| | Frankie1 | ThunderV | Shawn138 | Tavern R | Ryan5 | Miami Mi | Promethe | Furr Bur | 8/12/23 | Rams + A | Pickpock | Pigs on |
| Round 1 | Patrick Mahomes KC (10) | Jalen Hurts PHI (10) | Josh Allen BUF (13) | Lamar Jackson BAL (13) | Joe Burrow CIN (7) | Justin Herbert LAC (5) | Justin Fields CHI (13) | Trevor Lawrence JAC (9) | Justin Jefferson MIN (13) | Travis Kelce KC (10) | Deshaun Watson CLE (5) | Ja'Marr Chase CIN (7) |
| Round 2 | Amon-Ra St. Brown DET (9) | A.J. Brown PHI (10) | Aaron Rodgers NYJ (7) | Bijan Robinson ATL (11) | Stefon Diggs BUF (13) | Nick Chubb CLE (5) | Dak Prescott DAL (7) | Tyreek Hill MIA (10) | Austin Ekeler LAC (5) | Cooper Kupp LAR (10) | Christian McCaffrey SF (9) | Kirk Cousins MIN (13) |
| Round 3 | Saquon Barkley NYG (13) | CeeDee Lamb DAL (7) | Tony Pollard DAL (7) | Mark Andrews BAL (13) | Geno Smith SEA (5) | Derrick Henry TEN (7) | Rhamondre Stevenson NE (11) | Tua Tagovailoa MIA (10) | Daniel Jones NYG (13) | Anthony Richardson IND (11) | Jordan Love GB (6) | Jared Goff DET (9) |
| Round 4 | Mac Jones NE (11) | Russell Wilson DEN (9) | Deebo Samuel SF (9) | Jonathan Taylor IND (11) | Tee Higgins CIN (7) | Derek Carr NO (11) | Darren Waller NYG (13) | Chris Olave NO (11) | Davante Adams LV (13) | Garrett Wilson NYJ (7) | Kenny Pickett PIT (6) | T.J. Hockenson MIN (13) |
| Round 5 | Josh Jacobs LV (13) | Travis Etienne JAC (9) | Keenan Allen LAC (5) | Jahmyr Gibbs DET (9) | Jaylen Waddle MIA (10) | Najee Harris PIT (6) | DeAndre Hopkins TEN (7) | Joe Mixon CIN (7) | Brock Purdy SF (9) | DeVonta Smith PHI (10) | Calvin Ridley JAC (9) | Aaron Jones GB (6) |
| Round 6 | Dameon Pierce HOU (7) | Jerry Jeudy DEN (9) | Antonio Gibson WAS (14) | Kyle Pitts ATL (11) | George Kittle SF (9) | Amari Cooper CLE (5) | DJ Moore CHI (13) | Breece Hall NYJ (7) | DK Metcalf SEA (5) | Matthew Stafford LAR (10) | Javonte Williams DEN (9) | Kenneth Walker SEA (5) |
| Round 7 | James Conner ARI (14) | D'Andre Swift PHI (10) | Allen Lazard NYJ (7) | Terry McLaurin WAS (14) | Alexander Mattison MIN (13) | Brandon Aiyuk SF (9) | Rachaad White TB (5) | Evan Engram JAC (9) | Mike Williams LAC (5) | Dallas Goedert PHI (10) | Miles Sanders CAR (7) | Bryce Young CAR (7) |
| Round 8 | Tyler Lockett SEA (5) | Kyler Murray ARI (14) | Dawson Knox BUF (13) | Sam Howell WAS (14) | Drake London ATL (11) | Ryan Tannehill TEN (7) | Cam Akers LAR (10) | C.J. Stroud HOU (7) | Jimmy Garoppolo LV (13) | Christian Watson GB (6) | Chris Godwin TB (5) | Diontae Johnson PIT (6) |
| Round 9 | Marquise Brown ARI (14) | David Montgomery DET (9) | Gabe Davis BUF (13) | J.K. Dobbins BAL (13) | Christian Kirk JAC (9) | George Pickens PIT (6) | Michael Pittman IND (11) | Alvin Kamara NO (11) | Jaxon Smith-Njigba SEA (5) | James Cook BUF (13) | David Njoku CLE (5) | Pat Freiermuth PIT (6) |
| Round 10 | Greg Dulcich DEN (9) | Dalton Kincaid BUF (13) | Jerick McKinnon KC (10) | Dalton Schultz HOU (7) | Zach Charbonnet SEA (5) | Mike Gesicki NE (11) | Tyler Higbee LAR (10) | Dalvin Cook FA (-) | Mike Evans TB (5) | Desmond Ridder ATL (11) | Khalil Herbert CHI (13) | Isiah Pacheco KC (10) |
| Round 11 | Cole Kmet CHI (13) | Jahan Dotson WAS (14) | Marquez Valdes-Scantling KC (10) | Treylon Burks TEN (7) | Samaje Perine DEN (9) | Kadarius Toney KC (10) | Brian Robinson WAS (14) | Brandin Cooks DAL (7) | Rashaad Penny PHI (10) | Jordan Addison MIN (13) | Michael Thomas NO (11) | Skyy Moore KC (10) |
| Round 12 | Raheem Mostert MIA (10) | Quentin Johnston LAC (5) | Gerald Everett LAC (5) | Elijah Moore CLE (5) | Irv Smith CIN (7) | Jamaal Williams NO (11) | Odell Beckham BAL (13) | Courtland Sutton DEN (9) | De'Von Achane MIA (10) | AJ Dillon GB (6) | Romeo Doubs GB (6) | Sam LaPorta DET (9) |
| Round 13 | Jakobi Meyers LV (13) | Chigoziem Okonkwo TEN (7) | Cordarrelle Patterson ATL (11) | JuJu Smith-Schuster NE (11) | Jaylen Warren PIT (6) | Taysom Hill NO (11) | Nico Collins HOU (7) | Zay Flowers BAL (13) | Juwan Johnson NO (11) | Rashod Bateman BAL (13) | D'Onta Foreman CHI (13) | Tyler Allgeier ATL (11) |
| Round 14 | Rondale Moore ARI (14) | Damien Harris BUF (13) | Cade Otton TB (5) | Elijah Mitchell SF (9) | Baker Mayfield TB (5) | DJ Chark CAR (7) | Van Jefferson LAR (10) | Tyler Conklin NYJ (7) | Tank Bigsby JAC (9) | Kenneth Gainwell PHI (10) | Hayden Hurst CAR (7) | Jameson Williams DET (9) |
| Round 15 | Zay Jones JAC (9) | Tyjae Spears TEN (7) | K.J. Osborn MIN (13) | Kendre Miller NO (11) | Tyler Boyd CIN (7) | Isaiah Likely BAL (13) | Adam Thielen CAR (7) | Ezekiel Elliott FA (-) | Hunter Henry NE (11) | Chuba Hubbard CAR (7) | Luke Musgrave GB (6) | Kareem Hunt FA (-) |
| Round 16 | Jacoby Brissett WAS (14) | Trey McBride ARI (14) | Sterling Shepard NYG (13) | Michael Gallup DAL (7) | Jerome Ford CLE (5) | Devin Singletary HOU (7) | Rashid Shaheed NO (11) | Jonathan Mingo CAR (7) | Roschon Johnson CHI (13) | Jeff Wilson MIA (10) | Donovan Peoples-Jones CLE (5) | Darnell Mooney CHI (13) |
| Round 17 | Will Levis TEN (7) | Rashee Rice KC (10) | Austin Hooper LV (13) | Curtis Samuel WAS (14) | Jake Ferguson DAL (7) | Zamir White LV (13) | Kyren Williams LAR (10) | Noah Fant SEA (5) | Marvin Mims DEN (9) | Alec Pierce IND (11) | Chase Brown CIN (7) | Ty Chandler MIN (13) |
| Round 18 | Logan Thomas WAS (14) | Leonard Fournette FA (-) | Trey Lance SF (9) | DeVante Parker NE (11) | Gus Edwards BAL (13) | Isaiah Hodgins NYG (13) | Chase Edmonds TB (5) | John Metchie HOU (7) | Michael Mayer LV (13) | Jelani Woods IND (11) | Parris Campbell NYG (13) | Hunter Renfrow LV (13) |
| Round 19 | Kenyan Drake IND (11) | Jayden Reed GB (6) | Melvin Gordon BAL (13) | Latavius Murray BUF (13) | Clyde Edwards-Helaire KC (10) | Michael Carter NYJ (7) | Joshua Kelley LAC (5) | Darius Slayton NYG (13) | Jalin Hyatt NYG (13) | Justyn Ross KC (10) | Deon Jackson IND (11) | Zach Evans LAR (10) |
| Round 20 | Robert Woods HOU (7) | Clayton Tune ARI (14) | Greg Dortch ARI (14) | Chase Claypool CHI (13) | DeWayne McBride MIN (13) | Zach Ertz ARI (14) | Kyle Trask TB (5) | Terrace Marshall CAR (7) | Pierre Strong NE (11) | Mack Hollins ATL (11) | Tank Dell HOU (7) | Andy Dalton CAR (7) |
