WEBVTT

00:07.388 --> 00:09.651
[SPEAKER_01]: Welcome to that said, I am Michael Zeldin.

00:10.051 --> 00:31.455
[SPEAKER_01]: On today's show, we have a previously recorded special presentation in conjunction with Addis Israel Congregation of Washington, D.C., and Congregation Bethel in Montgomery County, Maryland, with Rachel Cockrell about her new book, Melting Point, Family, Memory, and the Search for it promised land.

00:32.093 --> 00:38.703
[SPEAKER_01]: So before we dive into melting point, tell us a bit about yourself, Rachel, and why you chose to write this book?

00:39.524 --> 00:45.152
[SPEAKER_00]: Sure, and also I just want to thank Robin and Marge for those very lovely and colorful introductions.

00:46.955 --> 00:48.777
[SPEAKER_00]: I, why don't you choose to write this book?

00:48.797 --> 00:51.021
[SPEAKER_00]: I kind of fell into it by chance.

00:51.261 --> 00:55.367
[SPEAKER_00]: As Marge said, I did a master's degree in journalism.

00:55.347 --> 01:02.581
[SPEAKER_00]: And I kind of thought maybe I would come a journalist, I have many siblings and some of them a journalist, my parents are both journalists.

01:02.822 --> 01:12.461
[SPEAKER_00]: And so I actually during my masters, I went on a trip to Tel Aviv where I knew that some sort of distant family members of mine were.

01:12.481 --> 01:15.988
[SPEAKER_00]: And I also

01:15.968 --> 01:27.184
[SPEAKER_00]: particularly my dad's cousin, Judy, who was born in 1940 and who's very articulate and sort of speaks in just beautiful sort of a decorative way.

01:27.564 --> 01:31.330
[SPEAKER_00]: And I wanted to sort of capture some of her stories on a on a microphone.

01:31.931 --> 01:42.145
[SPEAKER_00]: So I interviewed her and then I also interviewed my dad and I kind of got to thinking that maybe I could sort of piece these interviews together

01:42.783 --> 02:04.723
[SPEAKER_00]: and to tell the story of my dad's upbringing in North London during and after World War II, he grew up in a sort of slightly shambolic chaotic huge sort of crumbling house in North London with his siblings, his cousins, including Judy who, as I said now lives in Tel Aviv, his parents, Judy's parents,

02:04.703 --> 02:09.371
[SPEAKER_00]: his grandmother, his great aunt, and also just various other people who came and went.

02:09.391 --> 02:13.077
[SPEAKER_00]: So they're around 13 or 13 people in this house at any one time.

02:13.137 --> 02:23.233
[SPEAKER_00]: All the adults were Russian Jewish immigrants that this family had come from the Russian Empire just as World War I broke out.

02:23.574 --> 02:26.138
[SPEAKER_00]: So all the adults spoke Russian, apart from one,

02:26.118 --> 02:37.752
[SPEAKER_00]: And my grandfather, Grandpa Hugh, who had sort of a slightly sort of stiff upper lip Englishman who would married into this family of Russian Jews, and he was sort of the odd man out.

02:38.033 --> 02:40.380
[SPEAKER_00]: So I thought this was this would just be

02:40.748 --> 02:46.935
[SPEAKER_00]: something I could either write an article about or make a little sort of radio piece about and then it just kept on evolving from there.

02:46.995 --> 02:52.201
[SPEAKER_00]: I kept on finding out more and more about my family and I realized that this was going to have to be a bigger story.

02:52.301 --> 02:58.448
[SPEAKER_00]: It was not just this sort of domestic narrow story of one family and then I was in Kilburn in London.

02:58.468 --> 03:08.359
[SPEAKER_00]: I think every family is sort of intertwined with history in unusual ways, particularly in 20th

03:08.575 --> 03:28.002
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, and we'll dive into this, including sort of what set you on this path, the discovery of your great grandfather David Jockelman, but we'll hold who he was and what role he played in early Zionism for a minute, because I want to first now that we know who you are and why you wrote this book.

03:28.150 --> 03:32.135
[SPEAKER_01]: What really struck me is the style of the book.

03:32.315 --> 03:38.383
[SPEAKER_01]: It's nothing, I've read 180 books in my podcast in the last three and a half years.

03:39.044 --> 03:40.986
[SPEAKER_01]: No book is written like yours.

03:41.307 --> 03:43.770
[SPEAKER_01]: So give us a little bit about that, please.

03:44.491 --> 03:46.573
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I'll take that as a compliment.

03:47.274 --> 03:48.576
[SPEAKER_00]: It was intended as a compliment.

03:49.177 --> 03:53.142
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I mean, people do say it's very, very unusual.

03:53.422 --> 03:57.988
[SPEAKER_00]: And I never know quite what they mean by that.

03:58.508 --> 04:06.949
[SPEAKER_00]: I kind of, again, sort of came to this form of writing or writing, sort of,

04:07.604 --> 04:14.854
[SPEAKER_00]: As I was telling this, I guess the seed of it was always there when I first was interviewing members of my family.

04:14.975 --> 04:20.262
[SPEAKER_00]: I thought, what if I could weave these interviews together without my voice in there?

04:20.342 --> 04:36.666
[SPEAKER_00]: I imagined, so I didn't want to have a voice over by me, you know, this sort of random 20th, 21st century woman sort of bringing it all together when I wasn't there in North London

04:37.608 --> 04:42.412
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think it was always in my mind to not be a character in this book.

04:42.953 --> 04:45.976
[SPEAKER_00]: And I guess I sort of took that to the logical conclusion.

04:46.036 --> 04:48.738
[SPEAKER_00]: I took my own voice out altogether.

04:48.818 --> 04:50.880
[SPEAKER_00]: In my early drafts, I had had my own voice.

04:50.940 --> 04:57.446
[SPEAKER_00]: I think partly because I wanted to write a sort of normal book, a nice conventional sort of Jewish family memoir.

04:58.107 --> 05:06.214
[SPEAKER_00]: I had read books which I'm sure many people in the audience will have read like East West Street by Philippe Sands and The Hair With Amber Eyes by Edmund Devile.

05:06.194 --> 05:17.125
[SPEAKER_00]: and I kind of wanted to write something which was in that lineage, and then I gradually realised that they were both Philippe, Sands, and Edmund, of all, were both sort of characters in those stories.

05:17.145 --> 05:28.197
[SPEAKER_00]: There were sort of discovering their families and going to go across Europe and finding traces of their families, and I didn't want the book to be set in the 21st century whatsoever.

05:28.357 --> 05:33.923
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted it to be almost like a time machine taking you back to the early 20th century.

05:33.903 --> 05:40.656
[SPEAKER_00]: So I took my voice out and I let the sources and that these sort of voices from the past speak for themselves.

05:40.897 --> 05:44.163
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to tell the whole story through the eyes of those who were there.

05:44.964 --> 05:50.615
[SPEAKER_00]: And because I was working on this book during the pandemic, I was kind of in my own world.

05:50.636 --> 05:53.481
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't really

05:53.461 --> 05:55.563
[SPEAKER_00]: share the book with anyone for a long time.

05:55.603 --> 06:01.930
[SPEAKER_00]: It felt kind of like this sort of secret thing I was working on that no one close to me really understood what I was doing.

06:02.150 --> 06:04.413
[SPEAKER_00]: But I kind of got used to the form quite quickly.

06:04.473 --> 06:20.430
[SPEAKER_00]: So the form on the page, if anyone hasn't read it, is sort of snippets some one line long, some four pages long, everything in between from newspapers, diaries, letters, interviews and they'll in the margin they'll just be the person's name who's speaking.

06:20.410 --> 06:21.832
[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of a bit like a play.

06:22.052 --> 06:26.058
[SPEAKER_00]: So I had this strange form, but it felt to me very intuitive.

06:26.118 --> 06:29.262
[SPEAKER_00]: It felt like the sort of right way to tell this story.

06:29.783 --> 06:35.430
[SPEAKER_00]: And then I sent the manuscript to my sister, you know, after maybe two or three years of working on it.

06:35.851 --> 06:39.155
[SPEAKER_00]: And she instantly called me up and said, there must be some mistake.

06:39.476 --> 06:43.461
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know what this is you've sent me, but it's, this can't be the book you're working on.

06:43.481 --> 06:44.983
[SPEAKER_00]: It's just a load of notes.

06:44.963 --> 06:51.292
[SPEAKER_00]: So she got a bit panicked that I had just been sort of the whole thing had been a colossal waste of time by talking around in the end.

06:52.534 --> 07:01.627
[SPEAKER_01]: So what's interesting about it for the listening audience is it's not written sort of in paragraph form with your you telling the story.

07:02.088 --> 07:06.835
[SPEAKER_01]: What you have really are characters speaking to one another.

07:06.855 --> 07:08.878
[SPEAKER_01]: It says if you are

07:08.858 --> 07:32.790
[SPEAKER_01]: you've got a whole group of diaries and you're saying oh well on this date, this character wrote this in their diary and this person wrote that in the diary and what we read are the diary entries but it's still flow so lovely almost as if it were an historical novel as I was reading it as I got accustomed to reading and just watching the characters talk to one another.

07:33.479 --> 07:34.861
[SPEAKER_00]: That's exactly what I wanted.

07:34.961 --> 07:36.823
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted it to feel like a historical novel.

07:36.844 --> 07:40.028
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't, you know, some history books.

07:40.068 --> 07:46.917
[SPEAKER_00]: You sort of read and you feel like a good person because you're learning facts about things and you're educating yourself.

07:47.418 --> 07:48.079
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't want that.

07:48.179 --> 08:00.415
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted something which sort of plucked you out of 2025 and placed you back at the first sign as Congress or in Galveston or in North London.

08:00.395 --> 08:09.932
[SPEAKER_00]: And as you said, you know, the importance of having the characters talk to each other as if they're all sort of arguing with each other and backing each other up.

08:10.032 --> 08:18.808
[SPEAKER_00]: And it's almost like, yeah, you're being sort of someone sort of grabbed you by the hand and is leading you through the first half of the 20s.

08:18.788 --> 08:19.189
[SPEAKER_01]: That's right.

08:19.409 --> 08:28.505
[SPEAKER_01]: And not only do you have the characters speaking to one another, but you have the press accounts describing the events about which they are speaking.

08:28.545 --> 08:29.306
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's just brilliant.

08:29.346 --> 08:31.190
[SPEAKER_01]: I think Rachel, it's lovely.

08:31.210 --> 08:33.394
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for writing it that way.

08:33.434 --> 08:35.397
[SPEAKER_01]: It was a great treat.

08:35.377 --> 08:38.483
[SPEAKER_01]: So by the listening one is the book is in three parts.

08:38.683 --> 08:43.813
[SPEAKER_01]: Vienna is Basel is one of the first part London the second in New York.

08:44.054 --> 08:53.552
[SPEAKER_01]: The third we're going to focus because of time principally on part one, but don't think for a minute at the end of this interview.

08:53.792 --> 08:54.634
[SPEAKER_01]: Well,

08:54.952 --> 08:59.759
[SPEAKER_01]: I know all there is to know about this book because there is so much that we are not covering.

09:00.139 --> 09:03.183
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's definitely a two-by book.

09:03.924 --> 09:07.469
[SPEAKER_01]: So let's dive in in part one.

09:07.590 --> 09:20.908
[SPEAKER_01]: We are at the outset introduced to Theodore Herzl and for the listening audience, they'll probably recognize the name as one of the founders of the early Zionist movement.

09:22.508 --> 09:23.735
[SPEAKER_01]: He's an interesting character.

09:23.755 --> 09:25.687
[SPEAKER_01]: He was a journalist, not really.

09:25.707 --> 09:27.981
[SPEAKER_01]: He was not a rabbi or anything like that.

09:28.001 --> 09:29.228
[SPEAKER_01]: So tell us about Hurtselt.

09:30.187 --> 09:45.292
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't really know much about Hurt's all before I started writing this book, maybe partly because I am an assimilated quarter-do living in London and spent most of my history lessons at school looking out the window.

09:45.312 --> 09:54.827
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think I missed the Hurt's all lessons, but I've spoken to lots of people since the book came out and I think,

09:55.060 --> 10:12.647
[SPEAKER_00]: It is quite a common thing that we are perception of hurtful is that he was some sort of great thinker of the past, maybe a sort of political leader or statesman in some way, founder of, you know, maybe people know that he was the founder of modern Zionism.

10:12.627 --> 10:17.714
[SPEAKER_00]: But I don't think anyone, I don't think we really have a sense of hurtful as a man.

10:17.935 --> 10:20.258
[SPEAKER_00]: So I tried to sort of make him more human in this book.

10:20.759 --> 10:25.786
[SPEAKER_00]: He was, he founded Zionism when he was, I think in his late days, early years.

10:26.487 --> 10:33.657
[SPEAKER_00]: And he was a journalist, very much and assimilated Jewish journalist living in Vienna, Hungarian Jewish.

10:33.637 --> 10:43.371
[SPEAKER_00]: And he wrote this little pamphlet, I think partly because he thought it might be a way of sort of doing some more serious work because his journalism felt to him quite trivial.

10:44.172 --> 10:51.383
[SPEAKER_00]: He would write these sort of funny and clever little columns about cafe life in Vienna or about something his daughter had done that day.

10:51.423 --> 11:01.618
[SPEAKER_00]: And he wrote in his diary, you know, that this bigger sort of grander idea povers over his sort of more trivial journalistic work.

11:01.598 --> 11:14.884
[SPEAKER_00]: So he sort of founded Zionism by accident, and wrote in his diary, perhaps I'll bring the Jews back to their ancient homeland of Palestine, and if not, at least I can make it into a novel title, The Promised Land.

11:15.706 --> 11:16.327
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

11:16.347 --> 11:23.742
[SPEAKER_01]: So he's an assimilated Jew in Vienna, writing as a journalist, and

11:24.633 --> 11:35.590
[SPEAKER_01]: He has sort of an epiphany and, like your opinion about this, some suggest that it was in the aftermath of the Dreyfus affair.

11:35.650 --> 11:43.322
[SPEAKER_01]: Dreyfus is a Jewish French army captain accused of essentially espionage for the Germans that begins in 1894.

11:44.324 --> 11:51.315
[SPEAKER_01]: And some say that was a tipping point for Herzl,

11:52.139 --> 11:54.784
[SPEAKER_01]: hidden as a Jew in Vienna.

11:54.804 --> 11:59.213
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you have a point of view on drivers or if not, we can just go forward?

12:00.035 --> 12:04.082
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I am early in my research.

12:04.243 --> 12:10.515
[SPEAKER_00]: I read that historians are a bit conflicted about how much drivers had an impact on her thoughts.

12:10.535 --> 12:13.000
[SPEAKER_00]: I think maybe it was more

12:13.182 --> 12:18.211
[SPEAKER_00]: I think maybe that was a factor, but I feel like it was more about his own ego.

12:18.231 --> 12:23.260
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, I wanted everyone in this book to be sort of flawed, three-dimensional characters.

12:23.340 --> 12:31.495
[SPEAKER_00]: Herb's lives obviously sort of, you know, someone who has changed the world and was, you know, hugely intelligent and charismatic and...

12:31.475 --> 12:43.748
[SPEAKER_00]: Drew, people to him and could have, you know, was very statesman like, but he did have an ego and I think that played a huge role in his decision to found the modern Zionist movement.

12:44.008 --> 12:55.940
[SPEAKER_00]: I think he, there was a lot of sort of, he had a lot of sort of self regard and I think he had sort of these grand visions of himself as the sort of first leader of the modern Jewish state.

12:56.341 --> 12:57.702
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think that,

12:57.901 --> 13:07.438
[SPEAKER_00]: was in his mind all the time, you know, he has these volumes and volumes of diaries and most of it is just, you know, what, what do people think of me except

13:07.908 --> 13:15.724
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's funny to be in your 30s and thinking about your legacy, but that that seems to be what he was involved in.

13:15.764 --> 13:21.194
[SPEAKER_01]: Drife is or not, and again, to the list of the audience who who have not read the book.

13:22.036 --> 13:28.549
[SPEAKER_01]: You quote, because you have as if you have diaries, maybe they actually would diaries or letters, but you have first.

13:28.529 --> 13:45.542
[SPEAKER_01]: source material, and herdsal writes and I'll read it, apologize for turning left, but he says, of the pamphlet, the Jewish state, which he writes in 1895, for some time I have been occupied with the work of indefinite grandeur.

13:45.522 --> 13:48.366
[SPEAKER_01]: At the moment, I did not know if I shall complete it.

13:48.847 --> 13:55.397
[SPEAKER_01]: It has the appearance of a dream, but for days and weeks it has possessed me beyond the limits of consciousness.

13:56.078 --> 13:57.821
[SPEAKER_01]: It accompanies me wherever I go.

13:57.861 --> 14:00.245
[SPEAKER_01]: It hovers over my ordinary conversation.

14:00.265 --> 14:05.773
[SPEAKER_01]: It looks over my shoulder at my comical, trivial, journalistic work.

14:05.793 --> 14:08.017
[SPEAKER_01]: Hons me and intoxicates me.

14:08.417 --> 14:11.042
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's his thought process, right?

14:11.082 --> 14:13.926
[SPEAKER_01]: As he's writing in 1895, this little pamphlet.

14:14.969 --> 14:15.870
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's funny.

14:15.930 --> 14:25.725
[SPEAKER_00]: He always said, you know, my book, I'm writing my book, you know, he always called it my book and everyone else called it his pamphlet, because it was only sort of 60 pages long or something.

14:25.945 --> 14:28.749
[SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, he just became totally obsessed with this thing.

14:28.789 --> 14:38.884
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think a few lines after that in melting point, you know, he gives them the manuscript as he calls it to one of his friends.

14:38.864 --> 14:45.215
[SPEAKER_00]: And watches his friend as he's reading it and his friends starts crying and hurts all things.

14:45.295 --> 15:02.644
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yes, you know, it's true, you know, what a what a profoundly moving book I've written and his friend just turns to him and says, I think you've gone mad what what what what are you thinking, bringing the Jews back to Palestine, what could you

15:03.350 --> 15:05.894
[SPEAKER_00]: like, how could you have, you know, how could you have thought with this?

15:06.594 --> 15:23.498
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, the other thing that I didn't really put in my book is that Herzl didn't really realize that the Zionist movement had this huge precedent and that other people had written about this and sort of thought about it very seriously for many years before Herzl wrote his book.

15:24.179 --> 15:25.881
[SPEAKER_00]: And

15:26.283 --> 15:34.176
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think he wrote later, you know, if I had realized if I had sort of known a bit more than maybe I wouldn't have thought that I was having such an original idea.

15:34.216 --> 15:35.879
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's interesting.

15:35.919 --> 15:44.373
[SPEAKER_01]: So he writes this pamphlet in 1895 calls for the Jews to return to Palestine as their homeland.

15:44.393 --> 15:45.895
[SPEAKER_01]: Then he's now going about.

15:46.482 --> 16:11.123
[SPEAKER_01]: essentially promoting his idea and met with modest success, but he writes again in one of his diaries or letters that as he's going about this process, not knowing whether to be realizable or not, the center of gravity turns to London in late 1895.

16:11.103 --> 16:11.744
[SPEAKER_01]: until 1896.

16:12.144 --> 16:13.586
[SPEAKER_01]: So he's 1895.

16:13.646 --> 16:14.527
[SPEAKER_01]: He's got this idea.

16:14.968 --> 16:17.451
[SPEAKER_01]: So wandering around, give me the people who said he's gone mad.

16:17.511 --> 16:22.357
[SPEAKER_01]: He says, well, maybe I've gone mad, but at least I have the seeds of a novel here.

16:22.597 --> 16:29.746
[SPEAKER_01]: But it takes us to London, where Herzl meets Israel, Zanguel.

16:30.106 --> 16:31.188
[SPEAKER_01]: So who's Zanguel?

16:31.468 --> 16:33.210
[SPEAKER_01]: And why is it Zanguel?

16:34.271 --> 16:40.519
[SPEAKER_00]: It's funny that this moment when Herzl goes from Vienna to London for a visit.

16:41.005 --> 16:50.847
[SPEAKER_00]: It feels like this kind of world historical event and yet it had a this sort of butterfly effect which eventually led to my own family being in London.

16:51.008 --> 16:58.204
[SPEAKER_00]: It's strange to sort of be able to trace things back, you know, there's this phrase in the book, the unresting chain of events.

16:58.370 --> 17:08.024
[SPEAKER_00]: you know, the butterfly effect or the domino effect where you see how two seemingly totally unrelated events are linked together by all these many, many links.

17:08.705 --> 17:12.611
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm sure everyone listening has that in their own family as well.

17:12.691 --> 17:21.103
[SPEAKER_00]: You think, you know, the reason I am in, you know, Washington, you know, wherever I am is because of

17:21.083 --> 17:25.630
[SPEAKER_00]: because of all these events which seem so unrelated, you know, going back maybe a hundred years or more.

17:26.211 --> 17:30.698
[SPEAKER_00]: So Herzl goes to London and meets everyone tells him, oh, you must meet Israel's angle.

17:30.758 --> 17:41.996
[SPEAKER_00]: He's a sort of prominent Jewish writer in London and Herzl does and both of them write about it afterwards, and they both have quite different memories of this night.

17:42.217 --> 17:43.699
[SPEAKER_00]: Herzl has sort of

17:43.679 --> 17:55.215
[SPEAKER_00]: driven, you know, Samuel lives in North London and by the time hurts, I'll get that, I think he says, you know, long ride through endless, endless winding streets, I ride feeling a bit out of sorts.

17:55.595 --> 18:00.362
[SPEAKER_00]: So I think he was a bit car sick, you know, or like horse-drawn carriage sick, by the time he got there.

18:00.722 --> 18:02.224
[SPEAKER_00]: And I've actually had that experience.

18:03.205 --> 18:08.893
[SPEAKER_00]: My uncle still lives in, in the house in North London, where my dad grew up.

18:08.873 --> 18:11.919
[SPEAKER_00]: And I always arrive there feeling a bit out of sorts.

18:12.360 --> 18:17.450
[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of something about, you know, we don't really have the grid system in London like you guys do in America.

18:17.490 --> 18:23.461
[SPEAKER_00]: So you're sort of turning and turning, and you do feel a bit out of sorts when you arrive in North London.

18:24.343 --> 18:26.768
[SPEAKER_00]: But Hurtson's angle both wrote about this afterwards.

18:26.788 --> 18:29.633
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if you have the quote there or if I should prepare a phrase there.

18:29.613 --> 18:46.281
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, what Herzl says, and I don't know if this is the quote, what what Zangle says is a black-bearded stranger knocked at my study door, like one dropped from the skies and said, I'm theater, Herzl, help me rebuild the Jewish state.

18:46.741 --> 18:56.177
[SPEAKER_01]: And Zangle goes on to say, I'm never been heard of this guy, and Herzl will write, I never read anything that Zangle wrote, but I thought I sort of knew him.

18:56.157 --> 18:56.778
[SPEAKER_01]: Very odd.

18:57.419 --> 19:09.001
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's funny, you know, Hurt's little kind of says, like, I kind of know, I know, I'm saying, well, I've heard of him and Zanne will slightly sort of boastfully says, I've never heard of Theodore Hurt's little then.

19:09.201 --> 19:19.380
[SPEAKER_00]: And that kind of characterizes, this is our first introduction to Zanne, well, who's really sort of, I guess, the sort of protagonist of this book, despite the fact it was meant to be a family memoir and who's no relation to me.

19:19.360 --> 19:32.914
[SPEAKER_00]: but Zangwili is quite sort of grandiose and always sort of being a bit, you know, self-aggrandizing and saying, oh, hurt, so I had never heard of him at that point, but he had heard of me, is classic Zangwili.

19:33.115 --> 19:36.158
[SPEAKER_00]: These two men present sort of polar opposites.

19:37.399 --> 19:43.165
[SPEAKER_00]: Herzl, I think I mentioned earlier, was very handsome, beautifully dressed, very charismatic.

19:43.506 --> 19:47.730
[SPEAKER_00]: If you were sort of walking along the street in Vienna and you met Herzl coming in the opposite direction,

19:47.930 --> 19:54.882
[SPEAKER_00]: you would just do a U-turn and walk with him because wherever he was going was probably more interesting than wherever you had planned to go.

19:54.902 --> 19:57.626
[SPEAKER_00]: He was sort of the dialing of Vienna.

19:57.666 --> 20:02.655
[SPEAKER_00]: Zainwell was sort of the dialing of London, but people had a sort of affectionate.

20:02.875 --> 20:04.618
[SPEAKER_00]: People were affectionately rude about him.

20:04.658 --> 20:08.925
[SPEAKER_00]: They said that he was the worst dress man in London.

20:08.905 --> 20:10.528
[SPEAKER_00]: and the ugliest man in the world.

20:10.769 --> 20:24.195
[SPEAKER_00]: He had sort of crazy hair was always stumbling around carrying manuscripts under his arm, dropping pieces of paper, scribbling things down, then putting them in his pocket, always sort of string into the road and about to get run over by a horse drawn carriage.

20:24.656 --> 20:29.445
[SPEAKER_00]: But he wrote these books which the British and the American public became obsessed with.

20:29.505 --> 20:31.048
[SPEAKER_00]: He was sort of

20:31.028 --> 20:34.854
[SPEAKER_00]: best-seller sort of celebrity author in, you know, at the turn of the century.

20:34.914 --> 20:38.859
[SPEAKER_00]: And I guess his most famous book is Children of the Ghetto.

20:38.900 --> 20:44.728
[SPEAKER_00]: And that was a novel about Jewish life in London at the sort of Jewish ghetto at London.

20:45.309 --> 20:54.302
[SPEAKER_00]: So herds will go to London to meet the sort of most famous London's most famous novelist or really the English-speaking world's most famous

20:54.282 --> 20:56.325
[SPEAKER_00]: he was sort of called the Dickens of the ghetto.

20:56.365 --> 21:01.934
[SPEAKER_00]: And he really, you know, he kind of gets angle on board to sort of help with Zionism.

21:01.994 --> 21:13.151
[SPEAKER_00]: And eventually, Zion will, for a while, abandon his career as a novelist all together and become sort of swept up in Zionism and become swept up in hurtful Zionism.

21:13.492 --> 21:18.499
[SPEAKER_00]: I think he, like everyone else, sort of almost falls in love with hurtful.

21:18.700 --> 21:20.863
[SPEAKER_00]: And so he, yeah, he sort of,

21:20.843 --> 21:24.388
[SPEAKER_00]: drops everything, drops everything in his life for the sake of Zionism.

21:24.788 --> 21:25.049
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

21:25.129 --> 21:31.397
[SPEAKER_01]: And so the two of them embark upon crystallizing if that's a word you can use about a Jewish transcript.

21:31.617 --> 21:34.982
[SPEAKER_01]: His idea of a promised land in Palestine.

21:35.663 --> 21:41.911
[SPEAKER_01]: And the pamphlet gets published in 1896 as they embark upon their campaign.

21:41.951 --> 21:44.134
[SPEAKER_01]: And how has it received?

21:44.114 --> 21:50.426
[SPEAKER_01]: What was the reaction globally, if you will, to this 60-page pamphlet, the Promised Land?

21:51.007 --> 21:53.552
[SPEAKER_00]: Originally, it was received very badly.

21:53.592 --> 21:59.804
[SPEAKER_00]: Everyone in Vienna sort of turned and laughed at Herzl, you know, they would sort of mock him behind his back.

22:00.205 --> 22:05.034
[SPEAKER_00]: His friends would say, is this pamphlet you've written a joke or is it meant to be serious?

22:05.255 --> 22:06.477
[SPEAKER_00]: And then,

22:06.457 --> 22:16.152
[SPEAKER_00]: there is this sort of larger sort of this response which I think one person says it's sort of rose back at Herzl from the Russian, the Jews of the Russian Empire.

22:16.212 --> 22:21.921
[SPEAKER_00]: Herzl's name is sort of whispered from town to town and people sort of require pictures of him.

22:22.141 --> 22:27.469
[SPEAKER_00]: Almost sort of it's like a rumor of Herzl sort of spreads across the Russian Empire.

22:27.449 --> 22:49.592
[SPEAKER_00]: much like something would go viral today but if you think of the challenge of something going viral when there's no electricity and no internet and so on back in the turn of the 20th century, it seems amazing that the word could spread across such a huge empire or I guess the pale of settlement.

22:50.399 --> 23:05.421
[SPEAKER_00]: So the word spreads and it's really the Russian Jews who respond to hurtful's idea of modern Zionism, more than anyone else, more than that assimilated Jews up Europe, more than the Jews of America, and they sort of bring Zionism to life.

23:05.654 --> 23:06.195
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.

23:06.215 --> 23:09.763
[SPEAKER_01]: And I am White'sman in writing about this again.

23:09.803 --> 23:12.488
[SPEAKER_01]: This is the wonder of your book.

23:12.549 --> 23:23.612
[SPEAKER_01]: Is that you have these people talking to one another, as I said, White'sman writes that a virtual that he became a monumental mythical Jewish figure.

23:23.930 --> 23:27.474
[SPEAKER_01]: Herzl's brochure did not remain just on paper.

23:27.834 --> 23:36.082
[SPEAKER_01]: The message soon passed to every town, great and small, in Poland and Russia, in which there was a Jewish ghetto.

23:36.523 --> 23:50.477
[SPEAKER_01]: They said about this, they've got this pamphlet there, well known now in every, steadily in Poland and Russia and in between, and they've got an operationalized their idea and that,

23:50.457 --> 23:55.165
[SPEAKER_01]: brings us to the first Jewish Congress in Basel in 1897.

23:55.906 --> 23:57.729
[SPEAKER_01]: So tell us about what was going on there.

23:58.670 --> 24:07.345
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so how's it going to convene this this first sort of world first ever worldwide meeting of the Jews in Basel in 1897?

24:07.425 --> 24:09.428
[SPEAKER_00]: I think

24:09.610 --> 24:15.098
[SPEAKER_00]: The elegance from, you know, many continents arrived in Basel in the summer of 1897.

24:15.138 --> 24:18.783
[SPEAKER_00]: Hertsley instruction, everyone to wear evening wear.

24:18.983 --> 24:22.268
[SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, sort of tail coats.

24:22.288 --> 24:33.323
[SPEAKER_00]: And it was really, you know, this idea that we could just find a way to create a Jewish state in Palestine.

24:33.725 --> 24:57.083
[SPEAKER_00]: Probably quite quickly, you know, and that's just parsing words to the Zionist Congress word next year in Jerusalem, obviously this, you know, this line that's used in the parts of a ceremony, but I think he really meant it or thought he meant it, that Zionism would be a year-long project, maybe it would all be sort of wrapped up by 1898, and there would be a Jewish state.

24:58.058 --> 25:06.711
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think, you know, Herzl had no notion of this sort of vast century-long machine that he was setting into motion, or, you know, more and more.

25:06.731 --> 25:07.051
[SPEAKER_00]: Right now.

25:07.592 --> 25:15.804
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and in fact, Rachel, you quote him as saying, at Basel, I founded the Jewish state, you know, not so fast, right?

25:16.045 --> 25:16.606
[SPEAKER_01]: That's not fair.

25:17.186 --> 25:17.367
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

25:17.427 --> 25:22.935
[SPEAKER_01]: But well, I wanted to talk about one thing at Basel, before we go forward with it, at

25:22.915 --> 25:30.616
[SPEAKER_01]: Basel, they adopt the Basel program, which is the outline for the Jewish settlement.

25:31.177 --> 25:34.326
[SPEAKER_01]: In Palestine, but one line that struck me in the

25:34.930 --> 25:46.043
[SPEAKER_01]: program itself, it says Zionism seeks to establish a home in Palestine for the Jewish people secured by public-print international law.

25:46.063 --> 25:54.993
[SPEAKER_01]: So it was important to them in this 1897 Congress that what they do be secured under public international law.

25:55.034 --> 26:02.322
[SPEAKER_01]: They weren't about to come in there as colonialists, but rather they had a notion that they would go there

26:02.302 --> 26:21.324
[SPEAKER_01]: They would purchase the land from the Ottoman Empire, the Brits, wealthy Arabs who owned a lot of this private, the owned land, and it was sold, and they invited Herzl's has the expedient promotion of the settlement of Jewish agricultural lists, artisans, and tradesmen in Palestine.

26:21.344 --> 26:27.111
[SPEAKER_01]: So they, I raised this because of this notion of pre-48,

26:27.884 --> 26:32.771
[SPEAKER_01]: settlers, conquest, colonialist, but that wasn't really that what they had in mind, wasn't.

26:33.773 --> 26:34.494
[SPEAKER_00]: No, it wasn't.

26:34.574 --> 26:45.171
[SPEAKER_00]: I think rehearsal always wanted Zionism to be a sort of a political movement, which it was impossible not to accept.

26:46.032 --> 26:50.719
[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't want to cut any corners or give anyone in the world a reason to doubt

26:50.952 --> 26:52.714
[SPEAKER_00]: the legitimacy of Zionism.

26:52.915 --> 27:00.645
[SPEAKER_00]: So that was always that a Jewish state would be self-governed and would be sort of official in every way possible.

27:00.825 --> 27:17.027
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think, yeah, I mean, it's strange looking the way everything has turned out, I think that hurt so would be quite shocked by this movement that he brought into being the way it sort of strayed from his ideas of what he wanted to be.

27:17.227 --> 27:25.478
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so hurtful post-1897, and with singles assistance are going around meeting people.

27:25.538 --> 27:35.792
[SPEAKER_01]: They meet with Joseph Chamberlain, famous later of the father of Neville, Chamberlain, and they've got ideas for

27:35.772 --> 27:57.105
[SPEAKER_01]: purchasing property they want to purchase the sign I curiously but the the Egyptian government says no thank you we're not we're not selling and they're looking at this and their timeline is expanding and then there's a critical moment in 1903 in kishaneth so tell us about that

27:57.845 --> 28:02.210
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the kitchen of pogrom really brought Zionism into sharp focus.

28:02.471 --> 28:12.924
[SPEAKER_00]: But for the Jews, but also for non-Jews around the world to see that the Jews really did need a refuge that the Russian Empire was not a welcoming or safe place for the Jews to be.

28:13.144 --> 28:18.531
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sure a lot of people here already know about it or know about pogroms and, you know, I'm sure you all know about pogroms.

28:18.771 --> 28:26.080
[SPEAKER_00]: Russian Christians would sort of rampage through the streets, destroying Jewish property and injuring and killing Jews.

28:26.060 --> 28:27.943
[SPEAKER_00]: Survive of the Kitchener program.

28:28.143 --> 28:37.559
[SPEAKER_00]: This was in and what is now Moldova, which at the time was in the Russian Empire, said, May God grant that I will soon be able to turn my back upon this bloody country.

28:37.579 --> 28:41.605
[SPEAKER_00]: So it was really that was the moment when Jews

28:42.057 --> 28:48.009
[SPEAKER_00]: It was a turning point where Jews sort of decided on math that it was time to leave the Russian Empire.

28:48.049 --> 29:04.521
[SPEAKER_01]: There was an imperative, I mean, in Kishinev, which was one of these post-easter massacres, seems like Christians around the time of Easter, always got whipped up into a frenzy, and they kill 50 Jews, they

29:04.501 --> 29:19.973
[SPEAKER_01]: gravely injure about a hundred they destroy 1,500 houses and there's now an imperative that hurtful feels that maybe waiting till Palestine becomes a reality is not possible.

29:20.474 --> 29:22.358
[SPEAKER_01]: And so we're at the sixth

29:22.642 --> 29:35.918
[SPEAKER_01]: Basel conference in 1903, and Herzl proposes the possibility of a Jewish settlement in East Africa, the so-called Uganda plan, so tell us about that.

29:36.839 --> 29:37.520
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

29:37.740 --> 29:49.695
[SPEAKER_00]: As you mentioned, Joseph Chamberlain, father of Neville, says to Herzl that he's been on a sort of journey through the British colonies in East Africa.

29:50.570 --> 29:55.519
[SPEAKER_00]: a railway line through East Africa called the Uganda Railway, which went through several countries.

29:55.780 --> 30:05.037
[SPEAKER_00]: And Chamberlain had been on board and had glanced out the window and seen sort of rolling countryside which reminded him of the English countryside.

30:05.097 --> 30:11.228
[SPEAKER_00]: So we came back to London and said to Herzl, I've seen a land for you on my travels, and that's Uganda.

30:11.208 --> 30:13.771
[SPEAKER_00]: English roses bloom profusely.

30:13.811 --> 30:15.874
[SPEAKER_00]: It's much like the Sussex Downs.

30:16.455 --> 30:19.498
[SPEAKER_00]: It's yours if you want it, but maybe it's too far away from Palestine.

30:19.539 --> 30:31.614
[SPEAKER_00]: And Herzl, again, writes in his diary that he feels, you know, he feels that he has no choice but to submit this offer to the Jewish people just to see what they think of him over it.

30:33.136 --> 30:36.540
[SPEAKER_00]: That it's not really his choice, that it should be the choice of the Jews.

30:38.022 --> 30:44.000
[SPEAKER_00]: and so he does present that offer at the next science congress and it all goes quite catastrophically wrong.

30:44.521 --> 30:45.524
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's interesting.

30:45.745 --> 30:46.547
[SPEAKER_01]: Proposes it.

30:46.567 --> 30:47.931
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, he was a...

30:48.738 --> 30:50.701
[SPEAKER_01]: Zionism in Zion, Guy.

30:51.462 --> 31:18.019
[SPEAKER_01]: Then Kishnav happens, he's thinking, well, maybe Zionism without Zion is a possibility, and so I'll submit to the sixth Congress this offer of land in Uganda, and it's fiercely debated as you say, but the delegates vote 295 in favor and 178 against to at least send an exploratory

31:17.999 --> 31:19.301
[SPEAKER_01]: to go look at you.

31:19.341 --> 31:33.939
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sure these Polish and Russian Jews had no idea where you got that even was on a map, but they sent us this exploratory committee to come back in 1905 to the seventh Congress and tell us about that.

31:33.959 --> 31:34.800
[SPEAKER_01]: So what happens?

31:34.820 --> 31:40.227
[SPEAKER_01]: They sent out the exploratory committee they come back in 1905 with their report and what happens?

31:40.207 --> 31:58.603
[SPEAKER_00]: It's funny, I mean it is a history book that I kind of don't want total sort of spoilers because the Uganda plan is I feel like the drama of it all has been kind of forgotten and it's quite nice to sort of rely on people sort of patchy knowledge of history and of the Zionist movement.

31:58.583 --> 32:23.595
[SPEAKER_00]: so that everything is a bit of a surprise in the book, but yeah, it is quite a catastrophe, and I'll just give you one newspaper account from the time, which says that Uganda is a land filled with wild beasts and savages, and therefore perhaps it's not quite the perfect Jewish homeland.

32:25.448 --> 32:41.027
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, which causes us to encounter your great grandfather, David Jockelman, and Israel's

32:41.007 --> 32:47.495
[SPEAKER_01]: from the Zionist, the Herzl-Zionist, Herzl is dead, he's died in 1904.

32:48.216 --> 32:59.791
[SPEAKER_01]: He's not seeing the consequence of his actions, but they formed the International Jewish International organization, the ITO.

33:00.271 --> 33:01.733
[SPEAKER_01]: What was up with that?

33:02.354 --> 33:08.265
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they, as I was sort of wanting to carry on Herzl's legacy and find a Jewish homeland somewhere on earth.

33:08.525 --> 33:14.676
[SPEAKER_00]: He, so he set up this organization with the terrible name, the Jewish territorial organization.

33:15.217 --> 33:18.523
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not as catchy as Zionism by a long shot.

33:18.503 --> 33:24.991
[SPEAKER_00]: And his sort of motto really was if we cannot get the holy land, we can make another land holy.

33:25.031 --> 33:42.132
[SPEAKER_00]: And my great grandfather became his vice president, and together they sort of searched the world for some sort of temporary, either alternative to Palestine or sort of, you know,

33:43.242 --> 33:54.662
[SPEAKER_00]: the way this goes wrong as well and you know it's all there's all there sort of searches sort of come to nothing and then finally the thing that does work is Galveston.

33:54.702 --> 33:58.509
[SPEAKER_00]: Galveston becomes a sort of temporary promise land.

33:58.569 --> 34:03.698
[SPEAKER_01]: Right, so

34:03.678 --> 34:11.970
[SPEAKER_01]: searching for for new land all over the place, Western Africa, Western Canada, they want to buy a stage in the United States.

34:12.010 --> 34:19.481
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's it's comical in in a sense and sad in another sense, but that's what they're doing.

34:19.521 --> 34:26.732
[SPEAKER_01]: And you bring us to essentially 1907 and that they Galveston,

34:26.712 --> 34:28.175
[SPEAKER_01]: movement.

34:28.195 --> 34:31.642
[SPEAKER_01]: And that forms a big part of the book.

34:31.722 --> 34:42.463
[SPEAKER_01]: And can you just tell us about it a little bit more, again, I'm always cautious, not to spoil the book for prospective readers, but tell us about Galveston.

34:42.503 --> 34:44.046
[SPEAKER_01]: What was it that was?

34:44.228 --> 35:05.723
[SPEAKER_01]: in the minds that this is shift and others bringing people from Russia to the United States before World War I in response to the programs 1880 to 1940, 1914 is about the the most deadly pogroms that Russia experienced over a long history of a program.

35:05.763 --> 35:08.127
[SPEAKER_01]: So what was going on in Galveston?

35:08.579 --> 35:11.474
[SPEAKER_00]: And maybe, should we, after this, should we open up to questions?

35:11.514 --> 35:13.706
[SPEAKER_00]: I can see a lot of questions coming through in the chat.

35:15.274 --> 35:16.480
[SPEAKER_00]: Galveston.

35:17.607 --> 35:25.980
[SPEAKER_00]: was really chosen by both the American Jews and by Zangweil and my great-grandfather, as an alternative to New York.

35:26.420 --> 35:33.431
[SPEAKER_00]: The Lower East Side of New York was in 1905, the greatest Jewish center of the world had ever known.

35:33.491 --> 35:40.641
[SPEAKER_00]: If you walked through the streets of the Lower East Side, it would feel like you were stepping into another country.

35:40.661 --> 35:47.091
[SPEAKER_00]: It felt like you were sort of walking through a Russian Jewish town.

35:48.353 --> 35:56.541
[SPEAKER_00]: It was, you felt like you hadn't left Russia if you were on the Lower East Side and

35:57.787 --> 36:08.604
[SPEAKER_00]: German Jews who'd been in New York at a longer bankers like Jacob Schiff saw this sort of huge crest of immigration, these boats arriving at L.S.

36:08.704 --> 36:14.233
[SPEAKER_00]: Island every day, you know, there were no quotas on Jewish immigration at that time.

36:14.453 --> 36:20.503
[SPEAKER_00]: They saw this sort of huge mass of Jewish immigration as something which might

36:20.483 --> 36:30.562
[SPEAKER_00]: and already was creating a sort of menace to the longer established Jews of America that perhaps the Americans would turn against the Jews as immigrants.

36:30.782 --> 36:39.859
[SPEAKER_00]: So Galveston was a sort of alternative in a way for the ships to sort of bypass new local together and for Jews to still arrive in America, but to

36:40.210 --> 36:42.715
[SPEAKER_00]: spread out across the American hinterland.

36:43.216 --> 36:52.975
[SPEAKER_00]: So the idea was that a Jewish immigrant would get off the ship at Port of Galveston and then would then take a train further inland.

36:53.175 --> 37:00.970
[SPEAKER_00]: And this is what happened for seven years, 10,000 Russian Jews came to Galveston to call the Galveston movement and it's kind of

37:00.950 --> 37:26.029
[SPEAKER_00]: being totally forgotten apart from, I guess, by the descendants of Galveston immigrants, and by one plaque outside the synagogue in Galveston, which I sort of made a pilgrimage to a couple of years ago while I was writing the book and, you know, it's strange, as because I was writing this during the pandemic, kind of sometimes wondered if it's all a figment of my imagination, hurt, soul, and saying, well, I'm the Galveston plan, and everything else that

37:26.009 --> 37:27.171
[SPEAKER_00]: came afterwards.

37:27.411 --> 37:38.507
[SPEAKER_00]: It's as a historian having those moments where you see sort of some trace of what you're writing about in the world are kind of quite thrilling and sort of quite powerful.

37:38.707 --> 37:40.430
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, absolutely.

37:40.550 --> 37:49.823
[SPEAKER_01]: But before we turn to questions and we'll get to that in a moment,

37:49.803 --> 38:17.430
[SPEAKER_01]: And, I mean, maybe your title of the book, The Welting Point is a riff on it in some sense, but tells about the melting pot, because that invites what we'll talk about in January, about Roosevelt, Teddy Roosevelt, Roosevelt, Roosevelt goes to see this play by his angle called The Melting Pot, and talk about it, because it also raises the question of tradition versus assimilation, which was important at that time, and actually quite important to your family.

38:17.950 --> 38:22.797
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, assimilation is kind of what I was always thinking about while writing this book.

38:22.817 --> 38:32.231
[SPEAKER_00]: Zhang will write to Roosevelt and says, dear President Roosevelt, I've written a new play about the the experience of being an American.

38:32.391 --> 38:33.413
[SPEAKER_00]: Will you come and see it?

38:33.433 --> 38:39.962
[SPEAKER_00]: The premier is in Washington, DC, on I think it was October the end 1908.

38:40.183 --> 38:47.113
[SPEAKER_00]: Roosevelt comes to the premier as does every other

38:47.093 --> 38:56.070
[SPEAKER_00]: this night of the premiere, if you were in the audience, you sort of couldn't help but look around you and see all these celebrities in their boxes dressed in their finery.

38:56.090 --> 39:07.431
[SPEAKER_00]: And people said it was sort of, you know, when the curtain went up, people thought, how am I, how am I going to concentrate on the play, when they're all these, you know, there's a president and whoever else in the audience.

39:07.799 --> 39:15.246
[SPEAKER_00]: But this play, Zangle had written, despite being British Jew, he had written what some called the great American play.

39:15.446 --> 39:28.979
[SPEAKER_00]: It was about two immigrants who've come to America full in love, cast aside their differences, and melting to the melting pot, and emerges shining new Americans, and it all ends happily ever after, and how wonderful the melting pot is.

39:29.220 --> 39:34.785
[SPEAKER_00]: And there was sort of standing evations and people were clapping and cheering,

39:34.765 --> 39:39.350
[SPEAKER_00]: Roosevelt apparently shouted over the ballastrade from his box.

39:39.550 --> 39:45.536
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a great play, Mr. Zhang will, and that line was used on all the adverts in the newspapers after that.

39:45.736 --> 39:47.899
[SPEAKER_00]: And then the play went on tour across America.

39:47.919 --> 39:54.265
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you can imagine, again, it's kind of similar to something going viral in modern times.

39:54.405 --> 39:58.950
[SPEAKER_00]: The whole country was talking about the idea of the melting pot.

39:58.930 --> 40:08.903
[SPEAKER_00]: And those years of the play being on tour in America, sort of solidified this phrase, the melting pot, as a piece of American vocabulary.

40:08.984 --> 40:27.148
[SPEAKER_00]: People didn't use the phrase the melting pot before then, apart from what it really meant, which is like a culture and maybe not a culture and some sort of pot for melting down your sort of precious jewelry to make into new things, precious metals and so on.

40:27.263 --> 40:29.287
[SPEAKER_00]: sort of coined that phrase.

40:29.508 --> 40:43.517
[SPEAKER_00]: And this idea of assimilation, I guess, you know, I'm sure everyone here has certain feelings about it and maybe certain mixed feelings about it within your own family, you know, I for one feel that I have melted into the melting pot and I feel like I've lost.

40:43.497 --> 41:04.493
[SPEAKER_00]: So much of my Jewishness, or so much of my grandmother's Jewishness, and so this sort of bittersweet idea of the melting pot was something that I wanted to sort of explore, but I didn't feel like I could ever reach a conclusion about it, even now I feel sort of undecided about it all and maybe being undecided is the sort of the best way to be.

41:05.198 --> 41:11.724
[SPEAKER_01]: You write that in the afterward that, the Zangle of all the characters came most alive to you.

41:11.964 --> 41:25.617
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was wondering in your reflections on Zangle and this play was he promoting a simulation was he conflicted about the difference between a simulation and maintaining one's tradition?

41:26.297 --> 41:34.665
[SPEAKER_01]: How should we analyze what he was telling us in that play?

41:35.017 --> 41:42.023
[SPEAKER_01]: to the listening audience, half of your family remains non-practicing Jews in or not Jewish really in London.

41:42.103 --> 41:46.787
[SPEAKER_01]: The other half goes off to Jerusalem and become practicing Jews.

41:46.807 --> 41:48.409
[SPEAKER_01]: So what was angle telling us?

41:49.109 --> 41:56.215
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I think Zang was also either changing his mind or was actually just in two minds about it.

41:56.396 --> 42:05.023
[SPEAKER_00]: He said to one journalist, I think for the New York Harold, America is the use and asia of the Jews, if I had my way, not to single Russian Jew with

42:05.003 --> 42:09.129
[SPEAKER_00]: And then he was also proclaiming, you know, he was the leader of the Galveston project.

42:09.169 --> 42:22.227
[SPEAKER_00]: So he was proclaiming that America was, you know, the great American West was the new home for the Jews and that we should forget about Palestine and send all the Jews to Palestine, Texas, which apparently is a real place.

42:22.468 --> 42:31.420
[SPEAKER_00]: And reviewers, you know, for this play, wrote Canzang were really believe that the answer to the Jewish question is melting into the melting pot.

42:31.601 --> 42:32.682
[SPEAKER_00]: Surely he cannot.

42:33.050 --> 42:55.573
[SPEAKER_00]: believe this sort of deep in his heart and some of them had sort of almost conspiracy theories that Zangle had written this piece of propaganda in order to suck up to the original Roosevelt who had said things like immigrants coming from the old world must cast off their sort of barbarous, old world ways and revere only one flag, the American flag, no other flag can even come second.

42:55.753 --> 43:02.280
[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, reviewers thought, you know, Zangle just pandering to Roosevelt and to Roosevelt's

43:02.260 --> 43:11.974
[SPEAKER_00]: as America, as a place where people are Americans and not Irish Americans or Chinese Americans or Italian Americans, they're just Americans.

43:12.195 --> 43:20.888
[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, I feel like there was a little bit of truth in that that maybe Zangweil was doing a little bit of pandering, but I'd like to ask him.

43:21.689 --> 43:26.496
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, well, you've got to love the original source materials to try to

43:26.476 --> 43:32.484
[SPEAKER_01]: ask him again, but what we're so interesting again, we trace how did you get to write this book this way.

43:33.065 --> 43:46.442
[SPEAKER_01]: David Jockelmann, your great-great-father, and Zangle were at the very heart of this movement, and your great-grandfather's activities was more or less unknown to you at the outset of this project.

43:47.317 --> 43:47.717
[SPEAKER_00]: that's right.

43:48.038 --> 43:52.382
[SPEAKER_00]: And yeah, I think this will be the last thing I say because I know that we're running out of time.

43:53.163 --> 44:01.532
[SPEAKER_00]: My great-grandfather had been forgotten by his own family, by my family, everyone said to me, you know, don't bother looking into him, he's very boring.

44:01.712 --> 44:12.463
[SPEAKER_00]: And then, there are a few people who write about the Galveston Project academics at various universities in America

44:12.443 --> 44:19.476
[SPEAKER_00]: wrote to me back saying, oh my god, you're your jockman's granddaughter, a great granddaughter, very big deal.

44:19.536 --> 44:28.613
[SPEAKER_00]: So he's been sort of remembered by a few people, but for, yeah, I guess this whole book was sort of bringing back so much that has been forgotten from the past.

44:28.897 --> 44:29.298
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.

44:29.318 --> 44:31.803
[SPEAKER_01]: And as we said, there are three parts to the book.

44:32.404 --> 44:47.192
[SPEAKER_01]: And the London part, the third part, really explores the lineage from David Joccomand through your family in London when they're all together, 17 of them in this.

44:47.172 --> 45:01.490
[SPEAKER_01]: chaotic house which is so much fun to read to the split, Fanny stays in one great Aunt stays in London and you are raised not Jewish and the other go to Israel and our Zionists.

45:02.091 --> 45:05.175
[SPEAKER_01]: And you've got this Union in Yang in your own family.

45:05.756 --> 45:08.179
[SPEAKER_01]: Would you write about in part three, which is why you have to buy the book?

45:08.479 --> 45:09.080
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

45:09.100 --> 45:09.881
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Michael.

45:09.941 --> 45:10.622
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, Robin.

45:10.682 --> 45:11.523
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, module.

45:11.583 --> 45:12.825
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you everyone for listening.

45:13.396 --> 45:14.237
[SPEAKER_01]: It was wonderful.

45:14.297 --> 45:20.823
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, Rachel, and thank you for writing this book, and I hope it meets with tremendous success slowly.

45:22.445 --> 45:31.534
[SPEAKER_01]: Join us next week, won't be speaking with Sanjay Gupta, about his terrific new book, it doesn't have to hurt your smart guide to a pain-free life.

45:33.176 --> 45:41.344
[SPEAKER_01]: That said, is produced by Compro and the Museum of Public Relations, and is a proud member of

45:42.083 --> 45:48.475
[SPEAKER_01]: The theme music by Sam Post, please address any comments to that said, zeldon at gmail.com.

45:49.236 --> 45:56.690
[SPEAKER_01]: If you enjoy this podcast, please rate and review us on your favorite podcast app to help more people find us.

45:57.271 --> 45:59.395
[SPEAKER_01]: For that said, I'm Michael Zeldon.

45:59.415 --> 46:00.637
[SPEAKER_00]: M.S.

46:01.619 --> 46:02.100
[SPEAKER_00]: SW. Media.

