| | Captain | Old Scho | Siders'N | FM20 | THE FREN | Old Scho | Lil Ice | The Mand | Lil Ice | DNT | Captain | Siders'N |
| Round 1 | Breece Hall NYJ (10) | Kenneth Walker SEA (11) | Drake London ATL (14) | Treylon Burks TEN (6) | Garrett Wilson NYJ (10) | Chris Olave NO (14) | Skyy Moore KC (8) | Jameson Williams DET (6) | Christian Watson GB (14) | James Cook BUF (7) | George Pickens PIT (9) | Jahan Dotson WAS (14) |
| Round 2 | Zamir White LV (6) | Rachaad White TB (11) | Dameon Pierce HOU (6) | Isaiah Spiller LAC (8) | Brian Robinson WAS (14) | David Bell CLE (9) | Trey McBride ARI (13) | Tyler Allgeier ATL (14) | John Metchie HOU (6) | Alec Pierce IND (14) | Wan'Dale Robinson NYG (9) | Jelani Woods IND (14) |
| Round 3 | Greg Dulcich DEN (9) | Derek Carr LV (6) | Jalen Tolbert DAL (9) | Hassan Haskins TEN (6) | Pierre Strong NE (10) | Tyrion Davis-Price SF (9) | Keaontay Ingram ARI (13) | Mecole Hardman KC (8) | Marlon Mack HOU (6) | Gerald Everett LAC (8) | Justyn Ross KC (8) | Jerome Ford CLE (9) |
| Round 4 | Tyquan Thornton NE (10) | William Fuller FA (-) | Khalil Shakir BUF (7) | Marquez Valdes-Scantling KC (8) | Tyler Badie BAL (10) | K.J. Osborn MIN (7) | Kyren Williams LAR (7) | Romeo Doubs GB (14) | Terrace Marshall CAR (13) | Curtis Samuel WAS (14) | Kenny Pickett PIT (9) | Jameis Winston NO (14) |
| Round 5 | LAC Team Defense LAC (8) | Donovan Peoples-Jones CLE (9) | Tim Patrick DEN (9) | KJ Hamler DEN (9) | Kevin Harris NE (10) | Ryan Tannehill TEN (6) | Gus Edwards BAL (10) | Jalen Wydermyer FA (-) | Harrison Bryant CLE (9) | Velus Jones CHI (14) | Damien Williams ATL (14) | Eno Benjamin ARI (13) |
| Round 6 | D'Ernest Johnson CLE (9) | Chris Evans CIN (10) | DAL Team Defense DAL (9) | Abram Smith NO (14) | Taysom Hill NO (14) | Snoop Conner JAC (11) | Isaiah Likely BAL (10) | Younghoe Koo ATL (14) | Calvin Austin PIT (9) | GB Team Defense GB (14) | Darrel Williams KC (8) | Malik Willis TEN (6) |
| Round 7 | Hayden Hurst CIN (10) | Bryan Edwards LV (6) | Marquez Callaway NO (14) | Desmond Ridder ATL (14) | Austin Hooper TEN (6) | CLE Team Defense CLE (9) | Cameron Brate TB (11) | Sam Howell WAS (14) | Isaih Pacheco KC (8) | Kennedy Brooks PHI (7) | Ryan Succop TB (11) | BAL Team Defense BAL (10) |
