:18:16.157
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, the director calls cut and he's like, I'm sorry for doing this and she's like, it's okay.

01:18:16.617 --> 01:18:18.278
[SPEAKER_01]: Like that's an interesting moment.

01:18:18.959 --> 01:18:26.482
[SPEAKER_01]: There's like the moment where his zipper gets stuck and like take two or whatever and they have to reset and do another take.

01:18:27.223 --> 01:18:30.604
[SPEAKER_00]: For me, it communicated a few different things.

01:18:30.844 --> 01:18:31.005
[SPEAKER_00]: One, it,

01:18:31.965 --> 01:18:48.013
[SPEAKER_00]: demonstrated the lack of preparedness and a lack of care towards Mima in these moments like maybe a lack of respect of boundaries and what she would be comfortable with.

01:18:48.793 --> 01:19:02.847
[SPEAKER_00]: because to shoot this scene you're on setting you're going to shoot something like this you want to make the actor feel as comfortable as possible and that's not being done something as simple as like the zipper getting stuck is

01:19:04.108 --> 01:19:16.874
[SPEAKER_00]: minor carelessness, on production's part, we're making this person sit and live in this discomfort for longer, over something that doesn't even matter.

01:19:16.894 --> 01:19:29.280
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that there's other things that happen within this scene that are bigger problems that just undercut meme as feelings, the fact that it's not a close sight, you have onlookers.

01:19:30.240 --> 01:19:35.084
[SPEAKER_00]: you have like a group of people that are watching the scene from off on the side.

01:19:35.544 --> 01:19:42.489
[SPEAKER_01]: Things that I question if he as a filmmaker went too far with the scene are like these close-ups.

01:19:43.190 --> 01:19:44.711
[SPEAKER_01]: These like insert shots.

01:19:45.332 --> 01:19:50.736
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean the most notable one is like the guy reaching up her skirt and pulling her underwear down.

01:19:51.476 --> 01:20:00.901
[SPEAKER_01]: which is graphic in a way that I don't know if it is necessary because I don't know if it puts us in Mima's perspective.

01:20:01.621 --> 01:20:09.225
[SPEAKER_01]: I would say those moments where she's looking up at the lights, the studio lights, and they're kind of going in and out of focus.

01:20:09.585 --> 01:20:13.007
[SPEAKER_01]: That is far more effective than the just graphic

01:20:13.627 --> 01:20:18.268
[SPEAKER_01]: pulling her dress off and her breasts coming out and also like pulling her underwear down.

01:20:18.948 --> 01:20:24.689
[SPEAKER_01]: So I would question, what is the purpose of those very graphic shots?

01:20:25.510 --> 01:20:28.670
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it to show the brutality of the scene?

01:20:29.350 --> 01:20:36.792
[SPEAKER_01]: Or is it to, is it to almost like sexualize her in this moment?

01:20:37.387 --> 01:20:41.828
[SPEAKER_00]: Isn't that the thing that Mima is experiencing at this point, too?

01:20:42.648 --> 01:20:45.228
[SPEAKER_00]: This forced sexualization.

01:20:45.589 --> 01:20:55.390
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this moment in the scene with the photographer, and we are stripping away like the innocence of her in-cham.

01:20:55.850 --> 01:21:03.832
[SPEAKER_00]: So it is, like, forcibly, graphically stripping away all of these things.

01:21:04.852 --> 01:21:11.759
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't necessarily disagree that it probably goes a bit too far and that there's more effective moments in the scene.

01:21:11.779 --> 01:21:19.506
[SPEAKER_00]: I think in the grand scheme of it, I can rationalize some of the decisions made here.

01:21:20.107 --> 01:21:29.876
[SPEAKER_01]: So the scene also does cut out to this wide shot and we basically see the male actor like thrusting and there's a group of

01:21:30.296 --> 01:21:39.821
[SPEAKER_01]: other extras in the scene on looking and in some of them are in the foreground so they're kind of obscuring the action but it's still a very obvious what's happening.

01:21:40.801 --> 01:21:53.688
[SPEAKER_01]: That scene feels very violent and very brutal and I think that's effective but I think back to the insert of the guy's hand pulling down her underwear to me that doesn't feel the same way.

01:21:54.228 --> 01:21:55.789
[SPEAKER_01]: If this was a live action horror movie

01:21:56.429 --> 01:22:09.517
[SPEAKER_01]: I would make the argument that this is about gratuitous nudity, that this is about showing a naked woman in the film, and people getting a little bit of pleasure from that, and maybe that's still the case.

01:22:10.138 --> 01:22:18.463
[SPEAKER_01]: So I think there's moments in the scene that feel like that to me, but then there's moments that feel very graphic and very brutal, but they're effective in what

01:22:19.063 --> 01:22:20.284
[SPEAKER_01]: the film is trying to communicate.

01:22:20.304 --> 01:22:27.707
[SPEAKER_01]: So I feel like overall the scene is effective, but there's moments where I question if that was entirely the right choice.

01:22:28.227 --> 01:22:32.569
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, ultimately the representation of the scene, though, is pretty clear, I think.

01:22:32.689 --> 01:22:36.610
[SPEAKER_00]: It's really the death of Pope Idle Mima.

01:22:37.090 --> 01:22:47.535
[SPEAKER_00]: And kind of talks about the decision for her wardrobe in the scene is very like reminiscent reflective of what she wore in Cham.

01:22:48.455 --> 01:23:00.389
[SPEAKER_00]: So the chat that follows is she sitting in the dressing room in almost like a morning pose dressed in clothes that you would be wearing while while morning.

01:23:00.409 --> 01:23:03.452
[SPEAKER_00]: This is another one of those moments where

01:23:04.213 --> 01:23:11.779
[SPEAKER_00]: She just had something dramatic and traumatizing happen and there is no support.

01:23:11.879 --> 01:23:17.923
[SPEAKER_00]: There's nobody there checking on her well, being or there to be comforting.

01:23:18.303 --> 01:23:19.544
[SPEAKER_00]: It is that isolation.

01:23:19.924 --> 01:23:23.067
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the scene that follows, I think, to the coral.

01:23:23.547 --> 01:23:39.033
[SPEAKER_01]: all he really has to offer is let's go get something to eat I mean he completely lacks the the resources the understanding anything to really support her in that situation anyway so even when she is with somebody

01:23:39.893 --> 01:23:41.874
[SPEAKER_01]: She's still kind of alone.

01:23:42.494 --> 01:23:48.856
[SPEAKER_00]: And that shot is one of many shots where we see that reflection of Mima.

01:23:49.056 --> 01:23:56.919
[SPEAKER_00]: And there's so many shots where characters, especially Mima, have these reflections.

01:23:57.439 --> 01:24:00.961
[SPEAKER_00]: There's this thematic element of mirrors that continue.

01:24:00.981 --> 01:24:04.502
[SPEAKER_00]: I think we'll probably dive a little bit more into that as we go.

01:24:05.182 --> 01:24:25.927
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I mean, I think this is maybe one of the smaller things the film depicts or is maybe about, but I think this idea of sort of separating herself into like two versions, this pure version and this like dirty corrupted version certainly comes from shame.

01:24:26.007 --> 01:24:30.048
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think the shame starts even before the assault scene.

01:24:30.068 --> 01:24:33.129
[SPEAKER_01]: I think she's feeling shame for

01:24:35.269 --> 01:24:51.485
[SPEAKER_01]: not being true to herself and doing what other people want and expect and basically agreeing to things even though she doesn't really want to do them, you know, whether that be a career change, whether that be

01:24:53.540 --> 01:25:01.684
[SPEAKER_01]: taking this certain role, agreeing to a rape scene in the show, just agreeing to things that she doesn't really want to do.

01:25:01.744 --> 01:25:10.128
[SPEAKER_01]: I think there's a certain level of guilt and shame for doing that and not being honest with herself, not being honest with the people around her.

01:25:11.258 --> 01:25:33.654
[SPEAKER_01]: and then there's a certain level of shame of like after that scene after she does this graphic rap scene after she does nudity in film after she poses nude for a photo shoot this shame of like agreeing to do something she didn't believe in and feeling kind of like she's gone against who she is

01:25:34.655 --> 01:25:58.243
[SPEAKER_01]: if all of these scenes in which like these fans gossiping about her and her career are in her head, there's also a possibility that she feels guilty for letting her fans down or, you know, not being a good idol, a good role model, maybe for women, you know, like any number of things, but like there's shame that comes from that as well.

01:25:58.983 --> 01:26:08.628
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's all throughout the film, but I think that's another one of those things that could be the trigger for this spiral that she goes down.

01:26:09.088 --> 01:26:20.193
[SPEAKER_00]: We didn't talk too much about the opening of the film, at least not in a great amount of detail, but I think you see that shame even at the announcement.

01:26:20.913 --> 01:26:32.349
[SPEAKER_00]: There's that hesitation where she is ashamed to be leaving the group to let down the fans to any number of reasons.

01:26:33.330 --> 01:26:37.516
[SPEAKER_00]: This film does establish a lot of its themes, a lot of

01:26:38.598 --> 01:26:54.977
[SPEAKER_00]: important elements like right away even with like it's kind of some people might call it goofy or like out of place like power Rangers bit, but even that just has so much that's being communicated in it.

01:26:55.717 --> 01:27:10.723
[SPEAKER_00]: In regards to the shame, I mean, I think about those moments like when she comes home and all of her fish are dead, the emotional reaction there because there is a sense of shame and remorse for like failing them.

01:27:11.283 --> 01:27:15.205
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's just this continued feeling, I think, on her part of

01:27:16.065 --> 01:27:37.706
[SPEAKER_01]: everybody that she's letting down with the decisions and even like her mother says things like I thought you wanted to be a singer and that's sort of I think weighing on her as well that her mother maybe doesn't agree or doesn't understand the career change and she's letting her down as well.

01:27:38.366 --> 01:27:48.248
[SPEAKER_00]: As we've been talking about all of these different elements that lead into memos, mental collapse.

01:27:48.828 --> 01:27:59.511
[SPEAKER_00]: One of the things that we've touched on a little bit, but we haven't maybe necessarily explored is this web page that is presenting itself

01:28:00.371 --> 01:28:07.774
[SPEAKER_00]: as sort of this like blog and detailed information about Mima, it's referred to as Mima's room.

01:28:08.174 --> 01:28:23.579
[SPEAKER_00]: We talked about this earlier about how ahead of its time, it truly was because of, you know, in nineteen ninety seven when the film was released, but even like as it was being produced and made, you know, these were things that

01:28:24.199 --> 01:28:28.460
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe exist in just like certain corners of the internet, but it wasn't what it is now.

01:28:29.120 --> 01:28:43.004
[SPEAKER_00]: And Mima's room offers this insight into Mima's day, the things that she likes, she dislikes, information details that are very intrusive to Mima.

01:28:43.564 --> 01:28:48.146
[SPEAKER_00]: And it builds and it escalates as the film progresses.

01:28:48.266 --> 01:28:49.386
[SPEAKER_00]: At first, it's just like,

01:28:50.166 --> 01:29:06.573
[SPEAKER_00]: little details, I think she even kind of laughs about it or finds it like cute or charming at first, but then as Mima starts to spiral, it really gets in her head and there's a post on there about how she gets off the train with

01:29:07.447 --> 01:29:09.128
[SPEAKER_00]: stepping out with a certain foot.

01:29:10.049 --> 01:29:26.860
[SPEAKER_00]: I guess this was something that even now I still find fascinating this element of this internet personality, pretending to be somebody else within this virtual environment, was this something that mema did herself.

01:29:27.280 --> 01:29:34.525
[SPEAKER_00]: For a film that's about, I think, a lot of different things, the element of who you are online.

01:29:35.325 --> 01:29:39.026
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think was one that people would expect from this film.

01:29:39.486 --> 01:29:50.030
[SPEAKER_01]: The other thing is like just how this place where you can be anonymous sort of like frees you of like moral responsibility or something.

01:29:50.410 --> 01:29:51.850
[SPEAKER_01]: Like that's the perception.

01:29:52.371 --> 01:30:01.834
[SPEAKER_01]: You know people say things or do things online that most people wouldn't dare do to someone's face or in real life.

01:30:02.954 --> 01:30:04.216
[SPEAKER_01]: And it is certainly interesting.

01:30:04.256 --> 01:30:20.854
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I think this ties to the celebrity part, too, is like now celebrities, you know, use social media and obviously have very curated social media to give this impression that fans are seeing or getting a peak at celebrities' real lives.

01:30:22.115 --> 01:30:36.155
[SPEAKER_01]: And so they seem like real people and like almost like internet friends in a way, you know, you can see what food celebrities are eating and where they're going out and see them on vacation.

01:30:37.437 --> 01:30:39.638
[SPEAKER_01]: in a way that's sort of like what this is.

01:30:39.698 --> 01:30:47.160
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like a dire version of that where we're getting parts of her life and her feelings and emotions.

01:30:47.280 --> 01:30:56.602
[SPEAKER_01]: And so that's the thing that sort of changed is like in the film at the time it was sort of invasive or traumatizing for her.

01:30:56.923 --> 01:31:03.484
[SPEAKER_01]: And now it's like a tool to be used to feel and sort of stoke your celebrity.

01:31:03.965 --> 01:31:05.165
[SPEAKER_01]: What do you have to say about this?

01:31:05.545 --> 01:31:11.287
[SPEAKER_00]: It is fascinating how this piece of technology has evolved or its usage has evolved.

01:31:11.767 --> 01:31:25.591
[SPEAKER_00]: And within the context of the film, it is just another item that causes that spiral and becomes something that forces her to question her reality because it is quite intrusive.

01:31:26.671 --> 01:31:41.118
[SPEAKER_00]: One of the things that I do find interesting, and it really only comes up later when the perspective changes to Mamania, and there is this delusion of actually interacting with MEMA.

01:31:41.478 --> 01:31:48.661
[SPEAKER_00]: There's the question of maybe it is, maybe it isn't, for the sake of this conversation, I'm going to say that it's not.

01:31:50.122 --> 01:31:53.763
[SPEAKER_00]: and that Mamania is a physical character.

01:31:54.243 --> 01:32:16.748
[SPEAKER_00]: But just how this is depicted of that fandom taking over so much that you believe this internet personality, this blog or this website that you don't actually know who's behind it, who's running it and in charge of it, but we are such fans and we're so committed and dedicated.

01:32:17.448 --> 01:32:43.967
[SPEAKER_00]: that this must be the real Mima, this must be Mima's way of like interacting with me, her fans, and furthering some of the delusion, it does make me think about just the level of responsible nature that one has, and how this theme has evolved into our modern times of

01:32:44.888 --> 01:32:49.490
[SPEAKER_00]: It's just so easy to take what I'm seeing here on this site.

01:32:49.910 --> 01:32:56.413
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to believe it versus, well, no, I'm going to question this and I'm going to doubt it.

01:32:56.753 --> 01:32:57.753
[SPEAKER_00]: It's easier to believe.

01:32:58.053 --> 01:33:04.796
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, Mima is interacting with me versus the the stark reality.

01:33:05.897 --> 01:33:20.443
[SPEAKER_00]: Another avenue of this celebrity culture, too, is the significant desire of I want to be Mima so much that I'm going to create this web page and pose as her rather than

01:33:21.503 --> 01:33:43.081
[SPEAKER_00]: I guess finding something constructive for, you know, I'm not trying to be cute about it, but really like the obsession with celebrity and the desire to be them so much that we fake it and we pretend to be something that we're not to the point that we lose our identity.

01:33:44.222 --> 01:34:01.904
[SPEAKER_00]: If we are to believe that the end version of Rumi and that reveal is an actual physical Rumi, I do think that it's Rumi's website pretending to be Mima because it is in obsession at that point.

01:34:02.324 --> 01:34:04.905
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's the first step of becoming her.

01:34:05.425 --> 01:34:09.366
[SPEAKER_01]: It is, which only gets more and more drastic and extreme.

01:34:10.126 --> 01:34:21.710
[SPEAKER_01]: But the film I think does a lot to set up that things being written in the online diary, Mima's room, are things that Mima communicated to Rumi.

01:34:22.110 --> 01:34:24.291
[SPEAKER_01]: The obvious example is they're on the set.

01:34:24.751 --> 01:34:28.372
[SPEAKER_01]: Mima says she's another person when the camera is rolling.

01:34:29.253 --> 01:34:33.755
[SPEAKER_01]: And then that is directly repeated in Mima's room.

01:34:34.195 --> 01:34:35.916
[SPEAKER_01]: Of it that you can imagine that.

01:34:36.456 --> 01:34:39.898
[SPEAKER_01]: If you want to view it this way, Rumi is writing these things.

01:34:40.578 --> 01:34:43.880
[SPEAKER_01]: Mima does not understand how anyone knows these things.

01:34:44.220 --> 01:34:53.324
[SPEAKER_01]: She would never question or suspect that it's one of her managers doing this because that's the person who's supposed to be looking out for you and protecting you.

01:34:54.204 --> 01:35:01.808
[SPEAKER_01]: So she invents this fictional stalker who is the source of these online diaries.

01:35:02.408 --> 01:35:07.311
[SPEAKER_01]: That's how this stalker becomes a part of her mind.

01:35:08.031 --> 01:35:11.533
[SPEAKER_01]: If you view, Mamania is a fictional character.

01:35:11.993 --> 01:35:27.793
[SPEAKER_00]: As the film progresses, both through the story being told and that's the perspective of Mima, the blurring lines of what's happening in Mima's life versus her shooting this television show.

01:35:28.834 --> 01:35:35.639
[SPEAKER_00]: The lines between fact and fiction absolutely start to fall apart.

01:35:35.979 --> 01:35:47.006
[SPEAKER_00]: And just so you talked about this earlier, this is absolutely enhanced by the editing of the film where we enter the unreliable narrator phase where we're questioning everything.

01:35:47.366 --> 01:35:56.552
[SPEAKER_00]: It's depicted really well by the fact that we're going from one scene that feels like a continuation of something

01:35:57.432 --> 01:36:07.661
[SPEAKER_00]: And then it's revealed to us that, oh, actually this is part of the television show, or, you know, this actually is taking place at a completely separate time later.

01:36:08.041 --> 01:36:13.445
[SPEAKER_00]: And I would call it jarring, but I mean that in a, actually, positive way.

01:36:13.465 --> 01:36:24.374
[SPEAKER_00]: It creates this like jarring experience that does put us into memos psyche and like the constant questioning of reality.

01:36:25.195 --> 01:36:31.655
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you have any thoughts on how the spiral is displayed and just your overall feelings on it?

01:36:32.249 --> 01:36:39.911
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, I think the film is able to accomplish a lot because it's animated.

01:36:39.931 --> 01:36:51.915
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, certainly now we can kind of do anything pretty much with CGI and that opens up a lot of doors to tell different types of stories.

01:36:52.135 --> 01:36:55.756
[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, in ninety seven, you definitely would not have been able to do

01:36:56.656 --> 01:37:13.289
[SPEAKER_01]: is much as they were able to do through animation in terms of like blending the scenes together there's like these match cuts basically as we transition from one scene to the next and and whether that is like

01:37:13.869 --> 01:37:21.597
[SPEAKER_01]: from reality to fantasy or television to reality, television to fantasy.

01:37:21.617 --> 01:37:30.986
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I think the use of repetition, you know, like how many times we cut back to her just lying in bed in the same sort of composition and

01:37:32.948 --> 01:37:44.312
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, certainly the idea of her sort of like coming to in bed implies that it was a dream of some kind, but obviously that's too simple.

01:37:44.752 --> 01:37:46.693
[SPEAKER_01]: There's obviously much more going on.

01:37:47.373 --> 01:37:51.434
[SPEAKER_00]: The repeated scenes were those scenes that like mirror match.

01:37:52.014 --> 01:37:52.935
[SPEAKER_00]: It creates this

01:37:53.855 --> 01:37:58.519
[SPEAKER_00]: sense of like Desha Vue and disorientation as far as.

01:37:59.019 --> 01:38:00.901
[SPEAKER_00]: Wait, I've been here before.

01:38:01.461 --> 01:38:02.562
[SPEAKER_00]: Wait, have I been here?

01:38:02.662 --> 01:38:04.183
[SPEAKER_00]: No, it's different now.

01:38:04.203 --> 01:38:16.613
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the film challenges you to almost like question your own mental acuity as you're watching it because it does such a great job of putting you in me must choose with this.

01:38:17.453 --> 01:38:29.896
[SPEAKER_00]: If I struggle with anything with this film as far as like, I don't know if this completely works for me is sometimes the cutting back to like the the cop show in a way.

01:38:29.916 --> 01:38:34.717
[SPEAKER_00]: It feels like it's telling us what's happening in the actual film.

01:38:34.737 --> 01:38:42.339
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the rest of the film does enough to subvert that and misdirect away from it.

01:38:43.079 --> 01:38:46.380
[SPEAKER_00]: But it does still feel like those moments are

01:38:47.360 --> 01:38:51.822
[SPEAKER_00]: while they're interesting because they're continuing to like push the psyche.

01:38:51.842 --> 01:38:54.783
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know that they always work for me.

01:38:55.063 --> 01:39:10.869
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the one that stands out to me is the conversation between the two leads of the cop show where it's almost like they're having this conversation of oh she has like this dissociative personality disorder.

01:39:11.069 --> 01:39:16.391
[SPEAKER_00]: So she thinks that she's actually this person, but this person was created in her mind.

01:39:16.871 --> 01:39:27.038
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I think it's often popular in live action films that use like these similar themes to focus on the utilization of mirrors.

01:39:27.619 --> 01:39:37.066
[SPEAKER_00]: We touched on the use of a mirror before and how these are used to reflect this is who the character is, who they are

01:39:37.946 --> 01:39:56.195
[SPEAKER_00]: Oftentimes in live action films, there's the almost the obligatory, the person in the mirror is not the person looking back at them to kind of communicate and give the audience that this person is different or there's something off here.

01:39:57.064 --> 01:40:14.053
[SPEAKER_00]: It's interesting that even in animation and a different form of filmmaking, the visual language of this, it is just universal and cross-cultural too because you see this in a Japanese film versus an American film.

01:40:14.133 --> 01:40:19.857
[SPEAKER_01]: So, so much of this is about how we view ourselves.

01:40:20.777 --> 01:40:21.958
[SPEAKER_01]: how other people view us.

01:40:22.598 --> 01:40:36.389
[SPEAKER_01]: In this case, what we just talked about, there's like a disconnect between who Mima thinks she is, who she really is, or who she really believes she is, and sort of the outward appearance, the thing everybody else sees.

01:40:37.109 --> 01:40:44.475
[SPEAKER_01]: The mirror has the power to reveal who someone truly is as well, which is literally depicted.

01:40:45.235 --> 01:40:53.003
[SPEAKER_01]: through the reveal that Rumi is this cham version of Mima.

01:40:53.664 --> 01:41:03.053
[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I mean, I think it's is so much about wanting to be something, wanting to be what people may be expect and then not

01:41:04.394 --> 01:41:27.316
[SPEAKER_01]: representing that or not matching that ideal it's set up right away in the film like a couple shots in she's writing on the train and her reflection and then that shot is mirrored later in which that reflection then moves and talks to her and says sort of very derogatory things to her and

01:41:28.217 --> 01:41:54.759
[SPEAKER_01]: certainly hints at the shame that she's feeling it's relevant that like it sets up this concept of mirrors and reflections and it kind of pays them off in two big scenes I think though first being the reveal of roomy and the second being like it's the final shot of the film in which she finally looks in and is happy with what she sees in the mirror and

01:41:55.680 --> 01:42:01.467
[SPEAKER_00]: I believe much like a lot of this film, you can interpret that ending different ways too though.

01:42:01.787 --> 01:42:08.835
[SPEAKER_01]: I think you can, but I don't know if the film really gives you much to go off of other than what you, as if you were bring to it.

01:42:09.402 --> 01:42:10.683
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I agree with that.

01:42:11.704 --> 01:42:14.187
[SPEAKER_01]: I guess I'm going to first ask, did you actually like the end?

01:42:14.628 --> 01:42:15.208
[SPEAKER_01]: I do like it.

01:42:15.529 --> 01:42:17.030
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, because it's two things.

01:42:17.090 --> 01:42:29.083
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like there's that moment where the nurses are talking and they're like, um, was that Mima and they're like, oh, no, it must have been like a local like and then when she says, no, I'm real.

01:42:29.443 --> 01:42:30.404
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm the real Mima.

01:42:30.625 --> 01:42:30.785
[SPEAKER_01]: Well,

01:42:31.105 --> 01:42:40.412
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I watched the Japanese version second so that's the version that's in my mind most okay so in the Japanese version I think she says

01:42:41.680 --> 01:42:42.320
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm real.

01:42:43.141 --> 01:42:45.942
[SPEAKER_01]: And then what she says on the real Mima in the English version.

01:42:46.042 --> 01:42:46.362
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:42:47.862 --> 01:42:52.384
[SPEAKER_01]: But basically what she says into the mirror is almost like a response to the nurses.

01:42:53.024 --> 01:42:55.745
[SPEAKER_01]: But then it's also like a statement to herself.

01:42:56.166 --> 01:42:59.647
[SPEAKER_01]: But then it's also like a message delivered directly to the audience as well.

01:43:00.307 --> 01:43:02.248
[SPEAKER_01]: So I felt like that was really interesting.

01:43:02.688 --> 01:43:09.151
[SPEAKER_00]: I see the ending with her looking in the mirror and saying, I'm real or I'm the real mema.

01:43:09.171 --> 01:43:15.673
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think maybe I am taking this more from like the English dub version than the subtitle version.

01:43:16.093 --> 01:43:26.537
[SPEAKER_00]: I can understand somebody viewing it as it's her like reclaiming and reaffirming herself as her identity, taking that control back.

01:43:26.997 --> 01:43:28.218
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm also wondering like,

01:43:28.798 --> 01:43:38.641
[SPEAKER_00]: Is it intended to just be her reassuring herself that she's the real MEMA because there is doubt still the doubt exists?

01:43:39.341 --> 01:43:43.302
[SPEAKER_00]: And maybe there just isn't a real MEMA anymore?

01:43:44.262 --> 01:43:57.366
[SPEAKER_00]: Knowing what we know about the Japanese idol culture, the work that goes into it, then her being with Cham, then her transitioning out of Cham into being an actress and posing nude and

01:43:57.893 --> 01:44:01.335
[SPEAKER_00]: Everything that she has gone through is there even a real Mima.

01:44:01.675 --> 01:44:05.396
[SPEAKER_00]: It gives the impression of like a positive reaffirming ending.

01:44:05.996 --> 01:44:14.400
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that that's understandable and I can respect and understand, especially with like the things that Mima went through.

01:44:15.000 --> 01:44:23.364
[SPEAKER_00]: But then over the course of it, there's this constant theme of like duality in her fish tank, there were two fish that survived.

01:44:23.904 --> 01:44:32.510
[SPEAKER_00]: So even right there, the film is communicating no matter who we are, there's always like the different sides of us.

01:44:33.051 --> 01:44:41.417
[SPEAKER_00]: It's easiest to describe it as like, okay, I'm one person when I'm at work, I'm one person when I'm at home and we're constantly leading those like two separate lives.

01:44:41.457 --> 01:44:43.318
[SPEAKER_00]: Now in this case, it's far more extreme.

01:44:43.999 --> 01:44:50.424
[SPEAKER_00]: And if we compound it like with everything she goes through, there just is no recognition of oneself.

01:44:51.243 --> 01:44:56.345
[SPEAKER_00]: And the statement I am real is forcing it.

01:44:56.746 --> 01:45:04.189
[SPEAKER_00]: I do exist or I am this person even though there is potentially the self doubt.

01:45:04.649 --> 01:45:09.992
[SPEAKER_01]: The other thing is I've laid this out as a possibility is the idea that

01:45:10.692 --> 01:45:14.296
[SPEAKER_01]: Rumi, this version of Rumi is not real.

01:45:14.557 --> 01:45:14.737
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

01:45:15.097 --> 01:45:29.314
[SPEAKER_01]: In that case, the fact that she's visiting her in the hospital says that this is not over as a alternative Rumi died like this version that attacks her died.

01:45:30.095 --> 01:45:35.079
[SPEAKER_01]: It's almost like, okay, this is the death of this part of me, or this personality.

01:45:35.499 --> 01:45:38.341
[SPEAKER_01]: And now I'm my self again.

01:45:39.021 --> 01:45:44.545
[SPEAKER_01]: Mima dives in front of the the truck, the oncoming truck, and saves her life.

01:45:45.006 --> 01:45:45.946
[SPEAKER_01]: So she lives on.

01:45:47.027 --> 01:45:55.795
[SPEAKER_01]: And then she goes to visit her in the hospital, assuming that this is, you know, fictional version that's living in her mind, she lives on.

01:45:56.195 --> 01:45:57.616
[SPEAKER_01]: And she can always go visit her.

01:45:58.257 --> 01:46:05.603
[SPEAKER_01]: So at any point, she could return to this spiral that she had just experienced, like nothing's really changed.

01:46:06.304 --> 01:46:08.666
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's a possibility to view it that way as well.

01:46:09.323 --> 01:46:14.325
[SPEAKER_00]: There's also the way to interpret this that she's not there visiting.

01:46:14.625 --> 01:46:15.185
[SPEAKER_00]: That's her.

01:46:15.265 --> 01:46:16.225
[SPEAKER_00]: That's where she is.

01:46:17.186 --> 01:46:17.886
[SPEAKER_00]: Mima that is.

01:46:18.526 --> 01:46:18.746
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

01:46:19.166 --> 01:46:21.107
[SPEAKER_00]: Mima has been institutionalized.

01:46:21.687 --> 01:46:26.029
[SPEAKER_00]: I choose to maybe see it a little differently.

01:46:27.429 --> 01:46:33.131
[SPEAKER_00]: I see you have an interpretation or do you have the way of viewing this that maybe sends out to you.

01:46:33.732 --> 01:46:41.115
[SPEAKER_01]: At this point in time, I tend to believe that version of Rumi that attacks her is real.

01:46:41.135 --> 01:46:45.377
[SPEAKER_01]: I think I tend to believe that Mamania

01:46:46.557 --> 01:46:49.178
[SPEAKER_01]: is a fictional creation in her mind.

01:46:49.418 --> 01:46:55.561
[SPEAKER_01]: I think this is kind of where I land right now, although I probably will change my opinion and the more I think about it.

01:46:56.261 --> 01:46:58.222
[SPEAKER_01]: And so when it comes to the ending, I think

01:46:59.415 --> 01:47:10.163
[SPEAKER_01]: I, you know, for once, I think I'm going to believe that there's a bit of hope and I am going to embrace the hopeful ending for once in my life.

01:47:11.884 --> 01:47:15.447
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just feeling like, I guess I'm feeling good about things.

01:47:19.074 --> 01:47:21.715
[SPEAKER_01]: I stand by the fact that I don't have a definitive answer.

01:47:22.616 --> 01:47:24.556
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's kind of what's exciting, too.

01:47:25.097 --> 01:47:39.403
[SPEAKER_00]: And maybe that's one of the reasons why I do keep coming back to this film is every viewing, if you change your perspective or change the lens in which you look at it, it becomes something different.

01:47:39.923 --> 01:47:46.966
[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean this in the best way possible, like by all accounts, one could interpret this as a very simple film.

01:47:47.458 --> 01:47:55.841
[SPEAKER_00]: If we were just looking at everything ignoring like the subtext, just looking at it at face value, it can feel like a very simple film.

01:47:56.422 --> 01:48:04.145
[SPEAKER_00]: But then, once you start peeling back the layers and start questioning the reality of it all, you find so much more here.

01:48:05.336 --> 01:48:17.864
[SPEAKER_00]: I've touched on various points in the episode about the way that the scenes kind of cut together to create this disconnected nature between the scenes as an editor.

01:48:17.904 --> 01:48:22.827
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you have anything else that you want to maybe touch on or that stood out to you with us?

01:48:23.308 --> 01:48:30.252
[SPEAKER_01]: The film uses editing and structure the way you would typically see a live action film.

01:48:31.673 --> 01:48:31.953
[SPEAKER_01]: What?

01:48:32.533 --> 01:48:34.714
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that's pretty unique.

01:48:34.794 --> 01:48:37.335
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, there's a couple scenes that stick out to me.

01:48:37.375 --> 01:48:47.958
[SPEAKER_01]: The opening scene is obviously one in which we're cross cutting the performance, cross cutting that with Mima on the train.

01:48:49.579 --> 01:49:03.952
[SPEAKER_01]: going to the store buying fish food and inner cutting these things are cross cutting these things but the ability to like perfectly match cut because it's a drawing it's animated and you can you have a little bit more control over

01:49:04.952 --> 01:49:08.054
[SPEAKER_01]: character placement and character movement within the frame.

01:49:08.454 --> 01:49:15.137
[SPEAKER_01]: Just the way that this cross-cutting can communicate so much about who the character is so quickly.

01:49:15.517 --> 01:49:22.701
[SPEAKER_01]: So essentially this cross-cutting is really heightening and really emphasizing the contrast between these two different worlds.

01:49:23.181 --> 01:49:25.422
[SPEAKER_01]: There is the world in which she's on stage.

01:49:25.822 --> 01:49:29.624
[SPEAKER_01]: There's all these people watching her paying attention to her.

01:49:29.904 --> 01:49:32.025
[SPEAKER_01]: Sort of like every move and they're cheering for her.

01:49:32.345 --> 01:49:32.926
[SPEAKER_01]: It's loud.

01:49:33.686 --> 01:49:41.453
[SPEAKER_01]: and then we cut to this other version of her, the personal version and it's quiet and she's alone.

01:49:42.214 --> 01:49:54.185
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's contrasting these two worlds and so like cross-cutting these is just heightening that contrast even more and where we see her on stage for a moment and then we see her at the supermarket.

01:49:54.506 --> 01:49:56.688
[SPEAKER_01]: We see her on stage for a moment and then we see her

01:49:57.088 --> 01:50:00.811
[SPEAKER_01]: crossing the street and walking home and inner apartment.

01:50:00.891 --> 01:50:03.233
[SPEAKER_01]: So it communicates a lot about who the character is.

01:50:03.693 --> 01:50:15.222
[SPEAKER_01]: Does a lot of great sort of like set up an exposition about the situation, her transition in career, but that contrast heightens the loneliness when she gets home.

01:50:15.803 --> 01:50:17.084
[SPEAKER_01]: So I think that's a great moment.

01:50:17.104 --> 01:50:21.667
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, obviously editing is what's creating this sense of

01:50:22.508 --> 01:50:26.211
[SPEAKER_01]: disorientation in the sense of like what's real, what's fantasy.

01:50:26.251 --> 01:50:33.917
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that's created all through the edit, the fact that we're cutting from her filming something on set to her now in bed.

01:50:34.277 --> 01:50:46.427
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, she's looking at Mamania dead on the film set and then we cut to a crowd of extras and crew out cheering for her performance.

01:50:46.627 --> 01:50:48.829
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's like, okay, wait a minute, is this real?

01:50:49.189 --> 01:50:50.110
[SPEAKER_01]: Is this part of

01:50:50.730 --> 01:50:51.030
[SPEAKER_01]: show.

01:50:51.390 --> 01:50:54.651
[SPEAKER_01]: That's a juxtaposition that is created through the edit.

01:50:55.131 --> 01:51:05.613
[SPEAKER_01]: So the whole second half of the film in which she's slowly unraveling, we as a viewer are questioning what is real, what's not, that's created through the edit.

01:51:05.993 --> 01:51:15.815
[SPEAKER_01]: But the other scene that I really like that really stood out to me is the cross-cutting of Mima's photo shoot and the cham performance.

01:51:16.295 --> 01:51:22.119
[SPEAKER_01]: and how it communicates the different places that the group and Mima are in.

01:51:23.080 --> 01:51:27.463
[SPEAKER_01]: It communicates how her life and her career change so much.

01:51:27.483 --> 01:51:30.626
[SPEAKER_01]: It communicates where she would like to be potentially.

01:51:31.366 --> 01:51:41.690
[SPEAKER_01]: but it's like cross-cutting flash bulbs of like the photographer and then like reporters and paparazzi at the show and it's these perfect match cuts.

01:51:42.570 --> 01:51:55.355
[SPEAKER_01]: Both groups are being photographed at the same time but one has a very positive feeling and one has a very negative feeling and trading that meaning through that juxtaposition I think is interesting.

01:51:55.875 --> 01:52:13.472
[SPEAKER_01]: you know there's a lot of really interesting animation techniques here like if you're into animation to kind of look at like the use of planes like the use of like a foreground element in the background element and like creating that parallax as there's like a camera move creating that sort of depth that's interesting the use of it like action lines

01:52:14.153 --> 01:52:16.937
[SPEAKER_01]: At moments is interesting, like you want to analyze that.

01:52:16.957 --> 01:52:24.446
[SPEAKER_01]: The close-ups of Mima as she's running and using action lines to illustrate motion and movement and speed.

01:52:24.926 --> 01:52:29.852
[SPEAKER_01]: The way sometimes faces are drawn and sometimes faces are not drawn.

01:52:30.213 --> 01:52:31.995
[SPEAKER_01]: These are like animation techniques.

01:52:32.475 --> 01:52:37.299
[SPEAKER_01]: sort of techniques that only exist in animation, not necessarily in live action.

01:52:37.859 --> 01:52:45.425
[SPEAKER_01]: I think there's interesting stuff there to look at and analyze and but I keep going back to the fact that like this is not good animation.

01:52:45.625 --> 01:52:48.167
[SPEAKER_01]: This is just good filmmaking.

01:52:48.748 --> 01:52:50.269
[SPEAKER_01]: It's irrelevant that it's animated.

01:52:50.329 --> 01:52:51.029
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I think of

01:52:52.015 --> 01:53:19.255
[SPEAKER_01]: American animation I guess around the time period that this film came out it did feel like it was so much just about creating interesting characters maybe it was about good storytelling but it wasn't about good filmmaking necessarily now if we look at animation American animation today it feels like it's so much about creating beautiful shots or like being photo real through CG animation and it's about the tech

01:53:19.895 --> 01:53:30.670
[SPEAKER_01]: maybe pay for this film we have this new hair technology or we have this new rain technology and it's all just about creating pretty images.

01:53:31.209 --> 01:53:35.692
[SPEAKER_00]: Why do I feel like we have this conversation about live action filmmaking?

01:53:35.912 --> 01:53:37.373
[SPEAKER_01]: Because we do.

01:53:37.393 --> 01:53:48.159
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I don't watch a lot of animation to be completely honest with you, but like when I do, I just don't feel like I'm watching great filmmaking.

01:53:48.420 --> 01:53:50.801
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like the focus is always on something else.

01:53:51.441 --> 01:53:54.043
[SPEAKER_01]: And there may be moments that go against that.

01:53:54.083 --> 01:53:55.144
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I think maybe

01:53:55.964 --> 01:54:02.250
[SPEAKER_01]: I think people talk about like the opening of up as being like a really good piece of visual storytelling.

01:54:02.670 --> 01:54:10.237
[SPEAKER_01]: But for the most part, I just feel like the focus is on other things and this is an animated film that it's almost like a relevant and it's animated.

01:54:10.657 --> 01:54:13.280
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just such good filmmaking all around.

01:54:13.800 --> 01:54:32.411
[SPEAKER_00]: even the cinematography and I know that's kind of a weird thing to talk about when it's all animated but there still is like that cinematography mindset as far as you're framing as far as like where the camera would be set up one of the shots that we talked about before was that wide shot

01:54:33.411 --> 01:54:58.552
[SPEAKER_00]: after Mima's like shot the rap scene and even just like the framing of it and we're sitting in looking at something that maybe we're not meant to be there for but also it's communicating and and relaying more information about the state of Mima too the framing of Mima in her room we have like overhead shots

01:54:59.413 --> 01:55:05.254
[SPEAKER_00]: creates almost a sense of tension and that voyeuristic visual.

01:55:06.374 --> 01:55:28.439
[SPEAKER_00]: The way that the film visualizes and depicts through various methods, the pop idol memea versus the actress memea, there's a significant difference in the wardrobe, the color schemes that are utilized, even like the locations, when there's something like chamrelated at the beginning,

01:55:29.219 --> 01:55:50.770
[SPEAKER_00]: things are very like bright sunny but then as we get more into meme of the actress and model things are very dark even certain scenes where it's very well lit there's like very dark shading that's happening across those scenes

01:55:51.530 --> 01:55:56.034
[SPEAKER_00]: And again, like, that's not specific to animation.

01:55:56.574 --> 01:55:58.736
[SPEAKER_00]: That's not specific to live action filmmaking.

01:55:59.096 --> 01:56:01.037
[SPEAKER_00]: That's just good filmmaking.

01:56:01.458 --> 01:56:04.440
[SPEAKER_01]: The other thing is, like, we didn't really say this.

01:56:04.500 --> 01:56:10.725
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, people probably know this or whatever, but this is Satoshi Khan's first film.

01:56:11.325 --> 01:56:14.267
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I mean, we talk about great debut features.

01:56:14.808 --> 01:56:19.532
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, the pinnacle for us for a long time will be after Sun, right?

01:56:20.252 --> 01:56:22.153
[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, this has to be up there, right?

01:56:22.173 --> 01:56:25.556
[SPEAKER_01]: There's like one of the great debut features.

01:56:26.376 --> 01:56:45.508
[SPEAKER_01]: There is just so much, so many great examples of really well-construct scenes, great filmmaking, inventive choices, but then also like, there's such a strong point of view and a strong vision for a first feature, I think, all that is worth praising.

01:56:45.569 --> 01:56:47.290
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, it's not always the case.

01:56:48.438 --> 01:56:54.340
[SPEAKER_01]: There's two like sound design elements that stood out to me, both pretty simple techniques.

01:56:54.460 --> 01:57:01.583
[SPEAKER_01]: But the first is it happens when we're at home with Mima.

01:57:01.983 --> 01:57:05.464
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, she gets the phone call with like the heavy breathing.

01:57:06.265 --> 01:57:07.145
[SPEAKER_01]: She gets the facts.

01:57:07.925 --> 01:57:09.706
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like traitor, traitor, traitor, traitor.

01:57:09.886 --> 01:57:11.767
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's like that intense kind of music.

01:57:12.447 --> 01:57:14.608
[SPEAKER_01]: And she gets the sense that she's being watched.

01:57:15.308 --> 01:57:21.092
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the camera is pulling away from her apartment, pulling away from her window.

01:57:21.633 --> 01:57:32.020
[SPEAKER_01]: This intense music is sort of pounding on the soundtrack and she approaches the window and whips the curtains on how window closed and that music just cuts off abruptly.

01:57:35.242 --> 01:57:38.004
[SPEAKER_01]: Just think that's a really interesting sound design choice.

01:57:39.152 --> 01:57:53.295
[SPEAKER_01]: If that music represents either someone spying on her, or the paranoia that someone is spying on her, as soon as those curtains close, that paranoia doesn't really stop.

01:57:53.475 --> 01:58:05.098
[SPEAKER_01]: But there's a certain level of privacy that is introduced with those curtains being closed, and that paranoia kind of is diminished, or if it literally is someone spying, that person can no longer see.

01:58:05.638 --> 01:58:08.779
[SPEAKER_01]: And so like that sound representing that, I think is really interesting.

01:58:09.419 --> 01:58:11.381
[SPEAKER_01]: The second is the writer.

01:58:11.401 --> 01:58:27.817
[SPEAKER_01]: He's like in a parking garage and he is approaching elevator and we hear them music and we don't at first know where that music is coming from and then the elevator doors open and there's like a blue box sitting on the floor of the elevator blaring the channel music

01:58:33.479 --> 01:58:53.477
[SPEAKER_01]: And that music is clipped and there's like a level of distortion that comes with that clipping I thought that was a really interesting sound design choice as well to sell a sense of volume a sense of noise but also a sense of like chaos and a sense of danger it just adds to that moment because you know

01:58:53.717 --> 01:58:59.180
[SPEAKER_01]: As a sound designer, you have the ability to make that as loud as you potentially want.

01:58:59.780 --> 01:59:11.166
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's not just about volume, but it's about creating that tension and that danger in that moment and the crispy distorted audio coming from that boombox speakers.

01:59:11.227 --> 01:59:13.528
[SPEAKER_01]: I thought that was like an interesting sound design choice.

01:59:14.188 --> 01:59:23.071
[SPEAKER_01]: I think all the techniques being used just do a really great job of putting us into Mima's point of view as well.

01:59:23.571 --> 01:59:29.473
[SPEAKER_01]: Like we just get a sense that we're in her mind, we're seeing the world through her eyes experiencing it with her.

01:59:30.133 --> 01:59:56.013
[SPEAKER_01]: all of the sort of like cutaways to studio lights during the salt scene shots of the lights and like people like peering over her they kind of go in and out of focus like things like that that's put us in her perspective and actually like in regards to that that sequence as well is the way that that camera spins and you almost feel like your head is spinning with her in that moment.

01:59:56.690 --> 02:00:13.206
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think the detail, the detail of the animation is something that we have talked about this in terms of just like great filmmaking, but it is clear that this was painstakingly animated as well to just make sure that those details are captured visually.

02:00:13.887 --> 02:00:16.369
[SPEAKER_00]: This is one of my all time favorite films.

02:00:16.669 --> 02:00:20.253
[SPEAKER_00]: I hope you understand why based off of this feeling and

02:00:20.673 --> 02:00:21.473
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, absolutely.

02:00:21.513 --> 02:00:24.155
[SPEAKER_00]: Started this conversation by saying, I'm always conflicted.

02:00:24.175 --> 02:00:41.142
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know that I did necessarily the film Justice talking about it today and I know I'm going to wake up tomorrow and I'm going to reflect upon all of the other things I wish that we had time for that we could have unpacked spent more time with

02:00:41.582 --> 02:00:41.782
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

02:00:42.502 --> 02:00:43.463
[SPEAKER_01]: That is usually the case.

02:00:44.884 --> 02:00:51.127
[SPEAKER_01]: But there are certain movies where it feels like that's more relevant than others.

02:00:51.527 --> 02:01:02.652
[SPEAKER_00]: I just want to mention one thing since we're maybe diving a little bit into technique and we've been focused very much on just how there's like good filmmaking here.

02:01:03.012 --> 02:01:05.894
[SPEAKER_00]: I know that you and I often talk about just

02:01:07.434 --> 02:01:19.340
[SPEAKER_00]: We want to have a plan, but we are not going to handcuff ourselves to a plan, because we want to and need to just find those things organically, because that's what interests us.

02:01:21.141 --> 02:01:34.508
[SPEAKER_00]: During the perfect blue lecture series, Toshikan talks about anime versus live action, because he does talk a little bit about his process for creating this film.

02:01:35.468 --> 02:02:00.450
[SPEAKER_00]: and there is a lot there that I think is incredibly valuable and insightful, not just from an animation perspective, but the things that you and I were talking about on this episode, it really does come through because the effort, the thought, the meticulousness in crafting this film, is on display listening to him talk about it.

02:02:00.990 --> 02:02:02.411
[SPEAKER_00]: He does make a statement, though.

02:02:03.272 --> 02:02:08.375
[SPEAKER_00]: about anime versus live action because this was originally going to be a live action film.

02:02:09.256 --> 02:02:11.377
[SPEAKER_00]: In live action, you can capture accidents.

02:02:11.917 --> 02:02:16.200
[SPEAKER_00]: But in animation, it's a luxury not available to the filmmaker.

02:02:17.284 --> 02:02:20.427
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's probably pretty obvious, right?

02:02:20.687 --> 02:02:26.792
[SPEAKER_00]: You have to have that plan, the meticulous nature in which he approached making this film.

02:02:27.593 --> 02:02:37.842
[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's just very fascinating even beyond an animation standpoint, but just from a stance of this was a filmmaker.

02:02:38.622 --> 02:02:39.843
[SPEAKER_01]: Like this is his vision.

02:02:40.403 --> 02:02:42.285
[SPEAKER_01]: It's his pure vision.

02:02:42.405 --> 02:02:44.886
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it's still a collaborative medium.

02:02:45.427 --> 02:02:50.670
[SPEAKER_01]: There's so many examples of this, but I'm thinking back to our stranger than paradise discussion.

02:02:50.690 --> 02:02:57.495
[SPEAKER_01]: We talked about how that scene in which they'd go and visit Lake Erie and it was like a white out.

02:02:57.755 --> 02:02:59.096
[SPEAKER_01]: It was just snowing and how

02:02:59.756 --> 02:03:04.623
[SPEAKER_01]: that white-out actually added to the scene, but it was not intended.

02:03:04.984 --> 02:03:11.553
[SPEAKER_01]: Like that's one of those little accidents that happened in live action that can add to a scene.

02:03:11.933 --> 02:03:13.015
[SPEAKER_01]: None of that exists here.

02:03:13.335 --> 02:03:13.615
[SPEAKER_01]: U.S.

02:03:14.016 --> 02:03:16.700
[SPEAKER_01]: the animators have to create everything.

02:03:17.060 --> 02:03:37.949
[SPEAKER_01]: you can't accidentally draw snow maybe you're missing out on something because you didn't think of something or you didn't think to do it that way but at the same time it is purely your vision which I think is always worth acknowledging and worth praising I would love to see a film that is flawed

02:03:38.769 --> 02:03:49.498
[SPEAKER_01]: That has things that don't work, but it is like so obvious that it comes from a director who has a strong vision, then something that is like perfect and polished.

02:03:49.578 --> 02:03:54.182
[SPEAKER_01]: And the film with the vision is always going to beat out anything that's quote unquote perfect.

02:03:54.767 --> 02:04:02.310
[SPEAKER_00]: Not necessarily your first for Ray into anime, but how are we feeling about perfect blue?

02:04:02.930 --> 02:04:04.071
[SPEAKER_01]: I really liked it.

02:04:04.151 --> 02:04:07.132
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I think maybe my star ratings a little low.

02:04:07.192 --> 02:04:13.854
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I really enjoyed our conversation, and I think our conversation made me appreciate the film more, which is always great when that can happen.

02:04:14.715 --> 02:04:20.897
[SPEAKER_01]: But this is a film I will revisit, and it has made me, I don't know if I'll do it anytime soon, Joe.

02:04:21.577 --> 02:04:23.318
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I've got a lot to watch.

02:04:24.660 --> 02:04:28.763
[SPEAKER_01]: But you know, it's something that I will, I think I will revisit at some point.

02:04:29.583 --> 02:04:32.825
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's maybe more curious to watch his other films.

02:04:32.965 --> 02:04:38.389
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't say that I'm going to be diving into all of this Japanese animation now.

02:04:38.769 --> 02:04:40.450
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think that's true, but also that's not

02:04:40.860 --> 02:04:42.182
[SPEAKER_01]: That's not the film's job.

02:04:42.262 --> 02:04:43.503
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not the filmmaker's job.

02:04:43.523 --> 02:04:48.129
[SPEAKER_01]: That is some arbitrary pressure I put on the film or something.

02:04:48.209 --> 02:04:52.674
[SPEAKER_01]: But so yeah, I'm curious to dive into the directors of the work.

02:04:52.775 --> 02:04:54.276
[SPEAKER_01]: And I totally get it now.

02:04:54.737 --> 02:04:59.543
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, like why you've been recommending this film to me and why you like it so much.

02:05:00.174 --> 02:05:01.234
[SPEAKER_00]: I absolutely agree.

02:05:01.274 --> 02:05:16.380
[SPEAKER_00]: I think even just talking through this with you and I have seen this multiple times before hearing your perspective or thoughts and regards to interpretations that maybe I didn't necessarily personally have at first, but

02:05:17.080 --> 02:05:19.702
[SPEAKER_00]: You gave me something new and different to look at with it.

02:05:19.722 --> 02:05:28.948
[SPEAKER_00]: I was really happy that it held up even under maybe more scrutiny based off of I'm analyzing it.

02:05:28.968 --> 02:05:31.890
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm looking at it differently than I had before.

02:05:32.511 --> 02:05:36.914
[SPEAKER_00]: And in a way, I think it just did help me find a new level of appreciation.

02:05:37.714 --> 02:05:43.939
[SPEAKER_00]: So clearly for supplemental material, you're going to recommend the live action perfectly.

02:05:44.719 --> 02:05:45.900
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I'm not.

02:05:46.740 --> 02:05:53.502
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just gonna recommend one thing and it's kind of a recommendation, but I'm not claiming it's a great film.

02:05:53.582 --> 02:05:57.824
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm gonna recommend the documentary Otaku from nineteen ninety-four.

02:05:58.764 --> 02:06:00.605
[SPEAKER_01]: There's re-cuts of the film.

02:06:00.665 --> 02:06:06.267
[SPEAKER_01]: There's like a fifty-two minute cut, seventy-seven minute cut, and a hundred and sixty-eight minute cut.

02:06:06.952 --> 02:06:09.595
[SPEAKER_01]: I wonder what that hundred and sixty eight minute cut is like.

02:06:09.735 --> 02:06:12.418
[SPEAKER_01]: The seventy seven minute cut is available online.

02:06:13.078 --> 02:06:16.422
[SPEAKER_01]: Various places it is on internet archive.

02:06:17.002 --> 02:06:18.343
[SPEAKER_01]: It's an interesting documentary.

02:06:18.904 --> 02:06:21.206
[SPEAKER_01]: It's problematic at times.

02:06:22.067 --> 02:06:44.805
[SPEAKER_01]: it's kind of sloppy at times and I think maybe some of that comes from cutting a hundred and sixty eight minutes down to seventy seven minutes possibly because it makes some weird jumps from topic to topic but it is a great introduction to Otaku culture and it does spend a lot of time on idol Otaku's

02:06:45.445 --> 02:07:00.605
[SPEAKER_01]: which is relevant to this film, kind of dives into why such a prominent part of Japanese culture now and kind of the idea that because of Japan's place in the world at this time,

02:07:01.246 --> 02:07:05.668
[SPEAKER_01]: there's the lack of duty and like importance on working hard.

02:07:06.168 --> 02:07:12.891
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's sort of replaced by this pleasure prioritizing your interests over other things.

02:07:13.231 --> 02:07:15.692
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just a kind of a fascinating topic.

02:07:15.972 --> 02:07:17.613
[SPEAKER_01]: This was for the most part new to me.

02:07:18.173 --> 02:07:21.155
[SPEAKER_01]: So adding a little context did help me.

02:07:21.215 --> 02:07:24.676
[SPEAKER_01]: I think appreciate perfect blue a little bit more.

02:07:25.277 --> 02:07:28.158
[SPEAKER_01]: So I do think it actually does supplement

02:07:28.718 --> 02:07:31.681
[SPEAKER_01]: perfect blue and can add to that experience.

02:07:31.761 --> 02:07:34.524
[SPEAKER_01]: So I recommend that documentary.

02:07:34.945 --> 02:07:38.128
[SPEAKER_01]: But y'all, I think you probably have the better things to recommend.

02:07:38.148 --> 02:07:39.630
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the lecture.

02:07:40.038 --> 02:07:45.440
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, yeah, and I've touched on this a few times, perfect blue lecture series.

02:07:45.760 --> 02:07:49.222
[SPEAKER_00]: It's just a great series of conversations.

02:07:50.022 --> 02:08:04.088
[SPEAKER_00]: And we didn't talk about this on the podcast, but Satoshi Khan also talks about how the rooms and like the designs for each of the rooms, sort of like represents characters,

02:08:05.288 --> 02:08:14.331
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's really fascinating stuff, and it's a director who is reflecting on and having this retrospective on this project.

02:08:14.591 --> 02:08:18.032
[SPEAKER_00]: This is available on the steel book, Blue Ray.

02:08:18.752 --> 02:08:25.814
[SPEAKER_00]: It's the G Kids Showed version, but also on there is an interview.

02:08:26.554 --> 02:08:28.355
[SPEAKER_00]: He talks about getting lost in detail.

02:08:28.795 --> 02:08:52.689
[SPEAKER_00]: where where this came from is when he was sort of like brainstorming and and coming up with like the details of perfect blue he would go down these like rabbit holes my words not his just about like the details of the character like what kind of house do they live in like what do they wear things like that he mentioned how he loses sight of like the bigger picture and

02:08:53.009 --> 02:09:07.711
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's almost refreshing in a way to hear where filmmakers at a higher level than Justin and I are, do you just pour over those things in such a meticulous fashion that

02:09:08.072 --> 02:09:22.221
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it can result in losing sight of hears what matters within the film, because we're trying to make things, I don't want to say perfect, but, you know, we're trying to make them the best that they can be.

02:09:22.881 --> 02:09:34.148
[SPEAKER_00]: So long story short, you know, honestly, by the blue ray, if you don't already have it, but definitely seek out the lecture, I can't recommend it enough.

02:09:34.168 --> 02:09:34.909
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.

02:09:35.169 --> 02:09:36.350
[SPEAKER_00]: Joe, any takeaways?

02:09:36.970 --> 02:09:45.774
[SPEAKER_00]: Regardless of how a film is made, whether it be live action or animation, filmmaking is filmmaking and the fundamentals carry over regardless.

02:09:46.955 --> 02:09:53.718
[SPEAKER_00]: If people don't take anything else away from this podcast, especially filmmakers that might be listening to us,

02:09:54.858 --> 02:10:01.687
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, the craft of it, the technique I think does carry over.

02:10:01.707 --> 02:10:09.658
[SPEAKER_00]: And the way that we look at our projects and how to put them together, it remains relevant regardless of form.

02:10:10.619 --> 02:10:22.485
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the thing that stood out to me throughout our discussion is just the lack of clear answers and just the room for interpretation, personal interpretation.

02:10:22.505 --> 02:10:25.526
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I think that is something to

02:10:26.807 --> 02:10:48.009
[SPEAKER_01]: consider and keep in mind that you know you as a filmmaker making the film you certainly need to know what the film is about for you as the filmmaker when you're making it and you're gonna be collaborating with people who maybe have slightly different interpretations and I think that can sometimes enrich a film and enhance a film

02:10:48.710 --> 02:11:05.977
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think you as the filmmaker need to understand and embrace the fact that once the film is kind of done and put out into the world, people are going to bring their own personal life experiences, their own worldviews.

02:11:06.457 --> 02:11:15.721
[SPEAKER_01]: The film is going to mean something very personal to them based on those things and it may differ from what you originally had intended.

02:11:16.301 --> 02:11:18.842
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that's the great thing about art.

02:11:19.563 --> 02:11:24.486
[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody can look at the same thing, but have very different experiences with it.

02:11:24.986 --> 02:11:29.168
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I think, yeah, as a filmmaker, you just need to embrace that.

02:11:29.208 --> 02:11:41.375
[SPEAKER_01]: And if your film can accomplish that, where people are viewing it differently and having discussions about what it means and what happens and what's real and what's not, I think you've accomplished something great.

02:11:50.468 --> 02:11:53.054
[SPEAKER_02]: I don't know what to do.

02:12:08.220 --> 02:12:28.443
[SPEAKER_00]: Justin we're about to enter spooky season so we should break out our our pumpkin beers and rock out a Halloween movie or maybe more quote unquote traditional horror film yeah yeah this was tough for me I didn't have to pick

02:12:29.164 --> 02:12:30.386
[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm going with a film.

02:12:31.047 --> 02:12:35.193
[SPEAKER_01]: It's one of the, I don't know, quote unquote, classics.

02:12:35.934 --> 02:12:37.997
[SPEAKER_01]: It's maybe like a classic ghost story.

02:12:38.457 --> 02:12:40.420
[SPEAKER_01]: A film that gets mentioned a lot.

02:12:41.290 --> 02:12:50.696
[SPEAKER_01]: in terms of like the really great horror films of all time that has been influential, particularly in like the haunted house sub-genre.

02:12:51.136 --> 02:12:54.639
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's one of those classic films that I've never seen.

02:12:55.139 --> 02:12:58.421
[SPEAKER_01]: And that is Robert Wise's The Haunting, from

02:12:59.982 --> 02:13:01.283
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm cautiously optimistic.

02:13:01.323 --> 02:13:05.104
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to go into it with an open mind and that's all I ask.

02:13:05.344 --> 02:13:10.406
[SPEAKER_00]: Not having it on Wilson helps, so it's already bumped up a half star.

02:13:12.466 --> 02:13:13.327
[SPEAKER_00]: Good talk Justin.

02:13:14.027 --> 02:13:15.247
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, until next time.

02:13:15.267 --> 02:13:16.247
[SPEAKER_00]: Until next time.

02:13:16.748 --> 02:13:23.110
[SPEAKER_00]: And to our listeners, thank you for listening to our discussion of Satoshi Khan's perfect blue.

02:13:23.850 --> 02:13:35.833
[SPEAKER_00]: If you could subscribe to the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts, if you'd like to support the show, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and share us with someone who might enjoy us.

02:13:36.433 --> 02:13:40.434
[SPEAKER_01]: If you want to let us know whether you agree or disagree with our opinions on the film.

02:13:41.054 --> 02:13:47.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Or if you have any thoughts or questions about the show, you can email us at scenebyscenepodcast at Gmail.com.

02:13:48.336 --> 02:13:50.558
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Justin Johnson on Letterbox.

02:13:50.778 --> 02:13:52.239
[SPEAKER_01]: Joe is seen by scene Joe.

02:13:52.259 --> 02:13:55.401
[SPEAKER_01]: If you like the follow us, links will be in the description.

02:13:56.442 --> 02:14:04.768
[SPEAKER_01]: And join us on October third for our discussion of Robert Wise's The Haunting.

02:14:05.008 --> 02:14:07.750
[SPEAKER_01]: If you don't have to look at the set anymore, I mean movies over.

02:14:08.010 --> 02:14:10.051
[SPEAKER_02]: Your movie was over, that's what you said!

02:14:10.211 --> 02:14:12.472
[SPEAKER_02]: There's nothing going on in movies right now.

02:14:12.572 --> 02:14:13.272
[SPEAKER_02]: Great movie, huh?

02:14:13.572 --> 02:14:16.754
[SPEAKER_02]: So we're refreshing to see something like this after all these cop movies.

02:14:16.774 --> 02:14:17.994
[SPEAKER_02]: Have you seen a lot of movies here?

02:14:18.254 --> 02:14:19.955
[SPEAKER_02]: But he's so crazy about movies for him.

02:14:20.335 --> 02:14:21.816
[SPEAKER_01]: Obviously, they don't watch enough movies.

02:14:21.916 --> 02:14:23.016
[SPEAKER_01]: That's part of your problem, you know?

02:14:23.036 --> 02:14:24.297
[SPEAKER_01]: You haven't seen enough movies.

02:14:24.397 --> 02:14:26.378
[SPEAKER_01]: All of life's riddles are answered in the movies.

02:14:26.398 --> 02:14:28.078
[SPEAKER_02]: Do you have any experience of motion pictures?

02:14:28.178 --> 02:14:29.459
[SPEAKER_02]: Quite a bit of experience.

02:14:29.539 --> 02:14:32.200
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm active, rinter, and blockbuster.

02:14:32.380 --> 02:14:34.221
[SPEAKER_02]: I love the fact that you did all this work.

02:14:34.381 --> 02:14:36.462
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it will help you later, but not on this movie.

02:14:36.662 --> 02:14:37.104
[SPEAKER_02]: Sorry, can we pass?

02:14:37.124 --> 02:14:37.465
[SPEAKER_02]: Still all of us.

02:14:37.485 --> 02:14:38.047
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, no, not still all of us.

02:14:38.067 --> 02:14:47.640
[SPEAKER_00]: Go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go

